Woo, Wow, Win: Designing a Captivating Customer Experience

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Companies carefully design their products, but they also need to design the customer experience, according to the book, “Woo, Wow, and Win.” More: http://knlg.net/2lJhssQ 📂 Management;Marketing

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. argit's three Tom Stewart and Patricia O'Connell and we're going to talk up to them about their book Wow and win
  2. service design strategy and the art of customer delight Tom and Patricia thank you so much for joining us today on
  3. knowledge at Wharton thank you for having us delighted to be here McCool great but maybe we can start with you
  4. Patricia for the first question what inspired you to write this book I confess I had never heard of service
  5. design until four years ago and I was working with a client at the Savannah College of Art and Design and they
  6. started talking about service design classes and I said what's that and they said service design is when we teach
  7. people how to imagine and think through and then design a customer experience they said people think about user
  8. experience there's been a lot of emphasis on user experience because of all the emphasis on things going online
  9. but they said when you walk into a restaurant you walk into a hotel you interact with a company you go into the
  10. lobby of a business every step of that interaction between you and that company that brand of that business needs to be
  11. designed in order to give you a satisfactory customer experience and I thought this is absolutely fascinating
  12. and I started looking around and I realized that there was not a lot written on that for for the service
  13. market there's a lot about design from manufacturing and I realized that there was really a gap here too to connect the
  14. idea of service to strategy and that's part of where Tom came in and what inspired me to write the book was
  15. Patricia obviously no but seriously one of the things that's really interesting is when you think about it and
  16. particularly in service businesses and you know that a lot of what we know about management
  17. comes from automobile assembly plants and your Deming and and and and Frederick Taylor and and and and all of
  18. that but but when it comes to a service these things need to be can be should be
  19. designed as carefully as products are and when you think about it estate this is also this is the strategy connection
  20. that's the differentiation really and more and more studies are starting to show this that the differentiation is
  21. not the product or the service per se it's not price it's the experience you have what it's
  22. like to go into that restaurant what it's like to work with that law firm and it goes from from you know B to B the B
  23. to C and and in all areas and it also connects to what it's like to go to that auto dealership and and that what it's
  24. like I mean that's the strategic point and by the way that's really hard to copy I can match you on price and I can
  25. match you on how many thread counts are on the sheets in the hotel but what it's
  26. like is is is is a different is a strategic point of strategic differentiation that's hard to be I'd
  27. like to come back to the question of strategy in a bit but what you said reminded me of something really
  28. fascinating that I read right at the beginning of your book you start with this astonishing fact that most
  29. companies are not set up to design service as well and I was wondering why not well you know I think it's partly that
  30. in many respects this first of all the discipline is relatively new and the idea of I'm just in the management
  31. literature managing services has been done by analogy with managing manufacturing for a long time
  32. so I think that's part of it but I think at Patricia pick on this to pick up on this because you're really smart about
  33. it and so much of what companies do is about organizing internal operations but when it comes to services the act of
  34. production is with the customer it's not in the factory and then we hand it to the customer so the act of production
  35. has the girl right there with me when it happens the customer is co-creating the
  36. experience one thing we like to say is products are about handoffs services are about handshakes a service requires the
  37. participation of both parties and that is a very different thing than what we know about products and manufacturing
  38. and that's why there has been so little written about it and also this shift in our economy
  39. now such that 80% of our economy is services based now recognize that that is everything other than agricultural
  40. agriculture manufacturing and mining so that really is just about everything people have multiple interactions with
  41. every day whether it's b2b b2c whether it's something mundane getting a cup of coffee whether it's something really
  42. important calling your insurance company I mean I can't even imagine what how hard it must be for the insurance
  43. companies right now to try to deliver good customer experiences to you know the poor people in in Texas and and
  44. people so often confuse customer service with customer experience and those are two very very different things customer
  45. service is something you do usually it's designed around once something has gone
  46. wrong customer experience is the totality of my interaction with you from the moment I first come across your your
  47. name whether I google you know a service that I'm looking for whether someway an
  48. ad on television yeah yeah to when I'm done whenever our our business is finished
  49. you hear a lot about things like design thinking these days or industrial design
  50. manufacturing design or designing user experiences what is how do you separate service design from some some of these
  51. other buzz words that you hear about design it is that helping everybody integrate them I mean but but but I
  52. think that's one of the things that that's interesting and in fact you know Tim Brown of idea when we were talking
  53. to him said that if you think about it the ATM which is 50 years old this year was one of the first cases where people
  54. had to design in a thoughtful way how the customer interacted with in this case the user interface of an ATM before
  55. that the user interface of the bank was you know this smiling teller behind the cage and that person did all the
  56. touching and computer jet you know all the work with the bank systems so so design thinking is a way of approaching
  57. problems dust reel design is a way of course of making beautiful and functional designs
  58. and service design takes someone takes design thinking and take some of the same sort of aesthetic if you will of of
  59. industrial design but says how do we use that to apply to this train journey this
  60. ATM experience this you know how to what what are we trying to convey with the look and feel of what's happening in our
  61. interaction in the store and in the office or whatever it might be and actually something we include in service
  62. design is also service delivery because design with that the ability to execute on it is really meaningless that's part
  63. of that handshake yeah so in the course of the researching and writing the book which you have some of the companies
  64. that you encounter that are really good at this could you offer some examples and what can others learn from their
  65. experience eyes I think there are a few well there were many terrific companies that we wrote about ranging from you
  66. know strict services companies a company like Weber shadow collectors of PR and strategic communications company to
  67. Warby Parker you can started by you Pentagon's you know with the eyeglasses but one of the classic examples we use
  68. to explain service design really quickly is Starbucks versus Dunkin Donuts who's the Starbucks person who's a
  69. Dunkin Donuts person and people usually have a very strong preference and ostensibly they're both selling the same
  70. thing they're selling coffee but that's really not what they're selling they're selling two very different experiences
  71. Duncan is a grab-and-go there's a reason the slogan is America runs on Dunkin you
  72. know the logo is is very hot hot pink hot green Starbucks is much more designed about being relaxed and
  73. leisurely it's not for the person who who wants to get up and go and you know there were there were new companies like
  74. stitch fix which which even since we wrote the book has evolved at the time that we were doing the book it only did
  75. women's clothing it now includes men Edmonds the the car buying service which has evolved so much there
  76. a great example of a company that has just kept on evolving they started as you know almost a blue book yeah we also
  77. we also looked at an airline serf air which is a subscription all you call you can fly air service on on the west coast
  78. in California we look at a hospital system theta care in northern Wisconsin some of the trickiest I mean we all know
  79. how badly the design of medical care services is and these guys applying the Toyota Production system have actually
  80. redesigned hospital service so we looked across a whole a whole spectrum and and
  81. and but this the Starbucks Duncan example is wonder who even we're talking to an audience in Seattle once and asked
  82. for show of hands who's a Duncan person is the star effects person you know one person but if you think about it it's
  83. really interesting you know at Starbucks the seating is right back and it Dunkin
  84. their little stools if there's anything at all so these are examples of how you're selling coffee you're selling
  85. better than average coffee but what you're doing is creating two very different experiences and people are in
  86. one camp or the other they're not very many people who say whichever is closest that's they have a preference and that
  87. preference is because the experience is different and it's designed that way very very consciously on both sides I
  88. think one of the fun things that we also discovered intuitively we believed this
  89. but our research bored out was that the principles of service design hold across
  90. whether it's b2b b2c and across industries I'm glad you mentioned the principles because that's exactly what I
  91. wanted to come to next so you identify for among all the examples they gave that there are some common principles
  92. that these companies seem to follow which makes them good at designing effective services or service
  93. experiences and you start with you take the odd numbers and I'll take the okay all right and you start with the first
  94. which is that the customer is always right yeah or and and that but you to make sure the customer is right for you yes
  95. could you let's talk about that because there's this idea it's it's one of the first cliches anyone
  96. ever worked in a shop in service of any kind years that the customer is always right and you know something that's
  97. really not true if I go to McDonald's I have no business asking for a hamburger medium rare
  98. that's not what they are designed to do I am the wrong customer maybe just at that moment there are times I'm
  99. perfectly happy to go to McDonald's and get what's on the menu but if I want something very specific and custom-made
  100. that's not the place for me to go if I want a luxury shopping experience I should not go to t.j.maxx just as if I'm
  101. looking for a bargain I shouldn't go to Barneys so in those circumstances I'm not the
  102. right customer and it is incumbent upon both the customer and the company to ensure and that's part of that
  103. co-creation we were talking about is first of all companies have have to do two things they have to decide who the
  104. right customer is and be diligent about serving those customers well and they also have to be good about communicating
  105. who they are and that's with everything from their branding to the way they look
  106. to the experience that you have when you go on their website whether or whether you go into their store the people you
  107. encounter you know there's a very different feel when you walk into a Hyatt Regency versus an Andaz which is
  108. another high brand Andaz is there hip you know sleeker brand where everyone sort of dressed in black and someone's
  109. going to check you in with an iPad go into the Hyatt Regency and there's going to be a big ornate desk and you know
  110. people in sort of old-fashioned uniforms and those are two different experiences
  111. if I'm looking for this sleek hip I want to feel so so cool I shouldn't be at the
  112. Hyatt Regency I'll get a very different kind of experience it'll be a luxury experience but it'll be very different
  113. so so customers then also have to understand what they are buying and they need to understand that they should only
  114. they need to recognize whether or not they are the right customer in a given situation so what you just said reminds
  115. me a lot of some very interesting research that has been going on at Wharton in the marketing department led
  116. by Professor Peter fader on customer centricity who we introduced the book and he actually does he makes that point
  117. that you know customer centricity part partly depends on your own center of gravity to that you want to find the
  118. right thing we were talking to some people who want professional services for them actually we did we didn't
  119. listen many survey of some professional services firms and one of the things they said is a big problem is that they
  120. are lured from their sweet spot by clients who ask them to do things that aren't because they want to be customer
  121. centric but they're sort of getting the customers putting them on the wrong foot
  122. and and it's hard to say now our second principle which is is is don't surprise and delight just delight is is sort of
  123. expands or sort of it is another turn of the crank around around that idea and one of the things we we realized is that
  124. the people say surprise and delight surprising lies right what are you you know our point is focus on delight and
  125. delight is meeting expectations every time now if you wanna put up you know maraschino cherry on top of the sundae
  126. fine but get the sundae right and and the problem with that surprise and delight thing is it starts putting the
  127. monkey on the individual employees back and it doesn't focus on reliably robustly delivering on those promises
  128. that you make and that your customer expects I think it's Francis Frye at Harvard Business School who's now a new
  129. bird that's right that's right who says that that that if you're doing this you're creating sort of your almost
  130. institutionalizing the inability to do what you what your customers expect constantly and so that's our second
  131. principle the third principle is great service should not require heroics either on the part of the employee or
  132. the customer so this then is an extension of what you were just talking about so it's about consistency and when
  133. I'm delivering a service so now I'm in the company's seat I need to know what I'm doing it I should be able to do it
  134. repeatedly scalably and profitably and when you start requiring the heroics it means that something has gone wrong with
  135. the design look I'm not talking about emergency situations of course you deal with emergency situations but if you
  136. find yourself constantly running around you know like the fire alarm has just gone off something is wrong you were
  137. either not designing your services properly you're not communicating the expectations appropriately to the
  138. customers or you are being lured away from your sweet spot and then that's a strategy problem
  139. so these heroics are an indication to you of something's wrong now from the customers perspective it should not be
  140. impossible for me to get what you promised me and again when when you see consistent
  141. customer complaints that's also a signal to you we call those we have our moments
  142. that our moment is you know when a customer knows that they're in good hands and they know that they are in
  143. your hands you know don't just do it owl the owl moments are so the owl moments are the things that companies eat to
  144. look at those are the things that customers complain about and that is a signal that something is wrong either
  145. for some reason you are attracting the wrong customers or you are you don't have your services designed in such a
  146. way that it's easy for customers to get what they want need and have a right to expect from you is easy to do business
  147. with right I mean it's a simple question and most companies don't actually systematically ask it and what is an aha
  148. moment an aha moment is when I get it I as the Excel or save aha I know how this
  149. works I see the pain point I see the ah moment I know how to fix the pain point I know
  150. how to create the aha moment I understand what we're trying to do here and how to design it this is getting
  151. complicated in a world of omni-channel on the one hand this is the fourth press difference the fourth principle is that
  152. you've got to be able to deliver to your clients or customers at every point on the journey and in every channel so
  153. whether I'm on the web on the phone in their store it should feel like I'm in your hands and this what people are
  154. now sometimes trying to call even a post channel world is is is critical and we see all kinds of companies screwing up
  155. and in some cases it's because by the way they're still dealing with old computer stacks that and the middleware
  156. isn't very good sometimes it's simply a technical issue sometimes it's an issue of silos and failure to make handoffs
  157. classically for a long time it's been an issue of the analog guys and the web guys who just don't connect and that's
  158. complicated even more because it's not just the stuff under my control as a seller but in service environments I'm
  159. usually working in an ecosystem it's bad enough what the airlines can do to me but then add tsa the airport's the
  160. traffic you know the transportation system to the airport you know there's a whole ecosystem built around these
  161. things and so even one of the biggest challenges in service design is to work with ecosystem partners where you may
  162. not have authority but to try to sort of collectively work together to create an
  163. experience that you all want to create for the customers you want to serve and should we talk about the fifth principle
  164. the fifth principle is you're never done and that's really important because it's
  165. not a static thing people's expectations will change products will change markets
  166. will change your strategy will change and you've got to adapt to those things and there's a fine line between you're
  167. never done and as we were saying distorting yourself outside your sweet spot so that you're no longer
  168. recognizable as to who you are and and that's why it really does come down to service design needs to be part of the
  169. strategic fabric of the company all these decisions about service you know too often as we say it's lumped in with
  170. with customers the customer service department which is not sufficient or people think that only is a function of
  171. marketing and marketing is certainly a department that has responsibility for helping to create the notion of what
  172. that brand promise is but strategy is about deciding what that brand promise is going to be there's another thing
  173. about this innovation point which is that it's another difference between products and services right in products
  174. you know it's guy roll gear loose in the lab with the white coat then I mean innovation takes place in a place
  175. general you know in a lab but in services innovation can take place all across the value chain so how do you
  176. manage it how do you keep it coherent so they're not running off in different directions and how do you sort of give
  177. these sort of innovation skills to people who may not actually think of themselves as being innovators so that's
  178. a really interesting organizational and strategic question is the management of innovation and services which is
  179. different from that in Provence I wonder we could know more deeply into the relationship you see between strategy
  180. and service design how can doing service design will help you develop a really strong competitive strategy that can
  181. take you forward you know we we created in the book a set of nine archetypes and
  182. they're basically expressions of value propositions so one of the archetypes is the trend setter you know we're we are
  183. the apple of whatever industry is another is the bargain we're the Walmart of whatever industry is another is the
  184. classic we're the best you know we're the Mercedes of the Cadillac of whatever is and there are nine of them and you
  185. can find almost all of them in every industry but if you think about these archetypes as expressions of a value
  186. proposition that means they are actually sort of they're our strategy our strategy is to be the safe choice our
  187. strategy is to be the best whatever it is and these sort of help you envision then you know value proposition and
  188. strategy are pretty closely related right these help you envision what how we're going to take the
  189. value proposition and manifest it in the experience customers have and also in the tangible evidence of that experience
  190. the look and feel the things that customers can look at and say yes that's what this is going to be and I think
  191. when you're there you know that's really a strategic conversation and having one
  192. of those archetypes in mind it helps you I mean strategies partly the art of saying no right what you're
  193. not doing and the customers you're not serving and and having those archetypes in minds help you think helps you think
  194. now this this isn't us but this is us we can do this and this is what it means for the organization as a whole and for
  195. the customers we seek wonder if you could tell us a little bit about what are the biggest mistakes you find
  196. companies make in coming up with service design what did you find in your research well I will say one of the
  197. things we did do is we tried to focus a lot on the companies who were doing it right which isn't to say that there are
  198. only happy stories out there there are a lot of companies that aren't doing it right but I think a few of the things
  199. that we all see just from our own experiences on a day-to-day basis is people just they just don't walk in the
  200. customer shoes literally you know try to be your own customer that's that's part
  201. of how you find out if you're easy to do business with people just don't think it
  202. through you know crazy things that you'll see that that just makes no sense that why is why do I have to walk from
  203. here to there to get something done when when logic would flow that I need to only go from here to there it's not even
  204. about all the things I'm going to do from here to there it's just it's just a waste of my time
  205. it's and it's they also again they're not firm enough about their strategy and I think the biggest mistake though and I
  206. think this is one of the really fundamental things we've tried to do with the book is help companies feel
  207. empowered I think in an age of social media and it's too easy for customers to just go online and tweet you know I've
  208. had a really bad experience with with X and such and then so many customer service goes oh my god we better reach
  209. out to this per because there's going to be what if this goes viral companies need to feel
  210. empowered to be able to make these strategic decisions I think Patricia's mentioned it several
  211. times one of the biggest mistakes companies make is they confuse customer service I'm calling up I got a problem
  212. with customer experience and and and you know customer service is at the end and
  213. that's anymore it's important to make a good last impression but but that's that's you know failing to see the whole
  214. customer journey and as Patricia said to walk in the customers shoes and then failing to to make that as coherent as
  215. possible I think those are the are two of the two of the biggest mistakes that we see companies make another way of
  216. looking at it as we mentioned five principles you know and it's the it's the violation of those five principles
  217. you know saying yes to everything every customer asks you asks you to do you know not being coherent not being
  218. innovative you know requiring heroic efforts or making your customers work you are those
  219. are the you know those principles the flipside of those principles is what we see too darn many companies doing all
  220. the time bettan focus on surprise instead of delight you know I ask why should good service be a surprise now if
  221. companies want to become better at service design what advice would you give them how can they become better at
  222. this I think they need to be willing to be honest with themselves it is a gut check and it's not always pretty and I
  223. think they really need to make sure that it is going into the really decision level making of the organization we had
  224. a we created a little equation in blue bow and win and that's that customer delight is the product of the customers
  225. experience and technical excellence experience times excellence and we put five points under each one of those
  226. things empathy and engineering and and the economics of it and created a quiz I mean you can pay a report card so so I
  227. think too you know being honest with yourself sometimes requires let's sit down and audit and
  228. that report card is a way to audit and you can sit down and you can take it within a management team take it with a
  229. diagonal slice of the organization ask some of your customers or clients to rate you and then you can get you can
  230. get a report card and from there you can begin to say this is what's wrong another thing is this idea of charting
  231. the customer journey you know have we looked at that journey and what's gonna happen what is my customer experiencing
  232. at each what do we want the whole journey to be like the classic the bargain what do you want the whole
  233. journeyed to be like and what's happening at the key moments along that if you can do those two things audit and
  234. map and we're good start and when you're mapping you have to map both on stage and off stage if you will you know what
  235. the customer sees what the customer experiences and then what's happening offstage to make that possible or to
  236. screw it up they say I'd like to focus on the positive one last question that is are there any questions that you
  237. wanted to answer in this book but you didn't get to so well but what's coming up next
  238. know that you have done this I think something we realized is that the principles also apply internally as
  239. strongly as they do externally and I think it would it will be really interesting to explore it from the from
  240. the inside perspective as opposed to the outside perspective because your employees are stakeholders as well you
  241. know this was focused mostly on the external stakeholders but I think we'd like to focus more on the internal
  242. stakeholders and creating how to create a good service culture yeah and you know
  243. Jean Meister is doing some interesting stuff on the employee experience and if you think about the employee experience
  244. and the customer experience and think about that point that Patricia made that services are handshakes so an employee
  245. or a group of employees is interacting you know so looking those two sides the cult a culture that
  246. creates a great experience and a great experience that then feeds off of that I think that's something that we that we
  247. would like to learn a lot in fact you might find that one leads to the other precisely very happy employees will
  248. automatically yes that old research on the service value chain suggests that and then if you think about that in
  249. conjunction with this idea of experience who that gives you a whole new way to think about that
  250. classic insight well Tom Patricia thank you so much for speaking with knowledge at working about your book this has been
  251. a great experience angle yes exactly thank you thank you thank you very much [Music]
  252. you

Brief Summary

Tom Stewart and Patricia O'Connell discuss service design strategies and customer experience from their book, emphasizing strategic differentiation and effective principles.

Key points

  • The Essence of Service Design. Service design teaches how to create meaningful customer experiences, not just products.
  • Experience Over Product. Tom explains that the real differentiation in business is the customer experience.
  • Understanding Customer Experience. The difference between customer service and customer experience is crucial for businesses.
  • Universal Principles of Service Design. The principles of service design apply across various industries and customer interactions.
  • Continuous Adaptation in Service Design. Adapting to changing expectations is vital for successful service design.
  • The Management of Innovation. Managing innovation in services is a strategic question that differs from products.

Episode highlights

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes