Obama Correct on Net Neutrality

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Technology

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. i'd like to welcome reid hunt to knowledge at wharton today reid is a former chairman of the federal
  2. communications commission i want to ask you what you think about the president president obama recently coming out in
  3. favor of net neutrality i ask you as a former chairman of the fcc and uh obviously knowledgeable about these
  4. issues but also in the context there's a professor here kevin wereback who has said along with others that the real
  5. danger to the internet ecosystem in the us is the dearth of competition at the broadband
  6. provider level so in light of all that what what was your what's your view on net neutrality and what's what's
  7. happened based on the president's statements so there are two things about the president's statement the first is that
  8. he made his statement on youtube this is a case where the medium is the message he was basically saying you see me on
  9. youtube here everybody in america ought to have the capability to get access to this content or any other
  10. content they want without having to ask the permission of the internet service provider
  11. he was basically saying without without using these words the internet service provider should not
  12. be a sensor or an editor or a gatekeeper who says what website you can get to or
  13. whether or not when you get to that website you can actually watch the video in a high enough quality
  14. he was basically saying there shouldn't be any discrimination imposed on your personal preferences
  15. by the fact that you're limited to just one or two companies that are giving you
  16. internet service so it should access like a telephone line in the old days and you can call anyone you want is that
  17. the idea that's basically what he said um so that was pretty cool the medium was the message right uh and the second
  18. thing he said was he didn't use exactly these words but i think this was also pretty pretty clear
  19. fcc you have had a lot of trouble getting the courts to accept your rules and you've clued together lots of
  20. different compromises just say the following there is one single common medium of communication for the
  21. united states and from the world and it is called the internet it doesn't need a lot of rules but from
  22. time to time we might need the fcc to establish some rules that will guarantee just two things
  23. everybody will have access to this medium and number two when you have access to
  24. it you get to go to the websites that you want to and you get to do the picking that's what he told the fcc now what
  25. that means legally is please invoke title ii of the law but his message was not meant to be
  26. bogged down in the legal niceties he was saying just do it declare it title ii you don't need that many rules but you
  27. do need to give a guarantee to all americans that they can share as a community in the internet and they can
  28. get to the websites and to the content that they want to reach now that addresses the consumer accessing the
  29. internet behind the internet you have providers you know the netflix and others of the
  30. world who want sort of unrestricted access or they don't they don't want to be in a slow lane does the president's
  31. comments also affect that side of the internet also yes the president in effect is saying to the fcc
  32. suppose that the internet service provider cuts a sweetheart deal with some particular content company
  33. and the purpose of that deal is to exclude some competitor to that content company
  34. suppose that uh the internet service provider says i like nbc and abc but i don't i'm going
  35. to give them the ability to use the internet to broadcast their material not just over the year
  36. but i don't like the local broadcasters so much so i'm going to keep that person
  37. out of the package the president was saying you can't do that that's another way to discriminate
  38. against different content providers and i want everyone to have the chance to sell on
  39. the internet and everyone to have the chance to buy on the internet at the same speed always or he's saying roughly
  40. the act quality of the access needs to be approximately equal okay uh anything else that we that
  41. that we should learn from that statement what's likely to happen i know there's been it's been difficult for congress to
  42. come to any agreement on on any sort of rules and to give the fcc much direction
  43. there's been conflicting directions that have been trying to be there are five commissioners at the fcc uh three are
  44. democrats two are republicans i would imagine that the president doesn't expect the
  45. republican commissioners to agree with his position unfortunately as pretty much everyone in
  46. the united states knows the president has really had a hard time getting republicans in congress or at the fcc or
  47. in the senate to agree with him on any topic and i know that he's tried and he's
  48. tried and he's tried so the president then really needs the three democrats at the fcc
  49. to listen to pay attention to to inwardly digest and ultimately to decide to agree that the
  50. president is right i think that they will so um looking at the long game you think that
  51. this is a game changer moment i do i don't think it has tremendous uh economic significance for any of the
  52. content companies or any of the internet service providers they aren't right now basing their
  53. business plans on discrimination but you just want to be careful to make sure as a government
  54. that if somebody gets unchallenged to monopoly position in internet service or builds a tremendous
  55. vertical integration business where content and conduit are combined that you could step in and
  56. protect the little guy against the powerful and that's why it's right for the fcc to
  57. declare that it does have the jurisdiction to look out for everybody in the country
  58. if needed so it's providing a level or will provide if all is approved a level of certainty
  59. that's been missing this regulation that we're talking about is called title ii and some people will say to title two or
  60. not to title two that is the question i would say that really for the agency it is to be or not to be
  61. if you're an agency and you don't have a jurisdictional basis you don't have the
  62. legal authority to pass rules then you're out of business thanks very much you

Brief Summary

Reid Hunt discusses net neutrality and President Obama's support for equal internet access in this episode.

Related episodes