Redesigning the Business Model

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Innovation 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. my colleague Chris do and myself over started to do a research program that addresses the broad question of how
  2. firms do business and that is the business model the business model really a system of
  3. activities that are um interdependent and that create value for the stakeholders of the firm let me give you
  4. an example Apple so Apple in the old days uh you know produced the designed the hardware
  5. produced some of the hardware or assembled some of the hardware and then sold that hardware and the value
  6. creation was through the sale of Hardware enter the iPod that was a profound change in the business model of
  7. Apple because Apple realized that they can create value for the stakeholders by not just selling a gadget which is
  8. nicely designed but also create value through the use of the gadget so Apple in introducing the I the iPod profoundly
  9. changed it business model by having relationship with the music industry the owners of the intellectual property to
  10. the various songs convincing those Studios to sell by the song not by the CD and then through an electronic store
  11. iTune enabled people to download selected music and every time and a song was downloaded Apple got a share of the
  12. um proceeds and therefore the stakeholders of Apple namely the customer it created value for the
  13. customers created value for the shareholders the owners of apple and obviously for the emplo employees of
  14. Apple so the business model once again engage is a description of how the firm does business and it is a system of
  15. activities and when they introduced the iPod new activities were added and and and the value that was created by this
  16. modified business model was enhanced because there were new stakeholders note that the
  17. stakeholders um are they span both firm and Industry boundaries who would think that the
  18. computer company would be in the music business and suddenly Apple was literally in the music business so so
  19. over the years ER Chris who is now a yeser business school in Barcelona Spain and I have addressed a number of issues
  20. that relate to the business model for example what are the elements of a business model what is the what are
  21. activities that descri the content what is the structure how are those activities combined to create a system
  22. and as importantly the governance of the business model who carries out each activity we ask question how does a
  23. business model create value what are the fundamental value drivers in the business model and that's where we
  24. create created the so-called nice business model and we ask managers to ask themselves is our business model
  25. nice nice stands for novelty lock in complementarity and efficiency and these are the fundamental H value drivers what
  26. I'd like to talk about today is another aspect of the business model and that is the process by which
  27. companies go through the design of the business model and much of the work that has been done so far focused on the
  28. content of what is a business model how does the business model create value and
  29. so on but very little work has been done on how organizations design the business model
  30. how do they modify the business model and this applies by the way to early stage organizations you know new
  31. startups and to establish organizations you know we thought about when if you think about what do managers do
  32. obviously they have to come up among other things they have to Le the organization and develop the strategy
  33. how are they going to compete the business model answers a different question how are we going to do
  34. business so that's the essence of our research program and what I hope to be able to share today is the result of a
  35. study on the process of developing a business model what our research on the process
  36. of Designing a business model established is that by building on a method techology that was adopted for
  37. the purpose of product design by idio which is a leading design company in the Bay
  38. Area in on the west coast and applying it to the design of the business model we developed a five
  39. phase process that is embedded in the understanding of the antecedent for the design of the business model so the some
  40. of the work we have done has established that when a company designs its business
  41. model it doesn't do it in in a vacuum it doesn't do it it it has to do it um in by considering a number of antecedents
  42. for example what is the goal of the business model that's one antecedent what are some of the templates that
  43. other companies have been using and to some extent thoughtfully and mindfully adopting some of these templates at
  44. another anteceding understanding who are the stakeholders of the organization that would benefit from that business
  45. model and obviously looking at constraint whether these are Financial constraint human capital constraint
  46. regulatory constraint or any other set of constraints that would affect what the firm can and cannot do H for any one
  47. of these reasons I just mentioned so once these antecedents are acknowledged and communicated then there is a process
  48. that we suggest in that research paper that involves five steps first to observe to to to look to do a little bit
  49. of an ethnographic study how people use your product or your service what what do they like what don't they like when
  50. do they use it how do they use it who uses it and so forth who make the dying decision how the buying decision is make
  51. so lots of observation is involved then there's a period phase of synthesis taking all this information that you
  52. observe trying to pull it together then there is a point of taking this information and generating some
  53. prototype business model saying this is one idea of how we do business here's another idea of how we do business and
  54. let's compare them and therefore and and refine them as we think about it more rigorously and more definitely and then
  55. the last phase in this process would be implementation and that observation cycle you know observation synthesis um
  56. generation refinement and implementation should be an ongoing process it's not a
  57. static process it's a dynamic process which which The Firm should never sit still and say this is how we do business
  58. and we work in silos our our main observation here is the need for people in the organization to think in a
  59. holistic way not to think in the silos to take an broader view of the organization
  60. not just of the activity they involved in and that we believe based on the research that we have done will create
  61. value for all the stakeholders in fact this process paper is an attempt to generalize our past
  62. research that focused on young emerging companies and this was our attempt to move from focusing and empirically
  63. examining young emerging go companies to establishing to to focusing on multi- business large Global Diversified
  64. companies what I'd like to do is give you two examples what are the implications of
  65. not adopting a process of continuously updating and revising your business model look at a company like Blackberry
  66. Blackberry dominated the smartphone industry in government in business and among
  67. consumers everybody Blackberry almost became a verb in American society even the president of the United
  68. States used the Blackberry and blackberry stuck to a particular way of doing business and ignored the changes that
  69. are happening in telecommunication in the ability of wireless network to transmit videos and
  70. and other graphical information and they have not adopted the business model and today Blackberry
  71. is in a in suddenly in Decline and according to some on the verge of bankruptcy another example of a company
  72. that had not adopted its business model is Nokia that at one point was by far the largest market share holder in terms
  73. of handset for while communication today they dispose of their handset business and in Decline to
  74. a very small percentage of the number of the global number of handset that are being sold they've been taken over by
  75. the likes of Samsung and Apple ER HTC and others going to give you a concrete example of a company that totally
  76. transformed Itself by transforming a business its business model is IBM IBM historically was a product Center
  77. centered companies they sold computers they sold disc drives they sold tape drives they sold a number of
  78. boxes today the vast majority of IBM Revenue comes from Services where the product are means to an end are means to
  79. deliver the service that's a profound transformation of how IBM does business today the most profitable part of the
  80. company are not the boxes are the services the largest fraction of the revenue of IBM comes from services not
  81. from the boxes so IBM is a good example of a global multinational a large Diversified firm
  82. who has undertaken a profound updating or revision of its historical business model and
  83. and such enabled it to stay on top We Believe based on the review that we have done that we are the first one
  84. to focus exclusively on the process of business model Innovation there has been a realization that business model
  85. Innovation matters but before we did this study no one has really rigorously looked at the
  86. process of how how you innovate your business model and that's where we believe our main contribution
  87. lies I think the main there are two main takeaway that I think we should pay close attention to first they need to
  88. apply design thinking to the design of the business model traditionally design thinking has been applied to the design
  89. of products and what we have established through this research project that the process by which firms design the
  90. business model can in it off itself create enormous value that's the first thing and the second takeaway that I
  91. think is important to to um understand and internalize is that that firms need to
  92. develop a capability to continuously ask themselves how how to tweak our business
  93. model how to refine our business model how to revise so this is an organizational capability that needs to
  94. become part of the DNA of the firm so the business model needs to change as the environment in which the
  95. firm competes in changes and if it is if there is a realization in the organization that each and every one
  96. member of the organization needs to look at are we still doing business in a way
  97. that maximizes the value creation potential and the answer therefore is that designing the business model is no
  98. longer just a job that the CEO has to do each and every member has to ask thems is the activity that I'm involved in is
  99. another way to do this activity how do the activi that I'm involved in relate to other activities that are going on in
  100. our firm that create value for our stakeholders and when I talk about stakeholders there are obviously the
  101. customers of the firm they are the partners of the firm they are the owners of the firm and the employees and
  102. managers of the firm to pick a few stakeholders and all of them need to be considered in sying through the design
  103. of the business model so these are the two main takeaways a again design doesn't just apply to product design
  104. applies very much to design of how firms do business and secondly the point that
  105. this has to be a continuous activity that becomes part of the DNA of the firm on one hand
  106. the impact of the design of the business model on the performance of The Firm has
  107. been substantial greater than what I would have anticipated exante but what surprised me most is how rare are the
  108. organizations that we surveyed and talk to where the design of the the process of Designing the the business model is
  109. part of the DNA of the firm you know very few organization routinely think how can we tweak our business model how
  110. can we find a better more efficient greater value creating business model and and and that surprised me and and
  111. and and I think that managers and organizations more generally would benefit by thinking deeper about the
  112. design and thinking about it not as a one time you know once in two years thinking is is a better way but as an
  113. ongoing if you will Dynamic capability that the firm has and it's up to the leadership of the company to instill
  114. that kind of design thinking into the DNA of the firm and the fact that this is rare was a surprise to
  115. me in our view the perception is that Innovation is about product Innovation and what our study attempts to show that
  116. Innovation is not limited to the innovation of product that innovation of the very way a company engages in
  117. business how it interacts with its stakeholders who how are the various activities connected to each other who
  118. carries out each of the activities because in business model in today's environment where there have been
  119. enormous advantage in information and communication Technologies the business model of
  120. companies involves activities that are carried out by other companies and that's very much part of the business
  121. model of how a modern Corporation operates today and I can give you lots of examples how the various the business
  122. model of Amazon relies on UPS delivering the delivering the the product that people buy from Amazon and
  123. most of the product that Amazon sell Amazon doesn't produce or stock it's just drop ship from another company so
  124. the business model of Amazon involves companies involves activities that are happening outside of the
  125. boundaries of Amazon in fact outside of the industry that Amazon is in so I think the Innovation that is inherent in
  126. the Amazon business Market or or I can give you other companies e trades business model or or several others is
  127. the realization that there is a lot of innovation that can happen on in the way companies do business and in fact the
  128. there are companies where the entire Innovation is how they do business take Price Line price line is revolutionized
  129. travel rather than you going to the website of any Airline and and and looking at the menu of what
  130. they have to offer you it's just the opposite you sit there and say I want to travel from A to B and I'm willing to
  131. pay X dollar to travel from A to B and you airlin make him make me an offer and and that's that's a reverse um you know
  132. if if you think about it it's kind of a reverse auction in some sense H but in many ways it it's a way to create value
  133. for the airline to dispose of seats they haven't sold because if you fly an empty
  134. Street you make no money you might as well make some money and and so everybody wins all this is a value
  135. creating a business model and there's no product there eBay there's no product right they just the business model is
  136. where they value creation so so I think that that's the major ER phenomena that we want to communicate that Innovation
  137. is not just about product it's about business models as well and the process of developing that business model and
  138. that enormous value for the stakeholders is created through the business model Innovation what we are engag in now is a
  139. fairly massive effort of collecting data and addressing a related questions and um and that
  140. is focusing on large companies and how the business model evolves side by side with the organization the people the
  141. incentives and that's because the business model focuses kind of on what activities the firm is engaging in order
  142. to create value and how that system of activities create value how it's connected who does it but there are
  143. other elements of the organizations that need to be looked at and that's how we see ourselves in the next phase of this
  144. H research program which as I said we started over 15 years ago [Music]

Brief Summary

Chris Do discusses business model design, value creation, and the need for continuous innovation in companies like Apple and IBM.

Key points

  • Apple's Business Model Transformation. Apple shifted from hardware sales to creating value through music downloads with the iPod.
  • The Decline of Blackberry. Blackberry's failure to adapt its business model led to its decline and near bankruptcy.
  • IBM's Service-Centric Shift. IBM transformed from a product-centered company to a service-oriented business model.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes