What Worked (and Didn’t) in This Year’s Super Bowl Ads

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE This year’s Super Bowl ads featured big budgets, nostalgia, humor, and heavy AI integration — but did they truly stand out? Americus Reed, Wharton Professor of Marketing, breaks down why the creative bar may have reached a plateau, how brands leaned on familiar characters and emotional storytelling, and what the Pepsi vs. Coke dynamic signals about competitive strategy. Reed also explores how AI is shaping advertising creativity and why brands must extend the conversation long after game night.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#SuperBowlAds #AdvertisingStrategy #MarketingAnalysis #BrandStrategy #CreativeMarketing #AIinAdvertising ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, the Super Bowl this year was a bit of a boring game, at least for three quarters. But the other side of the Super Bowl
  2. every year is always the advertisements and which company did the best and drew the most connection with consumers. And a
  3. pleasure to talk about that with Americus Reed, Marketing Professor here at the Wharton School, and also co-host of the
  4. <i>Marketing Matters</i> podcast, which you can listen to every week on the Wharton Podcast Network.
  5. Americus. How are you, sir? Enjoy the game? Hi, Dan, I'm doing very well. It was not an exciting game, like
  6. you said, but you know, as a marketer, we're always ready for the ads. All right. So, what were your general thoughts about the ads? And
  7. maybe even more so, when you're getting ready for a Super Bowl, what are your expectations for the ads?
  8. I love that question, Dan. I think that— I mean, what I saw last night, I was, I dare say— use the term underwhelmed. But I
  9. have to be honest, I was a little underwhelmed. And that's not a bad thing. Because what I think I understand now, Dan, is
  10. that the stakes are so high in a situation where there are very, very few things where 100-plus million people are going to be
  11. watching at the same time. And so all of the companies, brands, products, services, organizations, they realize that
  12. we really have to come with everything we've got. And so it really raises the overall bar such that nothing is
  13. outstanding, nothing is so super differentiated that you're just so blown away. Because every one, every one of these ads, is
  14. really trying to do as much as it can. So I thought there were some good moments, but I have to say that we've reached— for me,
  15. in my opinion, we've reached kind of a plateau, in the sense of, it's just hard to do something that's so incredibly
  16. interesting and differentiated and innovative. Not a surprise that we saw as many ads in and around AI that we saw?
  17. Yeah. I mean, we talked about this last time on the podcast. Really thinking about this notion of AI, and how is AI
  18. changing things? And you and I discussed this. We said, listen, there's going to be a big movement, if not already, to
  19. really integrate creative outputs using AI. And so, you know, it's not surprising that we saw— we saw that last night.
  20. It's a tool, and marketers are going to be forced to use this tool and really try to use it creatively. So that wasn't
  21. surprising. But I think we're going to see more of this. You know, we're going to really see sort of creative wars happening to
  22. see who can really use these tools in the— in the best way possible. Any ads really connect with you? I mean, and even though it was a
  23. down year, in your opinion, there's probably one or two that probably did connect. I know I had a couple.
  24. Yeah, you know what? We were kind of talking about this a little bit back and forth, offline, Dan and I. I loved the
  25. Duncan's ad. I have to give props. - Oh, absolutely. I mean, I know— there's something about nostalgia for me. And by the
  26. way, that was a theme that I think we saw a lot of last night. Like, nostalgia, whether it be in the context of trusted
  27. characters that we've seen or songs that we— that we know really well. We saw a lot of that. And the Duncan's
  28. commercial, for me, had just about every single character from my favorite portfolio of shows that I could possibly
  29. name. And as I saw each one, Urkel and Carlton and Sam from from <i>Cheers</i>. As they come in, I was just like, "This is awesome."
  30. And so I had a really strong reaction to that one. How about you? So, I loved the Lays commercial with the father and daughter. The
  31. farmers. - Yeah. Nice. The— the Dunkin commercial, I thought was great. The one that really, I think, connected with me as well, and I was kind
  32. of a little surprised, was the Kendall Jenner Fanatics ad. - Oh, interesting. - Because that rumor
  33. of her having a negative impact on basketball players has certainly been out there. - Yeah.
  34. And to see her kind of say, "Okay, football guys, now it's your turn. That was kind of funny to me.
  35. That was very funny, Dan. And what I love about this, your point is another sort of theme that I saw last night, and that
  36. is sort of humor. So, one of the things that was very important is to try to strike the right tone. And we see a lot of this
  37. sort of absurdist, what's been called unhinged, kind of meme-erific, if you will, humor to try to sort of make those points
  38. that you were describing in the— in the Kendall Jenner ad. I also love the XFINITY Jurassic Park ad, because I'm a huge fan of
  39. that— of that movie. And I just love the way they sort of turned it around to sort of show, "Here's what would have happened
  40. if you'd have actually had the power to sort of juice the park," and it would have been a totally different, completely different
  41. turn of events for the movie. So that was pretty cool as well. So the— let me touch on the humor component of it as well, and the
  42. dynamic. And I think Budweiser is probably the example I want to use here, because they have a variety
  43. of different brands. So last night, they had an ad for Budweiser, which was the traditional. The horse and the
  44. American Eagle. - Yes. Then they had the Bud Light, which was Peyton Manning, Shane Gillis and other funny guys in an ad. - Yes. Yes.
  45. And so maybe because they have the variety of brands, - That's a great point. - they can play both sides
  46. of the fence a little bit here, and it works out on— great. And maybe there's an expectation of which
  47. brand is going to get which component. The humor, or the— kind of the supportive, you know, connection, the touch
  48. your heartstrings. I love that point, Dan, and I think you putting it into the context of a kind of multi- pronged strategy for Budweiser
  49. and Bud Light makes a lot of sense, right? Especially in the context of Bud Light trying to come back from the last few
  50. years of trying to deal with sort of being in the crosshairs. - Yeah. So I love what they did there, because to your point, they use
  51. a little bit of humor, but they also— for Bud Light. But they also leaned in on this "made of America." This was interesting,
  52. right? Made of America. And you're watching this, you're watching the Clydesdale, you're watching the American Eagle, and
  53. you're— they're trying to, like— they're trying to, like, redefine and really recapture that American identity. So, like,
  54. playing both sides here, and like trying to sort of do a little bit of humor to sort of, like, soften the blow
  55. here for what Bud Light's been dealing with in several years past, but also leaning in on to, "Hey, you know,
  56. we do have a sense of this Americana that we don't want to let go of with respect to our brand." I think it was a very
  57. interesting strategy. And I guess Levi's tried to do that with their commercial,
  58. because it seemed like it was just a variety of different generations of people wearing blue jeans over the course of
  59. that company's time. Dude, I loved that commercial. Recently— or it's, let's say, a
  60. couple of months back, we talked to the former CEO of Levi's. And it's just, dude, the red tag. It's iconic. And I was— I was
  61. counting, Dan, the butts that— sorry for the— the butts that I could recognize in terms of, you know, there's Bruce Springsteen.
  62. You know, you see this, like— wow, this is super iconic imagery. And the notion of, you know, your life is lived in
  63. Levi's just brought to a really nice— a really nice crescendo. And sort of touching all these famous people. I think George
  64. Michael might have been in this, or a reference to him as well. And then to end it with Doecii, sort of a more modern sort of
  65. current pop cultural icon, really just well done. And just really capturing the historical context of Levi's brand.
  66. Let me finish up with this. And it's the dynamic between Pepsi and Coke right now. And you and I talked about this offline. Is
  67. that, obviously they're playing for the same customer base, but they're using— or at least Pepsi is they're using— kind of some
  68. of Coke's backstory with the polar bears to try and support their narrative. And we saw this in another commercial where a
  69. Coke delivery guy was making a delivery to a store, and all the Coke cans fell off, and he drank a Pepsi instead. So that dynamic
  70. between those two companies is very interesting. It's super interesting, Dan. I got to tell you, you're my guy.
  71. I grew up in Georgia, so that's Coke country. - Yeah. - And dear Coca Cola, shots fired. You have 24 hours to respond, because
  72. this is like— we're coming right at you. We're gonna— we're gonna co op your polar bear imagery and iconicness, and we're just
  73. gonna— we're gonna do battle now. And so, Dan, the cola wars might have been revitalized last night. So this will be very
  74. exciting, to see what happens and what Coke's response will be, and sort of what the dynamic and the competition will be moving forward.
  75. What do, then, companies expect after they run an ad in the— in the Super Bowl? I love that question, Dan. So here's the thing. So, what's
  76. happened in the past is, we have this moment where all these folks are engaged in watching, and you capture them in that
  77. moment. What we've seen in marketing is that we've got a pre-build up to that. We saw a lot of brands releasing ads,
  78. teasing ads, all these different things before the big moment. Super Bowl. And then what comes after. Here's the interesting
  79. thing, Dan. They've got to keep this conversation going. They have to keep the water cooler discussion. They want Dan Loney
  80. to come on his podcast and talk about it. They need— they need to keep having the conversations and discussions and elevation of
  81. and amplification of these commercials, because it continues to breathe life into those— into those creatives that
  82. we saw last night. And so this is like a— this is a big event. This is a long-term horizon. And brands are trying to really keep
  83. that energy, that kinetic energy, going across this— this— timeframe, so that they can continue to keep interest and
  84. get people to really focus in and resonate with these different types of ads that they produced last night.
  85. Always fun to talk to you, sir. Thanks very much. Thanks a lot, Dan. Talk to you soon.
  86. Americus Reed, Marketing Professor at the Wharton School and co-host with Barbara Kahn of the <i>Marketing Matters</i> podcast
  87. every week here on the Wharton podcast network.

Brief Summary

Americus Reed discusses Super Bowl ads, highlighting nostalgia, humor, and the impact of AI in marketing strategies.

Key points

  • Super Bowl Ads Underwhelming. Americus Reed shares his thoughts on this year's Super Bowl ads, calling them underwhelming.
  • Nostalgia in Advertising. Reed discusses the nostalgic elements in ads, particularly in Duncan's commercial.
  • The Cola Wars Revived. A discussion on the renewed competition between Pepsi and Coca Cola following the Super Bowl.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes