How Google Is Using AI to Transform Marketing and Search
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Joshua Spanier, Vice President of AI and Marketing Strategy at Google, joins Barbara & Americus to discuss how artificial intelligence is transforming marketing from efficiency-driven automation to creative empowerment, redefining customer value, and enabling more personalized, “quest”-based consumer experiences.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Marketing Matters is hosted by Wharton marketing professors Barbara Kahn and Americus Reed. Each week they discuss marketing and advertising trends, consumer behavior, data and analytics, the latest in retail marketing, brand-building, and much more with their expert guests. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#GoogleAI #AIMarketing #FutureOfSearch #SearchMarketing #AEO ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- the technology is just fine. It's great and only getting better. In fact, AI today, this very second we you and the
- three of us are talking, is the worst it's ever going to be. Tomorrow it's going to be better. The challenge has
- been for us is the technology is improving exponentially. Us humans, the way we work, the way we approach and
- tackle problems is only sort of improving linearly. It's a little bit like our washing machines at home. They
- have 57 programs and we use hot and cold. Make sure you have the tools to give people to use, but how do you take
- the whole horse to water and get it to drink? How do you actually incentivize, inspire, and actually create the
- the things where they want to lean in and use these technologies even when they're not perfect?
- >> Hello and welcome. You're listening to Marketing Matters on the Wharton Podcast
- Network. This is our weekly podcast where we analyze the latest in advertising, marketing, customer
- behavior, new product launches, retailing, branding, anything marketing. I'm Barbara Kahn, the Patty and JH Baker
- Professor of Marketing, and I'm joined by my co-host, Americus Reed, the Whitney M. Young Jr. Professor of
- Marketing and the Brand Identity Theorist. And today, we are very lucky to be joined by Joshua Spanier, who's the Vice
- President of AI and Marketing Strategy at Google. I'm sure everybody's heard of Google. That's the global tech company
- that shapes the future of marketing through AI, data, and large-scale digital platforms like Search, YouTube,
- and Pixel. Joshua is a senior marketing executive at Google, and he spent over 14 years there and overseen more than
- $40 billion in marketing spend. As Vice President, he has led the integration of AI across global
- marketing operations, and he founded Google's central measurement and analytics function, which I'm sure he's
- being he's using to demonstrate the impact of all that money he's spending in marketing. Can you show that's the
- point of it? Anyway, Joshua, welcome to our show. Hi Joshua. Hey guys, great to be here. Thanks for so much for having
- me on the show. Of course. So you've been at Google for 14 years. Have you seen a lot of change or
- That's a loaded question, Barbara. I you know, I'm a very loyal guy. My I I I I've been married to the same woman
- since I been with the same woman since 20 my college sweetheart since we were 21
- and continuing to this day and of course I'm only 34 right now but massage those numbers down and
- I've worked at three companies in my life and Google has been the longest of my career. It's it's almost 15 years now
- and time has flown by and I feel like I've had a at least that sort of sidecar motorbike
- to some really big important moments in the technology space and the marketing space.
- I won't pretend I'm a marketer and Google is an engineering company, right? We build
- products which change the world for sure but as a marketer being close to that is really
- fun and I've seen a lot of cool stuff. Love that. I'm going to jump in Barbara. Apologies. I have to get this point out
- here while I still remember it. Joshua, thank you for that intro. It's amazing. I want you to start with your point of
- view on AI. There's I mean it's everywhere. Is it are we hyped? Are we over hyping it? Give me your point of
- view, your perspective in terms and we're going to get into this in a much deeper way when Barbara
- starts to asking her very pointed questions. Uh but I want you to I want you to lay the context for me because as
- a person who is like learning about all these things and feeling overwhelmed, give me your point of view broadly
- speaking about how we as a society should be thinking about artificial intelligence.
- So, I'm speaking to you as a marketer and I'm speaking to you from my personal view here because I'm not representing
- the entire company's view on what AI is. That mention of the word overwhelmed is
- pretty accurate. I'm very overwhelmed as a marketer, right? I work at Google. We
- have resources. We have some of the smartest, brightest people in the world. We have most amazing AI technology and
- it's overwhelming for me. I can't imagine how it is for everyone out there in the world, right? It's just a huge
- amount of change. I think two things can be true at once, though. It is a massive fundamental
- shift in the way the world is going to work at the broadest level and down to every part of marketing.
- And human beings are human beings. We crave companionship. We campaign. We we we
- crave connection. We all want good Wi-Fi. We just want to be able to live our lives and and and do so as humans.
- And so, the transition moment was so profound. Yes, AI has changed everything, but we still want stories.
- We still want entertainment. We still want connection. We still want love. That doesn't change and AI ultimately is
- a tool. It's a tool to enable better marketing. It's a tool to create new businesses. It's a tool to do all sorts
- of things. But us humans still want those core things. That's not changing even in a world with AI.
- Yeah, I want to add to that because that is that's definitely the way I've started to think about it myself. It's
- like if you think about AI replacing humans, etc. And all these things that people are afraid of, you got to go down
- to the basic core and it's like, well, what do humans want from life? You know, like I think about the big principle of
- marketing 101 that we teach in our core courses is the principle of customer value. So, you kind of have to figure
- out what is it the customers want? You know, give all the rest of the stuff to AI to do and then just kind of figure
- out how we can make the world a better place. So, how do you decide what customer value is?
- And before you answer that, how do you decide what customer value is from Barbara? I just want to say, guys, thank
- you very much for that wonderful, very humane opening. Joshua, your voice, by the way, your
- accent is soothing me. It's calming me down because I'm Barbara, I'm panicked. I don't know what's going on, but I do
- What talk about this customer value orientation that Barbara's pointing us to. I'm going to ask I'm going to answer
- that question in just a second. But first, I want to give a little bit of wider context as I see it. I spent 15
- years at Google, near enough. I spent the last 3 years as part of the core team helping the
- Google marketing organization embrace this AI moment. And I could talk a lot about the things which have worked and
- which haven't worked. And what I'm seeing right now is that we're sort of at the end of the beginning. We're at
- the end of the beginning of this AI transformation. And that first era, the first 3 years of this AI moment, really
- has been defined, as I see it, by honestly, fear, uncertainty, and efficiency. It's been about how can I do
- more for less? How can I get more for less? And that fear you that that where do you mention here, letting people go
- and having AI replace humans was like being the talk of the town, I guess, in the fear for the last 3 years. And what
- I'm seeing from smart CMOs and what I'm seeing from smart marketing leaders and business leaders now is the notion of
- actually AI can actually rethink and redo ways of working in its entirety. It's not about just making us 20, 30,
- 40% more efficient from the ways we used to work. It's what can we build with AI
- going forward? And so, the way I'd articulate this is everyone inside of Google marketing is a genius, frankly.
- They're all these Harvard, Stanford, Oxford, MIT, and Wharton Sorry. geniuses. I'm 100%, right? But they're a
- little bit like Tony Stark um out of the Marvel movies, right? Tony Stark is a genius. You put Tony Stark into an Iron
- Man suit, he becomes a superhero. And what I'm saying and what we're really exploring is how if we can give our
- teams, our geniuses the equivalent of an AI Iron Man suit, they can multiply their impact. They can actually do
- things they've never done before and the whole conversation shifts from one of fear and certainty to impact and
- opportunity. And that's been the really exciting thing. Focusing on the impact we can have.
- So, that's one point of view, which is this idea that it's a tool, it should augment, it should make humans who are
- good at things better at those things and the and the AI provides that tool. But another way of looking at it, which
- is kind of what I was trying to get at also with that question, is aren't there some things that humans
- want to do and some things that they want to pass off to HR to AI to do better? And have you given any thought
- to that notion of like what what are things that humans want like want to do? You know, like I would rather associate
- with another human probably than with an AI. I think that's the case with an AI companion or something like that. Or
- have you given any thought to that notion? What is inherently human value and what are things that AI
- could be offloaded on and we don't ever have to worry about again? Well, see, I I Barbara, I see the
- professor coming out cuz you're you're operating at at at a theoretical philosophical level, which may be beyond
- me. Here's what I will say. Inside of Google marketing, we have done for a decade and a half surveys of what
- are you working on? Where are you spending the most amount of your time? What are your deepest frustrations? We
- have this thing called Google Geist, where collect every year and then every week now we have these surveys go out,
- and we try to identify where our marketers are frustrated. And one of the things we've been looking at is
- where AI can solve with some of those frustrations and those pain points. And as a broad general rule,
- I'll I'll use very broad numbers. This isn't Google, this is for life. 30% of or 33% of what you do in your
- life you love. 33% you hate, right? Filling out your taxes. And then 33% in the middle, which
- is like indeterminate. Ah, I just got to get done, it's not terrible, it's not the worst, right? Um what we are trying
- to do is what we're constantly trying to do at the management level is like, how do we
- move people out of that bottom third into the middle third and then into the top third, right? And what we see is so
- much of what we do in marketing, media authorization forms, uh purchase requests, um compliance tasks, uh
- trafficking, um resizing, transcreation, these are tasks which no one went to Wharton to actually learn how to do
- well. It's the bureaucracy, they're not fun, they're they're they're boring, right? It's a little bit like and I I'm
- I'm not a huge car person, but a few people lament the passing of the manual gear stick, but for
- majority of us, the the Audi's Tiptronic gear changing system is better than we could do it, and it makes
- driving more fun. That's what we're seeing with AI, and so our focus is really on reduce the friction, reduce
- the frustration, and actually unleash the human creativity and ingenuity on the things which actually matter to our
- marketers. So, we 100% see our marketers saying, "I would love never have to anecdate myself. Back in the day I was a
- TV buyer, and I used to send faxes when I lived in the UK, growing up in London,
- to the ITV and Channel 4 and Channel 5 saying, 'These are the schedules of spots we wanted.' And I lived by the fax
- machine. What's that one away? That was my life was much better. We're seeing that again
- and again and again. Help people do the things they actually are passionate about and engage about and can make
- better. That's where AI's really helping us actually do some fun things. Can I give you an example?
- Can I give you an example of something we did creatively which I think is really fun?
- I feel like a lot of the AI conversation gets quite theoretical. So here here is
- a This is actually uh close to 2 years ago. So this isn't a brand new thing, but uh we
- have our Pixel phone, which is uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh
- uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh
- uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh
- uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh We got our creative teams in a room. We got our social teams
- and digital teams in a room. We did it on a Friday and a Saturday. They agreed to do it on a Saturday. And we asked
- people on social media, where should Pixel iPhone go on an adventure? All right? People sent us their ideas, and
- then using generative AI, using Google's uh near Nanobots and a VO and those capabilities, we made 300 customized
- adventures of Pixel and iPhone going in the world, and we sent them back to each
- one of those people who had a request for it. Those people have been both been pre-vetted and also had a significant
- following. If you receive an uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh 2 hours after asking for it, you get a customized
- video from Google say, here's how Pixel and iPhone are interacted living on YouTube. It's fun, and they shared it.
- And the reason I talk about this is it changes the dynamic. It's not fear of Google or fear of sorry, it's not fear
- of technology replacing a job. It's oh, I can make something that was impossible
- previously. That's the exciting part. And our teams, when they can see they can be more creative, have more
- imagination, can do more things, it's super fun. And I I um it's been really exciting seeing that, and that's what we
- began been striving to. How do we help our teams embrace this notion, this opportunity that AI can help me do
- things that I previously couldn't in fun ways, and drives business outcomes. That's a very good example. Creativity.
- I like that cuz that's what I was going to ask. How do you keep creativity instead of getting AI smushed? You know,
- like when when I have people, my students send in essays that they've written with AI, you can tell. You know,
- there really is this kind of smushiness to it, this bland flatness to it. But, if you start with the creative human,
- and then augment that, if you start with that as a point of view, I can see how you can kind of get around Yeah. And to
- your to your point, Barbara, the research that's coming out of Wharton right now is very clear on this point
- that sort of to your point, Barbara, the idea of kind of mindlessly using these tools produces things with very little
- diversity of creativity and thought. >> Yep. Right? Obviously, because it's coming from the same inputs. So, looking
- for ways to unlock the human potential is is a beautiful concept, and really trying to think about it that way as
- opposed to just a pure utilitarian argument around trying to be 5x productive on the joyless things That's
- what we do. Let me let me let me build on this cuz I I I my title is VP of AI and marketing
- strategy, whatever that means, right? I was going to ask you. Yes. I got I love that title, by the way.
- For the for the last 3 years, I've been helping Google marketing transition and embrace these AI tools, and the single
- biggest learning that I've had, that we've had, is the technology is just fine. It's great, and only getting
- better. In fact, AI today, this very second we you this way of us are talking, is the worst it's ever going to
- be. By tomorrow, it's going to be better. In 6 months, it'll be amazingly better. In a year,
- exponentially better. The challenge has been for us is the technology is improving exponentially. Us humans, the
- way we work, the way we approach and tackle problems, is only sort of improving linearly. It's a little bit
- like our washing machines at home, right? They have 57 programs and we use hot and cold, right? That's
- So, everything that I've been doing >> lot even worse. Yeah. Everything that I Not everything, but a lot of what I've
- been doing is yes, make sure you have the tools to give people to use, but how do you get take the horse to water and
- get it to drink? How do you actually incentivize, inspire, and actually create the the the things where they
- want to lean in and use these technologies Interesting. >> even when they're not perfect. And
- that's a critical piece of this. And one of the mindset shifts is we've all had that experience. We use an AI tool, it's
- not great the first time you use it. So, you go, "Ah, come back in 6 months." But
- if you don't use it for 6 months, by the time that 6 months rolls around and you
- come look at it again, someone else who's been practicing even with the imperfect tool has got so much stronger
- and better at it. So, so >> Go on. >> ask you a pedestrian question about this? Like, I've been talking to a lot
- of students and young people and they really embrace AI. I mean, they just have no problem thinking creatively and
- asking them all sorts of questions that it shocks me that they would think of to
- ask a tool. And to your point, if they come out with that human face on it, then the AI answer is, you know,
- augmenting what what they're inputting, which I think is a nice way to think about how to keep the creativity alive.
- And I don't know if you're prepared to ask, so if you want to deflect this question, that's fine if you don't want
- to answer this. But one of the questions people ask me is like, as we more and more accept these AI tools, how are we
- going to choose which AI tool to use or how are we differentiating among the different choices we have? And
- clearly this is where we're going to start spending money. You get addicted to an AI tool. 100%.
- >> Maybe it's free now, but you know you're going to pay for it eventually. >> Or
- it may just disappear. Right. >> which one? Or is there a differentiation in the market? I mean, can you give us
- some structure on that. >> Yeah. Um, I So, we spend within Google marketing significant effort and and resources
- trying to get people to embrace and use Gemini and its suite of the suite of models we have within Google. From Nano
- Banana and V O and and Flow and all the other Notebook L M. These are remarkable
- tools. I do think this may be one of the largest marketing challenges of the next
- two or three or four years because um at a certain point the technology is like magic but it comes
- indistinguishable. But I would argue that that car marketing, like what is the difference truly between a BMW, a
- Lexus, and a Mercedes? And yet, those brands do spend a lot of money and actually do find a way to articulate
- that. So, it's on me and on us Google marketing to help define the Gemini suite of tools such that you believe in
- what they do and what they have. There are certain capabilities. We had a moment with Nano Banana, our image
- generation technology, where that where it it effectively went viral. We had billions of hundreds of millions of
- assets of generative assets being made with Nano Banana in a very short period of
- time. You do have breakout moments with these tools which can help set the stage
- as it were and get people using them. But, what you're identifying, Barbara, is a long-term marketing
- I don't want to say the word war, but it's going to be a grind because we get used to ways of working and then we sort
- of stick with them. I I want to ask a question to build on Barbara's point here, Joshua. I love that point. I'm
- just I'm struggling and overwhelmed. But then things happen in the marketplace. For example, Sora just
- disappears suddenly. Uh, and it's like the marketplace is recalibrating and shifting and all that
- stuff. What is And and and maybe what I'm hearing you say is that this is going to eventually end up being a
- winner take most uh, type of market. Uh, and if that's true, like what is Google doing to help us as consumers
- perceive more value in terms of interacting with Google products. And and and and how are we going to you know how
- are you guys going to help us along this journey? Uh and that that's question number one.
- Question number two, I want to get your reaction to this too, Barbara. Give me your thoughts, Joshua, on the the
- regulatory implications here. Right? So, you were mentioning early on I cuz it made me laugh because I was like, yeah,
- I remember when I first jumped on uh these tools and I would create pictures of myself with six fingers. And suddenly
- now I almost can't tell the difference between these incredible tools, which reaches a point where at some point
- there has to be some rules around this that come from somewhere. So, can you talk a little bit about in addition to
- Barbara's question, can you talk a little bit about like your point of view on how you help us
- as consumers bring us along this journey, but also establish for us parameters of how these things should
- and or should not be used? I don't know that it's a winner takes most at this stage. I think the creativity
- uh is in in in the AI space around the world is truly remarkable. And and the way I the way I articulate this is
- back in the day we all used to carry around those little HP and Kodak point and shoot cameras, right? The digital
- cameras. And we thought they were great, and they were great. And then the cell phone camera got good enough that all of
- a sudden you didn't need this. And that was the challenging for HP and Kodak in that moment. However, the Cambrian
- explosion of creativity in business out of that out of the cell phone camera you
- had Uber, you had Google Lens, you had um Snapchat, you've had DoorDash, you've had all these myriad and myriad and
- myriad of businesses emerge out of the cell phone camera being good enough. I think we are at the Cambrian explosion
- space phase of AI. So, I think the winner takes most is a is a misnomer because the explosion is going to is going to
- happen. I That's what I think. That's my general theory. That's fair. Uh you asked the question about um the
- regulatory sort of posture. Look, uh this isn't getting it gets into sort of difficult territory to talk about, fair.
- Is what I'd say. Sundar, our CEO, has talked about Google being bold and responsible. Bold and responsible. He's
- repeated that phrase a lot, and we around the world do everything we can to protect consumer privacy, protect
- everyone's uh uh operate in a way which actually is responsible and careful. And that's why
- in some cases we haven't rushed to market with certain products or done things because we're actually being bold
- and responsible. I'll leave it there because I I don't want to get into more uh sort of complicated areas. Uh
- there was a third question. I don't remember what it was though. Gemini Nano Banana Gemini Yeah. There's a whole
- suite to Barbara's point. There's a suite of things, customer value. How do we choose? How do you get in front of us
- and convince us that Gemini and Nano Banana is better than X, Y, and Z and all of these other things? Yeah, so so
- so you know, you you also said about Marcus that you're you're kind of intimidated and scared by all this. And
- so so I'm going to come I'm going to answer your question in a slightly roundabout way.
- I think like Nike, you just have to do it, right? You just have to do it. That means you
- need to and this is true true of everyone on this call who's listening to this. You need to set dedicate an hour a
- day or an hour a week to just exploring in this space safely in a way >> you can learn doing that. It really is
- because the AI helps you learn. It's unbelievable. So so Google has a new uh music generation uh uh model called
- Lyra. Um I think it's Lyra 3 now. I hope I said that name right. I'd be embarrassed if I didn't, but
- a couple of weekends ago I spent some time with some friends. We were having drinks, and I pulled it up, and we ended
- up making rap songs and country music songs about the events that had happened in our week. It was so fun. It was it
- was fun. We we were giggling and and and having a great time. My kids started listening in as well because they were
- in the house. And I guess the the point was is I'm using AI in a very sophisticated way. But from the to me it
- just feels like I'm just making some fun songs. It was just a great thing. I think we can overthink this somehow
- that we're not doing it enough or when it's too hard. I will say if you go on to Google,
- remember Google search? I do. If you go on to Google search and just ask look for uh
- Google AI spites. We have in Google on YouTube and on various websites to think with Google, a whole variety of training
- materials specifically designed for quote-unquote regular people. Just simple ways and these are three to seven
- minute video lessons. Each one ends with a uh now you try it. And it talks you through how you do it and stuff. And
- interesting. Just do it. But AI Google, just go to Google search and search Google AI boost bites and you'll find
- these video lessons. Again, just to get I agree with everything you're saying. It's
- incredible how fast you can learn and you can make feel way more creative and produce different outcomes the more you
- input or prompt your unique point of view. Which which I agree is very interesting.
- And like if I think about what your business is like Google search, you brought up Google search and the
- advertising model and the revenue and all the measurement you would have over search, how does all of that change when
- the it's not a search engine anymore? It's like a an AI engine. The questions are I find myself typing really
- different questions into my into Google search. It It puts me into the AI thing right away because of the nature of the
- questions. But how can you measure all of that? How how does your business change?
- So um I'll say very briefly um at the Google company-wide level cuz then I'm not
- super qualified to talk about it. But what I can say is there were more searches on Google last year than in any
- year in Google history. And we're expecting more searches this year. And what's actually happened is is AI is
- actually allowed a level of innovation in our core Google search product. AI mode, AI max,
- inner mode, and AI queries that is actually kind of transformed and it's turned from what
- you might call queries into quests. Oh, I saw a celebrity wearing a cool leather
- jacket. Instead of typing in three word Brad Pitt leather jacket and hoping you can get lucky, you literally can type in
- Brad Pitt at the Oscars wearing this leather jacket with a half cut shape, you know, that's and you can do these
- long quests and it works in and it's actually incredibly powerful. So, we are seeing higher engagement. We're seeing a
- lot of usage of both on YouTube and on Google core search by younger audiences in a way which is really really
- um super exciting. From a marketing side though, I just want to say the Google has more AI engineers, more AI patents,
- and more incentive to build high quality AI advertising solutions. So, AI max search is one of them. Everything we're
- doing with creative tools on YouTube, everything we're doing on discovery. Every time we in Google marketing turn
- on one of our AI products, demand gen P max and beyond, it drives performance. It increases our effectiveness in the
- marketplace. Now, you can believe me or not, but as a marketer who spent a lot of money to
- start this conversation, performance. We want to drive business outcomes. We want to drive growth for
- the company. We spend money across the entire ecosystem. We don't just spend any money on Google's platforms. I can
- tell you that Google's AI solutions, powered by Gemini and all the AI technology we've got, are driving real
- business growth. That's really really exciting. So, it's transforming the business and went to this new era of
- excitement for both search, for YouTube, for Google's platforms overall, and I think for the marketing technology
- industry. We've always had this promise of the right message to right person at the right time. We're getting closer and
- closer to that and that's great. >> You know, that it it brings true with my own personal experience. I've never used
- search or those kind of things more because I can ask so many more interesting questions. It's no It's not
- a query anymore. It's definitely a quest. Um and I can imagine how if you can monetize all of that in ways that
- are productive for me and for businesses, it is an incredible growth market for Google. It's pretty exciting.
- Yeah, and let me just I'm sorry. Joshua Barber's going to hate me for saying this.
- But I love this this terminology you've presented for the following reasons. From query to quest. For me, Barbara, in
- my mind, I'm hearing that it's a journey and it's longer and extended and more thoughtful. And from what I'm hearing is
- that it's my opportunity to have more of my identity in this engagement with the tool BECAUSE
- IT I KNOW. THIS IS A RECORD. WE'RE ONLY WE'RE 27 minutes in before I bring up identity.
- But I love that point, Joshua, because like literally, you're unlocking my potential and I'm going to look at
- Gemini I'm going to look at this Google suite of tools and I'm going to see them
- as part of who I am in engaging with the world to be creative and to bring myself, my voice, my vision, whatever it
- is that I want to create to the world. That should result in incredible loyalty. Would Would you agree with that
- or What's your perspective? Not only will it result in credible loyalty, but it comes
- through utility. It comes from actually being solving a problem, an issue that you have as a consumer of the of the
- world, just a person. One of the things which I'm particularly excited about is when you sign up for Gemini, you can
- choose if you want to to connect your YouTube, your Google Maps, your Gmail, all your Google products into Gemini.
- And so it's truly starts getting to know you. So as an example of this, um Oh, that's a really interesting point. I
- I I was I was making a I was asking a question I was on spring break last week, went on vacation, we went to
- Canada and I had asked in Google search about I asked in Gemini about some of the weather conditions and it identified
- and said look you're you're going there but you may not want to buy an expensive
- jacket cuz it's not going to be that cold but if you do you actually there are three you know
- stores nearby you where you live and there are three stores over where you're actually going to which you can get to
- and here are the opening times for them. Do you want to pop by on your way home from work? I can plot the route for you.
- And it my mind was blown because Yeah. a customization My dream in life is I I love Batman.
- That's incredible. I already mentioned mentioned Tony Stark but I was like like Alfred from Batman this this this
- personal assistant who just That's what I want in life. I'm never going to have a butler but Gemini is
- starting to become my butler assistant. And that drives loyalty, right? Because the more
- information I put in one particular quest or whatever we're talking this, the more they're going to personalize
- the answers to what I've responded to before and the much less likely I am to switch to another tool because I don't
- want to start populating that other tool with all my history again. It already knows me. 100% 100% and
- imagine Gemini reaching out to that store and finding a coupon for Barbara. Yeah. I mean there's just all kinds of
- like Yeah. third fourth order level stuff that could be really to this is Barbara's point originally like customer
- value opening up that spigot of just unbelievable utility which then I think results in for me like becoming super
- loyal to the to the tool itself and to Google for that matter. In five or six weeks we have Google IO followed by
- Google marketing live. Google IO is sort of the sort of the the the the wide stage where Sundar shows all our latest
- developments and technologies. Google marketing live is where we do the same but for advertisers. There's going to be
- a lot of information about agentic shopping, agentic commerce and how we can help your customers find find your
- customers and and and and and convert them. Ultimately though, and I I said this
- sort of at the beginning, humans are humans. The fundamental core of what Google have been built on is start with
- the user. Start with people. Find the problem they have, solve it for them, and then everything else will follow.
- And that's what we're doing with Gemini, it's what we're doing with AI. Build something that people actually want to
- use and solves their problem, and then we'll worry about everything else after that. That's the focus.
- >> value. Well, Joshua Spanier, it's like very fast, but the time is now up. So,
- where can people go to find out about all the stuff you're talking about? Specifically, where can they go? Okay,
- so I I I have two resources. I host a podcast myself called Frontier CMO, and I publish a weekly newsletter on
- LinkedIn for the for that. So, just go on LinkedIn or go to YouTube and search for Frontier CMO, or search on any place
- you get podcasts. And then at thinkwithgoogle.com is our sort of collection of all our
- thought leadership around every aspect of the marketing business. So, thinkwithgoogle.com, you can also get to
- Frontier CMO within that portal as well. But those two resources have an unbelievable wealth of free resource
- for you to learn AI. It's incredible. Thank you so much for joining us. That's all we have time today for today. We'd
- like to thank our producers Dianne Simpkins and Marissa Ranna, and thank you all for listening today. We'll be
- back soon. Till then, this has been Marketing Matters on the Wharton Podcast Network. I'm Barbara Kahn here with
- America's Read.
Brief Summary
Joshua Spanier discusses AI's impact on marketing, emphasizing adaptation, creativity, and personalized user experiences.
Key points
- Human Connection in an AI World. Despite AI advancements, human desires for connection and stories remain unchanged.
- AI as a Tool for Creativity. Joshua Spanier discusses how AI can enhance human creativity rather than replace it.
- The Future of AI. Joshua Spanier reveals that AI is only going to improve from here.
- The Cambrian Explosion of AI. We're witnessing a surge of creativity in AI, akin to the rise of cell phone cameras.
- From Query to Quest. The evolution of search into a more engaging, personalized experience is transforming user interaction.
- Building Loyalty Through Utility. Gemini's personalization capabilities are set to foster deep user loyalty.
Episode highlights
- Human Connection in an AI WorldDespite AI advancements, human desires for connection and stories remain unchanged.“We still want stories. We still want entertainment. We still want connection.”4:53Apr 10, 2026
- AI as a Tool for CreativityJoshua Spanier discusses how AI can enhance human creativity rather than replace it.“Help people do the things they actually are passionate about.”11:36Apr 10, 2026
- The Future of AIJoshua Spanier reveals that AI is only going to improve from here.“AI today, this very second, is the worst it’s ever going to be.”15:01Apr 10, 2026
- The Cambrian Explosion of AIWe're witnessing a surge of creativity in AI, akin to the rise of cell phone cameras.“I think we are at the Cambrian explosion space phase of AI.”20:55Apr 10, 2026
- From Query to QuestThe evolution of search into a more engaging, personalized experience is transforming user interaction.“It's not a query anymore. It's definitely a quest.”27:03Apr 10, 2026
- Building Loyalty Through UtilityGemini's personalization capabilities are set to foster deep user loyalty.“The more they’re going to personalize the answers, the less likely I am to switch.”29:52Apr 10, 2026





