Wharton Professor Olivier Chatain on Friction and Competition

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

When developing business strategies, it is wise to think about frictions, the forces that make it difficult for buyers and sellers to connect. Those elements location, convenience or even a customers desire to support the little guy can give a small local retailer a fighting chance against the pricing and marketing power of a nearby national chain store, according to research by a Wharton management professor and an INSEAD colleague. 📂 Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] So by friction we mean uh anything that's uh a feature in the environment
  2. that is making your customers less likely to make you compete very hard against a competitor.
  3. So it's anything that's making that that causes your your customers to find it harder to find a second source. Uh so
  4. there are many reasons why this may happen. It can be because they have an established relationship with you. It
  5. may be because it's hard to find someone else. It can be costly. Uh maybe it's not worth for them to to look for a
  6. second source. So think for instance of the the book retailing business before the internet. Uh there was quite a lot
  7. of friction because when you and I were going to uh to a bookstore, it was hard to find an alternative. You would have
  8. to drive to find a different bookstore. But now with the internet, you know exactly who's selling what. Uh it's very
  9. easy to find a second provider for for the for the book you want to buy or even different book from what you wanted to
  10. buy. Uh and then there are situations where uh actually there's quite a lot of friction. think of any new product. Uh
  11. when if you're a firm and you're trying to buy a new software for your company, you're very reluctant to uh to you want
  12. to do that piece of business with someone you trust, with someone who knows you if it's very important for
  13. you. You don't want them to screw that up. So that would make you less likely to to shop around to many different
  14. providers. So all these are examples of frictions uh that are I we think in this
  15. paper quite important for competition. Uh so uh this paper was uh written in collaboration with Peter Zamsky of
  16. Vinsat and I guess the the idea emerged when we we wanted to use u theoretical tools like mathematical tools such as
  17. game theory to address fundamental questions in strategy. And we wanted to find a way to be able to really speak
  18. about competition in a way that would be able to tie together different aspects of theories that we have in strategy and
  19. put that in one model and be able to talk about the interaction between all these elements. So friction is one one
  20. way for us to try to tie together ideas that are coming from for instance Michael Porter and the five forces about
  21. the environment and how competitive forces are affecting firm profitability on the one hand and in the other hand uh
  22. it was could use that to think about how firms develop their capabilities. So the
  23. idea of frictions was really coming from let's try to text a feature from the reality
  24. and put that into a mathematical model so that we can really think deeply about how different aspects of competition
  25. matter for managers. So let me talk about u two different situations in which these ideas can help
  26. think about what to do. Look at the current uh situation in the economy. Uh presumably customers are suddenly
  27. shopping around much more. Now the question for as a manager is to understand whether this is a threat of
  28. an opportunity. So what we we argue I think in this paper is that if you try to think in terms of the the current
  29. level of friction in your market and maybe this level of friction is going down uh it can help you understand
  30. whether it's a good or bad thing for you. So it may be a bad thing for you if frictions are quite low and it means
  31. that customers are even more likely to put you directly into competition against uh other suppliers in which case
  32. you're not losing sorry you're not gaining much but it can be good for you because maybe actually you will have a
  33. whole lot of new potential buyers who would come to you before they did not bother looking around because they were
  34. satisfied with what they had. Now that they're less satisfied, they're actually uh seeking to to have new suppliers and
  35. this represents an opportunity. So that would be one scenario where thinking in ter of frictions can be useful. Another
  36. one that that's a bit different is when if you're one firm in in a market and you suppose that you have a you have a
  37. weaker firm, there's there's another firm that's much better than you are and suddenly there's an innovation that's
  38. coming up that maybe allows you to to invest and to leaprog and to to suddenly become the better firm in the market. So
  39. here there's a complicated game and interaction that may happen and what we show in in in the paper is that you you
  40. have to understand uh to what extent the gap between your current abilities or current
  41. capabilities and your competitors is because if this gap is not too too too large then it may be possible for you
  42. actually to to leaprog that that competitor and become the better firm in the market.
  43. uh but if this gap is very far away so what we showed in the paper is that sometimes it's just not even worth
  44. trying should improve a bit but not that much so thinking in terms of frictions and their interaction with technology is
  45. also a way to to to to think about whether you want to to challenge an incumbent because there are cases where
  46. it's possible it's not sure you can make it but it's possible and there are other
  47. cases where we say that the analysis suggests more that it's not worth really trying.
  48. So in this paper what we are able to do and these are also things that we discovered for ourselves is that we are
  49. able to to understand a bit better the uh the relationship and between different concepts that we have in
  50. strategy. So I think most MBAs they learn about the five forces of Michael Porter which are
  51. very very important framework in strategy. This is something that we teach to all our students. And in this
  52. framework for instance we have several forces. We have like barriers to entry rivalry uh powers of buyers powers of
  53. suppliers u and whether there are substitutes. Uh the thing is that it's a great
  54. framework to for instance to understand how how to analyze the environment and organize the information but as such it
  55. doesn't tell us much about how these different forces are interrelated but in this paper we are able to understand
  56. much better how some of these elements are interacting with each other and we're finding things that are a bit
  57. counterintuitive that we actually discovered doing this paper that we felt that we we did not know before. So for
  58. instance, you have u I mean counterintuitively uh businesses want to have a certain level of friction. Even
  59. if you're a very good firm, you're better off having some friction in the market. And the reason is that uh if you
  60. start with a small level of friction, it's always better to reduce competition even though it is at the at the cost of
  61. losing a few few customers. But this also means that there's an optimal level of friction which is something that was
  62. not clear to us when we started this paper. So as a manager you want to monitor the friction that's in the
  63. market and maybe sometime it can if it goes up it can be good for you but sometime it can be bad.
  64. [Music]

Brief Summary

This episode covers market friction and its effects on competition and strategy, featuring insights from Peter Zamsky's research.

Key points

  • Understanding Friction in Competition. Friction in the market can impact customer behavior and competition. It’s crucial for managers to understand these dynamics.
  • The Optimal Level of Friction. Finding the right balance of friction can be beneficial for businesses, even if it means losing some customers.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes