Does Your Strategy Need a Strategy Part 1

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

πŸ“‚ Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. your strategy and is a strategy um is based on roughly the last 10 years of research on strategy that we've been
  2. doing in the BCG Bruce Henderson Institute so as you mention uh indeed we did a a detailed survey of 150
  3. multinationals in terms of their perceptions of their environments their elected approaches to strategy and their
  4. actual strategizing behaviors uh we also looked at the data the performance data
  5. from for all uh US public companies since 1950 uh for patterns we did in-depth uh case studies and interviews
  6. with CEOs which you see featured in the book and uh we also um validated our conclusions uh by constructing a what we
  7. call our Universal strategy simulator which is a a simulation of what sort of strategies work in what sort of
  8. environments that's the evidence on which the book is based that ey conclusions from the book
  9. are that business environments are now so diverse that we need different approaches to strategy in different
  10. circumstances and more particularly the classical style of strategy analyzing and planning is still perfectly fine for
  11. some situations but it's no longer a Panacea a second conclusion is that large companies especially need to
  12. deploy multiple approaches to strategy in different parts of their business so we call that ambidexterity they needs to
  13. master the art of ambidexterity and the third conclusion is that we need to modify our concept of leadership to
  14. be able to lead and direct and Design This Mosaic of of of strategies that applies to uh to companies and the last
  15. conclusion is that if you do all of those things there's a demonstrable performance uh benefit for companies to
  16. to pocket the most well-known approach to strategy and implementation is what we
  17. call the classical approach this is the one that we probably learned about in business school and it's to do with
  18. analyzing and planning and implementing in a disciplined manner following the plan uh this is an approach which works
  19. perfectly fine in predictable environments that are not shapable they're they're given and uh this style
  20. of strategy is perfectly applicable in very predictable Industries and we give the example of for example The
  21. Confectionary uh industry uh in in the bo demand grows roughly at GDP relatively
  22. stable relatively plannable uh so that's the most common approach to strategy the
  23. second approach to strategy is what we call the Adaptive approach the Adaptive approach works really well in highly
  24. unpredictable industries that are also not easily shapable and a good example of that is software in particular say
  25. the gaming industry where the competitive conditions are highly volatile and the technology is
  26. constantly changing the idea here is since we cannot plan we use a biological approach
  27. we create variation we select that which works we Implement that and scale it and
  28. then we repeat the cycle again and again so if you like strategy in this particular case emerges
  29. continuously from experiments at the cold face of the organization the third approach to strategy is what we call the
  30. Visionary approach here conditions at least in the eyes of the entrepreneur are predictable
  31. and also shapable so this is about not participating in an industry but creating an industry and the approach is
  32. to Envision a possibility that others have not seen to then realize that possibility
  33. and then to persist and scale that opportunity so we've all heard of entrepreneurs that have done that and
  34. know we give the example in the book for example of 23 and me which is a new genomics testing services company with a
  35. novel business concept I think the big news here is that large corporations are increasingly vulnerable to upstart
  36. Challenger companies and therefore to defend themselves large corporations also need to master the Visionary style
  37. which was probably present at their Inception decades ago the fourth approach to strategy is probably the
  38. most exotic one we deal with and may not be familiar to everybody and that is what we call the shaping approach so
  39. here conditions are both shapable and unpredictable that sounds like a contradiction
  40. What's Happening Here is that not a single company but a whole ecosystem of companies is collaboratively reshaping
  41. an industry uh most often with a two-sided Marketplace and an ecosystem of many companies collaborating to uh to
  42. create a new space and a good example of this would be for example Alibaba or uh
  43. red hat or Amazon uh these companies have not only deployed a strategy at the level of an individual company but
  44. they've created a successful position within a successful ecosystem the recipe here for thinking about strategy is
  45. really very different it is to influence to orchestrate the contributions of others in the ecosystem
  46. and then to co-evolve that collaborative system the fifth approach to strategy is
  47. what we called renewal uh it's very common and it's applies to those situations where companies have gotten
  48. out of step with their competitive environment and their competitive or financial performance is suffering we
  49. found actually that this is a very big bet for companies 75% of renewal exercises fail and the difference
  50. between failure and success in npv terms is roughly the Enterprise value of the company so a very big risky bet and the
  51. way to think about renewal strategy is firstly to anticipate because the sooner you uh enter this exercise the more
  52. successful you're likely to be secondly to think about economizing it's necessary to free up resources but not
  53. only for the purposes of financial viability but also to fund the journey back to growth and the third stage
  54. critically is growth and Innovation the company cannot cut its way to success he
  55. needs to fund the journey back to growth and Innovation there are many many examples of this but for example uh AMX
  56. is is an example of a company that did this very well uh during the recent financial crisis pivoted very quickly
  57. back to growth and Innovation we deal with tricks and traps in the book and there are some fairly
  58. prominent ones um so when we looked at how companies perceived their environments and the strategies that
  59. they uh choose we found that there was a very human bias towards perceiving business environments as being more
  60. predictable and more controllable than they actually are it's a comforting thing for people to believe that they
  61. can control and predict their surroundings and sometimes it's the case and sometimes it's not the
  62. case second big trap is to be stuck in one way of doing strategy most often the classical way of doing strategy analyze
  63. plan execute that's not a bad way of doing strategy under the right circumstances uh but if you have a very
  64. fast moving part of your business one where the rate of Technology change is very high for example uh then it's
  65. totally inappropriate and in particular there's a couple of capabilities which uh large corporations
  66. need to create to Avail themselves of these uh other approaches to strategy one of them is the Adaptive capability
  67. the ability to uh undertake disciplined experimentation another one is the shaping capability the ability not just
  68. to participate in their environments but actually to shape them uh to their advantage and the third one is the
  69. capability of ambidexterity which is the ability to run different approaches to strategy in different parts of the
  70. organization so let me just expand on some of those capabilities a company building an
  71. Adaptive capability will build a process for experimentation they will build metrics for measuring the effectiveness
  72. and the speed and the return on investment from their experimentation they'll be empowering their employees to
  73. take risks and to experiment locally in the business the second capability for large companies to build is the shaping
  74. capability and this is essentially an obsession with what's going on outside of the company what's new in technology
  75. what's new with customers what's new with disruptive Mavericks on the edge of the industry what's new with
  76. regulation and typically large companies are very introverted they mainly think about what's going on inside the company
  77. but the Strategic plan of a shaping company consists in large part of a very deep understanding of what's going on
  78. outside the company the third key capability for large companies to build is that of
  79. ambidexterity uh which means to run different types of strategy in different parts of the company uh so a good
  80. example might be for example the the digital strategy in China a very fast growing uh environment very fast moving
  81. industry will likely be uh either a a shaping approach or an Adaptive approach it'll be a very Dynamic approach to
  82. strategy uh whereas for example a more stable business in a more slow growing Market let's say the the printing
  83. industry um will typically be more more classical in nature so how do you do that uh well the book deals with the
  84. four ways of actually achieving this uh one way is by separation the most common
  85. way which is we simply have separate business units that are allowed to have different cultures different ways of
  86. measuring things different goals different performance contracts the second way is switching
  87. when products progress very rapidly uh in their life cycle you may not uh it may not be expedient to actually
  88. uh separate the exploratory from the exploitative and therefore we need what we call a switching strategy which is
  89. the same group of people may need to modify and modulate their behaviors over time and a good example of that uh was
  90. the Corning Glass company that we we deal with in the book a third way of getting at ambid
  91. dexterity is with an internal ecosystem and we deal with the example of higher in the book The Chinese white goods
  92. manufacturer that essentially creates an ecosystem of hundreds of small business
  93. units that all negotiate with each other to create a very very uh flexible enterprise
  94. system the last uh example of an ambid exra strategy is to create an external ecosystem uh so in answer to the
  95. question how could Apple a company that had never made a smartphone before defeat a 60% market share market leader
  96. Nokia in a highly technology intensive High fix cost Global regulated complex industry well the answer is they didn't
  97. their multi hundred company collaborative ecosystem beat Nokia so you can see that the diversity
  98. that they needed in approaches to to strategy and implementation if you like was outsourced to an ecosystem that's
  99. the fourth approach to ambid dexterity [Music]

Brief Summary

Large companies must adopt diverse strategies to succeed in unpredictable environments, emphasizing ambidexterity and adaptive capabilities.

Key points

  • Diverse Business Environments. Business environments are increasingly diverse, requiring varied strategic approaches.
  • Mastering Ambidexterity. Large companies must learn to balance multiple strategic approaches for success.
  • The Classical Approach. The classical strategy approach is effective in predictable environments.
  • Ecosystem Collaboration. Companies must collaborate within ecosystems to reshape industries.
  • High Stakes of Renewal. Renewal strategies are risky, with a 75% failure rate.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes