Should You Trust Crypto?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW In the second part of this two-part episode, Wharton marketing professors assess the growth of cryptocurrency so far and how consumer confidence can influence pricing. This episode is part of a series on “Cryptocurrency.”

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#crypto #cryptocurrency #cryptomarket #blockchain #bitcoin ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. John Zhang: I definitely agree with that. I think that— certainly that there is still a way to go, right? So you have
  2. some— the financial institutions that get involved in this. But you don't really see a lot of pension funds, for instance,
  3. that want to invest their money into the cryptocurrency. You don't see the sort of sovereignty funds, and— for some
  4. of the countries and that will begin to invest in the cryptocurrency. Once those things happens, I think that
  5. you're going to see that the market potential is huge. Dan Loney: What's the— what's, then,
  6. the key driver, then, to start to see that occur, do you think? - Well, I think that— number one, that you have these young people who are
  7. very enthusiastic about the cryptocurrency, and these are the future of the country, right? So you never bet against
  8. the young people. I think once those people basically go out there and basically push for the sort of regulation, push it for
  9. the— for the technology change, and cut down the cost of the process, and Bitcoin and so on so forth, it will become a
  10. widely spread currency. I think that's one part of it. That will happen. I think the second is basically that once you have
  11. a more— a sort of a certain regulatory environment, you can imagine the institutions will see the potential and they will
  12. jump in. Once they all start jumping, of course, that— I think that we have a really bright future there.
  13. - Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host,
  14. Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that
  15. Wharton professors have conducted, and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today.
  16. - How then, do some of the instances of fraud in and around cryptocurrency factor into the perceptions of the public, and then potentially
  17. impact either their buy-in, stay out, the pricing component? I mean, we've certainly seen a few instances that would— you would
  18. think would move people away from it. Dave Reibstein: So you would think, whenever
  19. there's— you know, any hint of fraud— you know, the big arrest of Sam, you know, Bankman-
  20. Fried, you know, you would anticipate this is just going to crash the market. I actually have been surprised how
  21. resilient the market is. That there's been these sort of instances that have happened, and yet, the market has been
  22. surprisingly stable through all of that. And— and so it sort of says people believe in this overall concept more than, you
  23. know, this individual or that particular individual. It hasn't affected the overall industry. Well,
  24. Well, that's the interesting thing as well, is that we've seen this absolute surge in pricing, especially around Bitcoin, in
  25. the wake of, you know, FTX and all these concerns. Obviously it's more tied to, as you said before, the results we saw in
  26. the presidential election. The Trump family, maybe, being a close advocate of cryptocurrency now. So it is reactive to a lot
  27. of different factors. I actually agree with what Dave just said. I think that if you
  28. look at— into the cryptocurrency market, and that market is so big today, and there are so many people who are involved in this
  29. particular industry. And it's almost like the US dollar, for instance. You have scandals here and there, and you
  30. basically have the dirty money. You have the tended money. All kind of different scandals going on there, but it
  31. doesn't really overall affect the value of dollars. And— but I think for cryptocurrency, we probably have gone beyond the
  32. point, I think certainly in the last couple years— we've gone beyond the point where a small scandal somehow is going to sink the
  33. whole boat. And that probably is not going to happen. I think that— I would imagine that going forward, and— the market can
  34. easily absorb a lot of other scandals. - Dave? On a small scale, that's totally true. I mean, we haven't seen
  35. anything big that's going to happen. And I think it's pretty resilient. - It's hard to have a big one.
  36. I think it is to have a big one, simply because the market is so distributed and so many people
  37. actually hold the cryptocurrency. And not only that, in fact, it's very difficult for any institution to
  38. unilaterally change anything in the marketplace. I think, given that, I would imagine going forward, that the scandal
  39. probably have a less and less impact in the market. Because they know that there's a component of that kind of built
  40. into what you're getting into in this marketplace anyway? - Exactly. Yeah. - I mean, part of it is this whole notion of distributed trust. And
  41. it's one of the things we're looking at, is, people that believe in distributed trust are those that are more likely to be
  42. investing in crypto. And take it away from the major institutions. So there's no one institution that holds so much
  43. power in the overall system. And that's what has attracted a number of people to— to the currency.
  44. How do you think that impacts finance in general, then, potentially? Because a lot of people have talked about, you know, are
  45. we starting to round a curve in terms of the importance of cryptocurrency in kind of the investing landscape?
  46. Dan, there's no question what we see, some of the major banks are investing in cryptocurrency, just to, you know, balance their
  47. portfolio. And so we're going to see this distributed amongst the institutions. It was supposed to be this non-
  48. institutional entity. And now, the institutions are really investing in it. I definitely agree with that. I think that— certainly that there
  49. is still a way to go, right? So you have some of the financial institutions that get involved in this, but you don't really
  50. see a lot of pension funds, for instance, that want to invest their money into the cryptocurrency. You don't see
  51. the sort of sovereignty funds for some of the countries, that will begin to invest in the cryptocurrency. Once those
  52. things happens, I think that you're going to see that the market potential is huge.
  53. What's the— what's, then, the key driver then to start to see that occur, do you think? - Well,
  54. I think that number one, that you have these young people who are very enthusiastic about the cryptocurrency, and these are
  55. the future of the country, right? So you never bet against the young people. I think once those people basically go out
  56. there and basically push for the sort of regulation, push for the for the technology change and cut down the cost of processing
  57. Bitcoin and so on and so forth, it will become a widely spread currency. I think that's one part of it that will happen. I
  58. think the second thing is basically that once you have a more— a sort of a certain regulatory environment, you can imagine the
  59. institutions will see the potential and they will jump in. Once they all start to jump in, of course, that— I think that we
  60. have a really bright future there. - Dave? I mean, I can't argue with that at all. I think it's absolutely the
  61. case. And as it spreads more and more to— to more of us individually, owning them,
  62. it's going to be hard for it to falter. So that then kind of leads me into my next question— is, where
  63. is, then, the future kind of larger scale ownership in and around cryptocurrency? Is it going to be through 401ks and
  64. different accounts? Is it going to be individual? Where is the path potentially leading us? Where do you think?
  65. So I think we are going to see it more and more in our 401ks. It's basically— you could— you could think of it as, this
  66. is just another one of my stock holdings that I have. It's part of my portfolio. I'm going to have it, you know, in my
  67. retirement fund, I'm going to have it in— in my speculative fund that I have. More and more, that's going to end up
  68. happening. And we can just treat it like we would any other investment. One of the things, by the way, I find humorous—
  69. we've asked people, "Do— would you want to be paid in in crypto and or would you rather be paid in cash?" And people say, "I want to
  70. be paid in cash." However, if you have crypto, "I don't feel bad about paying with crypto." So, I don't fully trust it yet, but
  71. we're going to get to this stage where people say, "Pay me in crypto, and I want to invest
  72. in crypto, just as I would any other stock. Well— so it's interesting, because you've seen different
  73. companies kind of dip their toe in the cryptocurrency water, in that— in that realm of accepting cryptocurrency, you know, for
  74. payment on different services. Which is an interesting pattern, obviously, that it's so different from what we've seen
  75. in the past, because the company that's accepting the crypto is also, to a degree, speculating on what the value of that
  76. currency is going to be as you move forward down the road. Absolutely. I think that if you feel really optimistic about the
  77. future, there probably is something that you want to do, and obviously that if pension funds begin to get into it, I
  78. think that that particular asset class will become a whole lot less risky, for sure. And I think one of the things I— in this
  79. context, I want to add is that, as marketing professors, and obviously, that— we really think that the marketing will play a
  80. huge role in this whole process of actualizing the value of the cryptocurrencies. The reason is because they all use more or
  81. less the same kind of a technology, right? So they all don't have a intrinsic value. So ultimately, I think that is
  82. marketing efforts that you're making. And that probably will make a huge difference in terms of whether or not— and the whole
  83. industry is going to consolidate on you, versus somebody else. So I'm really glad you brought that up, not just because we're
  84. marketing professors. Of course we want to bring that up. But one of the industries that invest a lot in advertising is
  85. actually financial institutions. And why? Well, I want you to have confidence in us. And so what it is that we're going to
  86. see— and it relates back to the earlier question of all these different brands— you need to have confidence in our brand.
  87. And while these other fraud or scandals are going on here or there, you need to have confidence in us. And so there's
  88. more and more marketing effort that's going behind trying to create a brand, and in particular just the trust that people have.
  89. Well, and doesn't, then, cryptocurrency gain a level of security by being connected with financial institutions, which in many
  90. cases are relied upon by the public in general? Those institutions are basically bridging a gap along the way.
  91. - They do. - Which is so ironic, because part of the reason for the cryptocurrency is to decouple from the financial institutions.
  92. So there's that irony that's there as well. Where do you want to take this research?
  93. Where do you think are— are the next areas that need to be investigated? So it's so funny. We just came from the meeting where we were
  94. going over, where do we want to be taking this? And one of the things that we're thinking about is the crypto creep. That more
  95. and more people starting to use it, we're going to— and we're trying to track and predict retail acceptance. You know, you
  96. mentioned some places starting to take it. We at Wharton took— you know, you could pay for a course in crypto. - Oh, really?
  97. And so we did that. And you see it, you know— movie theaters are accepting crypto. We'll see it in all sorts of different stores. And
  98. so, can we anticipate which stores are going to end up taking it? And that distribution and what types of
  99. stores is one of the next things that we're going to be looking at. And which types of people. So we have looked at who— what
  100. types of people are the most likely to own crypto right now, and sort of seeing where that diffuses. An interesting finding
  101. that we see— and if I— I should quiz you, because I'm a professor, and what do I do as a professor? Do the East Coast,
  102. West Coast, or in the Midwest, own more crypto? Oh yeah, I'm gonna say West Coast. - Okay.
  103. you're wrong. - Okay. And if your next guest was East Coast, you're wrong. It's— - Really?
  104. It's— - Midwest. And that was most surprising to us. And part of that is, they are opposed to that
  105. centralized control. - Oh, yeah. And when you— and when you pause and think about it that way. - Yeah.
  106. So that's another way of, you know, can we anticipate and predict who are going to be the people
  107. most likely to be investing in crypto? John, what's still piquing your interest?
  108. So obviously this is a very, very complex topic. And I think every one of us is really trying to feel the elephant. And I think
  109. this is really at the very beginning stage of our research on the cryptocurrency. I think that the bite we are taking
  110. essentially not only look at the consumer confidence, what are the determinants of the consumer confidence in Bitcoin, and whether
  111. or not the confidence index will predict the Bitcoin price changes, and— so we can predict where they're going, and so on,
  112. so forth. Most important, that this whole idea of distributed trust is really new. I think a personal trust, we know what
  113. depends on. - Sure. - And— but for distributed trust, for instance, we don't know. And so that's why, in fact, that a lot of
  114. research we can do in terms of figuring out, and what are the determinants of distributed trust, and that's definitely one
  115. big topic. And what's most important, from a pricing point of view, of course, that we want to know what the underlines the
  116. changes in prices? Is there any way that we can get a hold of the price changes in some way and then predict how they would
  117. change? So there are a lot of modeling and data collection and processing to do.
  118. Great to have you both here with us today. Thanks very much. Well, thank you for having us. - Thank you so much.
  119. Thank you. Great to talk to you. Dave Reibstein, John Zhang, Wharton Marketing Professors
  120. joining us here in studio. Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this episode
  121. informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight
  122. from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Experts discuss cryptocurrency's resilience, future growth, and the role of institutional investment in this episode of The Ripple Effect.

Key points

  • Market Resilience Amid Scandals. Despite instances of fraud, the cryptocurrency market remains surprisingly stable.
  • The Future of Cryptocurrency Investment. Young people are the key drivers for cryptocurrency adoption and regulation.
  • Cryptocurrency in Retirement Funds. Expect to see cryptocurrency included in 401ks and retirement portfolios.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes