A Plan for CEOs Who Want to Do Good

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The Inter-American Development Bank's corporate social responsibility program is intended to generate goodwill and spur a concrete increase in a company's revenues. More: http://knlg.net/1zWC9Uk πŸ“‚ ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Our guest today is Kelly Pacini, chief of strategy for the private sector at the Inter-American Development Bank or
  2. IDB. Uh we will speak with her about the bank's social impact initiatives and specifically the shared value appraisal
  3. that the bank uses in its investments. Uh Kelly, welcome to Knowledge at Wharton. Thank you for joining us today.
  4. Thank you very much. Thank you for having me. So to begin with, I wonder if we can
  5. start by talking about IDB's approach to social impact and specifically uh what is the shared value appraisal and what
  6. role does it play in the bank's lending? Sure. Uh well, IDB as an institution for many
  7. years, of course, uh as a mission-driven lender is very concerned and interested
  8. in social impact. Uh the shared value appraisal is a relatively new tool that we developed
  9. specifically to work with our private sector clients because there's a big area of the bank
  10. uh that I'm part of where we're supporting for-profit investors um across Latin America and the Caribbean.
  11. Uh and the intent of that instrument is to help those private investors really find the intersection between their
  12. business challenges and drivers for better, stronger, more robust growth of their companies.
  13. Uh the intersection of that with the social needs and sort of social surroundings uh
  14. in the place of operation where their companies are operating. So it's really surfacing opportunities that really can
  15. address both elements at the same time. So let's discuss one concrete case, right, where you use the shared value
  16. appraisal. And this is the uh San Ignacio University in Lima, Peru. Can you tell us about that deal and how the
  17. shared value appraisal was used? Sure, absolutely. Uh that was a a really wonderful opportunity for us to put this
  18. tool to work. Uh university was established back in 1995. It's growing robustly and it came
  19. to IDB for, let's say, a a basic brick-and-mortar expansion loan. We do a lot of infrastructure lending uh across
  20. all sectors. Uh it is for-profit university and they need to expand. They need to build more
  21. campus buildings to accommodate the growth in in students. Um yet from our knowledge of the region, we know that in
  22. Peru uh there's a dramatic lack of access to quality education, especially at the higher uh
  23. tertiary levels for income low-income students and disadvantaged students. Uh And so when they came to us for an
  24. expansion loan, we said, "Okay, well, we you know, we want to help you expand and
  25. uh while we're looking at the credit, let's look at your business model because we think we could put this new
  26. tool" We had we had developed it recently when they had come to us back in 2012.
  27. "We think we could put this new tool to work to really figure out how to enable you to grow and meet these growth
  28. projections." Because remember, we're a lender. So we're looking at their growth
  29. projections to make sure they can repay. Um if you really want to meet these growth
  30. projections, you can't rely on what is potentially shrinking segment of your base, which are tuition-paying
  31. students. Um and so let us use this methodology that we've developed to really figure
  32. out how we can enhance your business model and also enhance access to students that wouldn't
  33. otherwise have access to your quality institution." Uh so it was a it was really a win-win
  34. um of putting the two together. So when you approach situations like this, how do you balance the financial
  35. considerations versus the social considerations? Right, that's a very good question because it's
  36. a common question and it's not extremely obvious to many people when we're going
  37. about doing this, including our clients. Um and what we really our practice area in
  38. this in this instrument is to say, "Look, what I tell my team is if this is not going to have a beneficial impact to
  39. in a tangible way to the bottom line of this company, this case the university, then we're not prepared to really put it
  40. forward. This is not a CSR program. It's not something that we will submit or assert will generate
  41. revenue by some form of goodwill. Like we want to see concrete increase in revenues.
  42. Um and therefore there's no there's no trade-off. You know, and that's for us that was a big
  43. move when we we sort of discovered the whole shared value concept, which is it's really not if if social gains, you
  44. know, financial returns lose and vice versa. It's really how to really pursue both at the same time. So so once we
  45. remove this trade-off kind of paradigm that we've lived with for a long time, uh
  46. we get into this zone of how are we really pushing the envelope and really it really increasing the overall pool of
  47. economic capital. Uh and that's what makes it exciting because you really, you know, when you
  48. discover there are ways to do that, um it really really feels good because you're really serving your client and
  49. you're really serving again our mission, which is um improving, you know, lives of of people across the region. And I
  50. want to follow up on on what you'd said, you know, you said it's not this isn't CSR. And I think there's been a lot of
  51. skepticism about corporate social responsibility, arguing that it's just kind of marketing, it's window dressing,
  52. it's not it's not real and authentic. So do you think this shared value approach
  53. is the kind that can um give rid of that skepticism and really build a an authentic approach to corporations
  54. having a social impact? Right. Well, let me be clear. I don't have anything against CSR and I think companies who
  55. who commit to robust corporate social responsibility programs can be fabulous and can have a dramatic impact.
  56. The distinction I make is that um what we're looking for is not something that's going to be a cost center because
  57. what what I've seen in my years of business and particularly in the context of uh
  58. IDB where I work with the private sector, CSR programs, as wonderful as they may
  59. be, when budgets get tight, it's first thing to get cut, right? And so what we're looking for is really sustainable
  60. change, transformational change. And you can't really rely on that tremendously if you at any time risk it gets cut
  61. because, "Oh my god, we got to go back to core business because this extra thing that we love and we've shown great
  62. results with, we just can't afford it anymore." And so when you weave in these investments that will derive social
  63. impact that's part of their core business, you get rid of that risk. You you seriously mitigate that risk. I
  64. mean, of course, you know, you always have some risk, but you certainly have dampened
  65. this dichotomy of this arm of the business is doing these great things and this arm of the business is continuing
  66. to produce revenue. Um and really, you know, that nexus of of weaving them together so they're inextricably linked
  67. um is really the sweet spot that we're after. So let's say you weave together the the
  68. financial considerations and the social impact. One of the big challenges uh of course is that measuring social impact
  69. is very hard. Mhm. Uh can you walk us through how you do that uh using your shared value
  70. approach? Sure, it is very hard. Um and we what we do is we we take a basic cost-benefit analysis uh you know,
  71. methodology that's that's known all over um and we apply it to figure out how to
  72. prioritize uh you know, we start at the the starting point is what's your challenge
  73. to growth? So it's very much a business starting point. Um in the case of the university, business
  74. challenge was, "I may not have as many new students entering and uh you know, and and paying tuition."
  75. It's a pretty primitive business model, you know, when you get down to the sources and uses of capital for to run a
  76. for-profit university. Um and so if we said, "Okay, so if that's your challenge,
  77. what can we do to help you ensure that you will really increase your sources of revenue?" Um and then
  78. when we look at this from the social angle, what are the pockets that are tremendously in um
  79. sort of inordinately underrepresented to attend university? Peru's had a rapid expansion in what we consider emerging
  80. middle class, which is a tremendous success story. They've had robust um GDP growth and so forth. But there's still
  81. large pockets um that just don't have access. 50% of the youth actually don't graduate high school. So you're already
  82. dealing with half of the potential universe to potentially enter college. Um So when we look at those things, we
  83. figure out how can we best design a program that will enable you to recruit more students
  84. and not only recruit them, but retain them because the highest dropout rates are from this demographic.
  85. That their opportunity cost to not go out into the labor force immediately, even if it's not a high-paying job, is
  86. so high that the dropout rate continues to be a big struggle. Um and so in this case, we said, "Look,
  87. let's figure out how to create programs that you you, university, will have to invest in
  88. that will create a platform that will enable these students to make it to the finish line.
  89. Not only recruit them, but retain them. Um and so we measure that by in case of the university, of course,
  90. my public sector colleagues have all sorts of data that is well established in terms of you know higher income and
  91. so forth for people who do graduate from college as opposed to high school graduates or or even not
  92. graduates. So in that case it was um sort of the social impact empirical data pool that we could rely
  93. on was was quite great and some of the other projects that we've looked into engagements we've worked with
  94. we had to extrapolate at times but we do we do a lot with stakeholder analysis. We go out we do a lot of interviews with
  95. people. What will really matter to you? What will really improve your quality of
  96. life? And many times another fascinating thing of the tool as we've been implementing it has been
  97. the answers we collect back and we bring back to our client are different from what their expectation had been.
  98. So even when clients have been entertaining I really you know I feel in my gut that something I we need to do
  99. something. Um when we bring back the answers of this is what would matter most because
  100. from a financial perspective that's what you want to invest in if you want bang for your buck.
  101. They say really? Cuz I thought it was this other thing. So it's been a really um
  102. it's been a really useful tool also just as an eye opener. Um even for companies
  103. who are on the journey so to speak of of looking for possibilities to prioritize and kind of re-stack the
  104. deck of look if you really want this to be impacting your bottom line you really
  105. should go this way. Quick follow up. Can you give an example of that? Something that surprised you in this
  106. way. Sure. Our first engagement we did with avocado producer in in Chile. So it was a had been a small size
  107. company really started growing. Again they came to us for an expansion loan. And we said you know we think this is
  108. it's such a high it's such a densely um sort of high employment type industry in
  109. terms of agribusiness. They have all the pickers and packers and everything. Um we said what's your biggest challenge
  110. and they said well our biggest challenge is turnover. You know people leave the farm and we have to retrain people and
  111. it's a huge cost and drain on net income right? Because we have good gross income and then we
  112. have to you know it gets used up. Um so we said um well what have you been you know what have
  113. you been contemplating on your own before we got here to address this? And they said well you know we're
  114. we know we've got to figure out some you know the key to cost avoidance is getting is retaining better retention
  115. and better retention we think will be some form of loyalty and we really don't know what that is. But we're thinking if
  116. we just bite the bullet and and invest the money to build a daycare center that might be
  117. the ticket because people will want to come and you know they'll have a place for their children so forth.
  118. And we said well that sounds great. You know well that let's put that into the kit of things that we explore.
  119. So we did. Uh and what we through the process and the methodology that we followed what we surfaced for
  120. them was well you know it turns out the two million dollars that it would take you to build the daycare center
  121. probably would not be your optimal investment vis-a-vis cost avoidance for retraining.
  122. Because between yourself the people who work for the company as well as sort of outsourced supply chain farmers of
  123. 20,000 total you'd reach maybe 100 that would be able to walk to the facility of the daycare with
  124. their kids. And so those 100 would certainly stay with you but you got to figure out how
  125. to retain you know 20,000. So when we did the stakeholder analysis what we found was more and more and
  126. predominantly was women that were employed uh and that they needed to increase the retention
  127. of. And more and more the answers were well if the company had some program so that
  128. my kids could get an education and basically they wouldn't be this wouldn't be their only option you
  129. know to to be gainfully employed. That would make me really want to stay with the company.
  130. And so we said okay so instead of taking the two million dollars that you were prepared to spend to invest in this
  131. daycare center you'd need to set it up for educational credits for for the various employees and redirect. So again
  132. it's not an increase in spending right? Cuz again CSR you know people say oh how
  133. much are you spending? Can you spend more? This is an optimization and reallocation
  134. of resources that they were already prepared to spend. Um that will drive that retention which
  135. of course then drives better bottom line. So that was a interesting and it was our
  136. first you know our first case out of the gate. Out of the gate. It is it is. So you know when you
  137. approach the issues through this shared value do you find the clients receptive to to the approach and are there some
  138. challenges with getting them to to understand why you're doing it and how they can implement it?
  139. There are definitely challenges yes. Um I think the why is probably less of a challenge right? Cuz we are the IDB and
  140. so anyone who's who's coming to us for a loan has a certain expectation that you know
  141. they are aware of our mission. They know we're really not uh engaging them for profit reasons. So
  142. so they figure we're going to be coming with something right? And and for many years that something has been
  143. we'll support private activity to a do no harm standard. And so we have very high standards for you know social and
  144. um environmental compliance. In this space what we've said is yeah that that's still there.
  145. That's not going anywhere. But this is to really tap into a different way of doing business and
  146. really shift your business as usual. So challenges. Challenges have been um initially often times we get kind of
  147. redirected to whoever they have in charge of sustainability um or if they have a CSR program you know
  148. we're talking to that person. Uh and what we found absolutely 100% of the time and when I talk to practitioners
  149. who are doing similar types of engagements you need the C-suite. You need either the CEO or at a minimum the CFO
  150. to be on board with us cuz it does have to be part of the core business. And so saying yeah I'd love to talk to your CSR
  151. person but I really need to talk to that CFO. And the unique ability of us to accomplish
  152. that is that of course we are usually coming also with a loan. We're not just consultants coming in as you know
  153. providing advisory services. They're also looking to us for a loan uh for some kind of expansion or
  154. sometimes you do greenfield projects you know that didn't exist before. Um and clearly in that capacity we're
  155. talking to the CFO and the CEO. And so we say no no no. Um sir or ma'am we have one more agenda
  156. item we want to talk to you about not with the guy down the hall. Uh so so that's you know that's a recurring
  157. challenge but we we seem to manage it and we uh we've got a lot of good mean the the
  158. projects we've we're now we've now done almost a dozen of these and every time when we do make that sort of
  159. business case to the people in charge they really you know they really get it. It hasn't been
  160. that tremendous a struggle. It's just getting the time and and maybe you know getting the agenda item to be properly
  161. worded so that we have the time. As you were developing the shared value methodology
  162. um what were some of the challenges you faced in in in in developing it? And and
  163. what would be your assessment of what the model does well and what it doesn't do as well?
  164. Well let's see. Um some of the challenges initially were we know we brought in some outside
  165. consultants that big consulting firms you know to help us really build the nuts and bolts of of a model
  166. that we could use. Uh and there we encountered far too frequently than than I would have expected
  167. this sort of um creeping along into kind of the the well it'll produce goodwill. Like no
  168. you know we're going to be really really hardcore like I need to see dollars and
  169. cents of what it's going to produce vis-a-vis the bottom line because if it's too
  170. um intangible it's not going to meet my bar to say to the CFO who I'm insisting to talk to not
  171. the CSR guy uh it's not going to meet the bar to say this deserves your attention. This needs
  172. to be part of your core business. So that was you know was a challenge. I think now you know we've been working
  173. with some of the same folks and they know we're rather dogmatic on that. Uh and so it's happening less.
  174. Um So I think the the methodology is robust in that sense um and that's really what makes it kind
  175. of click. So where do you see IDB going in the future in the area of social impact
  176. investing? Well I think increasingly we are um we're definitely going more into the
  177. space of um it's not enough to say it's a great investment and you're meeting these very high
  178. international best practice standards. It's really about where's this sort of voluntary area that you can go in. I
  179. mean, the shared value vis-a-vis social impact we're also replicating in the climate
  180. space and how can our how can we green our portfolio and make our companies more energy efficient?
  181. How can they invest in natural capital in ways that will again drive their bottom line? Working with the some very
  182. large forestry project sponsors in that space. So, it's really about you know, using that engagement that we have with
  183. private sector actors, big, large-scale private sector actors to really shift that business as usual
  184. model into this area of sort of driving profits and driving impact at the same time.
  185. Yeah, I you know, I I see a big future ahead of us because it really looks it looks like it really works, you know,
  186. it's it's really dovetails and aligns interest. And once you get the alignment of interest, you really can start to
  187. look for scale. As as we wind down, could we end perhaps with an example of one or two of your
  188. green growth investments and and how you went through the the financial and social impact analysis
  189. there? How how how do you approach it? Sure. Um well, the in terms of green growth, we
  190. are looking at a lot of um we're doing a you know, the our infrastructure practice is doing a huge
  191. amount of renewable energy. We're really haven't done fossil fuel-based generation projects in several years,
  192. which is a fantastic thing for me to be able to say because of course, you know,
  193. they're still out there. Um What I find I guess most uh fascinating is really our ability
  194. to get some private investors and private owners of companies to make investments
  195. that are not urgent. Because so so we the shared value thing was really born on the back of they're coming to us for
  196. organic growth purposes. They need to expand. And so let's use that entree to say,
  197. let us tell you about this other really interesting thing for you. Now we're we're we're moved beyond that to say,
  198. you're operating. You're not coming to us for a loan. But you know what? If we surface these
  199. opportunities for you to invest, and particularly in energy efficiency where usually they're small-scale investments,
  200. um they that you know, we we are able to lend to you for this, right? So, it's a
  201. different it's a different starting point. It's not they're coming cuz they need to expand.
  202. It's we're telling them, "Hey, you know, there's opportunities for you to actually save on your energy
  203. consumption, save on your bills. The return, you know, on the investment will only take a couple of years. We'll make
  204. sure we structure the debt in a way that, you know, it work the economics work."
  205. Um and it's it's building into a whole new um business line that that really changes the dynamic of
  206. how we're going about addressing the climate change issue and and um really producing, you know, mitigation in ways
  207. that we hadn't really pursued beforehand. So. Great. Well, Kelly, thank you so much
  208. for speaking with me. Sure, my pleasure.

Brief Summary

Kelly Pacini discusses IDB's shared value appraisal and its impact on social initiatives in Latin America.

Key points

  • Shared Value Appraisal Explained. Kelly Pacini discusses the shared value appraisal and its role in IDB's investments.
  • Transformational Change Over CSR. Pacini argues for sustainable change rather than temporary CSR efforts.
  • Balancing Financial and Social Impact. Pacini explains how IDB balances financial considerations with social impact.
  • The Challenge of Measuring Impact. Pacini addresses the difficulties in measuring social impact effectively.
  • Future of Social Impact Investing. IDB aims to integrate social impact with climate initiatives in future investments.
  • Green Growth Investments. Exploring how green growth investments can drive profits and impact simultaneously.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes