Lessons Learned from Developing Markets: Knowledge at Wharton Real Estate Forum

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Highlights from a panel discussion at the recent Knowledge at Wharton Real Estate Forum

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so Emerging Market assets have appreciated dramatically this year across the board Emerging Market debt
  2. emerging market stocks real estate is this the beginning of a bubble is this a bubble your your comment that there are
  3. certain inherent attractive features would indicate maybe not or at least not yet uh what does the panel think about
  4. where prices are today Megan I think you have to look at it in relative terms uh Russia for
  5. example uh had a had a the equity Market was off 80% uh e fixed income markets off
  6. probably 50% um most of the activity that you saw in those in those issues was was was
  7. Russians buying back um their debt uh corporates buying back their debt people basically reallocating reallocating
  8. their shares but you're seeing now 100% revaluation is is really I I don't think
  9. uh a bubble U I think you know the question is what's next um and that's the next step which is the money that's
  10. coming in uh from institutional investors who are basically leveraging at lior plus 25 basis points is 50 basis
  11. points right okay so that that's that's the issue the issue is whether this hot money coming back into the market will
  12. spur another bubble in the next wave because what we're hearing in the in the first quarter of 2010
  13. there's several billion dollars that's going to be coming into uh dedicated real estate in in in Europe uh dedicated
  14. Russia funds uh and that's definitely going to put push up asset prices uh you know another 30% if you read Goldman
  15. Sachs I would tend to agree I think in our Market there's been a lot of of people asking this question and uh I
  16. think when we look at how real estate has appreciated in Eastern Africa a lot of those demographic fundamentals do
  17. tend to explain the the heat up in prices and uh with a with a slight slowdown it's very easy to link you know what's
  18. happening in the west with some of the you know just some of the interlinkages we have with d diaspora remittances and
  19. and foreign exchange from tourism and also our Horticultural industry and commodities um so there's we we think
  20. that uh speculation is quite minimal and it has it has tended to be borne out so
  21. what we've seen is a is a a slow down not in in prices but just in price growth that is you know moderate so so
  22. think we it's quite stable and it's in the place that it needs to be but as he says the question is is what happens now
  23. and are we going to see you know another runup that might not be so the other question though who's underwriting the
  24. risk you know two years ago uh library was at two and two and a half three 3% a bank puts 300 basis points 350 basis
  25. points on it and Loans the money to Russia okay Bank says I need 300 basis points to cover my risk uh 50 basis
  26. points for this and and lior is is properly valued okay so today the bank needs needs 800 basis points or 900
  27. basis points but who's really taking the risk not the bank the government who's basically underwriting library at 25
  28. basis points and this is the problem because people are are more than happy with the money that they're going to
  29. take but the they're you know it's it's headed the wrong way it's a new Shadow banking system funding everything right
  30. yeah but the bubble idea also uh can be applied at various points in time as too
  31. much money shows up for something you know I believe there was a bubble in Indian land for example when too much
  32. private Equity showed up uh and uh there's uh there was a a bubble uh in the uh Brazilian Home Building Market
  33. when too much public Equity showed up we don't need 19 publicly trade home builders in Brazil um nicely that's uh
  34. taken care of itself we've bought one and others will be Consolidated as well there is a bubble that's uh forming in
  35. China because the government wants now to push credit into the real estate industry
  36. well government uses the banks to do so now there's land auctions government controls all the land it's a speculative
  37. Market it's impossible virtually we have two home builders in China to accumulate
  38. land uh on an economic basis that's a bubble somebody just showing up in an auction how do you define because the
  39. interesting question is the domestic versus the international market in terms of how a bubble's created because a lot
  40. of times you have a lopsided situation where as you pointed out you have private Equity coming in from foreign
  41. investors who artificially push our prices as locals just settling into that right but then you have another
  42. situation where there's there's a a genuine dynamic in the market where you have local investors and foreign
  43. investors who are actually trading trading assets which is which is which can also be the perception of a bubble
  44. but it's a lot more stable than a situation that you described because I've seen them both in Russia and I
  45. think it's interesting because you know before 1998 Russians were doing one thing was selling and foreigners were
  46. doing one thing which was buying and then in 2000 everything switched around and Russians were buying and foreigners
  47. were selling well there's there used to be quite a pejorative connotation to Emerging Markets it used to be called
  48. the third world right yeah and I think it seems that there's a rethink going on among serious investors about how much
  49. of their portfolio how much opportunity they ought to devote to the so-called Emerging Markets versus the develop
  50. Market but I think also you have to look at the the amount of money that actually
  51. circles into these economies which is domestic money okay recycled through offshore conduits which is called
  52. Capital flight in some countries um and and in Russia I would say that pre98 it was 70% foreign money 30% domestic money
  53. and I would say today it's the opposite in the equity markets it's higher but in
  54. the domestic uh real estate market and things and the more substantive real assets um the majority is is Russian
  55. money coming back from offshore

Brief Summary

Emerging market assets rise sharply; panel debates potential bubble risks and economic stability.

Key points

  • Emerging Market Assets Surge. Emerging Market assets have appreciated dramatically this year, raising questions about sustainability.
  • Risk Underwriting Concerns. Discussion on who is really taking the risk in the current market environment.
  • China's Real Estate Bubble. Concerns arise over a potential bubble in China's real estate market due to government actions.

Related episodes