Nandan Nilekani: 'We Are on the Razor's Edge'

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In Imagining India: The Idea of a Renewed Nation, Nilekani tackles themes ranging from education and demographics to investment and infrastructure. Nilekani, who was recently recruited by Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to head a project to create a national identification card for the country, spoke with India Knowledge@Wharton about the book at the recent Wharton India Economic Forum in Philadelphia. 📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] the 2009 Wharton India economic Forum titled India the road ahead took place
  2. in Philadelphia and brought together CEOs of leading Indian companies investors heads of nonprofit
  3. organizations Sports celebrities and Bollywood stars to discuss where India is headed in an age of economic
  4. uncertainty Indian knowledge at Wharton brings you one-on-one conversations with
  5. these leaders thank you very much an for that very kind introduction uh Nandan welcome to uh Warton India economic
  6. Forum very happy to have you here thank you mul it's great to be here uh so before we start talking about your book
  7. which is 531 Pages we'll try and cover it in 20 minutes uh I just wanted to tell you a small incident that happened
  8. the first time that I visited infosis I had come to meet one of your colleagues MH and it just so happened that the week
  9. before I came to Bangalore I was in Bombay where my mother lives and one day as I was walking about at night I
  10. stepped into a pothole and I fell down and as you know I'm not a very light guy so I I fell on my hands and
  11. fractured my Wrist all right so when I came to infosis and met your colleague he saw that I had a cast on my right
  12. hand he said what happened to you and I said I fractured my wrist how did that happen said I said I
  13. think it happened because the world is not flat I asked him to pass on that message
  14. to you I don't know if he did he didn't mention okay all right all right anyway uh from uh Thomas
  15. freedman's book to your book uh I I I I I should start by saying that it's I I really really enjoyed it very much oh
  16. that's great uh but I was very curious about one thing you know when normally when company CEOs or chairman or
  17. co-chairman write books they tend to write either about their biggest deals or they write about their
  18. perspective on management Theory or philosophy you wrote a book about India why well uh you know I I I wanted to do
  19. something different and uh you know my role in the last several years has been going around the world and uh uh you
  20. know projecting India in in global forums and all that and uh you know I was not able to answer a lot of
  21. questions that people would ask me they' ask me why why is it that you have uh such beautiful campuses like infosis and
  22. such large slums why is it that there are so many billionaires and so many poor people why is it that uh you have
  23. all these educated people in technology and the world's largest elited population you know why is it that you
  24. you guys seem to coexist in the 17th century and the 21st century at the same time so that s of and I was not able to
  25. give very convincing answers so I felt I needed to get down to the bottom of why
  26. why why are we the way we are the other important thing I felt was that uh uh India was you know at a very small
  27. window of opportunity it had this huge demographic dividend and this young population but uh you know that
  28. demographic dividend could well become a demographic disaster if we didn't make the right investments in our human
  29. capital and I felt that window of opportunity was ebbing by so I felt the need to put it down and say hey guys you
  30. know we have this beautiful opportunity let's not mess with it and also I found that a lot of books on India were
  31. written from a particular perspective and E Economist view or a sociologist view I felt that to really get give
  32. India its due you had to take a much more holistic look at it which is why I looked at it from all these angles I
  33. interviewed 126 people wow including people from IC Bank mhm and uh uh it's really a sort of a composite of all that
  34. right well uh well it clearly shows uh one thing I wanted to ask about the introduction is you say that the most
  35. important driver for growth lies in expanding access to resources and opportunity as you just said now what do
  36. you see as the major barriers that block this access for millions of Indians and
  37. how do you think they can be removed well one one clear barrier to access is education I mean if if you you know the
  38. the opportunities for somebody say who lives in Bangalore and goes to an English medium school and goes to IIT is
  39. dramatically different from a young child in a Bihar Village who doesn't have a school in his village and
  40. therefore access to education and providing good education in the public Space is really very important second is
  41. access to English you know we have really practiced very hypocritical policies on English we have denied
  42. English to Our People and therefore they have not learned English and English has
  43. become the language to participate in the global economy or it's access to roads you know if if you live in a
  44. village and you need to go to go to school you need to have a road to go to school or you need lights at night to
  45. study very simple things so if you deny people these basic instruments of Education Health infrastructure jobs
  46. then you are bound to deny them access to building a better life I think I I agree with you completely you know
  47. knowledge at w is a Chinese Edition and uh once when I was in China I I met somebody there who has a very fast
  48. growing business teaching the Chinese English I was happy to know he was a Barton Alam right uh the uh uh well uh
  49. coming back to the phrase you used the uh ear a little earlier the the demographic
  50. dividend uh it's very interesting that in the' 60s the India's population was seen almost as a burden uh but now you
  51. use the term human capital uh you know to to describe uh India's population uh how do you think that uh the Democrat uh
  52. the demographic dividend divides across the country is is it in the same Pace or
  53. are the regional differen there are three or four things here one is that uh you know we have you know a demographic
  54. dividend is typically a point in a country's history when the bulk of its population is in the working age of 15
  55. to 65 and therefore they have a very low dependency ratio in other words they support less people and have more people
  56. to work and that's typically the Golden Age of Any Nation because you have more people working you have more creativity
  57. and so on and India is very fortunate to be having its demographic dividend now and it's the only country in the world
  58. which will have its demographic dividend so it's not only a young country with a
  59. dividend it's a young country in an aging World which opens up even more strategic possibilities uh but actually
  60. India's demographic divid is not one curve there are two curves there's one curve which was in the South and the
  61. west of India which is almost fully absorbed by 2015 the South and the West will start uh aging and there's a second
  62. curve which is in Middle India the central states of up Bihar chhattisghar orisa all Madia Pradesh and that is
  63. going to be the real demographic the next the next demographic bubble so unless we address very fundamental
  64. issues in that region of education and access and all that that that's really going to be a big challenge because
  65. today you see for example so many problems of uh migrant workers coming to Mumbai and and the reaction to them what
  66. you're seeing is really a small part of what will happen if we don't address this very quickly because in the years
  67. from 2001 to 2025 only 12.6% % of the new population in India is going to be in the South 50% is going to be in the
  68. northern states so there's a huge you know difference because fertility rates in Kerala today are like a West European
  69. country you know it's some onethird of what it is in utar Pradesh so we have to understand these nuances of what's
  70. happening to really think of what we need to do and how do you think the second bubble can be addressed you know
  71. it has to be addressed by expanding access to that young population uh it's about you know improving the quality of
  72. school it's about better infrastructure it's about job creation there as opposed
  73. to job creation by migration and uh you know all these things we don't have much
  74. window we have window of maybe four five years to pull it off right because otherwise the pressure of uh the
  75. disparities will will go up even further right you know very much like the issue
  76. of the population where there's almost been a sea change uh in the way the country has t about this issue which you
  77. address in the first part of your of your book uh the other issue like that I felt was the the assumption that was
  78. made soon after Independence that India needs a democratic socialism you and and
  79. you you say in your book that there has been a similar transformation in that thinking with much more accept
  80. acceptance of business friendly policies and and and capitalist policies uh but now when you come to a place like the US
  81. and you look at the mess that's going on out here MH and people talking about nationalizing ing Banks like City Bank
  82. and Bank of America do you think this is the kind of capitalism what kind of capitalism does I think the the message
  83. in that is that uh you know I think what we need to find the right balance between markets and regulated Society
  84. because if you have markets which are unregulated and untrammeled and then they it can lead to a situation where
  85. they create you know the kind of challenges we have in the US and then you have the reaction to that which you
  86. are seeing today so I think the the challenge is to find the right balance and I think uh India has the opportunity
  87. to find the right balance because we had wear too much to to one side it doesn't
  88. mean that we wear too much to the other side but strike the right justos of uh entrepreneurship business and the
  89. markets because at end of the day you need Market forces and entrepreneurs to create jobs to create Innovation to
  90. create new products and services to improve productivity to improve the quality of life and so on so you know
  91. you can't do that with the state but you need the state to create a regulatory and other Frameworks and rule of law to
  92. ensure that businesses play within within the same play pen so I think that's the message from what's Happening
  93. Here and I think in India India is very fortunate that it has I believe the largest array of entrepreneurs anywhere
  94. in the world except the US you know we have uh large companies uh in the uh in the family sector we have large
  95. companies in the public sector we have large global companies and we have thousands of young entrepreneurs so it's
  96. a very diverse and Rich uh base that we need to take advantage of right absolutely uh you the other really
  97. fascinating part of your book uh that I found was how you talk about the the impact of technology in transforming
  98. different Industries and also the growth of India's it sector uh in providing IT
  99. services and BPO services to the world now amid all this success story Along Comes satam which probably happened
  100. after your book was done what sort of an impact has that had is a specific case of fraud it happened to be somebody who
  101. was in the it sector who also got into some real estate activities so it was a case of fraud I don't think it anyway
  102. takes away from the enormous uh success of what technology has done to Indian economy and Society now Tom fredman in
  103. the blur to your book calls you the great explainer what I'm what I hoping you will explain to me because I don't
  104. understand is is how such a huge fraud could go on for such a long time uh and and when you talk to your clients do
  105. they see this as an isolated instance or is Indian business being T no I think absolutely it's seen as an isolated
  106. instance because uh it's a case of one uh one uh entrepreneur going erant and I think uh I think it's I guess it's all
  107. part of what happens in in in in a bubble in some sense I mean Bernie mov $50 billion scam nobody seemed to know
  108. about it and some very very influential and knowledgeable people seem to have put money there so you know it's
  109. difficult to say where where you draw the line on these things right so I think uh it was an unfortunate episode
  110. because we have been trying to project India's entrepreneurs as the new phase of India and this this incident you know
  111. took us back because the whole argument was predicated on the statement that these were you know good honest
  112. entrepreneurs so it was definitely a very uh you know sort of setback for the Indian image you want to build but it's
  113. defitely very much uh an isolated instance I think uh you know we we have excellent companies today in India which
  114. are and I think the technology story is huge because you know people tend to see
  115. the technology story as the stuff which is to do with Outsourcing which is a h achievement but how technology has been
  116. used within the country is an equally compelling Story I mean the fact that you have an election coming up next
  117. month with 700 million voters and 1.1 million voting machines which are all electronic there's no other country in
  118. the planet which has has gone to completely electronic way of voting you know what people like IC Bank have done
  119. using technology I've given many case studies in my book they transformed the way the common man gets access to
  120. banking because the poor can go to an ATM and withdraw money and there's no Clerk and there's nobody who can come in
  121. the way so I think technology has played a huge role not only in the ex external
  122. side but also domestically now uh uh I'm very glad you brought up the election because towards the end of the
  123. book you focus on the big issues of the environment Health Care education and for all this to continue the you you
  124. need government Buy in to to to make these uh goals succeed uh based on that what's your prediction about what's
  125. going there's an election coming up in April uh who what do you think is going to happen and will India move ahead or
  126. will India fall back well I have no clue what will happen in the elections so you must be think have some scenarios
  127. in mind if if uh Congress wins a BJP wins a mayavi becomes prime minister well you know even if I have
  128. scenarios I don't think I'm going to talk about them in this forum fair enough we'll but but I think I think the
  129. basic thing is that you obviously are going to see a continuing Coalition and and this confusing environment and
  130. that's why and my point is therefore the only way to drive unity in this is to have a Unity of ideas and that's what
  131. I'm trying to do that's why I call my book a safety net of ideas if you can get more people to bind to these basic
  132. ideas it doesn't really matter what combination comes into Power you know the the infrastructure section of your
  133. book is also really interesting and there the question I thought about was there's so much to despair about as far
  134. as infrastructure goes but in telecommunications infrastructure has worked extremely well are there any
  135. lessons from the Telecommunications experience I think I think couple of I mean Telecom is a huge story I today we
  136. talking about 8 million mobile phones a month 99% of the mobile phones are prepaid which means they're being taken
  137. by people who don't have a credit history and 40% of the prepaid charge is less than 10 Rupees a pop which is a
  138. phenomenal achievement of really creating a mass movement I think part of it was you know the regulatory
  139. environment being uh changed I mean there are some challenges there but still it it is trying to create a
  140. playing field between both public and private money and also I think technology played a big role because you
  141. know you had a huge M law kind of thing operating there and uh uh but I think there other
  142. sectors too where infrastructure I mean uh airports are coming up the Bangalore airport has come up the Hyderabad
  143. airport has come up Bombay and Delhi are getting redone the highways of course it
  144. did slow down a bit but there's been a lot of movement on highways it's I mean I the challenge we have it's nowhere on
  145. the scale and scope of China so we tend to compare but I do see a lot of improvements in
  146. infrastructure uh I'd like to ask one last question and then turn it over to the to the audience uh since your book
  147. is imagining India what kind of an India would you imagine for your grandchildren and their
  148. children well I think you know my point in this book is to say that India is at a strategic opportunity it's combination
  149. of its demographics its entrepreneurs it's its technology press it's uh democracy the fact that the world is
  150. aging while we are young uh the fact that we have English as a language all these are very unique attributes that
  151. there's no other country in the world which has those and if we make the full use of that I
  152. think it can become a role model for the 21st century because you're talking about a billion people reaching
  153. Prosperity reaching uh you know living in a peaceful manner in a democracy handling extraordinary diversity I mean
  154. the whole issue today of so-call clash of civilizations India has daily you know all those civilizations are all
  155. coexisting so I think the ability to show this combination of development diversity democracy will really make it
  156. a very very successful country if you do it right but it can also go the other way because the same demographic
  157. dividend if you don't harness our people well their aspirations have been Unleashed and as they become more
  158. disgruntled and disaffected by lack of jobs and lack of economic growth they can also become a huge source of
  159. violence and divisiveness so we are on the razor's Edge whether we go this way or that way well it's definitely very
  160. compelling argument and you make it extremely well [Music]

Brief Summary

Nandan Nilekani discusses India's economic opportunities, demographic challenges, and the critical need for education and infrastructure improvements.

Key points

  • India's Demographic Dividend. India's young population presents a unique opportunity for growth, but risks must be managed.
  • The Role of Technology. Technology has transformed India's economy, enabling access and efficiency in various sectors.
  • Future of India. India's potential as a role model for the 21st century hinges on harnessing its diversity and democracy.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes