Why Social Entrepreneurs Should Pressure-Test Their Ideas

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Social entrepreneurs -- or those who try to tackle major social problems such as poverty and disease while generating revenues -- are often well-meaning people. But in their desire to make a difference to society, they sometimes fail to subject their ideas to rigorous tests. Ian MacMillan, a professor of management at Wharton, and James Thompson, who leads the Wharton Social Enterprise Program, are working on an e-book titled, The Social Entrepreneur's Playbook, to help them do just that. In the first of a two-part interview, MacMillan and Thompson explain why it is important for social enterprises to subject their beloved notions to tough love. 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] to begin with uh I I wonder if we can talk a little bit about the work that
  2. both of you have been doing with social entrepreneurs for the past 13 years and how that led to the writing of this book
  3. so Mac maybe you could start us off on that so the origin was uh we felt that there's so much need out there for
  4. people to uh to be helped and so much funding kind of being used Without Really accomplishing too much in the way
  5. of uh uh impact uh not because people weren't well meaning but because we needed a more managerial way to look at
  6. uh how how to provide provide this assistance to people and uh since we're in the entrepreneurship program uh one
  7. of the things that came to mind as we were talking about this is can we use entrepreneurship as a weapon to tackle
  8. social problems uh both of us feel that there needs to be practical things to tell people to do
  9. or suggest they do and uh we decided that one of the ways to really come up with practical stuff was to go actually
  10. go out and try to do it ourselves and uh and learn our way into what the methodologies would be to create
  11. sustainable uh organizations that don't create self dependence but rather create
  12. self-sufficiency and that was the basic theme and uh Jim uh was the first guy in
  13. to to to go out there and actually begin to try to do it uh working with an entrepreneur who uh wanted to develop uh
  14. a feeds program to raise chickens did you have anything to add yes I think the one of the key distinctions of the
  15. approach we took was the use of field research and uh social entrepreneurship back then
  16. wasn't what it is today so when we started out the conventional path there wasn't a lot to go and research in the
  17. form of you know casework and and uh other material and to Max Point uh one of the key outcomes of the research that
  18. we were looking for um was a framework a tool you know how do you go and do this
  19. and do it in such a way that uh that you increase your chances of success and and
  20. minimize uh the resources used in attempting to do what you're trying to do so uh we used field research to learn
  21. our way into the space and of course the book is the fruit of uh the last decade
  22. plus of field research right now one of the ideas that you really emphasized in the book is the idea of uh pressure
  23. testing uh the the the core idea of the social Enterprise why is it important for a social Enterprise uh to subject
  24. itself to this kind of a pressure test M you want to take this one first the theme if you think about it is that
  25. if there were an easy entrepreneurial solution to the problem it would have been developed
  26. already and so these are very very tough intractable problems and uh the characteristic feature of these types of
  27. Enterprises is huge amounts of uncertainty and so uh it's so easy to go charging down the road spending other
  28. people's resources uh only to find out that your idea wasn't well baked in the first
  29. place so the theme of the book is to give the wouldbe social entrepreneur a series of questions they
  30. need to ask themselves after going through what we call a a number of due diligence phases and if at the end of
  31. that particular due diligence phase you can't answer yes to most of those questions you fail the pressure test and
  32. you should abandon get out early and cheap and conserve those resources for something it might might
  33. work I think uh adding to what Max just said um the distinction we make by using
  34. the term pressure test is that we suggest in in in certain instances particularly where there's
  35. really high uncertainty or what we call neonian uncertainty that rather than going in
  36. trying to prove you're right it is sometimes smarter to go in and try and prove you're
  37. wrong provided you've structured your activity in the right Manner and that's the pressure testing of this so it's
  38. doing the due diligence up front and not trying to force your case into a highly
  39. uncertain environment but rather trying to find ways to show where you're wrong so that you can learn adapt redirect and
  40. build your Enterprise right now to go back m to the point that you raised a little earlier uh all startups face
  41. risks but you said that social Enterprises face a much greater degree of uncertainty uh than normal startups
  42. why why is that the case and what can be done about it well we use the term uncertainty in the context of an
  43. economist named Frank Wright and Frank Knight sorry and and what Frank said was uh that uh when you have a distribution
  44. of possible outcomes that's risk when you don't even know what the distribution is that's
  45. uncertainty and this is one of the problems with the startup you don't know whether there's going to be appropriate
  46. governance you don't know whether there's a market you don't know whether there's customers you don't know the
  47. prices you don't know what materials are going to cost and so on so there's just
  48. huge amounts of uncertainty and U truly uncertain you know you can't do anything because you
  49. just don't know what's going to happen and that's why we coin the phrase NE nighty and uncertainty where the levels
  50. of uncertainty are enormous let me uh suggest you that one of the features of what we're trying to do here is by
  51. putting the wouldbe social entrepreneur through their Paces by giving them what we call these tough love questions to to
  52. ask is that we driving the risk out so the uncertainty doesn't go away but if you're able to configure your your
  53. Enterprise in such a way that you you uh uh have driven out the risk then you can
  54. afford to take on un certain projects Jim uh whom was this book for uh it sounds like uh I mean you've
  55. written it for social entrepreneurs but would it be relevant to other people including conventional entrepreneurs
  56. absolutely M I think uh one we're we're reticent to make very very Broad and general claims of applicability but as
  57. we've as we've put the drafts of the book out to various uh communities we've got overwhelmingly positive responses
  58. with of course some some good commentary uh from other areas for example our school of social policy and
  59. practice the nonprofit students uh are finding ways to use this material so the nonprofit sector of course
  60. uh we believe to be uh a Market that or a sector of the economy as big as it is that might find this
  61. very useful so that's the one you know people in nonprofits trying to do more with less uh this book will help them do
  62. that the second Community are the the funding agencies foundations philanthropists uh the one of the big
  63. cries out there today is transparency so how do we know when these activities are
  64. doing what they claim they're doing uh how do we compare them one against another uh and you know let's face it
  65. nonprofits face the equivalent levels of comp competition for funding that a regular firm does and we think that this
  66. book will give them tools to communicate to their funding communities uh fairly strongly how it is they're doing what
  67. they're doing and how they're measuring the social impact that they're having so
  68. that's the second the third are corporations many many companies around the world today um are looking at social
  69. impact indices are getting measures on you know measured on Corporate social responsibility programs and a lot of the
  70. folks we spoken with in these companies said look this is not what we've typically done how do we do it
  71. responsibly you know they have stockholders they have stakeholders in The Firm out of the firm and we think
  72. this this will give them a set of tools to begin to think about what they're doing and do it in a manner that gives
  73. them uh greater impact with the resources that they dedicate to these programs um Mac how how does your model
  74. help social entrepreneurs move from uncertainty to risk or in other words from what is plausible to what is
  75. plannable the basic idea is to give them a series of exercises to go through and
  76. you start off really thoroughly uh identifying what the real problem is and how it's
  77. dispersed uh so for instance is is this problem something that's unique to a small territory or is that something
  78. that's you know across a whole continent uh make some decisions about who the initial Target segment would be
  79. that's going to benefit so you go for the segment that will benefit the most but will also adopt your offering the
  80. easiest then uh the next step is to start to think pragmatically about uh what is the act the competition today
  81. for you know the solution to this problem and often times that's simply doing nothing so people have existed in
  82. many cases for you know dozens if not hundreds of years uh suffering from malnutrition or hunger or lack of
  83. education and it's something that they used to so we have them have a look at what are you competing against Because
  84. unless you can come up with something that from the beneficiary's point of view is better than the nearest Al
  85. alternative you're wasting your time so we have a look at the market characteristics and we look at the
  86. competition we have a look at the finding the segment where you'll get the most traction as soon as possible and
  87. then begin to think a little bit about the uh uh politics of going into the space and uh what you need to do to make
  88. sure that you don't fall foul of the politics uh and so what you have is a systematic unfolding of more and more
  89. insight and what it's going to take to really do this and make this happen great uh Jim uh since you mentioned
  90. fieldwork uh was a big part of the way in which you worked on this book uh uh could you tell me a little bit about
  91. what some of what are some of the most common mistakes that you found social entrepreneurs make by not following the
  92. process that Mac just outlined it's a good question M um I think possibly at the top of that list
  93. is the formulation of a plan by a group of individuals with the best of intentions to go somewhere else in the
  94. world that they don't know a lot about they perhaps know a lot about the subject that they're attending to in the
  95. the part of the world they come from conceiving this plan you know on another continent for example going raising
  96. resources sometimes you know significant amounts of resources to go and do what they believe to be you know a wonderful
  97. uh uh activity and getting there and realizing that the way they envisaged it to work
  98. was never going to work and yet they've committed themselves to this unilateral course of action a business plan if you
  99. will and then spend 2 3 four 5 years floundering and learning uh why it's not going to work the way they they uh
  100. envisioned it would so that would be the top the the others that come to mind are
  101. uh cash flow management and we stress this in the book um as a result of a lot of these
  102. activities what we find is that there's even greater uncertain uncertainty with respect to cash flow uh in these types
  103. of environments this is not new to anybody in entrepreneurship but in these environments it can be even tougher to
  104. manage cash flows uh for all sorts of reasons regulatory uh availability of foreign
  105. exchange for example Etc so that would be the second one and then uh perhaps the third one to mention here and we
  106. have a list of them in the book of course is uh is the idea of redirection is how does one think about
  107. redirecting as you know the reality of of being on the ground unfolds and what we've tried to do in
  108. this book is attend to to that because we know it happens we've seen it in every single case we've been involved
  109. with is is this realization that your plan needs to change if you want to keep doing what you're doing but now you've
  110. got to redirect and that means getting all your stakeholders on board to redirect uh reconfiguring your your
  111. operations model sometimes reconfiguring your funding model so those would be the
  112. three that that are top of Mind thing to add I I'd rather than add rather sort of
  113. reinforce I think one of the big tragedies that is that people assemble a wonderful solution to a problem that
  114. they've not really studied hard enough for the for the context where it's going to be
  115. implemented uh and then they'll go over with all that money and all that energy and all that excitement and find that
  116. the so-called beneficiaries the recipients of this lares that they've put together is they just could care
  117. less or they're very very resistant and and so all that money which is desperately needed to help people who
  118. are in need just goes to waste because people have been thoughtless uh another big problem is
  119. that people go over and they set in motion this program and then find that they can't sustain it and then they have
  120. to walk away from what they set up in the first place and uh a specific example here was uh a case which was
  121. identified by one of the authors that we use and he went over to East Africa uh and while he was there he ran
  122. into a group of people who would were feeding children and what had happened is that mothers had stopped nursing
  123. their children and fed the FED these children with what they they called wet wet feed and uh they ran out of funds
  124. and and so what they did now is they just packed up their tents and went home and all those women who would have been
  125. able to continue feeding their children by breastfeeding uh now could no longer do
  126. it they were out of lactation and so all these kids are under enormous stress because the the money's not there the
  127. Project's not there nobody's really thought through what the uh what the outcome would be in the event of failure
  128. so you create dependence and then you fail and so one of the big learnings that we got out of this program in
  129. observing what was happening over in Africa and uh uh other countries is uh the whole idea that uh if you have to
  130. leave think about having to leave the project before you even start it think about how if you have to leave you you
  131. leave behind what we call a light footprint so that if you you have to go you've had minimal damage on the people
  132. who's who are supposed to be the beneficiaries of what you're doing and and so to end you know I I I
  133. wonder what would you like knowledge at warton's readers and viewers to do uh to
  134. participate in your project uh so that you you can move it on to the next phase Jim what do you want when did you
  135. go you firstly to read it um we we've taken a slightly different approach in the publication of this book
  136. as you know um there's this ebook uh that's going out pre-launch of the full book and what we're trying to
  137. do is use it you know in the spirit of uh of of the approach of the book you know start small uh and and change fast
  138. is we'd like to get responses from readers out there and we're going to use the those not every response but we're
  139. going to use those responses to tweak if you will the balance of the book uh pre final
  140. publication um in uh October November this year and the third thing is spread the
  141. word uh you know if if any of our readers uh are in the space you know use the book to spread the word and if any
  142. of our readers know people in the space uh please get the book out there um we think it'll be useful and everybody
  143. we've tested it with has found it very very useful in the field nonprofit or for-profit so hopefully our readers can
  144. help us do that Ma any final words yeah you know the basic strategy at the moment is is our ebooks a free book we
  145. want to we want to give anybody access to it if they want to download the first piece which is the due diligence piece
  146. which will help people really think through with want to do something that's going to do some good out there and
  147. increasingly people want to do that particularly the younger generation so uh the idea is that if you
  148. if you know of anybody who might be interested just send them the the uh the address the the URL and they can
  149. download it it's theirs we don't want to make money out of this uh what we want to do is is is have impact and
  150. uh you know anybody who you know know who's making charitable contributions and may be a little
  151. concerned about how well those contributions are being spent and dispersed uh send them the the ebook and
  152. they can have a look at it because if I'm I mean I make donations uh I want to be able to think that my donations are
  153. being spent well rather than you know just spent uh squandered and uh the uh the idea would be that anybody who's
  154. making donations today might want to have a look at it and then challenge the people to whom they're making the
  155. donations to see whether they're in fact following the disciplines we suggest uh
  156. to me this is not a popularity contest you know we're not there to be popular we're there to have
  157. impact Mac Jim thank you so much for speaking with knowledge at Wharton no thank
  158. you it was good to chat to you [Music]

Brief Summary

Mac and Jim discuss their book on social entrepreneurship, emphasizing field research and pressure testing ideas to ensure effective impact.

Key points

  • The Role of Entrepreneurship in Social Change. Exploring how entrepreneurship can address social issues and create sustainable solutions.
  • Understanding Uncertainty in Social Enterprises. Discussing the unique challenges social enterprises face compared to traditional startups.
  • Common Mistakes of Social Entrepreneurs. Identifying pitfalls that social entrepreneurs often encounter in their projects.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes