Basel III, CFPB, and the Future of U.S. Financial Regulation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The Wharton School Professor David Zaring explains how banking regulation could shift under a Trump or Biden administration, including key differences in approach to Basel III and the CFPB. He explores how reputational risk and regulatory oversight may evolve for U.S. banks. Insights include potential changes for mid-sized banks and global capital standards.

#FinancialRegulation #CryptoRegulation #EconomicPolicy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: One expectation as the Trump administration took office was that the regulatory landscape might see some significant
  2. change, and that still could be some of the case with some of the potential impacts playing out. But will the regulations
  3. themselves change, especially in and around the banking sector? Pleasure should be joined right now by David Zaring, who is
  4. Professor of Legal Studies and Business Ethics here at the Wharton School. Hi, David, great to talk to you again. David Zaring: It's great
  5. to be here, Dan. - All right, so as the election played out and you're thinking about the landscape of regulation, what
  6. were your thoughts about what we potentially could see us with some of the rhetoric that had been put out
  7. there? - Yeah, I thought there could be some real differences between sort of second Biden term and Trump administration term. Maybe
  8. not as many in financial regulation as you might see in other places. The Biden administration had tried very
  9. hard to get a new capital rule across the finish line, and they eventually failed to do that. So I assumed they were going to
  10. come back with something. But the Trump administration has also said, or at least Chairman Powell has said, that the Fed
  11. wants to do a Basel III Endgame rule. That's the rule that the Biden administration couldn't get done. And so we'll
  12. see if that happens. But in some ways, I think financial regulation may well be different. I think there's a
  13. concern that there's too burdensome set of sort of oversight on normal banks, and that's going to change maybe.
  14. There will be some tailoring of rules to make it more modest. The CFPB is obviously going to be completely different over the
  15. course between the Biden administration the Trump administration. That's the Consumer Financial Protection
  16. Bureau, which the Trump administration looks like they kind of want to shut down. And then, I think, has a really
  17. different approach to crypto. - So is it not necessarily then the regulations themselves, but
  18. how maybe the agencies would work? You mentioned the CFPB. There's talk about, you know, maybe some changes and different
  19. approach there. There's talk about maybe cutting regulators from the Treasury Department. So it might not necessarily be the
  20. regulations, but how these agencies work. - Yeah, I think that will be something -- excuse me. And one of
  21. the things that you have seen, and I wonder if this will change a little bit, but banks used to be worried that their
  22. supervisors would sanction them on the basis of reputational risk, and that is the risk that you're sort of doing business
  23. with some unsavory or maybe unsound clients. That's going to be bad for your reputation. And banks complained a lot during
  24. the Biden administration that they were being sort of encouraged to de-bank crypto firms and to maybe consider
  25. getting out of energy lending because of reputational risk. You don't want to be seen as somebody who's opposed to, you
  26. know, caring about the planet, that kind of thing. And the Trump administration is completely getting rid of
  27. reputational risk as something supervisors can consider. But the way they did it is kind of interesting, because they just
  28. sent out a memo to all their supervisors and told them to stop considering reputational risk. So the problem there is
  29. in the next, you know, Elizabeth Warren, or whatever administration, she can just rescind that memo and put
  30. back another memo. And so that's a difference where, you know, personnel is all that matters, but personnel
  31. doesn't always change regulation for forever. And so I sort of wonder if they'll think about doing a rule making on stuff
  32. like reputational risk, which would be more permanent. - Does this, to a degree, though, show how much the focus around the
  33. banking sector in the wake of the financial crisis, you know, the changes that were made were really even maybe more
  34. substantive than we gave them credit for? - Yeah, I think there was some sense that, you know, the
  35. Dodd Frank and the Obama administration, after the financial crisis, didn't do enough to reform a financial
  36. system that had really gone awry. And I thought that the pandemic suggested that maybe the Obama administration had
  37. done a pretty good job there. The banking system really sailed through that crisis with flying colors. And you know, it was not
  38. an easy crisis for other sectors of the economy by any stretch of the imagination. So that is, you know,
  39. a reform that maybe worked out fine. And now the question is, as the financial crisis gets further and further in the rear
  40. view mirror, you know, banks are going to complain, "We're being over regulated. You know, when we finalize this Basel III
  41. Capital rule, you're departing too much from the minimum standards that is really where we should be to
  42. create a level playing field at the global level, and not, you know, gold plate there." And I
  43. think that we're seeing a current administration that looks like it's going to be receptive to some of those
  44. complaints. And so there, you may not just see difference in personnel and policy of the
  45. administration, but some sort of more longer term efforts to ease that regulatory burden. - Well
  46. take a moment and talk for a second about Basel III and the potential impact that it could have, because we talk so much
  47. about, you know, the banking sector in the US, but there are certainly been instances we've seen play out in the last few
  48. years of banks overseas and in Europe specifically, that have had their issues and have kind of gone awry of the rules.
  49. - Yeah, yeah. No, I think it's fair to say that, you know, American regulators kind of take the position that European
  50. banks are systematically under capitalized, and that doesn't matter for all of them, but that does mean that some of them are
  51. not sort of resilient to a bunch of crises which have proven to be problematic for the European Union where the economy isn't so
  52. great, and so the banking sector is finding that lending is difficult and asset valuations are hard to improve upon. And
  53. then in addition, you had this effort to sort of finalize the Basel III Capital Accords to make sure that everybody was
  54. well capitalized. And that sort of hit a pause right now, because the United States can't figure out exactly what it wants
  55. to do. And so the European Union said, "Okay, well, we'll wait to see what happens in America, and depending on what they do,
  56. that'll affect what we do." And the same thing goes for the United Kingdom as well. So, you know, we had this sort of global
  57. agreement that was supposed to create uniform standards for banks, and it's largely done that. But the most recent effort
  58. to, you know, improve upon those standards is really kind of in turnaround while everybody waits to see what, if anything, the
  59. United States does. - Well, then I'll wrap it up with this. What are you most watchful on then right now, in terms of
  60. how the landscape could potentially be adjusted in the months ahead? - I will be interested in seeing if the US is serious about
  61. finalizing its Basel III obligations. I'll kind of be interested in knowing, once it does that, what's it think about
  62. these mid-sized regional banks? There's a ton of them in Europe, and there were some in the United States. And there was a
  63. blip in 2023 that really affected those regional banks. And so one of the things that the Biden administration's
  64. proposal wanted to do was bring them into the toughest aspect of Basel III. And I think it's a very open question as to whether
  65. the next administration, the current administration, will continue that effort. So I'll be interested to see, does Basel
  66. happen? If it does, what happens to those mid-sized banks in the United States? And then I'll be looking at sort of gobbledygook
  67. stuff like the supplemental leverage ratio and whether that continues to be applied or exempts treasury bills. Banks
  68. care a lot about this, and hopefully your listeners do too. - Yeah, absolutely. Hey, David, always great to chat. Thanks
  69. very much for your time today. All the best. - Yeah, happy to do it. - You got it. David Zaring, Professor of Legal Studies and
  70. Business Ethics here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

David Zaring discusses potential changes in U.S. banking regulations under different administrations and the implications of Basel III.

Key points

  • Basel III Endgame Rule. The Trump administration aims to implement a Basel III Endgame rule, a significant shift in financial regulation.
  • Reputational Risk in Banking. The Trump administration is eliminating reputational risk considerations for bank supervisors, changing the regulatory landscape.
  • Impact of Dodd-Frank. The Dodd-Frank reforms may have been more effective than previously thought, as the banking system thrived during the pandemic.
  • Future of Mid-Sized Banks. The future of mid-sized regional banks hangs in the balance as Basel III obligations are considered.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes