Doing Good, Doing Well

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello I'm Katherine Klein I'm the vice Dean for social impact at Wharton and a professor in the management department
  2. and I am delighted to be here interviewing Our Guest Jonathan greenblat uh who has an extraordinary
  3. career in the social impact space every every uh venue within that space Jonathan you are a senior fellow at
  4. Wharton and we love having you here you are a Serial social entrepreneur with lots of experience in the business SE
  5. you built uh several successful Brands including ethos water which many of us may know from buying ethos water when
  6. we're not buying coffee at Starbucks so you've had successful exits uh you're an
  7. experienced corporate executive you worked at Starbucks you've worked with Google you've been in politics you were
  8. a member of the White House a director of the office of Social Innovation and civic participation at the White House
  9. until quite recently uh and you will soon take the role as National director or CEO of the Anti-Defamation
  10. League so this is business government nonprofits uh and uh I I think today I want to focus on this this title we've
  11. we've said this your experience as a serial social entrepreneur and talk about the business of social impact sure
  12. you want to start with uh when you think of yourself and you get this you're obviously comfortable with a label
  13. serial social entrepreneur let's start with what's a social entrepreneur so I think about a social entrepreneur based
  14. on a definition that was laid out many years ago by Sally osberg of the skull foundation and Roger Martin who's the
  15. dean of the rotman School of Business uh up in Canada I think about a social entrepreneur is someone who tries to
  16. create change through a market-based approach that's about taking direct action so not necessarily lobbying or
  17. doing advocacy but Lally going in and creating something that is trying to do so in order to create or let's say fix a
  18. broken disequilibrium so it's not someone who's trying to do something on the outside that isn't causal but
  19. instead trying to create systems change and repair a difficult societal ill so the social entrepreneur creates direct
  20. action to fix a broken system for profit necessarily I think it can be both so I
  21. think you can see social entrepreneurs in the nonprofit space who use that sort of model to attack a particular issue in
  22. a field it could be healthare could be housing could be micro could be Finance I'm all I personally am more interested
  23. in what we've seen in terms of social entrepreneurship in the business Community okay so let's talk about that
  24. social entrepreneurship in the business community and let's start with uh with ethos water you were relatively early in
  25. this space we've seen a lot of evolution what what did you try to do in in ethos
  26. water talk brag a little bit what have been the successes and the the wisdom of what you created so ethos Water started
  27. with my business partner Peter Thum we were roommates in business school at Kellogg for two years which is a lesson
  28. for all the young Wharton students out there as they think about their classmates uh Peter had this idea of
  29. creating a bottle of water that would use part of its profits to fund humanitarian water projects as we
  30. initially thought about it he thought about it initially over time we we then started the company and over time our
  31. model evolved and when did you start the company we started Pete started working
  32. on it in 2002 and we came together in late 2002 m 2002 and when did you sell the company to Starbucks we sold it in
  33. April of 2005 so fast fast yeah pretty fast it's funny you see this pattern of starting scaling and selling on a pretty
  34. rapid time frame in Silicon Valley all the time right in cpg or in other kind of categories it's a little less common
  35. right nonetheless the model was predicated on this notion that we could connect consumption to the cause so if
  36. you look at the first generation of social Enterprises in the business world businesses like Ben and& Jerry's yeah or
  37. Body Shop yep or Stonyfield Farms here you had products and brands that were about ice cream or about yogurt or about
  38. you know uh hand like hand cream lotion personal care products right that were not
  39. necessarily tied to the causes they sought to address they were organic healthier may have had better supply
  40. chain more that's right right that's right they they they aimed in that like I think you know Ben and Jerry's didn't
  41. use recombinant Bine growth hormone right right but now consumers didn't understand that and the body shop
  42. aspired to do things with better sourced inputs from the Amazon but again consumers didn't understand that we
  43. thought consumers would understand this basic idea of bottled water which is kind of an irrational category to begin
  44. with connecting its consumption to clean water issues it's a huge Global problem
  45. so what's gotten more familiar and there is a a one for one model so so people may have heard from of a one for one
  46. model we see that in Tom shoes perhaps most famously you know and and I know they've evolved their model but it was
  47. hey hey consumers you know buy a cool pair of these shoes and we will donate a pair of shoes right so ethos water it's
  48. a little bit of a different it wasn't hey hey hey uh buy a buy a bottle of water from Starbucks previously you and
  49. we will donate a bottle of water elsewhere what what was it so our notion was if you buy this bottle of water we
  50. initially aspired to donate up to 50% of our profits to fund humanitarian water programs around the world now I say
  51. programs because it wasn't just a project or that kind of Hardware like a like a new
  52. latrine instead or or a new uh like well and that matters but the hardware is no
  53. good without software so we also sought to do hygiene education and to create sort of economic schemes that would make
  54. the water system sustainable yeah so that approach is really different than saying I'm going to invest in a
  55. community here in order to create an ecosystem around water is very different than saying we'll give somebody a pair
  56. of shoes but there it seems like it's different in at least two ways one is right it's a commitment that's around
  57. we're going to donate 50% of our profits not uh you know it's not it's not tied to we're each one of our products we're
  58. selling it's tied to our products and um it's not tied to a particular solution I'm going to give away a bottle of water
  59. you had more flexibility more ability to change the an ecosystem yeah I think our
  60. approach so let's take those two things starting with the latter I think our approach was more strategic and the one
  61. for one model is often more tactical right so we were investing strategically versus techically giving someone
  62. something sure it's more like it's not teaching a man to fish it's creating an ecosystem around a fishery ecosystem
  63. better than giving someone a fish right but on the on the flip side look I will say that I think Toms and Warby Parker
  64. and these other businesses who are endeavoring to do this model I think it's admirable I think we should
  65. encourage them right I would simply say I think the model can continue to evolve
  66. in ways that create more enduring change and you know what else connect the consumers to the issue more effectively
  67. though I would argue that can when you you know the Simplicity of the hey buy a pair of shoes and we'll give a pair of
  68. shoes away uh may not be the right solution and I know Toms has has been criticized and has evolved their their
  69. model but from a consumer perspective it's it's very concrete very clear well now you're kiding something of the key
  70. so the consumer wants to understand hey I do this what happens yeah so our slogan was every bottle makes a
  71. difference helping children get clean water right simple I buy this water someone gets water but the fassil I buy
  72. this water we give someone a bottle of water that's crazy right and so we we thought it would be more respectful of
  73. the consumer's intelligence right to have a model that was honestly more intelligent and smarter with that said
  74. um I do believe that Toms and Warby are evolving their approaches absolutely to accommodate for what is the complexity
  75. of the issues and as a consumers as consumers awareness has increased their expectations have increased and they
  76. demand more from these Brands than just oh I buy it you give it away right right
  77. so you know you started this company by the way you know Tom's didn't start you know who started this model Nick Negron
  78. started this model remember the one laptop per child oh yeah sure the way he went to Market out of the digital Lab at
  79. MIT and he had a great partnership with companies who helped you buy a laptop initially he was going to give them away
  80. and then he realized you buy a laptop here we'll give one away over there yeah yeah very interesting so if that's the
  81. start of the one for one model and your your company was an early social Enterprise what are you seeing in the
  82. space as you look at the new ways that businesses and let's stick with that the business enterprises the new ways
  83. businesses are engaging in social impact whether you want to be thinking about social Enterprise or corporate social
  84. responsibility or the places they're they're blending what are you seeing that you think this is interesting and
  85. and there's potential here if we can grow this in the bus sector what's interesting I think is you certainly are
  86. seeing lots of innovation in the supply chain or the value chain more and more give us an example well more and more
  87. businesses are using um more sustainable Supply chains so think about a business
  88. like um oh I don't know like a so Tesla be an example right so it's a better battery and it's produced in a way that
  89. makes the car more efficient right we hear this a lot about about Nike for example exactly so there're interesting
  90. models where it could be the inputs if you will the materials it could be the labor force so there are businesses that
  91. are trying to use labor forces let's say overseas and give their workers better opportunity even here at home the
  92. company in Detroit The Watch Company in Detroit is doing this whose name I can't
  93. seem to remember now very unhelpfully one watch one I think it's got the word one in it but there but there but you're
  94. starting to see some interesting models like that so from it could be the labor force it could be the materials it could
  95. be the way you go to market right like using climate friendly vehicles to deliver your product if you will or
  96. something so that stuff the supply chain work is interesting and of course there
  97. are businesses who are doing interesting things on the back end V how they give away part of their profits right uh I
  98. think the interesting things are happening not in the value chain and in the profit distribution but on the front
  99. end and how these businesses are getting created and how these business are measuring
  100. their impact so great let's talk about so the first side you know we've seen we're here in Philadelphia which is the
  101. headquarters of blab right the organization that has developed this interesting model of certifying
  102. companies right um and you get that cert you take their audit and you get that certification and you get this B
  103. Corporation status right or there's actually right a distinction between the legal status of being a b Corporation a
  104. benefit Corporation and the certification process of of being bab certified and and the you know just to
  105. clarify the bab certification is assessing uh multiple aspects of the company right what is its Workforce what
  106. is its Mission what is its environmental impact and so on in all the ways this could be a mission driven company it's
  107. exactly right so their certification process is what's interesting to me because we're seeing all kinds of
  108. businesses start to adopt this businesses you might not expect consulting firms an example like or
  109. different companies who really don't fit the Ben and Jerry's Tom Sho ethos water
  110. model right um now as you were saying we're now starting to see policy catch up with this as different states are
  111. accommodating for and allowing businesses to incorporate as for benefit companies right using in many case some
  112. of the stuff of the B Corp um certification process so that's very interesting because as we see more and
  113. more businesses take those princip and put it into their Charter right make it part of the way they serve not just make
  114. it explicit part of their value proposition to serve stakeholders as well as shareholders that's really
  115. different and that flips Milton Freeman on its head right so that's neat and then kind of related to this becomes the
  116. way that we measure value so let's let's pause for a moment I want to get to there but I know one of the questions
  117. that that um you know that I've heard about this B certification is okay this B certification and if you believe in
  118. these social missions you believe businesses can do this this is good and yeah we kind of know that that consumers
  119. may be interested but the vast majority of these companies uh are are private companies a few of them have gone public
  120. um or been acquired uh but one of those question marks out there is what happens
  121. when they go IPO right did you know will people look at this company and say wow
  122. we want to invest like crazy this has so much of a social Mission and an economic
  123. Mission or will they will they say H that's nice economic Mission probably just okay given the social what are the
  124. assumptions that investors may have in their heads about a company that's Mission driven you know B certified and
  125. is it worth investing so that's it's an interesting question I don't think we know the answer yet you know today as
  126. the day we're recording this Etsy just filed for they filed for the public offering 90 days ago they're going out
  127. today they'll start trading today we'll see how we'll have one case at least and
  128. there's another firm there's email marketing firm in North Carolina that I think is out but Etsy will be the most
  129. prominent public Equity with the B status yeah so that's fascinating see how it plays out when there are
  130. questions in the boardroom shareholders versus stakeholders when there are questions in the annual meeting
  131. shareholders versus stakeholders who wins right hard to say right um so I think we're going to work those things
  132. out on the other hand we do have lots of big companies who aspire to be better for the world and don't even have that
  133. status right so think about Google for example yeah sure Google's been very explicit with their don't be evil Mantra
  134. they don't have B certification and they are trying to maintain their line now the way they've done it right is with
  135. the different the different classes of stock and the the controlling stock if you will is owned by the founders Sergey
  136. and Larry I think maybe Eric Schmid but all of the shareholders the common shareholders don't have the controlling
  137. stock that they do right so they continue to make the Strategic decisions for the company because of these two
  138. classes of of equity right and Whole Foods would tell you I know we've been we were recent speaking with the co-ceo
  139. Walter Rob I mean he was very explicit hey our purpose comes first and our profits follow and very much sees the
  140. mission driven elements of of Whole Foods Howard Schultz would say the same thing as Starbucks right sure right um
  141. you know we see other corporate leaders beginning to adopt a similar Mantra you know Richard Branson has started his
  142. thing called the B team with corporate CEOs who are trying to Aspire to similar a dual mission where
  143. purpose theoretically comes before profit yeah now on the other hand if you don't have any
  144. profit got to be very right so so it's it'll be inter profit allows you you know in the ideal world what we hope
  145. we're seeing in this space is that the profit drive a virtuous cycle right that's right profit purpose drives
  146. profit drives purpose but we come back to this question that you raised earlier which is you know as we see companies go
  147. public and there are shareholders getting involved how does that actually play out
  148. what are the pressures upon those buses and then you wanted to talk about the other end of the spectrum oh measurement
  149. so I think ultimately and this may answer the first question as firms are beginning to develop integrated models
  150. to actually measure not just their financial performance but their sort of social environmental right Etc
  151. performance so out of that b certification process has come something called gears right which is a
  152. measurement system which is quite interesting um M gears it's the impact in global impact investing rating system
  153. right and that is being applied right now to funds yeah to evaluate their portfolio right and I think what's
  154. meaningful about that is it's creating the conditions in which these fund managers are looking at their portfolio
  155. of investment say how do we perform right and by the way that may be one of the most interesting things about blab
  156. is not the thousand plus companies who now have the certification right far more businesses have taken the self-
  157. audit right the fact that they've created the conditions in which entrepreneurs and Executives managers at
  158. all levels are thinking about these issues that alone is a contribution I think to the to the National
  159. conversation right yeah know i' I've heard the founders speak essentially it's like a checklist that says huh I'm
  160. not eating enough enough vegetables am I right you know they're they're reflecting on that yeah it's like a food
  161. plate of uh firm performance isn't it right and the impact measurement piece I think is is a really important piece to
  162. come to in this conversation because um you know as as you know when we've talked about this in the in the past
  163. there's such there's so much that's inspiring in this in this space but there are parts that are worrisome right
  164. that companies may come on board without a genuine commitment to social impact without careful evaluation of what
  165. they're doing and without uh accountability to create an impact and there's you know potential for abuse I I
  166. fear down the line as this as these kind of business become businesses become more and more common so the commitment
  167. to impact assessment and accountability and transparency about this is what we're doing this is what the real impact
  168. of our business is would seem to be a really important Safeguard it's absolutely crucial it's crucial for a
  169. couple reasons so number one although I think Millennials in particular maybe in
  170. part because of social media they can sniff out what isn't authentic um so brands that aren't
  171. really you know True to this are often exposed yes um so that is a bit qualitative but on the quantitative side
  172. if we ever really hope to bring Capital into this field at scale if we hope to do the kind of comparative analysis that
  173. makes gives us the ability to analyze those public equities like we were just talking about so you can compare whole
  174. foods' performance to superv value or to Kroger's or to Albertson's we need a set
  175. of common measures by which we can judge their performance on something other than EPS right um so I think it's
  176. important for that reason and then thirdly because because if we really hope to create change at scale we need a
  177. discipline and a rigor um around measuring you know quarter on quarter year on year how we're making progress
  178. on key metrics so you know you manage what you measure sure so the Advent of measurement systems I think augur well
  179. if we want managers to be focusing on this great Jonathan it's been fabulous talking with you we need to uh pull this
  180. to a close even though we could keep talking for hours I know so great do it again I hope so and great insights on
  181. the you know the business of social impact thanks thank you being with us [Music]
  182. thanks

Brief Summary

Jonathan Greenblatt discusses social entrepreneurship, ethos water, and evolving corporate responsibility models in this episode.

Key points

  • Ethos Water's Unique Model. Ethos Water connects consumption to humanitarian efforts, donating profits to clean water projects.
  • The Evolution of Social Enterprises. Katherine Klein discusses how social enterprises are innovating in supply chains and impact measurement.
  • B Corporation Certification. The B Corporation certification process assesses companies on their social and environmental impact.
  • The Importance of Measurement. Effective change requires rigorous measurement of key metrics over time.
  • Closing Thoughts with Jonathan. A reflective conversation on social impact and the need for ongoing dialogue.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes