Climate Crisis: Environmental Corporate Social Responsibility | Brian Berkey — Ripple Effect Podcast

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW: With time running short to stop catastrophic climate change, there is a moral and ethical imperative for companies and consumers to act now, according to Wharton Professor of Brian Berkey. In this conversation, he describes why decision-making must change in order to save the planet.

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 1:01 - Prof. Berkey’s interest in climate change 2:47 - Are discussing ethics enough? 5:55 - Is this a pivotal moment in society? 10:03 - Climate imperative vs. profit maximizing 13:43 - Defining “greenwashing” 15:58 - What needs to change?

PODCAST OVERVIEW: Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect

#climatechange #UPenn #Wharton #UniversityofPennsylvania #environment #ethics #ESG #businessethics #corporatesocialresponsibility #CSR ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. you know the idea that the world is just so convenient for everyone in the business world that you know doing
  2. what's kind of maximally good from the perspective of profit making will just always be consistent with kind of doing
  3. their part from a moral perspective to kind of address the threat of climate change this seems so improbable that
  4. there's just no good reason to believe it right I mean there's no evidence that tends to be kind of presented for this
  5. it's generally kind of Highly speculative welcome to the ripple effect the podcast
  6. that takes you on a journey through the minds of work and faculty I'm your host Dan Loney and in each episode we'll be
  7. diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton
  8. professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today we'll be covering a diverse
  9. range of topics bringing you the latest insights and knowledge that you can apply to your life into work so get
  10. ready to dive into new ideas with the ripple effect start I guess just where your interests
  11. around the issue of ethics and climate change really kind of formulated yeah so I wrote my dissertation
  12. um finished all the way back in in 2012 uh on our obligations to the global poor
  13. uh that was kind of the case that kind of focused my my theorizing um and one of the issues that I
  14. discussed uh is kind of how demanding our obligations can be there's kind of a debate in moral philosophy about what we
  15. call the demandingness of morality how much relatively well-off people are obligated to sacrifice in order to make
  16. the world a better place relieve suffering help people who are unjustly disadvantaged and so on uh and similar
  17. issues arise of course uh with respect to climate change uh although there um the challenge is that
  18. um the main kind of moral obligation that it seems like we have is to protect environmental conditions for future
  19. generations for people who don't already exist and there are a lot of kind of interesting philosophical puzzles about
  20. how we can have obligations to future people who don't yet exist what the nature of those obligations might be
  21. might be how we can explain them and then our answers to these questions have implications for uh what and exactly how
  22. much we ought to do in the face of the threat of climate change so that was uh a set of issues that I kind of took up
  23. after finishing my dissertation uh when I was in my first uh postdoctoral position
  24. how much do you think the question of Ethics around climate change comes up in a lot of the conversation today I think
  25. you know you get a lot about the data and and where we need to go but I'm wondering if the ethics side of it and
  26. the obligation as you said the moral obligations of companies and people kind of in this process comes up enough
  27. so I don't think it comes up enough I think there's a divide I think uh there are kind of people
  28. um who have certain kinds of um approaches to thinking about the challenge of climate change
  29. um that are such that in effect they really are kind of generally talking about ethics even if they're not kind of
  30. talking about it the way that you know people like me who are trained in moral philosophy talk about it right but
  31. they're thinking about uh you know am I required to uh you know Drive less and live in a smaller home and fly less and
  32. uh eat a vegan diet and you know do all of the kinds of things that um we as individuals can do to reduce
  33. our contributions to climate change they're also thinking about things like what sort of public policies we ought to
  34. have what sort of you know regulations we ought to have and thinking about it in the way that's characteristic of
  35. um ethical reasoning right they're thinking about you know what does Justice require that we do for future
  36. generations and so on um in other circles discussions of ethics seemed to me to happen much less right
  37. the goal uh that others have in kind of thinking about how we ought to approach climate change seems to be like trying
  38. to figure out kind of Technical Solutions um or uh you know kind of win-win Solutions
  39. ways that you know we might be able to kind of make progress on dealing with climate change without any of the
  40. relevant uh actors having to really sacrifice anything right uh and to the extent that it's possible to deal
  41. with climate change in this kind of way um you know we should kind of take advantage of of those opportunities but
  42. the worry that I have about this is that um it may not be possible to do that and
  43. you know we're kind of uh now especially short on time right we haven't done nearly enough or uh you know 30 plus
  44. years and so limiting our discussions to you know something like the question of
  45. uh is there a way that we can you know reduce our emissions enough to keep warming under two degrees or under 1.5
  46. degrees without you know having to sacrifice anything in the way of our current Lifestyles or corporate profits
  47. or other kinds of things that might in fact actually need to be kind of traded off uh against the aim of
  48. addressing climate change in a serious way um is I think it's kind of dangerous to
  49. kind of approach the issue only in that way so then potentially are we kind of in a pivot moment do you think at this
  50. time in terms of what's occurred in the past where we are at the moment and obviously as you said where we need to
  51. go in a relatively short time that that this is the time where action uh is is very important to move forward
  52. I mean action is certainly important at this point uh we we've done far too little for a very long time since we've
  53. known about the threat um that climate change poses and we really are running out of time right uh
  54. the experts now seem to think that uh you know we basically have less than 10 years at this point to bring about a
  55. pretty radical shift in emissions trajectories uh I mean if we're going to reach the goal of limiting warming to
  56. 1.5 degrees uh the most recent estimates suggest that we need to get to net zero
  57. emissions globally by 2050. and we need to make significant reductions by 2030. um
  58. that requires a great deal of change in a very short amount of time and given that what we've
  59. seen over the past 30 plus years is relatively little progress um you know the the sort of shift that
  60. is required um is you know to some extent kind of hard to get our minds around right I
  61. mean it would it would be quite transformational in ways that it's not obvious that we're prepared for
  62. you've talked uh in other interviews and other papers I remember about a climate
  63. of a climate imperative for business take us through what that is and and how you think this will factor in
  64. yeah so um I've got a paper that my colleague Eric ortz and I have been working on
  65. um in which we argue that uh approaches to business decision making that have kind of have kind of become
  66. standard um you know over the last you know say 50 years or so um that involve focusing at least
  67. primarily if not exclusively on uh increasing profits kind of within the limits of the law
  68. um has to be rejected in a pretty significant way uh in the face of of the threat of climate change uh the climate
  69. imperative idea is that whatever approach to business decision making we endorse it has to be
  70. consistent with a kind of serious commitment to do what's necessary uh and within business practices to
  71. sufficiently address the climate threat and so the imperative says that uh each business decision maker or say you know
  72. an executive of a corporation is obligated to take the threat of climate change into account in their decision
  73. making in a way that leads them to ensure that their firms emissions [Music] um are kind of no higher than is compatible
  74. with [Music] um basically doing their fair share right kind of on the assumption that everyone
  75. else is doing their fair share too in order to uh ensure that we kind of do enough to uh
  76. to mitigate the threat of climate change and for a lot of firms that would require pretty radically transforming
  77. the way that they do business and the way that their key decision makers go about reasoning about
  78. um you know how operations are going to be structured and what priorities are going
  79. to be um this is just necessary if we're going to um successfully deal with the threat
  80. so there is also the uh argument that climate of imperative and profit maximizing are compatible how do you
  81. look at that yeah so this is kind of what I was talking about a little bit before
  82. um so some people um suggest not always you know all that explicitly but you know they seem to kind of have in mind
  83. that uh firms don't really have to give up much if anything in the way of profits in
  84. order to kind of do their part when it comes to dealing with climate change you know people talk about you know
  85. opportunities to kind of shift business models in ways that will you know be even more profitable in the future uh
  86. but there's a degree of optimism that comes out of some hoarders that seems to me
  87. um at the very least exaggerated um you know the idea that the world is just so convenient for everyone in the
  88. business world that you know doing what's kind of maximally good from the perspective of profit making will just
  89. always be consistent with kind of doing their part from a moral perspective uh to kind of address the threat of climate
  90. change this seems so improbable that um there's just no good reason to believe it right I mean there's no
  91. evidence that tends to be kind of presented for this it's generally kind of Highly speculative and you know
  92. um of course there's something appealing about this kind of optimism it would be
  93. great if the world were like this and you know sometimes there are these sort of fortunate uh situations where there
  94. aren't kind of serious trade-offs that have to be made between competing and priorities but you know the world isn't
  95. always like that um you know one of the obvious examples to point to of course is
  96. um oil companies uh you know companies that are in the fossil fuel extraction business if you kind of look at
  97. um their plans right there were some articles uh that got some attention back in I think
  98. 2019 2020 that um highlighted that uh a number of the major Global fossil fuel firms uh are
  99. planning increased extraction uh up through about 2030 or the early 2030s uh that's their current business plan and
  100. so uh those who think that there's no conflict between profit maximizing and the climate imperative have to either
  101. think that uh you know the decision makers that these firms are just really bad business people they're really bad
  102. at you know pursuing profits in the best possible way they're just making a kind
  103. of deep mistake about what's going to be you know best in terms of profits for their firms because that's you know
  104. surely that's kind of what's driving these these decisions but in fact you know if the optimists are right these
  105. firms would do better by you know planning to reduce extraction and move in different directions but you know
  106. that just seems like like um it's unlikely to be true right uh the people who are making these decisions
  107. are well informed they kind of know what they're doing they're competent business
  108. people um from my perspective they're just making decisions that are ethically problematic yeah uh they're not kind of
  109. taking the the moral importance of dealing with the climate threat sufficiently seriously but they probably
  110. are doing what's best in terms of profits for uh for their firms right and that hence brings us to the
  111. topic of green watching uh which is a a term that you know comes up quite often these days and you know basically the
  112. philosophy of a company saying one thing and doing another basically looking out for the profits
  113. and maybe not necessarily looking out for what they said that they were going to do and I guess the question is how
  114. prevalent do you think that is these days and how much impact is it having on the overall discussion around climate
  115. right now to begin with yeah I mean unfortunately uh you know I think it's fairly common
  116. um there is I think increasing pressure on firms to say the right things about you know
  117. their commitments on climate and kind of environmental issues more broadly um unfortunately for kind of reasons
  118. having to do with uh information that uh you know ordinary individuals can kind of uh realistically
  119. kind of uh process and so on um there's less pressure on firms to actually do all of the good things that
  120. they might be claiming to do um uh you know it's often possible for firms to kind of engage in
  121. um you know rhetoric that makes it kind of sound like they have all these really
  122. good commitments without um you know doing nearly as much as the rhetoric suggests they're doing and
  123. given that um you know there's still um a kind of dominant practice in business decision making of aiming again
  124. primarily if not exclusively at maximizing profits within constraints like the law
  125. um it's not surprising that uh it's fairly common for firms to kind of exaggerate
  126. how much good they're doing for you know climate or or kind of other uh you know
  127. other important purposes um you know in large part as a kind of marketing tool right uh given that a lot
  128. of people um do care about these issues so then what do you think needs to change at this point
  129. playing off of the mindset that as you alluded to before that you know change needs to occur and it needs to occur in
  130. a fairly quick fashion in order to be able to meet some of the targets that uh that experts have talked about what
  131. needs to change either from a corporate or a public perspective uh angle in order to make the change and
  132. get to the right uh to the right level uh of dealing with this issue yeah I mean quite a few things need to change I
  133. mean we're in a situation where we need to accomplish a great deal uh in a short
  134. period of time and make pretty significant changes to you know the way that businesses do
  135. things the way that kind of we as individuals do things in our in our personal lives and and so on um so uh I
  136. mean there are kind of multiple Dimensions to uh kind of what needs to to happen so you know as uh Eric Gordon
  137. and I have argued uh one of the things that needs to happen is that uh the norms for business decision making uh
  138. need to change in some pretty significant ways um you know corporate Executives and
  139. kind of others who have have impacts on on the way that businesses operate need to be taking the threat of climate
  140. change much more directly into account than they have been for for a long time uh in deciding
  141. um you know what their what the policies of of their organizations are going to look
  142. like what practices they're going to adopt and things like this um and sometimes they're going to have
  143. to make choices that involve sacrificing at least some degree of profitability for
  144. the sake of making a greater contribution to dealing with the threat of climate change uh the other side of
  145. that is we all as consumers need to change the way that we think about kind of how we interact with with firms what
  146. kinds of purchasing decisions we make um you know ultimately dealing with the threat of climate change is going to
  147. require [Music] um I think some fairly significant cultural changes right people need to be willing
  148. to make some choices about how they kind of live their own lives that are different from the ones
  149. that we're used to making so we need to um buy less stuff that's climate that's uh
  150. yeah emissions intensive to produce uh you know we need to be willing to you know okay
  151. take public transit when it's available rather than driving everywhere in uh you know smaller homes that uh
  152. it's energy to heat and heat and cool you know things like this I mentioned earlier adopting a vegan or at least a
  153. vegetarian diet um you know is one way of uh reducing one's kind of personal uh contributions
  154. to greenhouse gas emissions it's morally good for other reasons too so there are all kinds of things like
  155. this and of course um the choices at the different levels impact each other right the more
  156. consumer Behavior changes in the directions that I'm describing the more that firms will have to
  157. um change their business practices to kind of cater to the changing consumer preferences right so right you know if a
  158. lot of people start um adopting a vegan diet right that's going to require um uh you know companies that are
  159. producing um you know meat and dairy to produce less and maybe move into producing uh
  160. different kinds of options that are less carbon intensive uh you know the same goes for uh you know kind of other areas
  161. in which we might uh change our choices as as individuals so can you look out then five years ten
  162. years and think about where you think we need to be at that point uh and I would say
  163. it's not even hoping but but you know wanting to see significant change and and where we might be on a lot of these
  164. issues in the next decade or so yeah um you know it's hard to kind of paint a detailed picture in our minds of kind of
  165. what the world would have to look like if we're going to actually succeed in dealing with the threat
  166. um you know one of the sources of some optimism is that uh you know younger people seem to care about
  167. this issue a great deal uh that's not surprising uh they're going to be around a lot longer than uh than people who are
  168. a bit older and uh you know are going to have to live through some of the you know the really kind of troubling
  169. effects that you know we're already starting to see um now um so certain kinds of policy changes that
  170. have been resisted for a long time uh might be possible um as uh you know more and more younger
  171. people are involved in the political process and you know frankly as uh kind of more members of older Generations are
  172. no longer around to vote uh but you know there's um some concern about that too because uh
  173. there are kind of structural incentives in the climate change case uh to always kind of put off action a little bit
  174. longer and a little bit longer and a little bit longer right because when we actually do start uh
  175. doing more uh you know in a serious way to kind of address the threat than at least if I'm right uh you know that's
  176. likely to involve some genuine sacrifices for um you know people who are around when uh
  177. when we start making those changes uh and it's always kind of easy to say well you know a little bit longer won't hurt
  178. a little bit longer won't hurt but there's some kind of interesting um philosophical papers that kind of
  179. highlight in in detail kind of why this structure um makes dealing with a problem like
  180. climate change so challenging it's unlike most of the other uh problems that we faced uh in uh in
  181. society and kind of globally throughout history thank you for listening to the ripple
  182. effect we hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that
  183. we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the Wharton School

Brief Summary

The episode discusses ethics in climate change, corporate responsibility, and the urgent need for action to address the crisis.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Join host Dan Loney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton professors.
  • Urgency of Action. Experts believe we have less than 10 years to make significant emissions reductions.
  • The Climate Imperative. A call for businesses to prioritize climate change in decision-making.
  • Consumer Behavior Change. Individual choices can drive corporate practices towards sustainability.
  • The Challenge of Climate Change. Climate change presents unique challenges unlike other societal problems throughout history.
  • Thank You for Listening. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe!

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes