Management 101: The Marriage of Strategy and Leadership
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Focusing on strategy alone -- or leadership alone -- misses the big opportunities. Two Wharton professors offer six steps to integrate the two. π Leadership;Management π·οΈ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- we're joined today at knowledge at Orton by harier Singh and also Mike usim they're both management professors here
- at Wharton and they're going to discuss their new book uh which is about management and strategy and it's
- actually called the Strategic leaders road map six steps for integrating leadership and strategy thanks for
- coming in today to talk with usk you um good leadership or good strategy uh um I
- think one of the main points of the book is that some companies have really good
- leadership they fail on their strategy and vice versa some have great strategy and fail in
- leadership and it's the integration of the two that you talk about in this book as being so important could you each
- give me a sort of nutshell view of why that's so important and and why companies aren't doing it
- today so there's been a lot of emphasis on leadership over the past few years is
- an evergreen topic but if you look at Microsoft and Steve bommer in his term Microsoft was
- dominant Steve bomber was seen as a Visionary leader and inspired the troops in fact his meetings were legendary you
- know the passion and the inspiration and so on but in his tenure also they missed
- the boat on the mobile applications of Microsoft and actually opened the door for many other players in the industry
- and it has taken some time to try to respond to that so so that's an example of very very good leadership but really
- not having enough strategic sort of inspiration and discipline and in fact what we seem what we've learned is that
- the ideas coming in on the mobile side were actually set aside in favor of the desktop so sometimes a strategic Choice
- can limit the benefits of very effective leadership and vision and Steve to pick
- up on that and going back a little bit in time har and I have often taught almost backto back in in midcareer
- programs strategy first as it should come first and then leadership second and we've often cross talked a bit but
- uh a year and a half ago we sat down with the chief executive of Nissan also the CEO of Renault and came to know
- quite a bit about the Nissan turnaround which is one of the great turnarounds of
- the modern era Japanese Auto producer was pretty much going off a cliff back in 1999 not because it did not have a good
- turnaround strategy it actually had one but the incumbent top team at the time just couldn't seem to make it work so
- good strategy but the uh thinness of the leadership at the top uh in terms of making things happen driving change
- through the organization ultimately uh crippled the organization and that is when Nissan turned to Rena for a big
- cash infusion $4 billion accounting and Nissan brought in Carlos gone became his
- new became Nissan's new chief executive officer his strategy was U more than what he had when he came in there but
- his leadership was very different and from that experience looking at that case in some depth came to really
- appreciate that you got to have a great strategy you got to have a great leadership to go with it if you're a
- little bit short in one you're going to be in trouble so starting about a decade and a half ago or so there was
- a lot of talk about strategy and execution strategies very very important but the
- idea was it's not that hard to come by meaning that not that it's easy lots of companies have good strategies and
- companies with good strategies many of them weren't doing that well because they couldn't execute how does your idea
- of of of the marriage between strategy and leaders ship differ or complement that whole idea so execution was uh was
- the rage you know 10 years ago and particularly with the financial crisis even more so let's squeeze out cost
- let's become more efficient and so on and clearly very important but what we are arguing is that you need
- inspirational vision from the leader but you also need a very clear value proposition for the customer and then
- execution is sort of the way you can deliver value value create value and so in some sense if you look at again the
- Nissan case what you see is we we call it executable initiatives so the value proposition that you decide to have how
- are you going to actually navigate through your organization and get the best possible execution and we also
- realize that strategy is owned by everyone so we have a concept in the book called layering and Leadership and
- in the Nissan case laring leadership was they had cross functional teams which were largely
- people in their 40s and late 30s and even people reporting to them who kind of brought up ideas that fitted with the
- architecture that Carlos gon had created along with a senior team so the idea is
- execution is not just following orders it's actually creating and enhancing the value proposition to the client and
- getting the ideas from people throughout the organization so you want you want you want staff to have a strategy on how
- to implement the strategy how to implement the strategy and but then there's a very kind of lean set of
- initiatives that you pursue so there's not it doesn't get frittered away or lost in the confusion so the people also
- know what they're contributing to and that's important another example actually is when PNG bought Gillette
- they bought Gillette at a very very high price because it was an auction most people thought there was not much value
- left Gillette was already dominant but what PNG ended up doing with Gillette was actually creating a whole new set of
- uh you know shaving creams and other sort of assorted products that go along with the Shaving equipment but also a
- better supply chain so it's really how you link the value proposition with execution within the organization and
- then leadership that can kind of summarize what the key direction is so people are not kind of uh you know going
- in opposite directions or frittering away their energy you know harir Proctor and Gamble offers a really nice example
- of why we need to think about execution plus so in the case of the acquisition of Gillette as I recall it was a more
- than $40 billion deal it was a huge decision the then chief executive AG Lafley he needed a lot of thinking
- through he needed Good Counsel he needed smart people that would work with him and in that particular case he turned to
- his own board of directors and you wouldn't think of a board normally as getting into the the mechanics of of an
- acquisition the pricing how they were going to keep the CEO of Gillette if Gillette did come into Proctor and
- Gamble but the board of AG Lafley at the time had six former CEOs on it and their
- leadership experience their leadership background their leadership instincts proved vital for AG Lafley decision to
- go through with the acquisition to generalize that out I think I think we were all most of our readers uh and
- certainly our viewers recall the book by Larry basid and RAM Chiron execution a bestseller deservedly so because it was
- really about taking your vision and your strategy and bringing it into reality and they were quite critical of several
- companies that they name in the book for having failed to do that harbir and I were very influenced by that line of
- thinking of course what we've in a sense added here is um a call to take a look at people in The Firm on the board below
- the chief executive below the division heads not just for whether they can quote execute but whether they have a
- range of leadership capacities like inspiring people you wouldn't think of that as part of execution but if you
- move into then a broader terrain of leadership uh good decisions timely actions um listening to the customer in
- all kinds of ways leadership and our you is a more encompassing concept that has
- to be matched up with strategy if you got both we think you're going to go in the right direction you need someone
- that can get that Employee Engagement yeah going yeah exactly and also a decision process we kind of talk about
- deciding deliber deliberatively and the idea is that the quality of discourse matters in a company you know and there
- has to be sort of enough openness to new ideas but also a sense of selection and
- then proceeding forward um many companies struggle with this either you have kind of a top- Down sort of flow of
- decisions where people execute with their list in for direction or perhaps bottom up but I think to allow for kind
- of healthy debate and discourse but then choosing a direction and moving we talk
- about deliberatively deciding I think that's an important piece so it's it's always good to learn from companies that
- have done it well and been successful it's also interesting to get lessons from companies that haven't done well so
- what would be an example of a company that had a good strategy but failed because of leadership and then also the
- opposite what would be an example of company that had good leadership but their strategy just fell short Steve to
- pick a contemporary example Wells Fargo much in the news for apparently um a number of the staff members creating
- fictional accounts for customers actually using the customer's names and in some cases even signing their
- signature inappropriately on these accounts that were being created and human nature Being Human Nature we know
- a lot about The Human Condition behavioral economists and psychologists been looking at it for a long time uh
- would tell you in advance if you're a leader who is listening that if you put forward a very tough set of objectives
- and by the way all companies do that all companies have a strategy that are with
- stretch goals we got to increase um return on Equity by 5% in the next 12 months
- that's a pretty modest one right there but many companies go well beyond that and then in our view leadership at the
- top in the case of Wells Fargo just think of what leadership means it means you set the tone create the mindset
- absolutely especially in financial services but every company really create a climate of integrity and then within
- those call them boundary conditions then push people to get the job done of expanding the number of accounts at the
- bank but it would appear let's just say good strategy and aggressive strategy all companies uh Financial Services
- Beyond are growing want to grow and set tough targets as they should but then we
- got to think about as a leader what's going to happen when people translate the demand upon them for the end of
- month or end of quarter results if we don't have an ethical climate a code of ethics a uh a policy of integrity first
- and so predictably with a bit of a shortcoming there in the leadership uh people did what you can almost
- anticipate without having to be inside the company they would do and and did do so good strategy take existing customers
- sell them additional products just like with the w with the uh razor blades take
- Men's Grooming products and add them on so strategy good but execu or rather leadership big big
- big failure um which was costly to we're now finding out and probably more than we know right now it's got a ways to
- play out okay and on the other side so we have the example of besides of course Microsoft that I talked about earlier
- with Steve bomber's inspirational leadership but not necessarily the best strategic choices in the new products
- very good in the existing products I think there is uh if you look at Daimler and its acquisition of Chrysler Yen shm
- was a celebrated CEO he had gained a lot of momentum selling asset selling assets
- that were not related to automobiles uh and then he tried to answer the question of the analysts as
- to what's the US presence and where's your midsized product and damler had tried for years and he decided to go you
- know being sort of a strong leader let's go and make a big statement and against
- perhaps a lot of internal debate bot Chrysler and that turned out to be a leader who was very strong had you know
- a good track record kind of committing to a transaction that ended up losing a lot of value it was bought for $37
- billion and sold 9 years later for $7.5 billion it was for a company as successful as Daimler with a high
- quality management it's a very good example of you know just not pursuing not surfacing the right strategy and not
- being able to execute AR I think it's a great example on this terrain of strategy plus
- leadership when the announcement was made that Chrysler would be acquired or actually I think technically it was just
- simply a merger uh but it was acquired by diimler Jurgen shmp at one point publicly said uh for the first time in
- my life looking at the pay of the CEO of Chrysler at the time I'm feeling poor and that was a statement that the the
- pay structure for European Executives is much lower much more modest compared to
- American that was the tip of an iceberg um Sailors beware now because um that should have told you something that the
- the way of life not just compensation but the way um orders are given the way people convene a meeting all in this
- terrain of leading and acting uh they were very different different cultures different cultur different corporate
- cultures in addition to National cultures I guess harbir is is often citing statistics on the amazing rate of
- failure of even friendly Acquisitions yes uh so even though it can look to a strategist at a company this is going to
- be a good merger right the failure to look at the leadership pieces I think often uh behind the the high rate of
- failure the parts are are not going to lead to a greater hole without the right leadership and and I think the the
- important point there if we look at at the dialogue that has taken place in the world of published books on strategy and
- Leadership they're very segmented you have books on strategy that are very kind of analytic and conceptual and you
- know the beautiful strategies that you can get from them books on leadership very much on inspiration and you know
- engagement uh being part of something larger than yourself and I think the actual integration of the two uh is
- extremely important and we discovered that really in our teaching as as Mike was saying we had an audience that
- wanted to know about both and we wrote the book really based on the teaching materials we developed for that so would
- it be correct to say that better than having consciously having some managers who were really good leaders and another
- group that were really good at strategizing and having them on a team it's better to have them all sort of
- trained in in both things I'm assuming you would say that and then and that's that that leads to my next question
- which I think is so interesting is a premise of the book is that these skills can be taught right because we're
- talking about these legendary leaders it's easy to think well you know yes all you have to do is be Steve Jobs to be
- successful you know now go do it you know it's like Buy Low sell High okay it's very very easy advice but how do
- you do it but you're saying that you can actually teach these skills in both strategy and Leadership which I think um
- is is really interesting for companies that that want to think this through and do something about it you know if you
- think about a starting career in in business or really at any organization some people are on a
- strategy team or they're in strategy Consulting worth a company other people might be running a an office or a
- division later if not sooner and early on you might be more focused on strategy and all the issues there uh over here
- but then over here you may be more concerned how do you get people to show up at work and not quit and how do you
- pay them and how do you motivate them to get the job done but as people move up into the middle ranks and certainly
- above unequivocally you've got to be strategic in thought and you've got to lead well because all those functions
- now are are in effect coming together and uh with that uh We've Come to feel that we are not fully servicing or we're
- doing a disservice if people are leaving from uh our many many different forms where we work with people if we don't
- really make the argument later on if not sooner whatever you begin in it might be more strategy it
- might be more managing you're really going to have to become great at both and we offer a couple avenues for doing
- that you want to talk about those Avenues a little bit Yeah I think just to and I'll turn it
- over to Mike on learning how to be a good leader but I just wanted to elaborate on the earlier point which is
- that uh depending on your career choice you're not going to be in both you're going to start maybe typically in
- operation in some way maybe you join a consulting firm but I think what people have to recognize is that they have to
- build a larger skill set and the but then what is that skill set and I think that's what this book is about so for
- example if you are typically in operations you should be thinking about what's the value proposition to the
- client because that's part of your responsibility and you're becoming a better strategic leader that way but
- also you need to think about a very crisp statement of strategy that's what we talk about in the book that often
- strategy statements are 10 15 PowerPoint pages and what Carlos gon had was essentially a half page version which
- was these are the four profit drivers and I think we're trying to what we're trying to suggest is if you're in
- operations you need to understand that you really have to have a crisp view of what drives profit in your business and
- what's your value proposition on the other side if you're on strategy or Finance or a staff function you need to
- think about executable decision you know and look ahead to execution what are the
- initiatives that best represent these strategies and I think that's how people can learn because you're only in one
- part but you're trying to prepare for a larger role and be good at both inspiring people strategizing and
- executing so how do you do all those things so stretch yourself all along yeah during your career from early in
- your career learn from peers learn from people who you who you can learn from as
- mentors and Steve here are the three avenues that we emphasize SI they're pretty obvious as soon as I say them but
- to get to them we do describe uh a young uh manager named John Chambers in the book who had worked with a company
- that a lot of people don't even remember Wang instruments which was there sort of
- in the early days of the digital Revolution huge success but it did a total belly flop and went out of
- business after a couple years of extraordinary growth and John Chambers from that experience um looking back on
- it and he was he lost his job he was on the street uh he said you know I've got a better appreciation now for why a
- company really has to know where it's going where the Market's changing where all the value added propositions are
- going to be when especially all these disruptive Technologies are coming along and I've got to have a Workforce that's
- ready to in that case change quickly agile uh Wang apparently had neither of those capacities so John Chambers hired
- by Cisco uh soon after he was in there became chief executive and ran Cisco for 20 years and he has said we talked to
- him as well that really three Avenues are critical not only for him but and we have picked this up from others as well
- for combining those two functions that harbir just described one is just think about it study it pick up the book by
- execution uh called execution by BOS and RAM shiran Larry and RAM shiron um take
- a course uh online course maybe a a mid-career course that has strategy and Leadership somehow combined or at least
- as part of the general program read about it think about it watch people come and go number two really good to
- find coaches and mentors people know a lot about that so famously John Chambers when Cisco with the digital collapse
- back in1 when the internet had a big Hiccup and seemed to get itself into a lot of trouble uh the famous GE chief
- executive Jack Wells called John up and John Chambers and said John did you learn anything and Chambers said well
- it's been a hellish experience and Chambers uh Welsh said well think what you gone through and I'm coaching you
- right now uh think what You' gone through and don't let that happen again and because you went through it you're
- probably not going to let that happen again and then finally John Chambers as that market changed hugely over 20 years
- making connectors and switches and all the hardware that drives the internet uh he has repeatedly had to learn how to
- lead by literally doing it so he concluded for example it's not our book at one point a lot of ideas were down
- there in the engineering ranks and they just weren't getting up to those who made the final sign off and whether to
- go with him so he radically restructured how decisions were made in Cisco uh because he just he looked
- around him looked around and said look we got a better way to do it let's go with it and thus think about it read
- about it number one get coaches and mentors number two and number three just get out there put up your hand take a
- job that requires both a leadership skill set and an ability to think strategically what haven't I asked you
- that's important to know about your book I'll give you each a shot at adding to yes the book actually has a very Global
- Perspective so we also talk about Jack maah from Alibaba and the growth of Alibaba and in that we he is very much a
- strategic leader and he is uh what he creates is a agility in the organization adaptability but that's because he's
- empowered his leaders to address particular strategic problems so one is the global part I think the other part
- is just that um there is a protocol and even in the case of was go and we go back in his history and he was running
- Michelin in North America where he developed a template which he then brought with him uh it was not conscious
- but he actually used it when he was deployed when he was sent to Nissan from Renault so over time you build your sort
- of repertoire of uh ways of managing and linking them to strategy and Steve I think I would add coming from an
- interview we conducted with the chief executive of in India's largest non-state-owned bank it's a bank called
- ICICI um Chanda kochar is the chief executive today uh recently named by Fortune as the fifth most powerful women
- in business in the world and in our interviews several interviews with her uh she did make I think just a
- fundamentally important point which is as you reach the upper tiers of a company like ICI or a big hospital or a
- community organization you want people below you to think strategically and to exercise leadership
- and so she in recent years she's been CEO now for several years has put a huge emphasis she understands the combination
- of the two on making certain the Next Generation and the generation behind them can think strategically and act
- like a leader well thank you very much for thank you joining us and and uh look forward to uh hearing more about this in
- the future thank you thanks okay [Music]
Brief Summary
Harbir Singh and Mike Usim discuss integrating leadership and strategy in business, citing examples from Microsoft, Nissan, Wells Fargo, and Daimler.
Key points
- Nissan's Turnaround. Nissan's turnaround highlights the need for effective leadership alongside strategy. 'Good strategy but the thinness of the leadership...crippled the organization.'
- The Importance of Integration. Leadership and strategy must work together for success. 'You got to have a great strategy.'
- Wells Fargo's Leadership Failure. Wells Fargo's aggressive strategy led to unethical practices due to poor leadership. 'Good strategy take existing customers...but leadership big big failure.'
- Teaching Leadership Skills. The book emphasizes that leadership and strategy skills can be taught. 'These skills can be taught.'
- John Chambers' Leadership Journey. John Chambers led Cisco for 20 years, adapting through challenges and market changes.
- Empowering Future Leaders. Chanda Kochar emphasizes the importance of strategic thinking in leadership development.
Episode highlights
- Nissan's TurnaroundNissan's turnaround highlights the need for effective leadership alongside strategy. 'Good strategy but the thinness of the leadership...crippled the organization.'βGood strategy but the uh thinness of the leadership at the top...crippled the organization.β2:45Oct 11, 2016
- The Importance of IntegrationLeadership and strategy must work together for success. 'You got to have a great strategy.'βYou got to have a great strategy you got to have a great leadership to go with it.β3:26Oct 11, 2016
- Wells Fargo's Leadership FailureWells Fargo's aggressive strategy led to unethical practices due to poor leadership. 'Good strategy take existing customers...but leadership big big failure.'βGood strategy take existing customers sell them additional products...but leadership big big failure.β11:59Oct 11, 2016
- Teaching Leadership SkillsThe book emphasizes that leadership and strategy skills can be taught. 'These skills can be taught.'βThese skills can be taught.β16:00Oct 11, 2016
- John Chambers' Leadership JourneyJohn Chambers led Cisco for 20 years, adapting through challenges and market changes.βIt's been a hellish experience.β21:40Oct 11, 2016
- Empowering Future LeadersChanda Kochar emphasizes the importance of strategic thinking in leadership development.βYou want people below you to think strategically.β24:22Oct 11, 2016
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





