Factors Driving Reshoring

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] would love to explore with uh both of you uh marison Scot some of the reasons
  2. why reshoring is picking up steam and and Morris starting with you uh what are some of the primary factors uh that are
  3. driving the phenomenon of reshoring okay that's a great question and you know we're actually conducting research on
  4. this and traveling to different places around the world to work with companies to get their perspective on what are the
  5. drivers of this phenomenon which is uh just to go back to the earlier point this is not just one directional
  6. companies are most global companies are managing what I would call a network of sources and destinations they have
  7. factories they have places where services are generated where value is added and most global companies are you
  8. know have to manage the the flow of of information the flow of material across this network and in so doing there are
  9. many factors therefore which affect the decision of where do I make something or
  10. where do I Source something which is you know what are the drivers so so we can go through them cost is obviously a very
  11. obvious one and there's this notion of landed cost which is the fully loaded cost of a product to get to a market
  12. which takes into account all of the fixed and variable costs and transportation costs of all the stages
  13. of manufacturing and sourcing and so when you get to bring your product to a particular country a particular Market
  14. that landed cost becomes the basis of your competition and so labor is can be a big driver of that but there are many
  15. other cost components so that's one thing cost but even in cost we have to expand the perspective Beyond just the
  16. landed cost to what I would call cost of ownership the life cycle cost you many products are owned and used over a life
  17. cycle uh computers Aerospace automobiles it's not just the product cost of getting the product into the hands of
  18. the consumer it's what is the full cost over the lifetime of use of that product
  19. and then we get into after Sal service and support and maintenance issues as well but cost however we want to measure
  20. it how carefully we want to do it is a major driver the second Big Driver is risk there's lots of risk and when we
  21. start operating globally the risks compound not only do we have the usual Market risks of price and demand we also
  22. have foreign exchange Vari volatility in foreign exchange and other Financial aspects can wipe out
  23. overnight the profit of a global company and a well-crafted strategy of where to
  24. Source based on costs can be rendered completely obsolete you know in the twinkling of an eye and so there's a lot
  25. of how do we mitigate that risk how do we absorb that risk so our research has shown a lot of people have studied this
  26. that you have to combine the option value of the manufacturing Network with financial options so we have real
  27. options and financial options basically what I'm saying is if you have different
  28. sources for which you can go and I uh as conditions change as contingencies occur
  29. prices demand availability of Labor uh natural disasters all kinds of risks companies can shift if they've invested
  30. upfront if they've purchased that option built those plants developed those processes hired the right people then
  31. they have flexibility so flexibility has become a very important issue and then the final one I'll
  32. mentioned we could go on but technology is have become a very important issue there are those who say that this whole
  33. argument about labor costs and Manufacturing has become moot because of automation we now have lowcost robots
  34. that are highly flexible that can actually assemble do the the the the fine motor skill assembly that we could
  35. only have people do and some companies are Outsourcing so there's a reshoring of Phillips for example has brought back
  36. the Assembly of razors electric shavers from China back to the Netherlands in a factory that has about a 100 robots and
  37. I don't know 10 people and it's more productive than the sister plant in China so can we automate our way out of
  38. this and then another point that was mentioned is the availability of skills and then so another theory that says it
  39. has to do with Innovation if you Outsource manufacturing you lose the ability to develop new products and once
  40. it leaves it won't come back so there's a lot of competing theories a lot of competing arguments and a lot of
  41. tradeoffs but I'd say fundamentally it's cost Risk Technology and Innovation right thank you for that very uh you
  42. know comprehensive overview of the factors now specifically in the technology space or the IT industry
  43. Scott what are you seeing as some of the primary drivers of reshoring in your experience I think the biggest one is
  44. the talent availability uh factors if you look at um you know large engineering schools across the us over
  45. the last four years most of them have seen at minimum a 10% increase in enrollment so if you go back four years
  46. you're talking about a 40% increase in enrollment and engineering that's a lot more kids in the market and there's a
  47. little bit of a trickle down effect that happens there I think uh universities I
  48. think uh you know uh community colleges even high school systems are starting to
  49. realize that there's jobs in technology and so they're starting to enable and and push kids that way who who have an
  50. acclamation to doing that we're seeing uh major universities you know we we have a partnership with the University
  51. of Florida whose engineering school is now close to 8,000 kids that is just a huge number and that's very good news
  52. for the United States that big programs like that are are starting to become available but we're also seeing
  53. community colleges step up and you see um a lot of magnet schools at the high school level starting to emerge where
  54. they are just focusing on engineering or technology so kids are starting to get uh into Tech early on um they become
  55. very tech-savvy at an early age by the time they get to uh College they're very well prepared by the time they get to a
  56. company like M tree they're ready to hit the ground running with minimal training
  57. so I think the biggest factor of all is the increase in the size of the talent pool that's happened here in the US and
  58. I think it's really driven by the fact that there's a lot of jobs in the tech space that are open the other main
  59. factor is that and we talked about this earlier that the cost of of of Outsourcing or offshoring has increased
  60. to a point where there's not a lot I mean there's still a difference between us and places like India but it's not as
  61. big of a difference and so now it makes uh a lot more sense to do some work here
  62. in the States but continue to do work offshore as well and get that balance that we talked about earlier right just
  63. to to drill a little deeper into uh some of these factors um a lot of uh what Morris was talking about for the
  64. manufacturing space uh refers to the you know physical property whereas in technology you're dealing mostly with
  65. intellectual property uh what what are some of the unique factors there that that go into the reshoring phenomenon
  66. sure and and I think you know the the big one there is that the kids that are coming out of college today are so more
  67. well equipped than they were 10 years ago they come out with you know thinking innov Innovation they come out with a
  68. drive to be entrepreneurs even um you know I I just talked about we've got a 400 person us delivery Center in
  69. Gainesville Florida in part parip with the engineering school at the University of Florida we opened that Center up last
  70. year in 2012 I don't think we could have done that three four years ago the universities weren't ready for it the
  71. states weren't ready for it the cities weren't ready for it but what we're seeing across the country is that uh
  72. major universities major research universities the cities that they're in and the states that they're in are all
  73. starting to come together to realize that if they pull their efforts and they pull their resources they can produce
  74. better better talent and attract more companies like M Tre to set up centers there so that's a big change that we've
  75. seen over the last couple years uh what the to what extent is um currency policy the the RO of the dollar
  76. versus uh the RMB for example uh playing a f a role in uh spurring reshoring well
  77. it does affect the the the landed cost quite quite directly and and not only currency but also taxation and other
  78. forms of government incentives and restrictions the local content there are a lot of things and currency just being
  79. the most visible um so some countries like China have a somewhat controlled currency and uh they you know and they
  80. have kept the exchange rat so that the the cost disadvantage uh has been reduced uh people have argued if they
  81. let let it float then there would be higher prices and there would be less of an incentive to Offshore uh and of
  82. course the government is restricting that to some extent and I think every country is playing this game you know if
  83. you don't let the your currency float then that creates uh all kinds of problems in terms of imports and exports
  84. and costs uh but the reality is that governments are a main actor in this whole equation as they should be their
  85. goal is quite different than the goals of the multinational corporations or the domestic
  86. corporations uh they're not looking to to maximize profit they're looking to maximize the welfare of their population
  87. the employment of of of the population uh and and the opportunities for that population are are very important and
  88. they want to influence that to the extent they can companies on the other hand have to operate in this environment
  89. in a competitive and somewhat restricted environment so it has a big fact it has
  90. a big impact and it continues to uh and you know there are those who argue for more relaxing those restrictions and
  91. others you know argue in this country as well you know that we should restrict immigration we should restrict Imports
  92. that that would be the answer and others say no that's just the opposite of what
  93. we need to do so it becomes a very interesting debate and very contentious I'm sure yes uh Scott what do you think
  94. is is uh uh the the the relationship with the dollar and the rupe being a factor in uh your business uh at M and
  95. what do you see at M Tre yeah it's definitely a factor um because what it inevitably drives is a level of your
  96. profitability and depending on which way the rupee and the dollar are going it really affects the profitability of
  97. Indian companies and when Indian companies have higher profitability they can take that money and invest back into
  98. the business and it's just you know Common Sense and and natural business practices so it's important to watch and
  99. there's obviously no you know magic for figuring out which way it's going to go but it clearly has an effect uh and I
  100. think in addition to uh currency fluctuation you know taxation uh incentives and things like that are are
  101. certainly affecting how near Shoring can be done and I think states are really stepping up to helping companies bring
  102. technology jobs back to the US and controlling that aspect of the incentive incentives has been really really well
  103. done okay so so uh just to wrap up this particular part of the conversation any final thoughts on the factors at play
  104. anything you'd like to add that we have't tou the only comment I would make is I I I do see some of the the changes
  105. that Scott mentioned you know in terms of better preparation and more interest in technology but um we have a big gap
  106. in this country to overcome you know and if we stand back and look at you know all of the all of our this generation
  107. and how many of them are taking Science Tech you know the stem you know in engineering and Mathematics we've lost
  108. ground in that regard and we have to make it up and we have to provide High pain jobs for this next generation and a
  109. lot of you know we see Technology and Manufacturing as a source but uh if we look at the the the gross numbers
  110. there's still a big gap so while I'm I'm also an optimist uh I just put in a word
  111. of caution that we don't have unlimited time to solve this problem yeah I couldn't agree more uh the the we're I
  112. think we're in the early days of rebuilding our our stem capabilities the all the signs and all the trends are
  113. positive and I'm an optimist that you know this is going to take off and it's obviously going to be great for the
  114. country but we still have a long way to go we've got to uh maybe even get down to a level below and start talking stem
  115. at a at a elementary school and a Middle School uh you know level so that we get
  116. kids interested at an early age and then that drives Innovation and growth it's it's clearly a path for the the country
  117. to you know move into the you know future decades and and we've got to continue to fuel the fire in stem
  118. education [Music]

Brief Summary

Reshoring is driven by cost, risk, technology, and a growing talent pool in the U.S.

Key points

  • Drivers of Reshoring. Exploring the primary factors driving the reshoring phenomenon, including cost and risk.
  • Talent Availability in Tech. The increase in engineering enrollment is reshaping the tech landscape in the US.
  • Impact of Currency on Reshoring. Currency policies and taxation significantly influence reshoring decisions.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes