Strategy from the 'Outside in'

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton Professor George Day describes the positive aspects of an 'Outside In' strategy. 📂 Marketing

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] Okay. The the unique features of our our new book on uh strategy from the outside
  2. in uh is actually embodied in the subtitle profiting from customer value. Uh the concept of outside in inside out
  3. has been around for a long time uh but in very different ways. The uh original outside in view was in fact the old
  4. Porter 54 structural analysis of industries which looked at forces of competitive rivalry and the aim was to
  5. find a defensible position. Uh the role of customers in this was really fascinating um as embodied in the notion
  6. of the bargaining power of customers. So customers were viewed as another competitive force and it was a zero sum
  7. game. uh that view still by the way still has a lot of validity. It recognizes markets are segmented and
  8. complex uh but it's been increasingly uh supplanted almost by the dominant inside
  9. out view of organizations respecting the resource-based view. And this idea is that you've got resources and job of
  10. management is to not only uh manage them but exploit them and leverage them. Uh and this is really inside out uh because
  11. it it's looking for efficiency improvements and finding ways to use those resources. We uh build on a whole
  12. other stream of research uh based on the notion of a markettoriented organization
  13. or a marketdriven organization in which uh you start with a customer, you stand in their shoes and look at how they make
  14. choices. Uh so it's all about your relative position in the customer's mind and how much value uh each of the
  15. alternatives is delivering. So we we build on that and from that vantage point we look at the organization
  16. through the customer's eyes and what are their competitive choices and then we from that derive uh four customer value
  17. imperatives but everything is focused on customer value and that's where the uniqueness comes in as as we look at
  18. companies that have done this uh well and consistently over time versus poorly I'm actually uh reflecting back on the
  19. uh story of McDonald's and uh they did both which is really fascinating in uh uh about 2001
  20. McDonald's frankly had lost their way uh their performance was awful share price
  21. down by twothirds and uh it was known basically as a fast food fuel depot uh and service was terrible uh food was
  22. uninteresting customer satisfaction ratings way down and and essentially what they had done
  23. is they had focused uh on this strong brand and how they could leverage it by expanding the number of franchised
  24. outlets. So they were all about growing by adding outlets i.e. from the inside out. Well, they just totally lost track
  25. of the customers. uh 20045 a new management team came along and said wait a minute we've had uh this
  26. deteriorating position let's start back and take an outside in view at our strategy and uh focus on improving the
  27. customer experience which they did in many many ways and I'll just give you one instance of the sort of things they
  28. were looking at uh they discovered u and through through some phenomenally good customer insight research
  29. that mothers would bring their kids to have lunch at McDonald's and the mothers wouldn't organ order a thing. They'd
  30. just stand there, have a glass of water, watch their kid eat the Big Mac. Uh so based on that insight, now that data had
  31. been around, but if you're an inside organization, if you're looking at the world from the inside out, you don't
  32. necessarily have those deep insights, you're not even thinking that way. They said, "All right, uh let's understand
  33. better what's getting in the way. What do they think about our food?" and then let's get creative about adding menu
  34. options that are appealing, including that was the genesis of the salad option. Now, you could say in
  35. retrospect, well, that's pretty straightforward, but the fact of the matter was the previous management team
  36. had not uh gone down that path because they were so compelled to add more franchises, but which by the way uh
  37. angered their existing franchise holders. There's been a long stream of research on uh market orientation and
  38. the effect on uh profitability and revenue. Uh in fact there was a recent uh analysis that uh pulled together the
  39. results of 114 different studies on the impact of market orientation which is uh
  40. variously defined as superior skills in understanding attracting and keeping customers or uh looking at the uh
  41. organiz looking at the business through the customer's eyes. So various definitions having to do with the use
  42. and dissemination and application of uh information on customers and markets. Um
  43. there's a very solid correlation between market orientation and revenue and profit. Um that is uh important uh as a
  44. as a touch point for us. I've also done work on the notion of peripheral vision of organizations their ability to see
  45. sooner and uh we find again businesses that are vigilant that is scanning their horizons standing out there at the
  46. periphery really outperform those that are purely focused on efficiency management and uh so we've uh built upon
  47. those two streams of research. The difference is we've taken the market orientation uh uh concept and have asked
  48. okay how is that going to help us build and manage better strategies better competitive strategies. So, we've taken
  49. that whole stream of research quite a bit further down the road.

Brief Summary

The episode examines customer value and market orientation using McDonald's strategic shifts as a key example.

Key points

  • McDonald's Strategy Shift. In 2001, McDonald's struggled with performance and customer satisfaction. A new management team refocused on the customer experience, leading to significant improvements.

Related episodes