Pros & Cons of Gig Work & Algorithms Managing Employees

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Can AI effectively serve as a manager to workers in the gig economy? The Wharton School professor Lindsey Cameron discusses the pros and cons of gig work. While gig workers have flexibility and may prefer gig work to other options, such as working at Walmart, they face challenges, including in "algorithmic management," where reaching a person when issues come up is often impossible.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#gigworker #algorithms #gigworkers #gigwork #gigeconomy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. But then you also have, and you use the term in your research, the good bad job.
  2. How does that come into play? You know, I trust what my workers tell me. You know, I didn't love driving, but a lot
  3. of my drivers did like driving. And I think that was my first "aha!" in the research. This is some sort of tension I need to look
  4. into. So yes, the driver is telling me, "I'm earning more than I was at Walmart, at the gas station. I can take care of my
  5. family. You know, I like driving around town and showing people the sights of my city."
  6. Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of
  7. Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the
  8. groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the
  9. world today. Well, as more and more people add gig work to their professional mix,
  10. we also see an increase in algorithmic management. This means that workers are following the instruction of so-called
  11. managers, who are the process of algorithms. Recent research examines what that relationship is like and how workers feel
  12. about being managed by tech and not by, directly, another human being. Pleasure to be joined by Lindsey Cameron, Assistant
  13. Professor of Management here at the Wharton School, who's led this research. Lindsey, great to talk to you. It's been a while.
  14. Always great to touch base. Yeah, definitely. Feel the same over here. I know how much you have focused on a lot of these
  15. elements in your research, but I guess when you look at that relationship, it becomes even more interesting with how gig
  16. work kind of factors in. Exactly. You know, one thing I love to say about the gig economy is that it punches above
  17. its weight class. It's only about 1% of the US workforce, but 97% of people have heard of Uber and Lyft. You know, it's
  18. about 60 to 70% of Americans have gotten in one of those cars. And you think about all the sweeping legal regulations
  19. that we've talked about before, Dan, in California, Massachusetts, Minnesota, all about redefining gig work, which
  20. has all these ripple effects for other types of independent contractors. So the gig economy is really just a microcosm that
  21. helps us understand broader changes in our economy. Right. And I guess, where this research is concerned,
  22. it's unique to look at how these workers are being managed, and what that might mean for the concept of management moving forward.
  23. Exactly. We always think of management as like, having a boss. And like, how do I avoid the bad boss and get the good
  24. boss? But you know, we have these longer conversations, larger conversations, about AI and control. And really what is
  25. AI doing? It's trying to algorithmically manage people. Outsource part of the work, the managerial function, to the
  26. algorithms. And Uber is a really great example, from end to end. You know, I worked part time as a driver for three years. Never
  27. spoke to a single employee of Uber. Hiring, firing, evaluating, disciplining, all done by an algorithmic
  28. management system. It's really gives us a precursor or a view into the future. What did that experience really mean to you in
  29. going through that? Because, I mean— I mean, it's unique. As you said, we're so used to coming into the office and
  30. meeting with a boss or talking with other people. And it's— it's— it's a totally different experience, isn't it?
  31. Yeah. It is— you know, you do— you do have a lot of schedule flexibility. You can— you can work around your schedule. But when things don't
  32. go right, then you don't know what to do. There's this whole period I drove in the DC, you know, Virginia area. And there
  33. was, like three hours— I was sitting near Dupont Circle. It was raining. I was seeing all these other cars go by and
  34. people getting in the back seat. I'm like, "That's an Uber. I think it's an Uber. But why am I not getting any rides? Why am I
  35. here in the dark, not earning income?" And I was texting, and they were like,"No, we're— you're logged on, you're eligible to
  36. get rides." I had no real way to have voice and resolve an issue. And the next day, they apologized. They said something
  37. was down to the system. I was logged online, but not getting rides. So there's this joy in schedule flexibility, and then
  38. there's this issue of when things don't go right, whether it's pay, something with a customer, not getting rides— then
  39. you're really— you're talking to a robo bot. And it's hard to get resolution. What does it mean, then, for the types of tasks that
  40. may be brought that person's way in terms of dealing with them and handling them, depending on who or what is kind of managing
  41. the process? So the types of tasks that you're going to see algorithms sort of step in and be the boss are going to be
  42. sliced down to the smallest unit possible. We call that de- skilling. But it's at a much deeper way than, like, factory
  43. work, when you're at a assembly line. Then it's a bit of de-skilling. But this is like, "Can a task be completed in two seconds?" You
  44. know, a micro task. So when you think about, say, ride hailing, for example, it's lots of little micro tasks. Will I accept this
  45. ride or not? Am I going to follow the GPS out, Ubers or Waze, to go where I'm going? Am I going to talk to the customer?
  46. Which way will I drive? And then will I rate the— do I rate them or not? They're all these very, very small components, but
  47. because they're so small, they can be algorithmically managed, and at the same time, the workers feel like they have
  48. choice, because they're all these little individual elements. I have a very small but very real amount of choice.
  49. And I think that's one of the reasons why people like this work so much, is this feeling of choice, Small but real.
  50. But then you also have— and you use the term in your research, the good bad job. How does that come into play?
  51. You know, I trust what my workers tell me. You know, I didn't love driving, but a lot
  52. of my drivers did like driving, and I think that was my first "aha!" in the research. This is some sort of tension I need to
  53. look into. So yes, the driver is telling me, "I'm earning more than I was at Walmart, at the gas station. I can take care of my
  54. family. You know, I like driving around town and showing people the sights of my city." But then if you zoom out of the workers,
  55. you gotta look at what's the larger legal, social, environmental influx. These people don't have insurance
  56. coverage if they get into an accident. You know. This— you might get in coverage when the passenger's in the car, but what
  57. happens when you're driving? You know, waiting to get that ride. You're not covered in the same amount. You saw during COVID how
  58. they— there were questions about whether or not they would be covered to get the same sort of employment protections. There's
  59. issues about not being able to earn the minimum wage. So there's a broader context that you've got to understand the
  60. work in, even if workers like it. And that's why I call it the good bad job. And the thing is, it's here to stay, and it's not
  61. just the gig economy. Most of our work is becoming both good and bad, because these tensions are generative.
  62. So then, when you're talking about working on these types of platforms, I guess you can consider it a bad job for a variety of different
  63. reasons, right? Yeah, there are reasons you can consider it a bad job. And I think just leaving it like, "It's a bad job,
  64. workers are exploited. They don't have insurance, they don't have minimum wage." It's true, but it's only part of the story,
  65. because people are also enjoying this work. And for those that have been shut out of the labor market, particularly if you're a
  66. first generation immigrant, many of the people doing this work, you know, they come over to the States, and their credentials
  67. are not transferring, even though they have the skills. So they go into this type of work. Or there's someone that's been
  68. out of the labor market. Maybe they were incarcerated, or they were at home taking care of kids, or they were sick. It does
  69. provide an income-earning opportunity. So the fact they enjoy the work is real. In the same time, it exists in these
  70. larger conditions. And I think we're finding more and more jobs, particularly as benefits for workers continue to be
  71. eroding, holding this tension. So when you look at where we are right now, in many cases, gig work is preferred to people over
  72. a traditional office. Ah, so that's a tricky one. So I would say for my gig workers that I focused on— so I've studied all
  73. the big platforms. Instacart, DoorDash, Amazon Flex, ride hailing, they typically have a lot of bad options. So it's
  74. warehouse, manufacturing, gas station, cater waiter. And so they see gig work as being the best option out of a set of
  75. good options. But these were never people that had traditional office jobs. And so when you're talking about those
  76. people who are preferring gig work over traditional, you know, office jobs, there, you're talking about more high skilled
  77. employees, or higher— you know, folks who are, like, doing Upwork, or doing coding or copy editing. And that's a different
  78. conversation, because you're talking about a different type of labor or skill. You talk in the paper about the element of
  79. consent, and the fact that that can be very important in terms of the perception of how good or bad a job may be. And I guess
  80. you have to look at it from those two perspectives, one being the human relationship, but two being the algorithmic
  81. relationship as well. That's it. You have to have conversations with both. And particularly in this context, it's conversations
  82. with the technology. But the classic question that paper looks at— and this is— you know, this question has been
  83. looked at over 100 years by different scholars— is, why do people keep on doing jobs— apologize for my French— that are
  84. kind of shitty? That are kind of bad? Why do people enjoy work that qualitatively looks like it's in bad conditions? And
  85. that's the issue. That's the tension of the good bad job that I'm hoping to unpack. You know, and deeper in the paper
  86. I talk about, people have small amounts of agency in their work. So they might decline a whole bunch of rides in a row because
  87. they don't want a shared ride. Because it's very— you know, you can get fights with passengers. You have three or four people,
  88. you know, that are in the car. Or they might use geo-spoofing apps to try to get higher paid work. Or they can try to inflate
  89. surges. This is one of my funnest stories. It was the Thurs— no, the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. You know,
  90. everybody's heading out to the airport. And I interviewed somebody who primarily drove in a college city. And he's
  91. like, "They weren't paying me enough to go to the airport, so I just stayed in front of the dorms and I click, decline,
  92. decline, decline. And then I got a ride for $160 to go to the airport, and it's usually 40." So there are ways— he
  93. quadrupled his wage. So there are ways they're able to have small amounts of agency within this larger system of work that's
  94. really not set up to, you know, give them any protection or benefits. How do you think, then, that that technology like
  95. we see used in these types of jobs potentially impacts our larger workforce as we move into the future?
  96. You know, the— it's a great question. And my first answer, I— it's— I think it's honestly scary. You know, you think about
  97. those means of recourse. You know, I didn't get paid for three hours. There are people that I interviewed who got
  98. kicked off the app for three days, couldn't pay a utility bill, and supposedly they said they were kicked out of the app
  99. because they had said something they shouldn't have said to a woman. You know, there is
  100. something that crossed gender norms, and then he got an apology message three days later, saying, "Oh, it wasn't you.
  101. The algorithmic management system made the wrong reference. It was actually a different driver. You could come back on
  102. the app." But for those three days, he had no income and he had no way to navigate the system to get back on the app.
  103. So there is a concern that as you keep on de-skilling and de- splicing the work, one, it drives down wages because people
  104. can't really build skill. But two, there's no one to— like, algorithms make mistakes, and without a human in the loop, the
  105. human is lost. Is the expectation that we probably still will have some of those conditions where algorithms do
  106. make errors from time to time for a longer time? Because I think it's— I mean, look. Humans are putting a lot of the effort
  107. in behind the algorithm, and we certainly know that humans are not perfect. - Yes.
  108. So, I mean, how can we expect the algorithms to be perfect if the humans are not?
  109. It is— The fact that people hold these algorithms to god-like status. Like, can't make a mistake. I mean, that's such a blind, naive view
  110. of technology. There's always, always going to be a gap between the how the technology is designed and how it's used and
  111. implemented by the workers. And in that space, you see agency, like what I talked about in the paper, but you also see mistakes
  112. the technical system is making. And I think the more we start— get blinded by techno Utopia-ism, that increases the risk. And the
  113. risk, particularly, for the most marginalized parts of our society. Because these algorithms, they're refined and
  114. they're tested on the most vulnerable parts of the population. Like, you think about predictive policing, you think
  115. about whether or not I'm going to give somebody that has a low credit score a loan, or whether or not I'm going to let them go
  116. out for a parole. These were tested on disenfranchised parts of the population, and once they were fine, bam, they come out
  117. for the masses. And so I think that's a way to think about the gig economy, and why it punches above its weight class, and why
  118. it's having such a ripple effect. It's— from— it started off with a group of more marginalized people who are shut
  119. out on the edges of the labor market. They're refining these tools, and now they're going after the middle paying, the
  120. higher paying, skilled jobs. And it's just changing— changing the landscape of work.
  121. But does the— kind of the concept of innovation really have the opportunity to grow and develop,
  122. because we're adding in this component of technology? I mean, before, a lot of it was just innovation based on humans. Now
  123. we're bringing in some other components to it. Maybe, if you want to be optimistic. I mean, you know, I think it's the
  124. question like, has Uber done more good for the world or more harm for the world? And it's hard, you know, as me, as an
  125. academic, to see so— so black and white. I do think there are innovative things that they've done. You know, in many ways,
  126. they've dismantled a taxi medallion system that wasn't working for a lot of people. And at the same time, I think the—
  127. the feeling of that, what they accomplished or— and I just want to— I don't want to pick on a ride hailing company. But
  128. like, when you have those easy wins, it can sort of blind you about the future, and then think that everything you're doing is
  129. right. Like you have a mandate to go forward. And that's where I get worried about the boundary of innovation. And what does it
  130. mean for people and human capital? Where do you think you would like to take this path of research?
  131. And what's that next step for you, do you think? I'm doing a lot of research in the Global South
  132. right now. Spent the summers in Brazil, in Nigeria, in Ghana, and I think— you know, back to that earlier point where I
  133. talked about how technology and these algorithmic skills are sort of honed on the most disenfranchised groups. I think
  134. the Global South is the future. And that—and I see it in many ways in thinking about how the gig economy and algorithmic
  135. management is evolving. It's— I'm seeing the big changes happen in the Global South, and I see it, like, refined, when I'm looking in
  136. the US. And it's easy to miss it, because it looks like noise within the data. And so, you know, I'm looking at my research
  137. in a more global scale. I'm also thinking about, what are the boundaries of liability? Like, I
  138. do not want to point my fingers at these companies and be like, "You're wrong, big tech." But I think there are questions about,
  139. what are the boundaries of the firm, and what responsibilities do you have if you're trying to build a marketplace and if you
  140. have independent contractors? We need to think about them in a more thoughtful way. Because this is not Walmart, but nor is
  141. it really like a bunch of, like, free floating, you know, consultants, you know, that are like, meeting through job— like a
  142. job board, the correct place. It's a new organizational form, and it does have some—
  143. some responsibilities and liabilities in play. Accountability. - Yeah. Lindsey, always great to talk with you.
  144. Thanks very much. All the best. Thank you. You too. - You got it. Lindsey Cameron, Assistant Professor of Management here at
  145. the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this episode informative and
  146. engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the
  147. Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Lindsey Cameron discusses gig work, algorithmic management, and the complexities of the "good bad job" in this episode.

Key points

  • Gig Economy's Impact. The gig economy is a microcosm reflecting broader economic changes.
  • The Good Bad Job. Exploring the dual nature of gig work, where workers find joy despite challenges.
  • Algorithmic Management Risks. Discussing the dangers of relying solely on algorithms for management.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes