SKS Microfinance's Vikram Akula on Mobile Banking

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Vikram Akula, founder and CEO of SKS Microfinance, launched the company in 1998 to offer small loans to very poor borrowers. Some 10 years later, SKS has become India's fastest growing microfinance institution (MFI), with more than two million borrowers. In the next two years, Akula would like SKS Microfinance, whose backers include venture capitalists such as Sequoia Capital, to grow to eight million borrowers -- which would make it the world's largest microfinance lender, surpassing Bangladesh's Grameen Bank. In an interview with India Knowledge@Wharton at the recent Wharton India Economic Forum, Akula spoke about emerging trends in microfinance.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by Indian knowledge at Warton please visit knowledge. won. up.edu India for more
  2. [Music] information India imagine was the theme of the 2008 Wharton India economic Forum
  3. that was held in Philadelphia recently the dayong event attracted several leaders including apj Abdul Kalam former
  4. president of India as well as CEOs of Indian companies nonprofit groups Consulting and private Equity firms
  5. Indian knowledge at Wharton brings you one-on-one conversations with these leaders we're going to speak today with
  6. Vikram akula founder and CEO of SKS micr Finance vickram thanks so much for joining us today thank you for having me
  7. I'd like to start by asking how you got involved with micro Finance can you tell
  8. us a little bit about how and why sure uh I was born in India but grew up in the states and uh I'll go back to my
  9. childhood here I used to go back to India quite a bit during school holidays and I would see the extreme poverty we
  10. have in India and then come back to a suburb of America and it was that jux position of extreme poverty on the one
  11. hand and extreme wealth that made me say Okay I want to do something to try and eradicate this kind of poverty so upon
  12. graduating from college I went and worked with an NGO basically as a field agent as a loan officer doing micro
  13. finance and I saw the tremendous impact that micro Finance has on the lives of the poor
  14. um but I also thought that you could do it in a more scalable Manner and that's when I left that NGO to set up SKS uh
  15. The Entity that I now run let's talk a little bit about the constraints that face you in the world of micr Finance
  16. for example lack of capital is always a problem lack of capacity is another issue and of course micr Finance has
  17. huge transaction costs what kind of Innovations has SKS brought about to tackle these issues
  18. yeah these these this is what I call the three C's the lack of capital the lack of capacity and the high cost of doing
  19. micr finance and in my analysis these are the three constraints that prevented micr Finance institutions from scaling
  20. up R rapidly so what we've done is three things against these problems that we think can overcome those constraints the
  21. first is to use a for-profit model to overcome the constraints of capital the second is to use best practices from the
  22. business world to overcome the constraints of capacity and the third is to use technology to
  23. overcome the constraints of costs to say a quick word on each we believe that even though most microfinance
  24. institutions are nonprofits and even though Professor yunice who's a mentor of mine talks about micr Finance as a
  25. social business meaning not paying dividends we feel that in fact you have to structure things in a for-profit way
  26. you have to pay investors High dividends because otherwise there's no way you're
  27. going to kind of access the capital the kind of capital that poor people need so
  28. we're structured as a for profit and that's been able that's enabled us to tap into commercial capital and provide
  29. an unlimited amount of um Finance to the poor on the second dimension of capacity
  30. if you look at most micr Finance institutions they're structured as NOS they're small they think about you know
  31. thousand clients or maybe 10,000 clients whereas a business whether it's Starbucks or Coke or McDonald's thinks
  32. about millions or tens of millions so what we've done is we've looked at those types of companies and adopted the
  33. techniques that they've used within micr finan and that's given us an extremely fast growth rate and finally when it
  34. comes to technology um we've developed an automated management information system because at the end of the day
  35. you're doing millions of very tiny transactions and there's a high cost to doing that unless you use technology
  36. you'll never be able to bring down the cost and to scale rapidly just to go back to that last point do you use
  37. mobile phones to manage transactions sure we're doing a a pilot project right now with mobile phones and clearly we
  38. think Mobile Banking is the future because doesn't make sense to try and build a retail you know brick and mortar
  39. infrastructure in rural India from a cost perspective it makes no sense at all and mobile technology today is
  40. robust enough that you can actually very easily do Banking and we actually have a
  41. very successful pilot that we've done the problem is the regulatory environment and the Central Bank in
  42. India has not understood Mobile Banking in its full potential and therefore there are regulations that make it
  43. prohibitive for us to do this and if those regulations get changed then clearly this is the investment that we'd
  44. make and this would be the future of micr Finance if you don't mind let's go back to that last Point first about
  45. getting capital from private sources I understand that SKS micr Finance has received capital from Venture
  46. capitalists when that happens does that change the expectations in any way what I mean is do Venture capitalists treat
  47. you more gently because you're lending money to poor women entrepreneurs than they would if you were lending to say a
  48. technology entrepreneur so we certainly have uh social investors who come at it with a double bottom line
  49. of making a social impact as well as a for-profit impact but we also have investors who have a Pure commercial
  50. interest take for example example Sequoia Capital the investors in Yahoo Google and so on they're not interested
  51. in the social purpose they're in there because their LPS need to earn a high return so they come in at a Pure
  52. commercial Angle now many people think that there's a dichotomy between the social purpose and the commercial
  53. purpose but we actually don't think there is a dichotomy we think that if you do what's right by the borrowers if
  54. you charge reasonable interest rates provide good service not only is that intrinsically the right thing to do but
  55. that's the way to build a good business especially when you're working with the base of the pyramid because the base of
  56. the pyramid customers is extremely loyal and if you treat them well they'll stay
  57. with you if they feel they're being exploited or taken advantage of they will turn on you in a second now if you
  58. treat them well it's not only the right thing to do but they'll stay with you and that becomes comes how to build a
  59. long-term healthy business and that's what our commercial investors want typically what are the interest rates
  60. for micr Finance Loans so we we charge an average interest rate of 24% now that seems extraordinarily high but let me
  61. put this in context informally the The Village money lender or the loone Sharks will charge anywhere from 50% to as high
  62. as a th% interest so we're charging much less than what they charge and I'll also
  63. submit that our interest rate is actually the lowest cost finan in available to the poor because even
  64. though a retail bank might charge let's say 12% or a subsidized government loan might cost 7% if you actually talk with
  65. borrowers and ask them how many trips they're making to a bank branch what are the lost wages the bus fairs what are
  66. the broker fees and sometimes bribes they're paying to access that 7% loan they actually end up paying much higher
  67. than 30% so at 24% we're actually the lowest cost financing available to the poor and the poor are earning such high
  68. Returns on their microenterprises that they have no problem paying 24% if their returns are averaging 100% or so well it
  69. sounds like the rates of interest you charge are less than what some credit card companies charge their customers
  70. but the point you rais is a really good one some time ago we interviewed Muhammad yunus the founder of gramine
  71. bank and the Nobel laurate and he told us that he thought micr finance companies need to be regulated because
  72. the rates of Interest they charge are so high and so urious that they're almost as bad as the rates they get from the
  73. village money lender do you happen to agree with that point of view well I think the best way to tackle interest
  74. rates is competition and certainly in some areas you've got some mfis that are you know really trying to extract and
  75. charge High interest rates over time you'll see competition pulling that down now when we compete in different areas
  76. the first thing you see is the local incumbent mfi will immediately drop its interest rates and we think that's the
  77. best way to do it so we wouldn't be in favor of Regulation that caps interest rates we were afraid that that that'll
  78. prevent other competitors from coming in and prevent the more robust way of lowering interest rates having said that
  79. we think there is a scope for regulation when it comes to ethical practices such
  80. as truth and advertising transparency with your borrowers those are the types of things that we think will will make a
  81. big difference to making sure that the the sector remains healthy and prevents the bad apples from coming in as you've
  82. gone about trying to build SKS micr Finance what's the biggest challenge you've faced and how have you overcome
  83. it sure the biggest challenge so far and and clearly the challenge going forward
  84. is the political environment the fact is that um micr Finance is still very much
  85. understood by politicians misunderstood by politicians and bureaucrats and people hear the interest rates and they
  86. don't understand the context and they feel that something exploitative is going going on so we spend a lot of time
  87. trying to educate politicians trying to educate bureaucrats so they understand the power that micr Finance has and
  88. understand understand how it works to actually help the poor the poor certainly understand this our customers
  89. do they come back to us year after year it's the political Elite that doesn't understand it and sometimes misuses
  90. micro Finance for political ends that's been the biggest challenge how many customers do you have and how would you
  91. describe your typical borrower sure So currently we've got um nearly 2 million customers spread across 25,000 villages
  92. in 15 states of India um a typical borrower typical first loan is about 8,000 rupees or
  93. $200 um a woman might take a loan to to buy a cow will sell the milk and then repay the loan on a weekly basis she
  94. might do a small Village Grocery she might do vegetable vending or another type of trading activities and what we
  95. see is there's very high Returns on investment and each year she's eligible to take a larger loan so even though
  96. $200 may seem relatively small eventually we'd like to get borrowers and we see many borrowers moving into,
  97. loans and then you begin to see huge impacts in terms of poverty eradication where do you think SKS micr finance will
  98. be 5 years from now so our our vision or give you I'll give you our two-year goal
  99. we're close to 2 million clients now and we hope to scale to 8 million clients um
  100. in the next two years now today we're the largest mfi in India if we hit that number of 8 million we'll become the
  101. largest mfi in the world so in terms of scale that's one thing that we'd like to
  102. do but we also have a vision to use micr finance that channel that we've created
  103. to distribute the full range of financial services now we do primarily credit and some insurance but we know
  104. poor people need savings they need remittances and they need other products as well so we want to introduce a range
  105. of different products we also think there's opportunities to leverage this channel to introduce non-financial
  106. products as well so currently we're in discussions with groups about doing Education Loans and and talking with
  107. education providers to provide lowcost schools we have a health insurance product and we're teaming up with low
  108. hospitals we are um giving loans to buy cell phones to buy you know consumer package goods and we think there's the
  109. whole range of non-financial products that poor people need that we can deliver through our Channel as well
  110. vicam thank you so much for joining us today thank you as [Music] well for more information please visit
  111. knowledge. won. up.edu India [Music]

Brief Summary

Vikram Akula discusses SKS Microfinance's strategies for poverty eradication and the challenges of microfinance in India.

Key points

  • Vikram Akula's Vision for Microfinance. Vikram Akula shares his journey from witnessing poverty to founding SKS Microfinance, aiming to eradicate poverty through innovative financial solutions.
  • The Future of Mobile Banking. Akula emphasizes the importance of mobile banking in revolutionizing microfinance, despite regulatory challenges.
  • Balancing Profit and Purpose. Akula discusses how treating borrowers well can lead to a successful business model in microfinance.
  • Interest Rates in Context. Akula clarifies that SKS Microfinance offers competitive rates compared to traditional lenders, benefiting the poor.
  • Political Challenges in Microfinance. Akula highlights the political misunderstandings surrounding microfinance and its impact on operations.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes