A New Way to Think About Startup Innovation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Paypal co-founder Peter Thiel talks about the insights on building the future that he gained as an entrepreneur and investor. See the full story: http://knlg.net/Z1iPGs 📂 Innovation;Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Adam Grant we're here with Peter teal co-founder and CEO of PayPal the first outside investor in Facebook as
  2. well as a legendary investor and entrepreneur in Silicon Valley he's the author of 0o to1 an extraordinary new
  3. book and we're thrilled to find out for starters Peter why is competition for losers well this was the headline of the
  4. Wall Street Journal excerpt of our book The the chapter title in the book itself
  5. said uh all happy companies are different so it was a slightly milder form of that but uh but it was this
  6. provocative idea because we always think competition is for winners and a winner
  7. is someone who's better at competing is more intense at competing uh that you know it's like you're in a high school
  8. sports team and you learn to compete against the people um you're up against and the Really talented people are the
  9. ones who compete the best um but what happens when you compete is you always just are focusing on the people around
  10. you on what people are already doing what's deemed valuable by other people and you often lose sight of building
  11. things that are one of a Kind different truly valuable and zero to1 companies are companies that have not been built
  12. before you know the next Bill Gates will not start an operating system the next Larry Page won't start a search engine
  13. the next Mark Zuckerberg won't start a um a uh a social networking company if you're copying these people you're not
  14. learning from them if you're competing against these people if you think you're competing with these people you're
  15. actually trying to copy them and again you're not learning from them wow so on the flip side of that then you argue we
  16. should actually think about monop is a good thing why well it it is certainly um from the point of view of a founder
  17. or entrepreneur you want your company to always be a monopoly you want to be um offering something to the world that no
  18. one else is offering and that therefore you'll have some really healthy profit margins around around your business so
  19. from the inside I would argue Monopoly is always a good thing and that's what every entrepreneur should should attempt
  20. to uh to build uh from the point of view of society as a whole I think monopolies
  21. deserve their bad reputation uh when things are static so if it's like the Parker Brothers board game where you're
  22. just reshuffling the Deeds or if it's like the post office or something like that where the Monopoly is just a rent
  23. collector or a toll collector that's bad but when it's something Dynamic like Apple computer building the first
  24. smartphone that work you have people lining up around the block to buy it that's a monopoly that does not create
  25. artificial scarcity but that's creating something new and that's doing something
  26. that's good for society as well so if you put these ideas together um is the suggestion then that that Mark Zucker
  27. shouldn't have started Facebook given that Friendster and Myspace were already out there that Larry and Sergey had alav
  28. Vista and S geves and others to compete with so Google shouldn't have existed well it's always um it certainly is
  29. always a question what um you know what dimension is is really new and and really different I would argue that with
  30. uh with Google and the search business uh it was the um page rank algorithm it was a way to automate search and
  31. computerize it that was quite new and that fundamentally transformed search into this uh vastly bigger
  32. um space than anyone had thought it was in the 90s in the preg Google 9s um and in a similar way I would say Facebook
  33. was the first one to really crack the code on making personal identity real you one of my friends Reed Hoffman went
  34. on to start LinkedIn in the '90s it started a company called social net so they already had social and networking
  35. in the name and their model was that uh you know we'd have these avatars on the internet and maybe I'd be a dog and
  36. you'd be a cat and then we have these questions how would we get along with each other and so there were all these
  37. virtual world simulated reality social networking plays but they were fundamentally about people being
  38. different from who they really were Facebook was the first one to really capture real identity so so sometimes
  39. companies are iterations on things where there's just a fundamental breakthrough
  40. in one really key Dimension so tell me a little bit about why you think software has been so
  41. lucrative and and why have we seen so much progress in digital technology recently well there's sort of a lot of
  42. reasons for this but this certainly has been the the last 40 50 years uh we've had enormous innovation in the world of
  43. bits somewhat Less in the world of atoms clean tech energy more generally uh Transportation biomed a lot of these
  44. other areas seem to have been a lot tougher um one of the things that I think is true of uh of any great company
  45. is you have to uh build something that is valuable to the world and you have to capture some fraction of what you create
  46. so you have to create X doll in value and you have to get y% of X and uh and X and Y are these totally independent
  47. variables in most cases Y is about 0% and this is a actually disturbing element in the history of innovation
  48. that a lot of innovators discovered things but weren't able to get anything you know Tesla was outc competed by
  49. Edison even though Edison had a inferior technology or uh the Wright brothers came up with a first airplane but they
  50. didn't get to be rich and of course in The Sciences it tends to be even worse if you're Einstein you come up with
  51. General general relativity you don't get to be a billionaire you don't even get to be a millionaire um and so there is
  52. something um there it's it's so it's always this question of how do you actually capture some of the value of
  53. what you create I think there is something very unusual about software businesses where so many of them um have
  54. this Monopoly like character that enables people to capture a tremendous amount of value and and I think that's
  55. that's sort of this very underexplored dimension of it you know the marginal cost producing software zero so you have
  56. these incredible economies of scale and that's sort of a classic uh Monopoly natural monopoly business it's really
  57. interesting it makes me wonder what's going to come next so if you think 20 30 50 years down the road is there going to
  58. be a next digital Revolution and where will that be well I think it's a safe it's a fairly safe bet that the digital
  59. Revolution just keeps going you know it's been it's been going for 40 50 years it's the contexts have gradually
  60. shifted from you know uh Hardware semiconduct conductors to software internet mobile internet and and so I
  61. think but I think in the space broadly is is a very good place to look and and and while we've constantly explored
  62. looking at you know all sorts of other technological verticals uh space biotech genomics um energy uh the bulk of our
  63. focus is still on software for this reason so let's talk about the people behind the software one of my favorite
  64. lines in 0o to one was that you didn't really trust a tech CEO wearing a suit well it's uh it was in the context of a
  65. lot of the clean tech companies in the '90s where you had these sort of uh people who they had a certain look to
  66. them where they and they sort of looked and and again it's always fact specific there're no hard and fast sartorial
  67. rules but in Silicon Valley if you were wearing a suit it looked like in a pitch
  68. meeting it looked like you were uh bad at sales and worse at Tech uh and so it had sort of that uh very specific
  69. meaning really interesting so you wouldn't make the broader statement that we should just leave Suits out of
  70. business Al together it depends totally on the context so these things are always always very context specific uh
  71. there are you know I think there definitely definitely one of the people rules that I find to be uh very true is
  72. that uh these companies often work well if the people have known each other for a long time or there's some some good
  73. prehistory so when I whenever I um talk to people who founded a company I often like to ask the prehistory question when
  74. did you meet how long have you been working before you started the company a bad answer is we met at a networking
  75. event a week ago and because and we started a company because we both want to be entrepreneurs um and a good answer
  76. is we were you know in college together for four or five years working on this thinking about this and you know I'm
  77. more on the business side and the other other person's more on the tech side or something like that and this was one of
  78. the the secrets behind the the PayPal Mafia that you were part of uh did you know back then that it was so critical
  79. to start a company with people that you knew well and trusted well it's it's I I
  80. don't think you need to know all of them super well but it certainly helps because you know what people's strengths
  81. are you know what people's weaknesses are you can be somewhat more honest in conversations you have with people and
  82. then it does it does lead uh you know you have all these crazy ups and downs in these businesses and you you don't
  83. want things to blow apart on one of the lows so you also make a statement that uh that you are not a lottery ticket
  84. what is that about well there's always this very important question in business you know what is the role of chance um
  85. and how much is everything just a matter of uh luck one way or the other uh and it's a very hard question to answer
  86. because we can never run this experiment uh twice but I I think it's always a good sense to have to to sort of to tack
  87. a little bit against this this chance idea and this luck idea uh certainly as a venture capitalist when I've invested
  88. in businesses uh if I treat them as lottery tickets where okay I don't know if this is going to work maybe it works
  89. maybe it won't I'll give them some money um you know once you do that a bunch of
  90. times you've already psyched yourself into losing money and and and I found that I do much better when I have really
  91. high conviction and willing to put put a lot of capital behind an idea uh whereas
  92. when I'm saying that it's a lottery ticket what I'm off what often is really going on is that I'm actually too lazy
  93. to really think about what some of the strengths and weaknesses of of a given business are and so so even though there
  94. is such a thing as luck and it's it's it's quite important in some ways I think we exaggerate its importance and
  95. often um when we use the word luck uh we should instead just be thinking a little
  96. bit harder and if you think that you've been lazy the rest of us have a lot to worry about by comparison but if you um
  97. if you think about this this idea of luck um in in the book you actually say in a way you are playing a lottery
  98. ticket because on average the most successful investment in a fund will outperform the rest of the funds and so
  99. how do you reconcile that with the lottery idea well that's that's not so much a lottery ticket as it is that you
  100. do have the these very extreme outcomes where some of these companies end up being vastly more successful than others
  101. and there's sort of this very unequal distribution not all companies are created equal and they're sort of more
  102. unequal than our intuitions about this this often are so I think of the the lottery ticket part is just is the
  103. company going to do well will it work or will it fail so I think you know there's
  104. some companies that do reasonably well some do a lot better than others so I I as long as they all succeed that's
  105. that's fine as an investor but I think it's also important to keep in mind that some do a lot better than others and
  106. this this changes one's thinking in a lot of ways so for example uh you might have um you would have been better off
  107. as the hundredth person at Google than the CEO founder of most venture-backed startups in Silicon Valley uh and and so
  108. so it's possible because these outcomes are so wildly uneven that we slightly overvalue people starting companies and
  109. we undervalue asking is there a really valuable company you should try to join join instead that's an interesting
  110. connection back to the Monopoly discussion because maybe one Mis interpretation of your Monopoly idea is
  111. that everybody should go and try to start a company that no one's building in reality you're recommending that a
  112. few of us do that and the rest maybe think about joining that company it's uh it's important well if you have a great
  113. idea uh you should go ahead and start it but you shouldn't you shouldn't start a
  114. company for for its own sake and certainly there's there's always a sense suspicion when that the fourth online
  115. pet food company the 10th thin film solar panel company are are not quite as original and groundbreaking as as people
  116. might advertise them to be so talk to us a little bit about how you think about when you want to actually be involved as
  117. a Founder versus an investor I'm thinking of paler as an example where um many people know it now as a killer app
  118. that's being used to fight terrorism there you co-founded in other cases you've invested and taking a little bit
  119. more of a backseat role when you decide to jump in full well I'm I'm mostly most
  120. work as an investor these days uh I think that uh I do think that um and palent I'm chairman which is sort of a a
  121. board level involvement but not uh not sort of a day-to-day showing up at the office every single day working some
  122. operational managerial capacity I think in most cases you're either sort of Allin or or not and it's it's not really
  123. possible to do these companies part-time and um and as an investor you always have to have a certain sense of humility
  124. that you know once you WR write that check you only have very limited control over over what you can do so you have to
  125. think really hard when you write those checks I would hope so anyway now when you think about your your investing
  126. career is there an investment that you regretted the most looking back and maybe learned the most from well sort of
  127. the the somewhat odd one that I always give as an answer to that is that the biggest mistake I made uh in the last
  128. decade or so was uh not doing the series B round at Facebook so I invested in summer of 04 the series a round uh then
  129. there was a a you know much higher valuation about 12 times the per share price eight months later which was the
  130. series B and I actually thought about it pretty hard but on paper my stake was already really
  131. big uh but it it was it would have really been a a good uh good investment to make you know the the uh there were
  132. more than 12 times as many users so on on sort of a per user basis it was perhaps actually lower than the first
  133. round and so there are all these intuitions we have um about these these companies that are quite tend to be
  134. quite off um things change can change very quickly they can change for the better in ways that are very dramatic
  135. and very underestimated and sometimes they also change for the worst maybe nothing has changed in a year and that
  136. itself is a change for the worst because you only have a certain amount of time during which you have to accomplish what
  137. you're going to accomplish it's like this option that sort of is running out of time let's take this back to the book
  138. then uh you were teaching a class at Stanford law school and there was a student Blake Masters who was taking
  139. notes which went massively viral at what point did you decide I want this to be a
  140. book and why yeah it was a it was a class actually undergraduate in the computer science department Blake was at
  141. the law school the time sat in on the class he he took the notes they went viral we had about 300 400,000 people
  142. read them on the Internet and and we concluded wow there's so much interest in this there's no reason we need to do
  143. this just in Stanford or just in Silicon Valley let's try to um distill all these
  144. thoughts into an even more crisp form uh and the best form we came up with was was to actually write a book and that's
  145. what we did the book is full of of some statements that are at best uh provocative but I think everyone in many
  146. cases would find them to be even a little bit contrarian how often do you believe everything you write versus
  147. you're pushing an argument to its an extreme but maybe questioning how far you'd go on it oh I I believe everything
  148. I say so I guess then as a follow-up question when you think about how to best get people to adopt opt some of
  149. your more radical ideas uh is there a point at which you don't want too many people to follow them so if we were to
  150. take for example the idea of of starting a monopoly we said not everybody should
  151. do it uh when you have people dropping out of college perhaps to uh to think about joining your fellowship um again
  152. it's for 20 people are you designing some of these ideas just for a subset as opposed to for the majority well I I I
  153. don't believe that there's a one-sized fits-all approach so I think on on um you know I don't think everyone should
  154. go to college I don't think everyone should drop out of college and start a company uh and uh and I think in terms
  155. of what we do with our lives with our careers uh there's there's no one right answer um I think my you my critique of
  156. our society and culture is that things have gotten way too tracked people get tracked from the time they're three or
  157. four years old testing Mania tracking Mania and um and it makes people somewhat better at
  158. the things are being tested on but then I think it also has this uh un fortunate
  159. narrowing effect on on on our whole country that uh that's probably not not the best way to be I think that's
  160. actually a great segue to the last question I wanted to pose which is you were on one of those tracks you went to
  161. law school you were working in the financial world and you managed to get off how how did you decide to make the
  162. leap well I sort I sort of think of myself as having had a rolling quarterlife crisis in my 20s where where
  163. it was where uh there were all these in my eth grade yearbook already one of my friends said I was going to go to
  164. Stanford as a sophomore in four or five years years and that sort of happened went to law school did the Wall Street
  165. Law Firm Wall Street bank and uh and it was it was a very strange Dynamic where from the outside everyone wanted to get
  166. in on the inside everybody wanted to get out and uh and you were forced to I really had to rethink what did I really
  167. want to do what was I really passionate about and then moved back to California and uh in the in the tech boom in the
  168. late '90s got involved in that and ended up starting PayPal but uh but I think you know if I had given advice to my
  169. younger self um I might I might still go to Stanford I might still go to law school but I'd ask far more questions
  170. why was I doing it was I doing it just for status and Prestige or was I doing it because I was really substantively
  171. interested great thank you Peter thanks for having me [Music] Adam [Music]

Brief Summary

Peter Thiel discusses competition, monopolies, and innovation in entrepreneurship with Adam Grant.

Key points

  • Competition is for Losers. Peter Thiel argues that competition can distract from creating unique, valuable companies.
  • The Value of Monopolies. Thiel discusses how monopolies can be beneficial for entrepreneurs and society.
  • The Role of Luck in Business. Thiel reflects on the importance of understanding luck versus skill in entrepreneurship.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes