How Presidential Power Is Rewriting Business Rules

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Philip Nichols, Joseph Kolodny Professor of Social Responsibility in Business at the Wharton School, joins Dan Loney to examine the evolving legal landscape of business in the United States. He explores how policy, social norms, and government involvement intersect with business strategy—and what today’s executives need to keep in mind as these forces continue to shift.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#BusinessEthics #GovernmentPower #ExecutivePower #EconomicsExplained #AIEconomy #GeopoliticsToday ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, we have seen the government recently announced that they were going to take a stake in Intel and we are
  2. seeing more potential moves coming in the future for assets seen as strategic to the strength of America. But what we
  3. aren't seeing is a lot of push back by leaders of various companies. They are staying silent over concern that their
  4. company maybe could be next. And this approach has both sides of the aisle a bit concerned. Pleasure to be joined
  5. right now by Philip Nichols who's a professor of legal studies and business ethics here at the Wharton School. Is
  6. also a professor of social responsibility in business. Phil, great to talk to you again. How are you, sir?
  7. >> I'm great, Dan. It's always good to talk to you. >> All right, so take us through what we've
  8. seen recently and give us your thoughts on some of these moves by the White House.
  9. >> Sure. Um, this is going to take a bit of time, but not much time. the what we're seeing recently is part
  10. of a larger shift in the environment of business in the United States. Uh and it's a huge huge shift. The only thing I
  11. can compare it to in the last century is the New Deal. And that's basically um what was once a fringe theory about
  12. presidential power, the exe the unified executive theory has now become the working way of
  13. thinking about the constitution of the United States. And and that's that's just this
  14. fundamental change. What it means is that we now have an executive who is not is immune to most forms of
  15. prosecution. Almost all. It's hard to think of any that they aren't. We have a president who's not bounded by the the
  16. the authority of Congress. Um, Congress no longer dictates how funds are to be allocated and how funds are to be spent
  17. on what laws are to be enforced. And we have a Supreme Court that in trying to figure out this unified theory is giving
  18. a lot of latitude to the president to the executive in all kinds of arenas of the business world and the social and
  19. political world as well. But our concern is the business world. It took after the the the many Supreme
  20. Court decisions that came late in the New Deal. It took decades to figure out what the new rules were. It also took,
  21. particularly after, you know, ironically, another Roosevelt, Teddy Roosevelt, it took decades to figure out
  22. the new social norms regarding the relationship between the executive and business.
  23. And so right now, you know, one of the funny things about um business people assessing risk is they
  24. have a team of lawyers who can tell you with with really really great accuracy the risks involved in
  25. taking action. Do this, this will happen. Don't do this, this will happen. We don't have the same kinds of teams
  26. regarding the risk with social rules, but people navigate social rules. Right now, we can't do either of those things.
  27. A a business cannot assess the risk involved in taking action or not taking action with respect to the law because
  28. the law is essentially being rewritten and it it takes a while. It takes it'll take a few decades. How much of this
  29. then is the time that we are in when you think about the advent of AI and the impact of cryptocurrency and so many of
  30. these new components >> absolutely >> that have that have come into our world in the last 10 years.
  31. >> Absolutely. And and they that is it's it's perhaps not a coincidence that this huge shift in law
  32. accompanies a huge shift in what we're able to do and how we're able to do it. But that only adds to the uncertainty
  33. about everything. The the social rules in particular are being rewritten as social media takes over the way that we
  34. interact with one another. And so once again, you point as you point out, it's impossible to assess the risk. We
  35. just don't know. >> So then what is your expectation as we move forward here? Because we see this
  36. move uh around Intel. Uh there's also the moves to receive revenue from Nvidia over sales of chips from China. Uh
  37. Howard Lutnik, the commerce secretary, said in an interview this morning that the Pentagon may start to look for these
  38. types of business partnerships. Is this going to be the new norm? Is that wall that was kind of there where the
  39. government stayed away from the private sector? >> Yeah. >> Has that been broken down now? Yes, I
  40. would guess that it has been. I would compare this and I I don't want to get political.
  41. People make their choices and that's great, but I would compare this to other regimes that have a powerful
  42. central authority without a check on it and they tend to get heavily involved in
  43. business and that isn't good for business. It reduces competition. It skews contracts in a particular way. It
  44. generally means that businesses are going to be smaller and more cautious in how they expand, how they innovate, how
  45. they do things. >> What does this mean then for seuite executives and how they have to approach
  46. not only running their business but obviously the relationship they have with the government and not only their
  47. government but obviously if they're a a multinational governments around the world. I would imagine that a lot for
  48. that very reason a lot of them will start moving their headquarters to more neutral places and then interact with
  49. the United States from someplace else. um because it's going to be really hard to grow and to navigate in the business
  50. environment that's being created now particularly during a time of uncertainty right I I think the
  51. interesting component I'll finish up on this is that as you look at it some people see this as a protection of a lot
  52. of the businesses that are out there others will say that it's not that and it's you know getting your hand in the
  53. cookie jar when it really shouldn't be. How do you view what we're seeing play out right now?
  54. >> That's a great So, if you look at other places and other times when this has happened, it may start out as it doesn't
  55. always, but it may start out as we're doing something beneficial to our our polity, our country, whatever, but it
  56. almost always devolves into the hand in the cookie jar. I mean, it just goes that direction eventually.
  57. >> Phil, great to have you with us today. Thanks very much for your time and your
  58. insight. All the best. Thank you. You got it. Philip Nichols, who's a professor of legal studies and
  59. business ethics as well as professor of social responsibility in business here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Philip Nichols discusses government involvement in business and its implications for executives in the current climate.

Key points

  • A Fundamental Change in Business Law. Philip Nichols discusses a significant shift in the relationship between the government and business, likening it to the New Deal.
  • Uncertainty in Business Risks. Nichols emphasizes the difficulty businesses face in assessing legal risks due to changing laws.
  • Government's Role in Business. Nichols warns that increased government involvement can lead to reduced competition and innovation.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes