Vanquishing Childhood Hunger in the U.S.

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Ten years ago, Billy Shore, co-founder of the nonprofit Share Our Strength, decided childhood hunger in the U.S. is a solvable issue. Today, he's close to solving it. 📂 ESG;Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello I'm Katherine Klein I'm the vice dean for social impact here at the Wharton School and I'm really delighted
  2. today to be interviewing Billy sure Billy sure is the executive chairman of no Kid Hungry and its parent
  3. organization share our strength Billy and his sister Debbie co-founded the organization thirty four years ago and
  4. in that time they have raised over six hundred million dollars to fight hunger and food insecurity and poverty in the
  5. United States so Billy thanks so much for joining me today thanks thanks for having me great to have you with us
  6. so my guess is that some of the people who are gonna be reading and listening to this interview don't spend a little a
  7. lot of time thinking about hunger poverty food insecurity in the United States they may vaguely have some sense
  8. of the nature of these problems but help us understand what is the problem of hunger in the United States what is the
  9. problem with food insecurity what's hunger what's food insecurity well hunger in the United States I'll start
  10. with hunger because hunger and food insecurity are actually pretty different but hunger in the United States affects
  11. various populations but the most vulnerable and the least responsible for the situation that they're in are
  12. children and we've got millions of kids in the country about one in six who suffer or struggle with hunger in some
  13. way or with food insecurity I guess the most important thing to understand about
  14. hunger in the u.s. is that it's a solvable problem you know and I would have to give you a single-factor
  15. statistic for you to know that kids here aren't hungry for the reasons the kids around the rest of the world are hungry
  16. it's not war or famine or drought kids are hungry here because not because we don't have food not because we don't
  17. have food programs like the food stamp program or school breakfast school lunch but because we haven't done a good job
  18. of connecting them so hunger is solvable food insecure and hunger is kind of a physiological issue are you getting
  19. three meals a day are you getting the proper nutrition are you getting what your body the calories and then the
  20. protein that your body needs to grow food insecurity is a measure that comes from surveying people and asking a whole
  21. series of questions that are more socio-economic in nature do you make enough money to feel like you can buy
  22. your family the best do you ever have anxiety that you're not going to be able to feed your children
  23. as well as you'd like to so there are a lot of families and children and food insecure who live in food insecurity but
  24. who may not actually be experienced hunger they're both important but in a triage sense you want to make sure that
  25. kids at a minimum are not hungry that they're not missing meals and having all the the negative effects that come with
  26. that right right and I suppose the question may be obvious we answer may be obvious but why focus on kids why not
  27. focus on families communities well for a couple reasons so when sheriff's trains
  28. started as you mentioned 34 years ago we were focusing on hunger and Ethiopia we
  29. were focusing on hunger all across the United States seniors families and one of the things that we thought about was
  30. how do we actually not just alleviate the problem or ameliorate it behind we actually solve it or is there some piece
  31. of what we're doing that we could solve there's a writer named Jonathan Kozol who says that you should pick battles
  32. that are big enough to matter but small enough to win and I love that construct because there's so many things that all
  33. of us care about and you know when you think about what's big enough to matter if it's small enough to win maybe we
  34. can't solve Syria or the Middle East or climate change or organizations can but when it comes to kids who are in this
  35. country who are hungry that is big enough to matter but small enough to win and it's solvable and as I as I
  36. mentioned a moment ago kids are the most vulnerable the consequences of being hungry when you're a child
  37. developmentally can last you the rest of your life and they're the least responsible for the situation they're in
  38. they're just they're kind of born into it so we thought that that was the a winnable issue and we've actually made
  39. tremendous progress against it if you ask me this question five or six or seven years from now I'm pretty sure
  40. we'll say that we've still got poverty we still got food insecurity and we still got hunger but we don't have
  41. hungry kids in the United States great so I want to explore that more with you but but first you've written and talked
  42. about how you made a significant shift and share our strength about ten years ago so talk with us about what made you
  43. make an organizational pivot what was that pivot how did no it was time to make one you know
  44. what's right there yeah well shower strength was a grant maker to probably three hundred to four hundred other
  45. nonprofits around the country well you all were raising money and passing it then yeah and I'd say first for the
  46. first twenty years of our existence what most people knew about us if they knew anything was that we had this very
  47. entrepreneurial way of generating revenues we didn't have any government money or foundation money or high donor
  48. program or direct mail we basically made money we organized chefs and restaurant
  49. tours to do events for us corporate marketing partnerships cause related marketing we did even today we have
  50. contracts with dozens of corporate partners that fund our organization it puts us in the position of not competing
  51. with brother and sister organizations and not having any strings attached to the dollar so we can spend them as
  52. strategically as we wish so we were raising that money bringing new money into the into the field granting it out
  53. it was satisfying to almost everybody except for a handful of us at the center of the organization who were asking
  54. ourselves you know in effect is the glass half empty or half full are we moving the needle are we solving a
  55. problem or we're just putting a bandaid on it and so we realized that we really needed to put kind of a stake in the
  56. ground we need it in this Jonathan Kozol sense of what's big enough to matter but
  57. small enough to win could we pick an area and hold ourselves accountable to actually solving it and again in that
  58. case it felt like childhood hunger would be the the place to do that it required
  59. a big culture shift on the part of the organization all of a sudden we weren't just the good guys giving out money to
  60. others we were accountable to achieving a very specific outcome some people felt
  61. that pressure and it's it's a very different feeling so it's interesting because one way I could interpret what
  62. you're saying is you made a decision to focus your efforts but it sounds like it's and I think many organizations do
  63. that though or you know we're too broad where our messaging is too unfocused we need to focus sounds like you're saying
  64. this was a change that was yes about focusing but it was more than that yeah I I think that's a really interesting
  65. distinction you're making because it was about focusing and accountability and the accountability piece was so
  66. important for us in one sense it's kind of absurd that one little nonprofit organization
  67. would say we're accountable for ending childhood hunger we're just one of many organizations the government plays a
  68. much bigger role than we do but one of the things that we observed in the space that we were working in is there was a
  69. real dynamic of almost everybody pointing the finger at somebody else so advocates in Washington would get
  70. legislation passed and then the governor's wouldn't implement it the way they should or the local organizations
  71. wouldn't everybody else was saying I did my job but somebody else's fault and so
  72. we thought in it just kind of the classic the buck stops here since somebody's got to raise their hand and
  73. say we'll be responsible for getting this done until it's done so as I say in one sense a little bit audacious but in
  74. the other sense it gave our stakeholders a real palpable sense of we can judge where these guys are against their goal
  75. in a world where you don't know if you're getting a better return on investment by giving money to Habitat
  76. for Humanity or Teach for America or City Year or Share Our Strength here's at least an organization that's saying
  77. we welcome you we invite you to judge us here's here's our role and here's how far we are from it and some years we
  78. came closer and some year so we didn't come as close as we said we would and and this has energized your your donors
  79. your partner's I gather I think so I think in a very big way it had a really catalytic impact on them again just kind
  80. of the confidence that we would succeed and the notion that this is not something we're going to be asking them
  81. to support forever there is an endpoint there's a I think the the consulting firm Bridgespan calls it an arrival
  82. point you know there is an arrival point that you'll achieve and you'll know that
  83. you can then go on and climb the next higher Hill right so with the no Kid Hungry campaign really capturing that
  84. with those those three words no Kid Hungry you shifted the focus and said we're gonna end childhood hunger how
  85. what is what share our strengths what is the no Kid Hungry campaign do to end hunger so we defined ending hunger as
  86. making sure kids had three meals a day usually at least whether parents are poor or food
  87. insecure or what-have-you they're probably able to afford at least one meal for their kids they may not be able
  88. to afford three but low-income kids in this country get a free or reduced-priced school lunch that's a
  89. program that was set up in 1946 when generals and admirals returned from World War two and they said to Congress
  90. our recruits by the end of the year we're not strong enough and there they weren't fit enough so we need to start
  91. feeding kids in school better then they added the school breakfast program in 1964 so we've got today 22 million kids
  92. in the country who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch all 22 million are eligible for
  93. breakfast as well but when we looked at this eight years ago only nine million of the 22 million we're getting it so
  94. less than 50% but the crazy thing Catherine is that it's bought and paid for for all 22 millions so try to think
  95. about another issue that we work on in this country where there's a pot of money literally billions of dollars
  96. sitting in Washington that can only be used for this and yet in less than half of them are being used so that was the
  97. opportunity to start enrolling kids and we've done that with breakfast and we've
  98. done it with summer meals and other programs that you're not a government agency so you're not a government agency
  99. saying hey school district put in this program or hey you know whatever the place is to deliver those kids breakfast
  100. so what do you actually do so what we're doing is we're going into school districts and we're saying there's this
  101. program available if you want to participate in it there may be some things you need in terms of startup cost
  102. that we will pay you might need insulated carts on wheels you might need to redo your cafeteria you might need to
  103. hire more cafeteria workers but we will pay for that if you do what you need to do to enroll in the federal government
  104. school breakfast program the meals are 100% federally reimbursed so you can go to any governor in the country and say
  105. governor did you realize that you've left 150 million dollars or whatever the number is in Washington and no matter
  106. how conservatory how liberal they are they all say what do I have to do to get it it's so interesting that's so
  107. interesting so you made this shift in around 2010 you said you're making good progress on the met
  108. you count so tell us about that progress well we've added about 3.2 million kids
  109. to the school breakfast program of the 22 million kids who get lunch not all 22 million of them should get breakfast
  110. because some will have breakfast at home with mom and dad or grandparents or whatever and that's great but the right
  111. number is probably about 15 or 16 million and today we're at about 12 and 1/2 closer to 213 so adding 3 million
  112. kids to school breakfast program over just five or six years has been a really an enormous task and we did it in one
  113. very simple way so I described this program started you know 50 years ago it's always run the same way forever
  114. with almost no changes and somebody said what if we moved breakfast from the cafeteria where kids have to get there
  115. early and many of them can't because the bus driver scheduled their mom and dad scheduled or what have you and then
  116. there's the stigma attached to being the kids who get to school early what if we
  117. move breakfast from the cafeteria to the first 10 minutes of first period every way so when you propose that two things
  118. happen one is everybody you possibly think oh I can think of objects to that idea yeah in the classroom etcetera
  119. etcetera but the other thing happens is participation rates go to almost 95 percent and after sometimes as short as
  120. a week the teachers embrace it and they say oh now I see why this is a good thing of the 3.2 million kids that we've
  121. added which is across thousands of schools nobody's ever gone back to the old way nobody's ever said I wish we
  122. were doing in the cafeteria again it's just it just works too well but it's changed I mean changes you know is
  123. uncomfortable for people right so having made this this this shift and pursue this change in strategy for 10 years
  124. what's the advice that you would give to other organizations whether it's a for-profit or a nonprofit that may be
  125. thinking you know we're not doing as well as we could we're not having the impact whether it's social impact
  126. whether it's financial performance we're not where we should be we need to focus
  127. hold ourselves accountable know I'd say there's three or four things that apply doubt I think many efforts not just our
  128. work in hunger and food security one is what I put under the umbrella of kind of
  129. go big or go home to have a big goal you know put a stake in the ground stand behind it have a goal that's you know
  130. big enough to inspire people the second is to be willing to build your own capacity and to make the assertion that
  131. building your capacity will lead to impact in the nonprofit world as you know everybody wants to know what your
  132. overhead costs are and how much you paying salaries and they want you to put as much money out into the community as
  133. you possibly can and that's great and for the most noble of reasons but if you don't have professional staff if you
  134. don't train them well if you don't retain them then you're really wasting donors money so building your own
  135. capacity is key this accountability issue which we both mentioned I think is also you know a very important one and
  136. then finally I'd say what we came too late later than we should have was this notion that public policy has to play a
  137. very important role then not there are very few problems that nonprofits can solve on their own there are things they
  138. can do in terms of innovating and taking risks but when it comes to scaling up a
  139. good idea that they've created or that they've advanced you're gonna need public support and do you think that
  140. there are other sectors other problems where there is you know as you put a money left on the table where the public
  141. where the public policy exists but isn't being implemented you know as effectively as it could and should be
  142. well I think yeah I think there are a lot of places where the advocates work so hard to get a policy to become law
  143. that once it does they're on to the next thing and that nobody really looks back
  144. so I had this interesting conversation with Marian Wright Edelman from the Children's Defense Fund who is this
  145. iconic leader you know in this space and we were talking about you know what battles we should be fighting and we're
  146. going around the table and she said well I think we should pay attention to what
  147. she our strength is doing because we won these we fought and won these battles 40
  148. years ago so and before we go fight the next ones let's make sure that what we won actually happens and comes to pass
  149. there's a little bit of this in the healthcare and the child health space in particular there states that don't fully
  150. utilize the child health insurance program but there's lots of you know in terms of just performance and
  151. executional issues separate from money there's a lot of improvement that be made across the board and terminate
  152. different pollinators yeah right it makes sense and I think of all the benefits that they do exist but they're
  153. difficult for people to access interesting so one of the big part of your model has been this partnering with
  154. corporations so I'd love to hear more about you know what corporations give you what these businesses are giving you
  155. what they get from it and then I'd like to kind of talk more expansively about the role of business in fighting hunger
  156. and food insecurity well we've thought from the beginning that there's a really big role for the business community and
  157. that there's a role for nonprofits to think about not just redistributing wealth but actually creating wealth you
  158. don't think of nonprofits being in the business of creating wealth of generating revenues but there's no
  159. reason they shouldn't I have a friend who always says that nonprofits should be a tax status not your management
  160. philosophy right you you want to make money and use it for the the things that you do and so when we had this notion
  161. early on and we part of it we understood part of it we stumbled into frankly but
  162. we as we started to organize chefs and restaurant tourists to get involved in the hunger issue since they made their
  163. livelihoods from food we thought they would feel connected to the issue of hunger as we started to do that
  164. companies that market it into the chef and restaurant industry that had something to sell them we're coming to
  165. us saying you're you're a more efficient marketer than we are you've got 500 of the chef's that we want to be carrying
  166. our product how about instead of us going up 500 of them one at a time we strike up a partnership with share our
  167. strength so Citibank is a good example they want chefs and restaurant ORS to use a Visa card instead of an American
  168. Express card and they want to go into the restaurant and have a conversation a little bit different than here's the
  169. point spread on our cars and the fees they want to go in and say hey you and I are we're both partners with share our
  170. strengths why don't we do this like why don't we have a partnership together williams-sonoma Fiji water lily espresso
  171. lots of companies have realized that there are some benefits of doing that and then I think there's also the
  172. important issue of just because they're human things like you and me they want to be
  173. doing something meaningful they want to be having an impact and some of them get
  174. involved for kind of marketing reasons but then stay involved because they find it really fulfilling to be able to offer
  175. their employees this opportunity to to have a big difference and so we often hear about engagement and social impact
  176. engagement by corporations for all those reasons right you know through philanthropy for marketing for
  177. engagement for reputation and even a real belief and the social issues is there you know as you think about the
  178. next 10 years you've been quite visionary about this is there you know as this conversation changes about the
  179. role of business and this notion that businesses should pay more attention to social issues business can and should
  180. have a social impact and it should be part of the social well the the the mission of the organization and the
  181. business model so not necessarily philanthropy or marketing but this is actually core to our business you have
  182. thoughts on that and in this space yeah I think well I think it's related to what's going on in social media and the
  183. pressures that creates on business so you and I are having this conversation on the day that dicks the sporting goods
  184. store announced that they're no longer going to stock the ar-15 right so there's been this you know terrible
  185. incident in in parkland Florida and gun safety is now risen to the top and we've
  186. seen just in the last 10 days dozens of companies start to change their relationship with the National Rifle
  187. Association because they believe it's important for their business it's probably something that they've you know
  188. wanted to do perhaps anyhow but maybe didn't have the courage or didn't realize it aligned
  189. with business reasons so yeah I think I think business leaders are going to play
  190. a larger and larger role and certainly in our case if we've got the CEO of a of a company that can write a letter to the
  191. governor the CEO of Deloitte did a press conference with us in which he said this
  192. was at the time a man named Joe Echevarria s' and he said you know we hire 30,000 young people a year so we've
  193. got to make sure that we've got a pool of young people who are healthy and fit and fed and do well in school and that's
  194. the reason we're so supportive of the school breakfast work so you have that all of a sudden the lens shifts
  195. from kind of this anti-poverty advert me to this very respected business leaders
  196. saying this is good for the economy so yeah I think business will play more of a role right right it's interesting
  197. interesting challenges for CEOs they start to have this larger and a public role so great well it's and if if
  198. somebody wants to learn more about food insecurity hunger or volunteer make a difference you know resources for people
  199. to pursue yeah we've got a lot of them so our our best link to our website is no Kid Hungry org but we've also got
  200. there a Center for best practices that talks about all of the ways that communities around the country are
  201. working on these issues of hunger and food insecurity and poverty we've got a list of all the events that people can
  202. volunteer at or donate to but yet no Kid Hungry or gets the place to go perfect great well Billy sure thanks so much for
  203. talking with me great to greta's hear all about your continuing good work at Share Our Strength thanks for more
  204. insight from knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton UPenn edu [Music]
  205. you

Brief Summary

Billy Shore discusses childhood hunger in the U.S. and the No Kid Hungry campaign's efforts to solve it through school meal programs.

Key points

  • Ending Childhood Hunger. Billy discusses the mission to end childhood hunger in the U.S. and the progress made.
  • The Shift in Focus. Billy explains the organizational pivot to focus on childhood hunger.
  • Impact of School Breakfast Program. Billy shares the success of adding millions of kids to the school breakfast program.
  • The Role of Business in Social Issues. Businesses are increasingly recognizing their responsibility towards social issues, impacting their operations and reputation.
  • Corporate Responsibility in Action. Following recent tragedies, companies are reassessing their relationships with organizations like the NRA.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes