How a Short-term Shock Can Change Your Firm's Long-term Course

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Using a large sample of 1,200 firms at the time they go public, Wharton's Luis Rios examines how companies adapt to their environments in order to survive -- or ultimately fail. He finds that decisions made in these nascent stages can have a long-lasting impact on the internal structures of a company. More: http://knlg.net/1LXnKcT 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm interested in the way that firms develop specifically I look at the origin of firm differences and within a
  2. technological context now the the subject of why firms are different has received some attention in the
  3. literature but traditionally people have sort of waved it away the standard view
  4. in economics is to actually control for firm differences and then to look at you
  5. know apples-to-apples comparisons across firms and that works within that context
  6. pretty well even within the traditional strategic frameworks it is very normal to take a stock of the firm's strengths
  7. weaknesses capabilities and then allow the firm to do an analysis of where it can fit into a competitive landscape now
  8. all of that person's that the firm's strengths and weaknesses are relatively fixed and that has served us pretty well
  9. you know in management but what happens when the environment change if the activity that your firm is engaged in at
  10. any given moment is serving you well and then there's a radical shift in the environment the firm might find itself
  11. had a loss as to how to react to that and so it turns out that we don't have a lot of very good frameworks to allow a
  12. firm to enact change and to consciously adapt to the new environment we know that firms can sometimes change we have
  13. observed that and documented it but even more frequently we see firms not being able to change and react and then the
  14. splendor and fail so for me my interest is to try to understand firm evolution from the early stages so that we can see
  15. periods during which firms are changing and adapting then possibly glean some insights into how that can then be
  16. consciously applied by firms add maturity in order to deal with the environmental turbulence that they might
  17. be experiencing now more specifically what I do is that I look at a sample of about 1,200 firms around the time when
  18. they go public my hypothesis is that this is a time of radical change for the firm during which they're much more
  19. plastic than they would be otherwise given the amount of things that are changing in terms of both the four
  20. normal and the informal structures so then what I do is I control for firms that went through the IPO as planned
  21. versus a set of groups as it affirms that experience a shock that was unexpected around the time of going
  22. public and then I compared to see whether that shock leads to divergent development afterwards so what I'm
  23. trying to find is to see if I can pick up a case of more hiding plasticity in the firm as it's going through this IPO
  24. process and then what I find is that in fact there's a very short window of about 18 months around the time when
  25. they go public where they are particularly susceptible to the environment and thus the conditions that
  26. they experienced at that point seemed to determine even 20 years later the type of firm that they are their strengths
  27. their weaknesses in terms of their technological direction some of the key takeaways from the
  28. research are that we find that not only do firms develop tastes and in preferences but rather they seem to be
  29. actually developing what we would call capabilities that is the the technological ability to do things
  30. differently the firms that were exposed to for example non conducive environments for acquisitions
  31. counterbalance that by developing stronger internal research capabilities and so that suggests that what is
  32. driving this is not so much the top management predilection or preferences for doing one thing versus another but
  33. rather something that is ingrained at deeper levels of the organization in terms of what the people and the
  34. routines and the structures of the firm allow it to do in my case looking at research intensive activities and you
  35. know so that is valuable in allowing us to actually locate you know the locus of
  36. where the persistence of these temporary sharks ultimately resides in the long term
  37. for businesses my research might ultimately give them a more insight into what they can change what they cannot
  38. change and how now this is a big agenda and for now I've barely scratched the surface by documenting that short
  39. periods of sensitivity can have lasting effect on what the firm can ultimately do but for managers even in the short
  40. term it hints at perhaps the importance of being aware of when they're going through a transition such as going
  41. public in how that might have unintended effects in disrupting their prior plans
  42. so the best-laid business plan up to the IPO may not be what works best going forward given for example an unexpected
  43. shock so you know for managers managing the transition from being a private firm
  44. to a public firm this should inform at least the awareness to be much more conscious about what the environment was
  45. like at the time and how that may have inadvertently influence decisions that you know seem trivial at the time such
  46. as what type of people they're hiring in what sort of routines are developing but
  47. also might end up shifting the direction of the firm in ways that they had not anticipated now stepping away from the
  48. IPO context I think it's important to note that these things are actually you know probably not limited to the IPO
  49. there's other disruptive events and I think that you know some of these findings should generalize for managers
  50. to think about whether other disruptions such as changes in management or mergers
  51. can also be disruptive in also managing that transition I think that my research
  52. suggests that it is important to look at the way that the environment is a hitherto you know relatively ignored
  53. component of what is shaping the firm and how it affects the firm differently at different times
  54. the choice of looking at IPOs is a convenient one from a data perspective in that looking at a very large sample
  55. it provides a very clean before and after situation where we can you know pinpoint when change what's happening
  56. but theoretically there's nothing to limit us to saying that the IPO is somehow privileged as a window I mean as
  57. I said there might be mergers acquisitions death of founders in all sorts of transfer transformative events
  58. that might have a similar impact on the firm so I'm extending my research by looking at different conditions that
  59. might also precipitate these periods of hiding plasticity in the firm moving beyond just the sort of temporal effects
  60. I'm also looking at digging deeper into what precisely is going within the firm so whereas you know my study so far have
  61. looked at large sample firms and statistical data that that hints at what's really going on to get a much
  62. more tangible feel for that requires getting into a smaller set of firms or going deeper in looking at actually
  63. interviews and more case grounded type of approach to really you know provide much more tangible evidence that the
  64. like I said the whether the change is being perpetuated through formal or informal routines or formal or informal
  65. relationships or whether it's at the top or at the bottom of the organization you

Brief Summary

The episode covers how IPOs and environmental changes affect firm adaptability and long-term capabilities.

Key points

  • Understanding Firm Evolution. Exploring how firms adapt to environmental changes and the impact of IPOs.
  • The Importance of Transition Awareness. Managers must be conscious of environmental influences during transitions like IPOs.

Related episodes