Climate Crisis: Why Climate Risk Is Investment Risk | Witold Henisz — Ripple Effect Podcast

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Witold Henisz, Vice Dean and Faculty Director of Wharton’s ESG Initiative, has been leading research on environmental, social, and governance factors long before ESG became a trending topic. In this podcast, he explains the importance of making the business case for ESG and addressing climate change, and why it’s so difficult to put hard science behind the numbers.

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 0:55 - Defining ‘ESG’ 5:08 - Discussing Engine No.1 and Exxon Mobil 9:29 - Using ESG data to adapt 13:28 - Addressing the limits of ESG investment 17:20 - The future of ESG investing

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Investments made today in an oil field that are going to pay off over 40 or 50 years might not pay off because no one
  2. might want that oil in 2050 or 2060. and so we have to think about the Investments we're making today that have
  3. a sufficiently long time Horizon with an eye to what the future is going to bring
  4. in terms of Environmental Policy environmental prices and the use of different sources of fuel welcome to the
  5. ripple effect the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of work and faculty I'm your host Dan Loney and
  6. in each episode we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton
  7. professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today we'll be covering a diverse
  8. range of topics bringing you the latest insights and knowledge that you can apply to your life into work so get
  9. ready to dive into new ideas with the ripple effect let's start with just kind of ESG as the
  10. concept in the framework because it's obviously been a topic that's been talked about a lot especially in the
  11. last few years why I guess ESG when we're talking about all of these components obviously there
  12. is the EVs and the G but what is it that has drawn the the want for the connection to this terminology
  13. uh well let's make sure all the um listeners know what ESG actually stands for e is for environment s for
  14. social G for governance and the collection of the set of environmental social and governance factors uh that
  15. influence materially by the SEC definition there are things investors should care about that materially
  16. influence the firm's revenues costs or efficiencies and should be incorporated into Financial models into investment
  17. valuation uh into strategic assessments but are often left out they're often not
  18. Incorporated they're often not addressed they're often taken for granted and the
  19. whole ESG movement is about putting them in so obviously this has been uh very much
  20. an important component of your research what was it that Drew you uh to looking at ESG and and climate risk in the first
  21. place well for 25 years I've been working I guess in the S Dimension and continue to
  22. still do a lot of my work there I look at political and social risk management so I've looked at how stakeholder
  23. engagement by firms managing the relationship with government officials with communities with civil society
  24. organizations is really a key value driver I did a lot of that work in the extractive space oil gas mining also
  25. heavy manufacturing like semiconductors or Pharmaceuticals you might have the formal rights to do something you might
  26. have all the permits you might have all the licenses but if you don't have the support of all the external stakeholders
  27. not just those in your value chain not just suppliers and buyers but those secondary stakeholders the community the
  28. government the Civil Society you might get stopped in your tracks by protests by strikes or you might operate for a
  29. while and then get sued there might be a regulatory inquiry you might get shut down and at one level when you tell that
  30. story it's really obvious but because those costs are in the future and they're unknown firms often don't manage
  31. them particularly well they under invest up front in the relationships that could
  32. help forestall certain risks and so for a long time I tried to make that argument clear and I tried to work with
  33. alternative data because there isn't publicly available data that often helps and help make the business case that
  34. more attention to political risk to social issues was actually good business and the ESG movement needed exactly the
  35. same thing an eye for a different approach to data and Analysis and a way of making the link between these ESG
  36. factors and the p l so you talk about the business case for addressing climate change and that's obviously been a back
  37. and forth now uh for for a little while make the financial case for addressing climate change at this point
  38. well I think it's increasingly easy and straightforward I mean they're going to be assets that are literally underwater
  39. whether it's a real estate investment or whether it's a Factory close to a port certain assets by 2030 2040 if we don't
  40. do something about the four or five degree scenario we're on are going to be underwater and you should be
  41. incorporating that into your evaluation models we're probably and hopefully shifting away from a heavy dependence on
  42. fossil fuels uh to more green sources of energy whether it be Hydro wind solar Investments made today in an oil field
  43. that's that are going to pay off over 40 or 50 years might not pay off because no
  44. one might want that oil in 2050 or 2060. uh similarly investments in um you know that are counting on there
  45. being fossil fuel vehicles in 2050 or 2060. may or may not pay off depending on how fast we have the uptick of
  46. electric vehicles and so we have to think about the Investments we're making today that have a sufficiently long time
  47. Horizon with an eye to what the future is going to bring in terms of Environmental Policy environmental
  48. prices and the use of different sources of fuel and I guess part of the discussion really is about the path that
  49. a lot of Corporations and their leadership are taking in this uh in this space uh one of the cases that is really
  50. talked about a lot in terms of being a potential important uh element in terms of moving this forward uh is engine
  51. number one and them winning uh seats on the board with Exxon Mobil now you were kind of around that and I guess let's
  52. start by talking a little bit about how that all developed over a course of time
  53. well engine number one began uh and its core business model uh is really focused
  54. on the idea of bringing ESG factors in but most people first became aware of them because of their campaign to unseat
  55. uh four board members of Exxon Mobil and they built a brilliant 78-page deck that
  56. analyzed the business case uh for Exxon Mobil doing more on the energy transition and highlighting that the
  57. company was actually destroying shareholder value uh by not attending to the energy transition they had forecasts
  58. for the future price of oil that were Rosier than OPEC they had forecasts for the future demand of electric vehicles
  59. that were more pessimistic than just about anybody in the world and they were making investment decisions today
  60. accordingly and that was leading to a massive waste of shareholder Capital um estimates of over 200 billion dollars
  61. of shareholder value destroyed uh there was also the question of Darren Woods's pay and the corporate governance of the
  62. company the G Factor uh during the time that he destroyed 200 billion dollars of
  63. shareholder value he got 70 million dollars of bonuses uh is that good corporate governance does that make any
  64. sense he also appointed to the board a series of Executives who underperformed their Industries when they were CEOs and
  65. had absolutely no energy sector experience so no one on the board could give him any realistic or tangible
  66. advice on the energy transition and what to do about climate transition because none of them knew anything about the
  67. energy sector again that's just bad corporate governance so you put all that together and you've got a very strong
  68. case uh that they needed more oversight and they needed more awareness to the energy transition on the board and
  69. engine number one mounted a campaign to do that I became involved as an advisor to engine number one on a different
  70. project what they call the total value framework which I co-developed together with a group from a major consultancy to
  71. generalize the case if you will of Exxon Mobil try to analyze which companies are
  72. destroying value to stakeholders and think about when that might hit shareholder value and we did that for
  73. the entire S P 500 and now it's been extended to the Russell 1000 and that was a major research project to really
  74. try to build a data set that would allow them to look not just in one company but
  75. at a whole set of companies and make investment decisions and engagements accordingly and I continue to to work
  76. with them on that project but in the scope of this process that's played out now for quite some time a lot of people
  77. talk about that movement to win board seats by engine number one as really kind of a pivot moment
  78. how so do you think that that is the case well I think there are a couple factors
  79. in play I mean when they first started everybody kind of wrote them off you own 0.02 percent of the stock who are you
  80. guys you're gonna unsee three board members really and then I kind of gather momentum you're like wait wait a minute
  81. this is credible this is serious look at this analysis and then there was a day where three of the four proposed board
  82. members were ousted and I think the next morning just about every board member in
  83. a publicly traded company anywhere in the world reading that newspaper article said I don't want to be them
  84. I want to keep my job what am I missing what do I need to understand about the hidden risks or the missed opportunities
  85. from ESG factors I better get a report about those at the next board meeting I want to make sure that I'm doing my job
  86. and I can stand up to this kind of attack and I think that amplification of the message not just the headlines not
  87. just the fact that it was Exxon Mobil not just David versus Goliath but the fact that every publicly traded company
  88. in the world's board is suddenly starting to talk about ESG factors at the next annual meeting I think that was
  89. the biggest impact that engine number one has had up to date well then that puts an even greater focus on the data
  90. that is out there for each of these particular companies around ESG and I guess the question is how can we better
  91. use that data to move that needle forward uh well let's start with the current state of the data that we have most of
  92. it honestly is quite bad it's based on voluntary unaudited Disclosure by corporations they either put stuff in
  93. their sustainability report or they answer these really long surveys that companies sell them and then different
  94. companies sell us the data um we're only getting a snapshot of what the company wants to share and what some
  95. third-party data provider can kind of Cobble together and then the bigger problem even if that data was accurate
  96. there's like a hundred factors sometimes 300 factors how do we weight them how do
  97. we put them together because we've got you know performance measured in one set of units here and performance on another
  98. factor in a different set of units here and another Factor you know should they be all equally weighted probably not you
  99. know Carbon emissions matters more for Exxon Mobil than it does for I don't know Facebook teenage depression matters
  100. more for Facebook than it does for Exxon Mobil but how do we shift the weights and and how do we turn tons of carbon
  101. and number of teenage girls in depression to dollar values that might hit shareholder value those are the
  102. questions the Kearney SG data sets don't answer and and frankly need to be answered so the total value framework
  103. was a big step towards doing that but but we've got a long way to go uh we've got to really measure the impact that
  104. companies are having and that's more akin to like impact uh investment or impact valuation but then we have to
  105. have a point of view about when those positive or negative impacts are going to hit shareholder value
  106. some firms some cases that's going to happen really quickly that happened with Exxon Mobil other cases maybe Facebook
  107. there's a more difficult pathway there's more protection for the firm from these
  108. stakeholder forces and it's harder to build a business case even though the firm is creating harm it's harder to say
  109. that shareholders are going to Bear the brunt in the short term and so we really
  110. need to think through both of those and very few ESG data sets allow us to do that
  111. what kind of role do you think then that Regulators will have to play in this process as we move forward
  112. well we're starting to see greater requirements for disclosure of things like the emissions you release and also
  113. greater attention to your risk mitigation mechanisms so what would happen to you if there was a four degree
  114. scenario how many of your assets would be underwater or what would happen to you if we had a one and a half degree
  115. scenario which means we have some kind of carbon tax or energy transition is your strategy robust to that so this is
  116. a major and material risk for companies and the SEC under the current guidelines
  117. being discussed they haven't been finally approved yet is demanding that firms both report their missions but
  118. also undertake scenario analysis on different scenarios that could occur in the future with respect to the climate
  119. transition that's going to help investors but it's not going to be the end of the game
  120. there's many uh factors many ESG factors for which we don't have strong disclosure standards yet which we're
  121. still figuring things out and some of those scenarios aren't as clear you know four degree versus one and a half degree
  122. warming scenario okay that's a pretty clear thing to model model but what about the future state of human rights
  123. law or the future state of uh you know customer uh customer damages like you know the Facebook teenage depression
  124. what how do we model those uh what sort of uncertainties do we face how do they differ from the European Union to the
  125. U.S none of that is in the regulations yet and and it's pretty difficult to put in there so I think the regulations are
  126. always going to establish a floor and then companies like engine number one other asset managers whether it's
  127. BlackRock State Street Alliance Bernstein Parnassus Morgan Stanley they're all going to be trying to figure
  128. things out above the floor and so it's good to raise the floor but there's always a lot of action above it well and
  129. as you kind of alluded to before there is in some of these instances kind of a time window uh that you need to really
  130. see significant action on and so you know the I guess the concern I have is is that are we going to be able to
  131. effectively deal with a lot of these issues if we have these time Windows really uh
  132. starting to clamp down on us well I think it's it's a really important observation it also highlights
  133. a little bit of the limits of ESG investing some people think that ESG investing is going to solve all these
  134. problems it's going to solve the problems of climate change solve the problems of racial Justice all it's
  135. supposed to do is incorporate ESG factors into an investment thesis if the current policies the current stakeholder
  136. opinions don't lead to that being internalized by shareholders it's not going to solve the problem it's only
  137. going to make sure we're not leaving stuff out we may have to go further in terms of pricing carbon in terms of
  138. addressing systemic racism uh to really have the impact we want on a society ESG
  139. ESG initiative and ESG investing more broadly just about not leaving things out but it's not about getting things
  140. exactly right so we may still need more policy more legislation more regulation to achieve what we want as a society on
  141. some of these issues so then I guess the question becomes is you you also have this anti-esg push that is out there as
  142. well and it plays out a lot in our political Discord uh these days uh I I think some people would say let's hope
  143. we've kind of reached the peak around anti-esg I think there are others that would say we're still not at that point
  144. yet well we're certainly seeing uh from the time we launched the SD initiative to
  145. the president a real surge in this anti-esg movement uh and it's gaining a lot of power especially with the new
  146. Republican Congress um should soon in the next few days uh be the target of President Biden's first
  147. veto uh pushing back against the repeal of and the the uh the allowance uh to do
  148. ESG investing within U.S Pension funds uh and so making sure that funds can do that can incorporate ESG factors I think
  149. we are getting to the point if I'm optimistic that we may be at the point of peak anti-esg because in recent days
  150. the state of North Dakota which is not exactly known as a blue state or a Bastion of progressivism uh nothing
  151. against the residents there my wife's family is from North Dakota uh but but overall it's a pretty red State their
  152. legislature voted 90-3 against anti-esg bills against bills that would restrict ESG investing why because they said why
  153. should we the government regulate the Financial Market's ability to incorporate ESG factors
  154. we're not in the business of regulating we believe in free markets and it seems like the free markets value ESG there's
  155. been similar pushback in Indiana in Kansas and Wyoming a number of states I was talking to uh representatives in
  156. Arizona yesterday about their efforts to push back against the anti-history I think the fact that the business case
  157. the financial models say that there's a there the history factors are material by the SEC definition and that the
  158. anti-sg movement is imposing regulation as a solution it's starting to highlight
  159. that this may not actually be about what they claim it is may not be about protecting pensioners value maybe more
  160. about protecting polluters protecting people who don't care about their workers or finding a political wedge
  161. issue kind of like critical race Theory or transgendered bathrooms that that resonate with some people but may not be
  162. as big of a problem as we think for society and maybe the costs of regulating the costs of taking certain
  163. financial institutions out of the market is our own Daniel Garrett's research has
  164. shown could be much larger than the political benefits in the short term at least that's my hope so for those funds
  165. out there that have kind of started to incorporate uh ESG components in their funds
  166. what kind of growth do you expect it you're going to see and maybe even what's the best way
  167. to attract more investors in that world of of ESG investing what we're trying to do with the SG
  168. initiative and what the better investors are doing is to build the business case
  169. you know in some ways talk less about ESG and talk more about profits losses efficiencies costs model the cost curves
  170. of the energy transition look at the Unexplained variances on the profits and loss statement and Link them to ESG
  171. factors but start with the p at L and focus on the p l focus on the business case the more we do that the more
  172. sophisticated we get in looking at the energy transition in looking at the changing Workforce uh in in looking at
  173. ESG factors from a business standpoint the better our investment decisions will be the better the Returns on those
  174. investment decisions will be and the easier it'll be for you as an investor whether you're red or blue when you go
  175. into the voting box to say this just makes good Financial sense I don't want to leave this stuff out let's make sure
  176. it's in thank you for listening to the ripple effect we hope you found this episode
  177. informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that
  178. we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the Wharton School

Brief Summary

This episode discusses ESG factors, climate risk, and Engine No. 1's influence on corporate governance.

Key points

  • Investments in Oil Fields. Investments made today in oil fields may not pay off in the future due to changing energy demands.
  • Understanding ESG. ESG stands for environmental, social, and governance factors that influence investment decisions.
  • Climate Change Financial Case. The financial case for addressing climate change is becoming clearer and more urgent.
  • Fossil Fuel Vehicle Future. The future of fossil fuel vehicles is uncertain as electric vehicle adoption increases.
  • Political Climate for ESG. The anti-ESG movement is gaining traction with the new Republican Congress.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes