Can AI Fight Corruption? Why Small Firms May Be at Risk
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
EPISODE OVERVIEW Artificial intelligence is often hailed as the ultimate compliance tool — but is it really ready to prevent bribery and corruption? Wharton’s Phil Nichols explains why AI can backfire for smaller firms that lack sufficient data, leading to misleading or “hallucinatory” results. He also discusses how Europe’s strict AI regulations could set a higher global standard for protecting human dignity, and why future forms of empathetic or intuitive AI might someday transform compliance and regulation. He outlines where AI helps and where it harms the global fight against corruption.
PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.
#AIEthics #BusinessEthics #ResponsibleAI #AIinBusiness #RegTech #AI ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- So in general, if we're talking about very large firms, particularly firms that have experienced corruption in ways
- that can be captured, right, >> AI is great. When we're talking small to medium firms, don't generate a lot of
- data, AI can be counterproductive. It can it can yield hallucinatory responses that that could hurt individual people
- or hurt transactions or relationships. Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the podcast that takes you on a journey
- through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Looney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the
- inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their
- findings resonate with the world today. Well, as we continue to hear that artificial intelligence is the
- technology that every firm should implement, [music] our guest today questions whether that can be the case
- when you're thinking about things like anti-corruption efforts by countries and agencies around the globe. Pleasure to
- be joined here in studio by Philip Nichols, professor of legal studies and business ethics here at the Wharton
- School. He wrote about that question exactly in a recent article for the American Business Law Journal. Phil,
- great to see you. How are you? >> Fabulous, Dan. It's always good to see you. >> Good to see you as well. So, I I guess
- let's dig in right into the guts of this because everybody thinks that every company needs to have AI in everything
- that they are doing. >> Exactly. >> How does potentially AI fit in or maybe not fit in in and around the efforts to
- prevent bribery, corruption, etc.? >> Great question. Um to answer that question
- we need to understand two things about corruption and two things about artificial intelligence.
- The first about corruption it manifests itself differently everywhere. The corruption you
- experience in one country is different than the other in one industry different than the other in one firm different
- than the other. And that means data is not fungeible. data is not easily translatable or usable
- >> right >> from one to the other. >> The second thing to understand about corruption and and in compliance in
- general is that misbehavior corruption uh occurs in the shadows. People don't want to generate a lot of
- data about it, right? Two things to understand about um artificial intelligence in addition to it uses a
- lot of energy and it requires a lot of processing power, >> right? It requires a a solid model of
- what the world looks like and it requires a lot of data, >> right? >> Therefore, if we put those two things
- together and and not even talk in specific about what we're asking artificial intelligence to do, but just
- whether artificial intelligence is viable with this particular realm of compliance,
- >> right? >> We don't have the data and we don't have the model. And therefore what we're
- likely to get when we ask questions of artificial intelligence is hallucinations or nonsense.
- >> Right? And I guess to a degree with the issue of compliance >> then you have to bring in the point that
- the rules in Europe are different than what we see here in the United States and [snorts] other parts of the world.
- And so >> we think about the use of AI as something that is global. We think about
- the ways of protecting from corruption as global. Yeah. >> Yet you have these different sets of
- rules in place. >> Yeah. The European Union's rules regarding artificial intelligence really
- protect individual dignity >> whereas the rules for the use of AI in North America, particularly United
- States are are much looser, >> right? And so using AI to like investigate one of your employees, are
- they accumulating wealth surreptitiously, >> right? >> You wouldn't be able to do that in
- Europe. And if you're a transnational firm, you really need to comply with Europe's they're they're kind of like
- the gold standard of use of AI. And so there's a lot of things like you point out that we won't be able to like dig
- into, investigate, etc. because that really would be an infringement on the dignity of the people who work with us
- and for us. >> So a lot of what is also asked involves up-to-date process, up-to-date software,
- etc. >> Yeah, >> at least right now it seems like up toate in the realm of what we're talking
- about is AI. It's it's taking that next step. >> That's my concern. I I you know someday
- I I have no doubts that someday new forms of artificial intelligence will be very useful empathetic or empathic AI
- intuitive AI but right now most of our a either is either in the form of large language models or is it is
- self-learning and therefore can categorize and make a sense of large ma large masses of unsorted data
- >> right >> neither one of those right now fits the the the things we need to do with
- corruption. And so the notion that oh we adopt artificial intelligence and therefore we're up to date and doing the
- best we can >> really doesn't work when we get into the weeds and think we want to solve these
- problems not just put a little sticker on that says hey we're using AI >> but are there processes components of
- what is being done now to try and prevent corruption prevent bribery etc >> where you see AI could have absolutely
- >> a level of impact. >> Absolutely. Two areas. One is areas um is in generally warning people. So we
- call that red flags. So sorting data. Yeah, your firm does this this does this transaction, this
- action, whatever a particular way for thousands of times and then there's one that's different, right?
- >> Well, that's a red flag. doesn't mean it's necessarily a misbehavior, corrupt.
- It just means that someone should take a look at it and see why it's different. AI is great for that. And the other way
- that AI is really useful is when we do have huge masses of data, right? >> So the Panama papers, the Pandora leaks,
- etc. or an individual firm, Seammens, Walmart, right? These are are are corruption incidents of corruption that
- did yield massive amounts of data and there artificial intelligence can be useful. So in general if we're talking
- about very large firms particularly firms that have experienced corruption in ways that can be captured right
- >> AI is great. When we're talking small to medium firms don't generate a lot of
- data, AI can be counterproductive. It can it can yield hallucinatory responses that that could hurt individual people
- or hurt transactions or relationships. >> Is there a level of this? And when you
- think about the rules that have been put in via Europe around GDPR in the last decade or two?
- >> Yeah. >> And they were seen to be at the forefront of the move to try and protect
- personal data. Yeah. Is there a way that you could say a region of the world because they have kind of taken the
- steps forward maybe finding a path sooner rather than later to implement AI to be able to use
- this in the process or are we still far away from that at this point? >> Um I think we're far away from it in
- general. Right. >> I your question is a really interesting question and and it's a question that
- that goes beyond just compliance or you know detection of misbehavior. the Europe, China, and the US all have
- very different approaches, >> right? >> Which one of those approaches is going to yield the most accurate detection of
- misbehavior? I I think there's an argument to be made for Europe's approach because un unlike you [snorts]
- know our use of for example um AI and hiring right now Europe's approach might lead to a better model which is half of
- what makes AI work model and data >> and Europe might lead to a better model that I mean it's a really interesting
- question that we don't really know enough about I mean we're what just a few years into this transition.
- >> Yeah. >> But there there's a a good argument for Europe. There's also a good argument for
- the US in that >> you know just letting people run wild and do whatever they want to with AI,
- you know, might yield the magic bullet too. >> So then from the same perspective then
- when you think about how regulation plays a role in how companies operate. >> Yeah. I guess to a degree the unknown of
- AI that we still have in a lot of areas really still puts us in an unknown in terms of how it would impact with
- regulation as well. >> Yeah. I I the the absolutely the the thing that I'm most concerned
- the thing I wanted to experiment with and play with was since AI seems to be the magic band-aid for everything in the
- world and you're not up to you know you've got to have AI AI or you're behind is that true right now and the
- answer I came up with is no >> there's plenty of areas where AI is neither not helpful or detrimental and
- compliance regulation is is one of them. >> Is that going to end up then leading us
- to kind of rewriting rewriting policy and regulation in some of these areas if we do get to a point of of implementing
- AI? >> Yeah, I I imagine just like with the industrial revolution um rules changed because the world we
- work in and the world we live in has changed, >> right? in that in in a number of years
- the regulations the the rules for business behavior will be written with an eye toward the fact that most
- businesses incorporate to some extent varying degrees um because by then we'll have a more realistic understanding
- artificial intelligence >> so in in the times that you and I have talked about these issues yeah
- >> I think it's fair to say when you think about corruption you're thinking about
- it at the business level at the firm I do. Absolutely. I'm here at Wharton. >> When you're when you're thinking about
- bribery, >> it's more of a personal, you know, one person to one person, two people to two
- people connection. So, how does that difference potentially impact the thought process of using AI to kind of
- mitigate the issues around bribery? >> Yeah. Um so if we go to the other end and talk about you the use of artificial
- intelligence in government in businessto business transactions >> um there is great potential there's
- great potential for abuse >> right >> there's great potential particularly since AI can leverage at huge scales
- >> right >> for all kinds of misconduct but there's also great opportunity for reducing or
- almost to nothing that kind of human interference and discretion that that can lead to corruption and the digital
- platform infrastructure in India and Aadhar in India are great examples of technology I mean and here we're not
- even talking self-learning or what you know whatever the AI bucket is >> right >> but where technology has done exactly
- what you describe and significantly reduced low-level corruption significant significantly redu increased the amount
- of money that people are entitled to from various government distributions that they're getting at the village
- level. So at the other end, the not not the compliance end, but the the government operation and regulatory end,
- yeah, there's potential for abuse, but there's also great potential for cleaning up corruption, which is a
- really neat story. What would then some of the policies or rules you think that would have to be put in place in order
- to have [clears throat] that kind of effectiveness? >> Yeah, one is giving people digital IDs.
- Uh right, you know, we kind of juryrigg that in the United States and in North America right now. We like use
- somebody's cell phone number >> um the email address. But the if you look at places like Estonia where they
- they they just from the ground up once they achieved reach achieved independence
- um digital IDs that opened up so much for working with technology which event you
- know will include of course self-learning and and artificial intelligence. You look at Adhar in India
- once you have that digital ID even at the village level it opened up access to the kinds of things that you're talking
- about. So that's one one thing that you know policy countries are leapfrogging those of us
- who still use what's your mobile phone number. >> Yeah. >> Um that's just a really simple kind of
- thing. Now how one approaches the mass leveraging the the depersonalization all of these things
- with with still some kind of form of justice and and and you know fairness that's something that you know the in
- the industrial revolution it took them 80 years at least to figure out. hopefully will be a lot faster, but we
- kind of need to see what intuitive AI looks like, what empathic AI looks like before we start developing those kinds
- of regulations. And maybe I'll throw in the cynic in me a little bit, but don't you don't you also have to assume that
- if we are looking at ways to potentially implement AI to prevent this type of criminal activity, Yeah. The criminals
- are out there looking for ways to use the AIB to conclude this activity. >> Absolutely. Without question. And and
- and and it does give them huge potential. Um the leveraging gives them huge potential from misconduct.
- The the ability to crack other, you know, previously secure forms of communication or interaction, huge
- potential. So there's no question. It's not that AI eventually it's it doesn't work now,
- >> right? >> But even in the future, it's not a magic bullet. It's a tool that we need to use
- wisely. >> And and we can never think of it as just well, we're done now. AI is taking care
- of everything. It's >> it it may become sentient. It may become whatever, whatever, whatever, but it's
- still a tool, not a magic bullet. And I'll finish on this because even with the implementation of AI in so many
- firms right now, the expectation is you still have to have the human component in there as part of it and I think you
- just kind of alluded to it. Yeah. That even if you're using AI in terms of trying to prevent this level of criminal
- activity, you still need to have the human component in there monitoring and helping go through the process.
- >> Absolutely, without question. >> Phil, great to see you again. Thanks very much.
- >> Dan, always excellent to see you. Thank you. >> Thank you. Philip Nichols, uh, professor
- of legal studies and business ethics here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to The Ripple Effect. We
- hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can
- continue to bring you the best insight from the [music] Wharton School.
Brief Summary
Philip Nichols discusses AI's complex role in combating corruption in businesses, emphasizing data challenges and regulatory differences.
Key points
- The Ripple Effect Podcast. Join host Dan Looney as he explores the groundbreaking research of Wharton faculty.
- AI's Role in Corruption Prevention. Philip Nichols discusses the complexities of using AI in anti-corruption efforts.
Episode highlights
- The Ripple Effect PodcastJoin host Dan Looney as he explores the groundbreaking research of Wharton faculty.0:26Nov 4, 2025
- AI's Role in Corruption PreventionPhilip Nichols discusses the complexities of using AI in anti-corruption efforts.“AI can yield hallucinatory responses that could hurt individual people.”7:06Nov 4, 2025





