A Five-Step Process That Can Help Social Enterprises Succeed

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In their e-book titled, The Social Entrepreneur's Playbook, Ian MacMillan, a Wharton management professor, and James Thompson, director of the Wharton Social Enterprise Program, offer specific suggestions to strengthen the effectiveness of social enterprises. In the second of a two-part interview, the authors discuss how two African social enterprises -- one in the chicken feeds business and the other in the sanitation industry -- used a five-step process to maximize the social and business impact of their operations. 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] uh I'd like to talk through some of the chapters uh uh uh that you have in your
  2. book uh uh and and some of the things that social entrepreneurs should be thinking about so to to begin with u you
  3. recommend that social entrepreneurs need to articulate the problem uh that they are trying to solve as well as a
  4. solution that they propose to offer could you take us through some of the steps that they should go through to do
  5. that um what we try to do is push people in into Thinking Beyond just sort of a high level problem there's a problem of
  6. nutrition or there's a problem of education and begin to think a little bit about what it is that the uh the
  7. so-called beneficiaries of this program are going to actually receive and and what the problem is from their
  8. perspective and whether they recognize that they have a problem so for instance in one of the projects in you relate to
  9. this thing mul in in India was the the concept of taking saet of disinfectant and distributing it in villages where
  10. the uh the water was unhygienic and people were subject to all sort of dis dentry type diseases gastric diseases
  11. and high death rates and so on when you arrive in the village it's not evident to the people
  12. in that Village who have very little education that the the connection between the diuretic diseases and the
  13. water and if you tell them that the water's bad and they can't see the microbes or bacteria in that they just
  14. don't believe you so you know it's really important to understand the problem not just from the point of view
  15. of the benefactor but also from the point of view of the beneficiary and so what we do in the
  16. book is we start to give them very systematic ways of beginning to unfold uh what the problem is in the eyes of
  17. the in the eyes of the person who's supposed to benefit one other chapter in your book refers to uh the need to
  18. segment the target population uh I Jim I wonder if you could help explain expl how that this process should
  19. work um ml mentioned in his M to your question M mentioned in in his first response this idea of of finding you
  20. know a group of these beneficiaries or a segment of them that has a higher likelihood of early adoption of what it
  21. is you're trying to do than you know others perhaps and again in the spirit of uh efficient use of
  22. resources and learning and you know the reduction of of of of risk and uncertainty what we we spend an entire
  23. chapter doing is framing a method for segmenting the beneficiaries and you know it's some of the typical
  24. segmentation uh instruments geographic location gender all of that but then there are also behavioral segmentation
  25. issues so what we have is we have a frame work for people to use to segment their beneficiaries and then to select
  26. one with which to start and we articulate the you know the characteristics of a good uh wedge if
  27. you will um uh and and and hopefully a segment that that is most likely to adopt in the shortest space of time at
  28. the lowest cost and provides you know a high rate of learning so that's you know
  29. there's a whole chapter devoted to that now as Mac as you said before sometimes a seemingly wonderful idea leaves the
  30. beneficiaries cold and unresponsive uh uh why why does that happen and what could social entrepreneurs do to uh
  31. prevent their Enterprises from falling into that trap well you know the the the fundamental problem is that people come
  32. in with what I call the wild eyed Western solution to a problem where you you expecting behaviors to
  33. take place in in defiance almost of deep-seated cultural behaviors there's some things that you know you just don't
  34. do so one of the projects that we looked at when I was in uh Cape Town a couple of years ago was the whole idea of uh
  35. beginning to distribute uh tricycles three-wheel bicycles so that women instead of having to carry uh their
  36. crops to the market could actually pedal their crops to the market and that sounds like a wonderful idea but when
  37. you arrive with the bicycles you find out that the the men have decided that women should not ride bicycles that's
  38. something only a man's allowed to do so there you know by not paying attention to what the cultural factors are they
  39. just they just wasted their time and and it's that type of thing uh going in with
  40. uh condoms uh to try and prevent AIDS and you don't take into account the fact that uh in many of the African societies
  41. of fertility is extremely well regarded a fertile woman a woman must be fertile and then secondly the sexual behavior is
  42. not taken into account and this woman goes to her husband and says uh you know I expect you to use a condom you got to
  43. be kidding she can get thrown out of that house she can get sent back to her original family and and live the rest of
  44. her life in disgrace because her husband has banned her from his home you know so
  45. this lack of of cultural sensitivity is often a huge problem why is it important for social
  46. entrepreneurs to identify the most competitive alternatives to the idea that they're trying to propose uh and
  47. how can they use this information that they gather to make their own offering more
  48. valuable there's always a competitor mul as you know Ma alluded to it earlier even if it's what they're doing
  49. today and we stress this because it forces people and we've done this ourselves it forces people into that
  50. environment and to spend time with their you know the beneficiaries they have in
  51. mind and the communities at large and by mapping out what the nearest alternative is to what you know
  52. the team has in mind in effect we're forcing them to build insight into the realities of
  53. that you know sector of the population on the ground as it exists and so that's the first thing the
  54. second thing is it gives a a methodical uh manner with which to compare step by step the idea that a
  55. team has for a social entrepreneurship activity versus what exists on the ground or could exist on the ground
  56. and so we use that to force people to get the kind of information that they should have and then to have a a fairly
  57. hard look at what it is they propose and how it Compares from the beneficiaries perspective with what they're already
  58. doing Ma what operational issues uh do social entrepreneurs need to address before they can deliver their product or
  59. service this is so important that we actually have the uh the would be social entrepreneur develop what what we call a
  60. deliverables table uh where the you need to be very clearly focused on articulating every
  61. that the beneficiary must go through in order to receive a benefit and then think a little bit about what it's going
  62. to take for that benefit to take place so uh let's say youve got a program in which you're Distributing product to uh
  63. Village communities out you know out in the boonies as they say uh you can't just assume that there's going to be a
  64. transportation system that will deliver that stuff you have to think a little bit about not just how is the product
  65. going to be sold but how is the product going to be transported to where you want it sold how are we going to know
  66. that we need to send more do we have a logistical system in place because in in many of these uh situations there just
  67. isn't the infrastructure to do it so what we're looking at here is what's specific operations from the time that
  68. the beneficiary first becomes aware that they have a need and you can fix it uh through uh the final delivery and
  69. consumption of that uh benefit has to be documented and then you got to sit down
  70. and sort of say what physically must happen because uh if the system isn't there it just ain't going to
  71. happen here was one project I think just in terms to illustrate it they had a program in lutu uh in which they were
  72. going to deliver uh medicines by motorbike cuz luta's got very bad roads but you can go on motorbikes to many of
  73. these places so they built this whole program with uh you know uh dozens of motorbike Riders taking taking samples
  74. and taking medicines out to remote areas and everything went fine until the motorbike started breaking down and then
  75. they suddenly found out that there was no one there to repair the motorbox so what you now have is like a mountain of
  76. on used motor BS in that have basically just G to waste the the the the next question is actually for both of you uh
  77. one of the things I found Most Fascinating about your book is the examples that you give of two companies
  78. uh Zambia feeds and eota uh and how they went through the different steps that you've just outlined so could you tell
  79. the knowledge at Wharton audience about these two companies and what are the main lessons that other social
  80. entrepreneurs can learn from their experience Zambia feeds is is a company in the
  81. Northwestern part of Zambia that basically produces fairly high quality animal feed
  82. at uh relatively good prices and the company started uh back in 2000 somewhere there um and has
  83. systematically uh built an alternative production system for poultry rearing in that
  84. region um at the end of last year they had nearly uh 2,000 customers um producing fairly
  85. efficiently really high quality poultry um so of course this had to scale over more than a
  86. decade uh the first thing um when we learned of this uh that we did was to sit down with the
  87. entrepreneur and say all right what is success for you and uh how do you know when you've got there and as simple as
  88. that sounds turns out that a lot of folks don't really think like that the reason we did it was because of the huge
  89. uncertainty in the area and um we put in place a few parameters um that the team needed to to commit to uh
  90. um in order for us you know to continue working with them not that you know not to be arrogant but you know uh we we we
  91. didn't want to commit ourselves to a team of people that was going to use the conventional you know let's come up with
  92. a great idea raise the money and go and build it approach and fortunately uh the
  93. team over there did um now we can't take all the credit we were working with a social entrepreneur from that
  94. environment and she had done this before not this kind of activity but she'd been
  95. in in in Commerce before so uh they started small you know as the book is the pick your segments geographic
  96. location accessibility Etc didn't buy news you know used equipment didn't buy buildings uh attended to the
  97. sociopolitics by starting it as an entrepreneurial venture within an existing company a big company that
  98. could provide some defense from interference and um they then spent the better part of of nearly seven years
  99. building an organization that systematically uh developed these new segments and in keeping with the
  100. philosophy of the book only began to ACR assets you know production assets when they needed to to ACR those uh th those
  101. assets to produce higher volumes at higher quality and fortunately for us that case was the first one we took on and
  102. it's been very very successful in fact they've impacted the the the whole industry in the country um to the degree
  103. where the entrepreneur when she retired last year was on the the national poultry Association uh
  104. board um and we use that case throughout the book as you know the kind of golden
  105. thread from the beginning through the end um as a way to show what was done um and it's it's the applicability of
  106. each of the tools and Frameworks to the case the other really interesting case you have is of a company called eota
  107. yeah uh can you tell us about that one too M do you want to take or eot was not something that we actually worked on but
  108. uh this was a project that one of the Warton students was involved in and uh when she took the course uh that we were
  109. teaching in entrepreneurship here uh what she did is start to bring to bear the whole concept that uh a gentleman
  110. called David Korea uh put together to provide sanitation facilities uh for people who you know
  111. were just basically using the streets and uh the interesting thing there is the is the segmentation of the markets
  112. because uh in adequate sanitation is a huge problem you know millions of people die
  113. every year under the age of five because of the diseases caused by inadequate sanitation and part of the challenge in
  114. the beginning was uh what we want to try to do is build these toilets which were
  115. you know functional uh and were senary but uh people were used to just using the
  116. streets and and uh and ditches and and things like that and uh you his problem is he had to charge money for them to
  117. use these toilets these facilities and people were basically thinking to themselves why the hell should I can pay
  118. we I can do it for nothing so the perceptual breakthrough uh was was enormous and so
  119. as he started to segment he had to think a little bit about make a distinction between the places where there many many
  120. people like in what they call the Estates which are basically the uh the slums in the east African towns uh where
  121. there were hundreds of thousands of people who were exposed to unsanitary conditions uh people in the towns were
  122. you had Municipal toilets uh but which were very very badly maintained and just basically not
  123. kept clean and and then people who could not just Avail themselves of uh you know
  124. uh kind of facilities uh at night where nobody could see them but uh uh and so as he started to focus in on which
  125. segment to go to he said let me try to find a place where uh people cannot uh you I cannot do it in in the open and
  126. then secondly where people do have some money and so the segment he chose was markets because people come to the
  127. markets they're there all day at the markets and uh and people who come to markets tend either to sell or to buy
  128. and that means they got some money and so he got the whole thing started by building in in in in market now the
  129. interesting thing about that particular project is that uh there were two what we call uh unexpected or out
  130. comes uh the first one was that these facilities that he built near the markets became attractive to women
  131. who were going to give birth to Children CU this was a place where you could go and give birth to your child and it was
  132. clean and it was sanitary and so it became a a birthing destination and not just a you know sort of defecation
  133. destination and so there was an unexpected consequence of what they were trying to do and uh the uh the other
  134. thing that they found is that uh the places where there were congregations of people with money uh were not only just
  135. markets but also Shel bus bus shelters places where buses congregated because large numbers of people go backwards and
  136. forwards all the time uh catching buses to and from the town and so they in a way discovered what the true segment was
  137. for that particular form of Enterprise uh neither of which had been anticipated in the beginning beginning but
  138. fortunately he didn't go and build you know a huge network of uh of toilets which no one was going to
  139. use that's a great example and and so to end you know I I I wonder what would you like knowledge at
  140. Warton readers and viewers to do uh to participate in your project uh so that you you can move it on to the next
  141. phase Jim what do you want when did you go yeah firstly read it um we we've taken a slightly different
  142. approach in the publication of this book as you know um there's this ebook uh that's going out pre-launch of
  143. the full book and what we're trying to do is use it you know in the spirit of uh of of the approach of the book you
  144. know start small uh and and change fast is we'd like to get responses from readers out there and we're going to use
  145. those not every response but we're going to use those responses to tweak if you will the balance of the
  146. book uh pre final publication um in October November this year and the third thing is spread the
  147. word uh you know if if any of our readers uh are in the space you know use the book to spread the word and if any
  148. of our readers know people in this space uh please get the book out there um we think it'll be useful and everybody
  149. we've tested it with has found it very very useful in the field nonprofit or for-profit so hopefully our readers can
  150. help us do that Ma any final words yeah you know the basic strategy at the moment is is our ebooks a free book we
  151. want to we want to give anybody access to it if they want to download the first piece which is the due diligence piece
  152. which will help people really think through if they want to do something that's going to do some good out there
  153. and increasingly people want to do that particularly the younger generation so uh the idea is that if you
  154. if you know of anybody who might be interested just send them the the uh the address the the URL and they can
  155. download it it's theirs we don't want to make money out of this uh what we want to do is is is have impact and uh uh
  156. you know anybody who you know who's making charitable contributions and may be a little concerned about how well
  157. those contributions are being spent and dispersed uh send them the the ebook and
  158. they can have a look at it because if I'm I mean I make donations uh I want to be able to think that my donations are
  159. being spent well rather than you know just spent uh squandered and uh the uh the idea would be is that anybody who's
  160. making donations today might want to have a look at it and then challenge the people to whom they're making it
  161. donations to see whether they're in fact following the disciplines we suggest uh
  162. to me this is not a popularity contest you know we're not there to be popular we there to have impact right well ma
  163. Jim thank you so much for speaking with knowledge at whorton yeah thank you uh was good to chat to
  164. you [Music]

Brief Summary

Social entrepreneurs must understand beneficiaries' perspectives and cultural contexts to create effective solutions, as discussed by Ma and Jim.

Related episodes