'Leveraging Corporate Responsibility': The Stakeholder Approach to Maximizing Social Value

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

"Do well by doing good" is now a mantra for many leading companies. Yet C. B. Bhattacharya, Sankar Sen and Daniel Korschun, authors of Leveraging Corporate Responsibility: The Stakeholder Route to Maximizing Business and Social Value, offer research showing that very few stakeholders -- including consumers, investors and employees -- are aware of what companies are doing to be socially and environmentally responsible. Wharton management professor Witold Henisz spoke with two of the authors, Bhattacharya and Sen, about why caring about the social and environmental concerns of your stakeholders makes good business sense. πŸ“‚ Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] it's a pleasure to have this opportunity to talk with you both CB and shenar uh I
  2. really enjoyed reading your book on corporate responsibility I think it offers a great uh framework uh and a
  3. strong evidentiary base spanning lab experiments the recent headlines Financial economics um I guess I'd like
  4. to start by asking you why you think CEOs board members stakeholders more broadly are increasingly focused on
  5. corporate responsibility and hungry uh for the kind of framework that you provide in this
  6. book one of the reasons is that stakeholders today are increasingly conscious of not just buying a good
  7. product but also kind of where does the product come from so who's the company that stands behind the product so that's
  8. something that we've seen in the consumer space and so they increasing pressure on companies to kind of deliver
  9. and make themselves you know look responsible in in the eyes of the market the same way employees today they don't
  10. want just a paycheck I mean they want something more from a company they want a sense of fulfillment of in terms of
  11. where they work so companies again you know even in a reactive mode they have to kind of you know uh get into the act
  12. of of being good corporate citizens uh investors as an investor movement as well uh so multiple stakeholders have um
  13. or you can say society as a whole have kind of uh risen up to the idea that we need to um be more responsible as
  14. organizations um and as corporate citizens and all of that has put kind of of course the the global warming and and
  15. the climate change movement all of this the human rights Everything Has Come Together to kind of suddenly catapult
  16. corporate responsibility I guess uh to the Forefront great and what motivated you personally to meet this Demand by
  17. writing this book how did you personally become interested in the topic I met the CEO of Ben and Jerry's
  18. uh Ben Goen a long time ago in the mid90s and he asked a very interesting question of me and he said can you tell
  19. me whether consumers would buy our brand rather than a competitor's brand because
  20. of the things that we are doing in the social and environmental realm uh being a marketing scholar this was clearly a
  21. marketing question but I had never thought of you know social responsibility as a driver of of
  22. consumer purchase and that's when I looked to my good friend here and I said okay maybe we need to kind of do
  23. something about this and indeed that was our our U first kind of dive into into this area of corporate responsibility
  24. and how stakeholders react to company's corporate responsibility initiatives over the years there are many other
  25. companies who came to us with similar uh questions you know uh PNG General Mills
  26. uh Target Denon I mean all of these companies kind of had seemed to have similar questions in mind and so our
  27. body of work just kind of kept growing plus there were the the whole theoretical space was wide open so there
  28. was question after question that one could answer and at some point it looked like hey I mean we've got you know a
  29. portfolio here that perhaps we can distill kind of and and disseminate the findings to you know to to a wider
  30. audience than just those who read scholarly journals and I think as an academic one of the things I saw um that
  31. was missing the space is what CB talked about which is uh the lack of an academic or conceptual uh uh perspective
  32. and rigor to a lot of the work that I was seeing and we were seeing in in this area and so we we thought that was a
  33. really interesting opportunity to kind of bring some of that as academics given our unique backgrounds to the to the
  34. questions that were raised in this area so do you think the the two main differences between this book and some
  35. of the other pieces in the field are this academic focus and the marketing as a discipline um or are there other key
  36. dri key differentiators of the book those are two of the key ones yes I mean the stakeholder perspective is is of
  37. course I think um a big differentiator of of this book from others no one really has or prior to this no one
  38. really had studied consumers and employees to find out kind of from the eyes of the beholder if you will kind of
  39. you know what do they feel about a company's um corporate responsibility um if you look at websites every company
  40. says that they're doing great work and fantastic work uh but this was an opportunity to kind of look at it from
  41. from the other side and what we found was uh as you can tell from the book um quite quite quite telling so I would add
  42. to that the you know the the fact that we're looking at it through the lens of the stakeholder is a big
  43. differentiator I was curious about the labeling there's so many top uh labels turned around responsibility social
  44. responsibility sustain ability uh how do you differentiate corporate responsibility uh from some of these
  45. other um some of these other topics these other labels uh the way I address it typically is
  46. that corporate responsibility is U kind of a means to an end and and the end would really be sustainability where we
  47. are thinking of uh the people the planet and as businesses of course we're thinking of profit so that triple bottom
  48. line is where we want to get to and companies are but one of the agents that can kind of take us there and when
  49. companies engage in what it takes to get to fulfill that triple bottom line uh we
  50. call that corporate responsibility we we've clarified that kind of in the book in in in very simple terms and because
  51. we are not dealing with the the other actors such as responsible consumerism I mean that's a big field in of itself
  52. that's that's emerging now um you know or or or any uh social entrepreneurship which is another thing that's kind of
  53. leading into it we figured that corporate responsibility was perhaps the best label um and the most honest label
  54. for for us in this book okay um you ground a lot of the analysis in the book at the level of the individual uh
  55. drawing on psychological research and experiments uh including many that you've conducted yourself uh could you
  56. highlight some of the key insights that come out of this research for people who
  57. are interested in corporate responsibility um well we we from the very beginning we took a very contingent
  58. approach in trying to understand stakeholder reactions our basic premise was that not everyone is going to react
  59. the same way which is very consistent with our understanding of how human beings behave and think and react to not
  60. only what companies do but what happens in the world around them so uh in that sense uh so that's the approach that we
  61. took and what we found were uh as it summarized in the book there was some key insights the first is that uh a lot
  62. of the people we talk to are not really fully understanding of what exactly companies were doing so awareness was
  63. very low uh we found that uh even when they knew what was happening there were certain dimensions of their
  64. understanding that really mattered when it came to how stakeholders at particular consumers React to what
  65. companies do uh that included uh things like uh what kind of attributions they made about why a company is doing what
  66. it's doing which is very key as you know in this space uh it also related to uh what expectations they had coming into
  67. what a company should be doing so those were some of the things and then um uh finally one of the key things that we
  68. thought really ma what we found really mattered is uh are are the the consumers feeling that what the companies are
  69. doing really does something for them personally and that's very much in line with the entire uh uh perspective on
  70. consumer needs and things like that so um I would say those are the key things anything else yeah I mean in simple
  71. terms we were able to distill this into the form of of a of of a model um that folks might find easier to remember and
  72. we call it the three use model and and we label them understanding usefulness and unity and unity is really the sense
  73. of belongingness between the company and the individual uh which drives outcomes
  74. such as kind of loyalty positive word of mouth resilience to negative information
  75. so we studied outcomes that are really of interest to to businesses I mean they and uh businesses have been coveting
  76. these outcomes for a long time and what we are able to do through this uh micr psychological perspective is we are able
  77. to show that corporate responsibility indeed can contribute to these outcomes even when you hold you know all else all
  78. else all else constant so we are able to show Fairly convincingly that this is an
  79. additional driver of kind of you know uh marketing uh and and business coveted coveted outcomes one of the things
  80. that's interesting is you're able to draw a contrast you're able to say it's not just what the company is doing that
  81. may or may not be responsible but how it's perceived uh and so the perceptions among consumers and employees are really
  82. what drives outcomes um that gives a real prominence to the media strategy and the communication strategy uh that
  83. the company employs can you speak a little bit about your findings there yeah I mean communication becomes
  84. absolutely key I mean as I said one thing was that first of all we found awareness to be low and a very simple
  85. truth is that if people don't know what you're doing there is no way that they can reward you so companies will have to
  86. work on increasing that awareness however that's a slippery slope because in our research we found that you know
  87. stakeholders often times uh you know receive these messages as kind of propaganda from from from companies or
  88. self-promotion so one of the implications that we kind of highlight in the book is that when it comes to
  89. talking about your corporate responsibility you know tell don't sell so so don't try to make more of it than
  90. you actually have uh but rather give the facts out there what we find is that stakeholders really want companies to be
  91. outcome focused rather than input focused and what that means is that in uh don't say that we are spending
  92. hundreds of millions of dollars on on solving this crisis but rather say that we've actually saved 100 lives or or
  93. we've kept you know 200 people warm from the cold winter so if you focus on what
  94. you've achieved as a company in the corporate responsibility realm that makes a much bigger difference than kind
  95. of if you just keep on saying that yes we are you know we we are trying so we do list these implications um which you
  96. know if companies follow that in their communication strategy and media strategy I think they can navigate
  97. what's a reasonably complicated path it's not straightforward because you know unlike advertising which which
  98. everybody accepts as okay I mean Company's trying to sell stuff in when it comes to corporate responsibility um
  99. there's far more skepticism and and what we are able to to do in in the communication strategies is we are
  100. suggesting kind of ways to to to navigate this path and uh achieve kind of a a good outcome for the companies
  101. the the one thing I would add to that is uh also in terms of communication one of
  102. the things we found is that if you can really address in your Communications what is it that you're doing in terms of
  103. the needs of your consumer your stakeholders and if you can address that very clearly I don't know if you
  104. remember the shell example that we had in uh one of the earlier chapters where uh we think one of the key uh issues
  105. there was that they did not really think about okay what is it that the this community needs as we're trying to do
  106. good in the environmental space and they didn't communicate that effectively so and in what form of media
  107. I mean are we talking about using U broadcast media using printed media using social media how do you integrate
  108. these these different forms of the communication strategy to Target individual stakeholders with the message
  109. of the outcomes and your uh your efforts in this area I I think it spans all of them uh
  110. in our book at this point we did not get into that level of the kind of the media
  111. planning strategy and and kind of at what point um or or with which Target segment a particular media strategy
  112. might be more effective um than another I think that would have to be kind of on
  113. a case-by Case basis depending on on the company and and and the context um if you look at the real world I mean there
  114. is a fair amount of print media as far as corporate responsibility is concerned and that's clearly an important one
  115. because people do get a little bit of time to kind of process the information that's given uh but social media clearly
  116. you know um things like uh Facebook and so on have have become also increasingly
  117. prominent um I don't think that what have the the implications that we've come up with are kind of more applicable
  118. to a certain form of media or less applicable to a certain form of media but rather I think it's best to say that
  119. we would work that out depending on a particular company context and I think one of the key points we make is that
  120. when it comes to your media strategy you have to again segment you know your stakeholders in your market in terms of
  121. you know what messages you want to go to which group at what stage of the evolution of your uh corporate
  122. responsibility initiatives um uh so you know if you take if you take Nestle as an example
  123. you know they they identify thought leaders in the space and they send them personal Communications whereas they
  124. might put out General ads and then they have their corporate responsibility reports so it's really a mixture of and
  125. then they have to address you know if an NGO attacks them in the social media space they'd have to be Savvy enough to
  126. to um you know address that issue in that space um throughout the book you you provide a
  127. wealth of of great anecdotes and experiences of individual companies with with whom you've worked I wonder how
  128. different you feel the the the perception and the Sea Suite is about the respons the importance of
  129. sustainability corporate responsibility uh from the classroom from future managers and and what explains that
  130. Gap well you know evidence recent evidence suggests that the SE Suite is uh taking notice of of of what's going
  131. on and there was a recent stud by accenta that was actually published in Business Week where they surveyed um
  132. CEOs and seite U managers and they all had very um strong unequivocal concerns about kind of uh sustainability and the
  133. important role that sustainability would would play kind of in the um um in the corporate world kind of in in the years
  134. to come um are they actually going to take note of the details no perhaps not so for them the message is very simple
  135. from our book I think for the sea Suite that the message is that the only way corporate responsibility makes uh a
  136. difference both to society as well as to the bottom line of the company is if it
  137. is fully integrated into the strategy of the company that it ought not to be kind
  138. of a Bolton and um you know if if you give it that respect and if you if you think about it similar to what you would
  139. think about your business strategy overall then and only then can you actually create create value and one
  140. important message that we emphasize is that the only way to creating value through corporate responsibility U
  141. business value through corporate responsibility is to create social value first so creating social value when I
  142. say social I mean environmental as well so creating social and or environmental value is a prerequisite to creating
  143. business value through corporate responsibility in other words there are no shortcuts and if if this is a message
  144. that we can actually communicate to the SE Suite in in simple terms and I have some tangible examples of where managers
  145. have taken one slide kind of you know from from our presentation and say okay this is the one we're going to show um
  146. and uh then I think you know all they need to do is to then you know give give go down the chain of command and say
  147. okay guys we need to think about this uh a little bit differently and uh then hopefully we'll make a difference so the
  148. this um Bears a lot of similarity to Michael Porter's recent work on shared value with Mark Kramer um it's a
  149. seductive appeal to say we can do do well create profits and create value for all stakeholders but at the end of the
  150. day we also have to capture that value uh for our shareholders capture our share of it uh if we just create social
  151. uh welfare if we just create uh total benefits uh how do we know that in the end we'll sustain ourselves as a company
  152. so what advice do you have in terms of making sure that the company captures its share of the value it's creating as
  153. opposed to it all being distributed to external stakeholders in the approach we take I
  154. mean if if you think about the outcomes that we study I mean you know if if a consumer is more loyal to the company's
  155. products or says good things about the company then that value is acing to to to the company I mean in in our
  156. framework there is we we are looking at social value and environmental value and
  157. we're looking at um you know business value so and our models and and uh statistical models as as well as the
  158. conceptual Frameworks are able to demarcate you know between between the the the creating value for the society
  159. part as well as creating value for for the company part uh so when an employee basically stays longer at the company or
  160. is going to be more productive which we also able to show statistically then that value is essentially being you know
  161. uh is is essentially being captured or is acing to to to the company and we don't see that Danger of of it being
  162. lost I think it comes back to the basic premise of our book which is that there is a demand for for uh corporate
  163. responsibility and sustainability from the companies from the external stakeholders and so if a company does
  164. that then the stakeholders will reward them because their needs are being fulfilled it's also obvious from reading
  165. the book that you're drawing a lot on statistical studies lab experiments I wonder you know if there's one that you
  166. think is uh particularly powerful that you'd like to share with us uh and share with the
  167. audience one all right well you start the one the one that stands out for me always uh is the work that we did with
  168. uh yogurt companies yogurt brands um we we contrasted uh Stony field which is very
  169. well known for its work in the uh corporate responsibility space with other brands which actually are you
  170. could argue equally involved but are not really positioned completely or not fully identified with that and what we
  171. found was very interesting um in that uh the consumers of Stonyfield felt much closer to the brand identified felt more
  172. Unity with the brand and ultimately rewarded the brand more than consumers of the other brands even though all the
  173. other brands uh were quite actively engaged in corporate responsibility and I think to me that really encapsulates
  174. the essence of the book uh which is that you know if you really understand your stakeholders if you really know what
  175. they're looking for and if you can uh deliver on that as part of your corporate responsibility uh initiatives
  176. then that's going to going back to your previous question that's going to uh help you capture more of the value from
  177. it than if you're just kind of doing it in a sort of scatter shock way let me add a quick one if I may and this is a
  178. different methodology and this was a secondary uh data study where uh with another co-author actually uh uh not the
  179. three who wrote the book but with another co-author I studied uh Fortune 1,000 companies and what we did was we
  180. related corporate responsibility to the market value of the firm and what we found there was that there was these
  181. interesting interactions between corporate responsibility and the product quality of the firm and and
  182. innovativeness of the firm and this data we got from Fortune's most admired companies and it turned out that you
  183. know corporate responsibility you know positively contributed to market value only in those contexts where the firm
  184. was perceived to have good product quality and was perceived to be Innovative uh which is interesting
  185. because it shows that mere engagement in corporate responsibility does not necessarily yield to kind of you know uh
  186. Better Business returns for for for the company but you have to as a company you
  187. have to have your house in order so to speak and you have to make sure that you know the fundamentals such as product
  188. quality and Innovation uh must be also up to Snuff you know before a firm goes out and kind of engages in in in in
  189. corporate responsibility so this one helps to tie the role of corporate responsibility with other kind of
  190. strategic elements of the firm in in a very nice way and again kind of makes it easier to for for Senior Management to
  191. see why corporate responsibility actually needs to be integrated into the business strategy great um what do you
  192. think is the most important Point uh managers need to remember about corporate responsibility uh that should
  193. guide their actions today and in the future okay um they should they should basically
  194. remember that again corporate responsibility has to be thought of in terms of a long run strategy that it
  195. it's not something that gives immediate returns you cannot make a difference uh in the immediate run and you have to
  196. kind of um work hard at it so if there's one thing we learned from the book is that it pays to be responsible only when
  197. your stakeholders perceive that there's some difference that you're making to the community and and and to the
  198. environment so the sincerity of the firm um is kind of you know is absolutely has
  199. to be U unquestionably there and if you make that difference then and only then can you can you reap reap the value so
  200. we say that there is value to be extracted but it's not it's not kind of you know um there to be grabbed it's
  201. it's not simple so you have to kind of work hard and make a difference to society and the environment to kind of
  202. kind of get that value out but it's a win-win for for all so the triple bottom line is not a zero sum game in other
  203. words which is seems to be kind of a belief in the in the corporate world that if we do uh invest in corporate
  204. responsibility we're doing that at the cost of our business I think our book clearly shows that that's that's not the
  205. case and the only thing I would add to that is um understand and respond to your
  206. stakeholders and it's easy to say but it's I think quite challenging at the operational level and I think if
  207. companies can figure out how to do that effectively um I think that would make a
  208. big difference thank you very much thank you thank you for having us [Music]

Brief Summary

CB Bhattacharya and Shenar Khosrowpour discuss corporate responsibility's growing importance and its impact on business strategy and stakeholder engagement.

Key points

  • The Rise of Corporate Responsibility. Stakeholders demand more from companies, pushing corporate responsibility to the forefront.
  • Awareness is Key. Low awareness of corporate responsibility efforts hinders consumer reward.
  • The Three U's Model. Understanding, usefulness, and unity drive stakeholder loyalty and positive outcomes.
  • Communicate Outcomes, Not Inputs. Focus on tangible results in corporate responsibility messaging to gain trust.
  • Social Value First. Creating social value is essential before achieving business value through responsibility.
  • The Value of Corporate Responsibility. Understanding stakeholders is key to capturing value from corporate responsibility initiatives.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes