What’s Next for ESG this Earth Day? Climate, Policy & Profit in 2025

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

This Earth Day 2025, ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) issues are under renewed scrutiny amid a shifting political climate and evolving economic landscape. Wharton School Vice Dean Vit Hennish joins to break down the current state of ESG, discussing key topics like ESG investing, greenwashing, and climate risk management. With billion-dollar climate losses on the rise, this conversation explores the long-term financial implications and strategic importance of ESG for business leaders, investors, and policymakers.

#ESG #Greenwashing #SustainableInvesting #CorporateResponsibility ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, the change in administration after the November election led many to expect big changes in various
  2. areas of government, with the impact felt in numerous areas outside of Washington, DC. One area to focus on is that of ESG.
  3. Where do each of those components stand at this moment, especially as we approach Earth Day here in 2025? Pleasure to be
  4. joined by Vit Henisz, who is a Vice Dean and Faculty Director of the ESG Initiative here at the Wharton School. He's also
  5. Professor of Management. Vit, great to talk to you again. How are you? - Doing well. Pleasure to be back with you, Dan.
  6. All right. So when you think of ESG right now, where do you think things stand at the moment?
  7. We're in the midst of a big shakeout, and a really important one. The tides have turned from this being kind of all things to
  8. all people, and popular, and a win- win, to a much more critical perspective. I think in some ways that's helpful. A lot of
  9. the greenwash is going away. Doesn't make sense to claim you're doing something that you're not doing. But there's
  10. also a lot of concern around what does it mean to advocate, to be out there as an ESG leader? To be putting your neck out?
  11. And could you get a boot on your neck if you do demonstrate that kind of leadership? So we're really seeing people
  12. staying a little more quiet. A lot of the hard work is still going on. And I think in the end, counter-intuitively, we'll be
  13. better off for having had this shakeout. But it's not pleasant in the midst of it.
  14. You and I talked a while back about the investment component that has been brought into ESG. Where does that stand
  15. at the moment? And obviously, the dynamics of where the global economy is right now may be factoring in as well.
  16. Well, there's still a long-term financial interest in being attentive and taking into account environmental, social
  17. and governance information. I think it's really important, just— I mean, as part of this conversation, let's just level
  18. set what we mean by ESG. ESG is the systematic inclusion of financially material environmental, social and
  19. governance information as part of an investment or strategy- making process. Why would you want to leave any financially
  20. material information out? I mean, at some level, it should be in there. So there is still investor interest in this. But
  21. some of the idea that it generates quick returns, or that it's easy, or you can just buy some off-the-shelf data, or that
  22. it always outperforms, that never held up. And it's been exposed, and people are nervous. So fund flows are coming out of ESG
  23. funds, because there's a lot of concern about short-term performance, about who's actually doing the hard work,
  24. and who's safe to invest in. Was the firm I was invested in just engaged in greenwash? So there's a lot of concern and
  25. trepidation, but the long-term impact of bringing more and better information into your calculation and being attentive
  26. to things like the climate transition, those long-term factors are still there, and there's still a lot of capital
  27. who's interested in this space. So because we have Earth Day coming up, let me have you focus
  28. on the environmental side specifically when you think about where things stand.
  29. Well, look, Earth Day doesn't change the importance of the climate transition or of climate information, right? I mean, the
  30. fact that we're already at or exceeding a 1 1/2- degree warming scenario, that highlights the importance of the
  31. E. E, S and G are all factors that have been left out. E is probably the easiest to measure and the most visible when we
  32. look out our windows, when we walk to work, or when we face some of these extreme storms we're having. I just jotted down
  33. some statistics before we started. For 25— sorry— for 25 years, from 1980 to 2004, we averaged $9 billion insured
  34. climate losses a year globally. Nine. From 2004 to 2020, it went up to $23. From 2020 to 2024, $27. Last year we had $28. These are
  35. billion-dollar losses. So we're seeing extreme weather. We're seeing extreme storms. That's not changing, and that's why
  36. there's so much attentiveness to the climate transition. Earth Day draws our attention to it. It draws our focus on it. But 27
  37. times a year, last year, we read about a billion-dollar loss caused by extreme weather. That should be keeping our attention
  38. well beyond Earth Day. And I was going to say, if you're talking about those types
  39. of losses in the scope of a company and their bottom line, things would change real fast.
  40. Well, you know, they are affecting companies and bottom lines, right? You know, we're seeing more worker accidents on
  41. days of extreme weather, when wet bulb temperatures get up over 100 or 110. We are seeing more companies whose supply
  42. chains are being disrupted because you can't access a canal, or you can't access— you know, your facilities have been
  43. flooded by a typhoon in Asia. So companies are being affected. But you're right, Dan, that the— it's not easy to fix climate
  44. change for any one company. It's impossible, actually. Takes companies and countries working together. And that is harder
  45. today, and that is a real problem with the current policy environment. It's much harder to get the coordinated action among
  46. governments, companies, across industries, to navigate and achieve a slowing down of the global warming that we're
  47. experiencing. So because of the dynamics we have here in the United States right
  48. now, then, maybe does the focus go more on the state and local level in terms of maybe trying to make some effective policy
  49. change? Because at times the federal level just— it becomes too much of a mess for a lot of people.
  50. Well, we are seeing some leadership on some of these issues. States like California and New York are pushing forward. But we're also
  51. seeing some states moving in the opposite direction and saying, "You know what? You can't include this information. If you include
  52. this information, you're in violation of state law and state policies." We're seeing that more in states like Texas and
  53. Florida. So you know, states having the right to go their own way— you know, you'll see more extremes on both sides. And
  54. there's some concern— including, I think, importantly, in the red states, where the state banking associations and some investors
  55. are saying, "Wait a minute, why can't we include this information? You know, this is— this is affecting our state too."
  56. I mean, think about the state of Florida. If you couldn't incorporate environmental or climate-related information into
  57. your investments in real estate, that wouldn't be really smart real estate investing if you didn't take into account sea
  58. level rise and hurricanes that are hitting the state of Florida. That same argument applies more broadly to state
  59. of Florida pension owners. So I think we're seeing pushback among asset owners about whether it's a good idea to rule this
  60. out. So there is more variation at the state level. It's not all good. It's not all in a way that's more informed than the
  61. national policy. Some states are actually being more retrograde and restrictive than even the federal government.
  62. How then do you look at the future around ESG? Well, I think in the long term, I'm confident that we'll better
  63. price financially material environmental, social and governance factors. The financial incentives to do so
  64. and to avoid ignoring it are just too great. But over what time horizon, and what does it look like from here to that?
  65. What I'm really concerned about is, in the short term, firms are going quiet. Even the firms that are doing the work or trying to
  66. figure this out aren't sharing as much. They're not talking as much about what they're doing, which makes it harder to
  67. understand who are the leaders? Who do I want to invest in, or who are the leaders in adapting and being resilient, and who's
  68. coming up with the new technologies? There's just much less sharing of information. And I worry— and also some sense
  69. that if we do share, if we do go out and talk about what we're doing and how we're trying to make progress, we might be
  70. punished. We might be targeted for some sort of political retribution. That means, in the short term, especially in the
  71. United States, we're going to move much less quickly towards investing in the kinds of technologies that could enable
  72. the climate transition. Because we're already in a 1 1/2- degree scenario, and we're rapidly accelerating that, the
  73. consequences of waiting, the consequences of delay are going to be many more of those billion- dollar losses that I described
  74. earlier. So you go from $27 a year to $30 to $35 to $40 a year. I mean, we can't predict exactly what, but the trend
  75. is pretty clear. And that's going to have real consequences. So I think eventually we'll get there. The
  76. financial reasons to do so are really strong. But it may be a much rockier next five to 10 to 20 years before we do that. And
  77. it's not going to be as coordinated, as you mentioned. Different states are enacting different policies. The European
  78. Union is doing one thing. The US is doing the opposite. Asia is working on a set of policies. What is China doing? China is
  79. continuing to double down in electric vehicles and pollution reduction. We might cede some of the potential leadership in the
  80. space to the Chinese economies and the Chinese peer companies. Is that in the long-term interest of the US and its
  81. competitive advantage? I don't think so. Vit, always great to talk to you. Thanks very much, sir.
  82. All right, it's a pleasure, Dan. - You got it. Vit Henisz, Vice Dean, Faculty Director of the ESG Initiative, and Management
  83. Professor here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Vit Henisz discusses the shifting landscape of ESG initiatives and the urgent need for climate action as Earth Day approaches.

Key points

  • The ESG Shakeout. Vit Henisz discusses the critical shift in ESG perspectives, moving from popularity to scrutiny.
  • Earth Day and Climate Transition. The significance of Earth Day in relation to ongoing climate challenges is emphasized.
  • Future of ESG Investment. Concerns about the short-term quietness of firms in ESG and its implications for investment.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes