A Holistic Approach to Conservation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Andrew Muir is executive director of the Wilderness Foundation, an organization dedicated to protecting the wilderness and wildlife of South Africa and providing environmental education and training to its citizens. In a recent conversation with Knowledge@Wharton, Muir talked about the Foundation's success integrating social programs into its mission, and how its efforts have been affected by the legacy of apartheid. He also discussed the important role that conservation has to play in Africa's economic development. 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] we're here today with Andrew mure executive director of the Wilderness
  2. Foundation Andrew thanks so much for being with us today great well thank you for having me um first of all we just
  3. want to talk to you a little bit about how did you become interested in this field and how did you initially get
  4. connected with the Wilderness Foundation well um obviously as a young boy growing
  5. up I had a great love for the outdoors I don't think you can live in Africa and not be moved by the Landscapes and the
  6. Animals the wildlife and so that was my initial attraction and then as time went
  7. on I also also begun to realize that perhaps this medium the um uh the platform of of wildlife and nature and
  8. our our reserves and and uh the protected areas that we have that it could also be a place where we can bring
  9. people from different backgrounds different walks of life and perhaps even make a difference to some of the Social
  10. Challenges that uh we have as a country a continent and even as the globe mhm and you were mentored by Wilderness
  11. Foundation founder Dr Ian player for 13 years before taking on the executive director role what were the most
  12. important things that you learned from his example or learn from him um he is an extraordinary human
  13. being and and I think that the important part about a mentor is to really uh be prepared to to really have a deep and uh
  14. um honest relationship with your MN people seem to uh not always um bear in mind that a mentorship is a two-way
  15. process it's not just um a one-way process and um Ian was so easy about it he uh he he was very um open to Bear all
  16. and uh I learned a lot through through areas where he had made mistakes as much as I learned from his greatness I mean
  17. he's one of the world leaders in conservation he's very much the John M of the modern time globally um he saved
  18. the White Rhino from Extinction and yet he has this ability to be incredibly human so I leared a huge amount through
  19. his humanness and uh uh that I think uh tells you a lot about the men MH now what would your advice be I mean Mentor
  20. finding a mentor seems to be sort of some of the top advice that is given to I mean young people or really anyone
  21. today in terms of getting getting the career you want or moving forward with the career that you want I mean what
  22. would your advice be to people in terms of finding the right Mentor finding the right match and just seeking out people
  23. who maybe you would like to Mentor you well first of all all the programs that I've started and begun I encourage the
  24. mentorship uh in all the programs that we have I don't think you can ever be too young or too old uh to have the
  25. mentorship I think we should see it as a a value added and as a huge positive and
  26. and a plus there's just absolutely no negativity in it at all um so what I would advise with finding a mentor is
  27. you really want someone who you uh have respectful uh that's important it's critical that there's a natural respect
  28. between the mentor and and the mentee trust is is earned you don't necessarily know immediately whether that trust
  29. relationship would be there but I think if you respect the individual it's it's fairly natural that trust will follow um
  30. and really the uh the chemistry that exists between the two really creates the depth of the mentorship and the
  31. impact that it will have mentors need to have the time uh it is a commitment uh it's not just something you can commit
  32. to easily you you need to have um a fairly descriptive um understanding between the two parties of what the the
  33. process will be what your goals are going to be how often you're going to meet and then before you begin the
  34. mentorship both parties need to agree to the the commitment the whole um facet of
  35. mentorship it's not a onewe process I would encourage at least a year commitment by both parties and then it
  36. can only be a positive um often life changing event now um getting back to the Wilderness Foundation what has been the
  37. philosophy I mean the group's the mission has really evolved over the years to you know going from
  38. conservation and expanding to include initiatives related to Youth and education programs and leadership
  39. programs I me what is the philosophy behind expanding the mission and how do you see all of these things as kind of
  40. fitting together what are the kind of the through lines that connect everything well I you know I just don't
  41. believe in the modern world that you can do a conservation uh particularly in Africa without taking into account all
  42. the aspects that are affecting Society at the time um environment is very about very much about people and environment
  43. is very much about the human impact on environmental issues so if you don't embrace your neighbors to the parks if
  44. you don't embrace your leaders of the future if you don't if you don't create custodian ship and ambassadors for the
  45. parks for wildlife for Rhino for whatever it is you're trying to protect as a so-called game Ranger how do you
  46. expect that one's going to protect these natural resources into the future so that's very much the
  47. philosopher uh the philosophy behind the Wilderness Foundation that we have to be
  48. about environment and people we need to bring the people element in in order to create custodians and ambassadors for
  49. the future so we need to create programs which are geared at the various interests and affected parties and
  50. groups that would would enable them to have the best possible understanding and impact with the environment that then
  51. would lead back to to what they do whether they're Farmers whether they Community people living on the outside
  52. of these reserves whether they are politicians or AC or academics the programs need to be Geared for the
  53. target market that you are talking to but our belief is that it really is uh this view of reach ing out to different
  54. leadership groups leaders are within your communities leaders are within your academics leaders are within your media
  55. your business your political and that is what we do we create programs that reach
  56. out to all these different Target groups that will give them a personal and direct experience with nature that is
  57. relevant to where they come from or what they do that they can then apply back into whatever business or um or work
  58. that they are involved in that's how we create a future I believe for the environment on this planet there's no
  59. point me talking to the converted that's easy it's easy for me to talk in front of a bunch of Greenies we can you have a
  60. good whiskey afterwards and we can all talk the same it's another thing trying to talk to a group that AR quite short
  61. about this environmental thing and about these issues that are facing us uh not just as a as a human species but also as
  62. a planet as a whole now how does your organization how do you identify and strategize for the
  63. different projects you take on and then what kind of measures do you use to determine whether something is to
  64. measure success that's that's a good question and and I think again one always needs
  65. to with these kind of questions understand and the context and the working environment So within South
  66. Africa it's a very Dynamic moving um um picture we have huge Social Challenges such as HIV AIDS and so obviously the
  67. first template with the planning is is we all develop programs around the current issues facing the country
  68. because that's where you're going to get attraction and that's where you're going
  69. to get support partnership funding and hopefully where where people will then take these programs seriously because
  70. they can be fairly easily mainstreamed um so that immediately means that your planning process uh uh has to be fairly
  71. dynamic because these issues are evolving the whole time um and uh and and yet fairly generic as well uh
  72. because obviously we talking to different Target markets and groups the whole time around these various issues
  73. so if we take HIV AIDS as a example um AIDS affects everything uh uh from a conservation perspective uh 3% of our
  74. work force uh in conservation areas in our country die each year due to AIDS so you can imagine if it takes five years
  75. to train a ranger uh uh in one year we could lose as a country a substantial portion of that Workforce in terms of
  76. the training and investment made in it never mind the social impact and the devastation that uh that causes on on
  77. the ground in the communities and where those people work so clearly any impact we can have to a reduce the number of
  78. people being affected uh with AIDS any impact we can have in reducing the number of people that die and any impact
  79. that we can have in making the communities far more aware of all these processes coming in only makes
  80. conservation better off but also gives them a perspective that we care because we do and therefore we don't just care
  81. about the wildlife we don't just care about our natural resources but we care about all living things and and this is
  82. the messages that we try and give So within the strategic planning it's really a holistic approach and it's
  83. really about developing programs that have a meaningful impact on the ground there's no point developing a program
  84. that looks great at a university or great in a book or on a paper we have to test it and we need to Benchmark it
  85. against the realities of the situations that we're dealing with and can you recall a time when an indiv when an
  86. initiative didn't work well or wasn't working out well and what did you take away from that or how did you kind of
  87. pivot and restructure it to work differently well I I I um I remember back in uh
  88. 19095 um our country was just moving uh uh into democracy we had just had our our elections we just had the new
  89. government in power but one of the challenges that we had was that uh Believe It or Not
  90. 92% of the population of the country at that time had never been into a park a reserve into a
  91. natural area now that's very hard to believe when you're talking about a country of South Africa that is endowed
  92. with natural beauty but that was one of the legacies of aparte there was a piece
  93. of legislation which pres which prevented black South Africans from experiencing large parts of of the
  94. country um and so we immediately had this Legacy issue to deal with and so one of the programs that we started was
  95. a program that would take um young people up the mountains of you know Table Mountain and into these
  96. natural areas so all almost create um black hiking clubs on a mass-based uh uh um process to get as many people safely
  97. in and out of of these natural areas um that was the idea I had two challenges first of all to raise and find a way to
  98. get the funding for these kind of programs and then the second challenge was was how to do it the mistake I made
  99. was that when we designed the program we thought well I'll just find a whole lot
  100. of Environmental Education officers uh and they would take these uh young people into the mountain where I made
  101. the mistake was that that that I was dealing still with the legacy of aparte and a lot of these black youth did not
  102. want to go with white men or white women uh who were the trained environmental Ed
  103. education officers so I then had to change the whole thinking and planning around the program and the solution that
  104. we found is we created a volunteer youth leadership program where we trained youth leaders from the very townships to
  105. be the guides we actually gave them guide training we taught them how to guide and then we made the program their
  106. program and they then guided tens of thousands of Youth over the years up Table Mountain in this instance so it's
  107. it's a program that still operates still works but is led by black youth volunteers for black youth from the
  108. townships very strong mentorship very strong you can just imagine that the teaching and the impact
  109. is so powerful because the youth can identify with the teachers and the medium so there's an example of a
  110. problem and and hopefully a solution which has worked now how has I mean how have like issues related to apartheid I
  111. mean how has that the way that they have impacted various programs that you do I
  112. mean how has that evolved over the years like I mean obviously they haven't gone
  113. it hasn't gone away but I would think that you know as you so the time the time goes on that it
  114. sort of evolves in the way that it impacts the country and impacts individual people and individual
  115. programs so I mean have you have you seen that or yeah I think I think you know it's really um related
  116. to uh this um the people being able to really see the program for what it is or see
  117. the impact that you're trying to give for what it is see the the genu of what it is that you're trying to do um and
  118. and and then bind into to that I mean I think to use a analogy I mean in in America you know the it's quite obvious
  119. that the Civil War although it was you know a long long long time ago there's still exactly residual um aparte that
  120. residual would be around for generations and generations to come and rightly so and you know we must never forget what
  121. happened never ever and so we need to have that but at the same time we need to develop programs that people can see
  122. that they are genuine they can impact on them they can be part of them they see it for what it is is when you hide
  123. things or when you try and uh create programs without communicating what it is that you're trying to achieve that's
  124. when I think some of of the legacies of the Past come on why are you hiding this
  125. why are you not telling us the whole thing why are you why are you keeping this or keeping that so it's just being
  126. transparent uh in what you do and people see that and they accept that I think also in the South African story um there
  127. are now millions and millions of young South Africans who we call the born frees including my two children they
  128. were born in a area where there was no aparte they were born post uh post 94 um and um Millions um I think about six
  129. million of them will have the opportunity to now vote for the first time V vote as the first population
  130. group or or group that can vote in a time when when they weren't born in apartheid and I think that's going to
  131. have a very powerful Dynamic on the future so we are talking to more educated people that are more aware um
  132. and I think it's really about transparency about being open uh and about ensuring that they buy into the
  133. process and now I mean Africa as a continent is really I mean and then South Africa certainly as a country I
  134. mean is undergoing a really a period of you know dramatic growth and economic development I mean what types of
  135. opportunities do you feel like that presents both for the region and for the Wilderness Foundation but also I mean
  136. what about the challenges related to that well the yeah I mean with every opportunity of course there are the
  137. challenges so I mean I think I think the opportunities are immense the the opportunity in oil and gas um
  138. exploration I think some of the greatest uh um gas and oil fields in the last decade have been found uh in and around
  139. Africa uh uh the mineral um and natural resource opportunity is huge uh the it uh uh um and mobile Community
  140. applications is equally um massive industry that's growing um the networking opportunities so those are
  141. all the positives I mean I think Africa's had a average economic growth of five% in the last uh 10 years I mean
  142. you know those are all very impressive numbers the problem is that that uh that we still have a very high level of um
  143. educational challenges throughout Africa we still have high levels of poverty and
  144. Unemployment uh we still uh have issues with that natural resource exploration it's you know uh uh we need to make sure
  145. that the policies and the laws and the rule of law is adhered to in terms of environmental legislation and ensuring
  146. that that exper operation happens in a in as sustainable way as one can have so I think we must not make the mistakes
  147. that if I may say countries like China have made where they've got huge uh environmental and ecological issues that
  148. they're only now beginning to to address um and we must not as Africa make that same mistake where we go so fast in our
  149. economic growth that we forget yet to do what is right by the environment at the
  150. same time as um as as as find the uh economic opportunities for employment and growth so the role of the Wilderness
  151. Foundation U as a africa-wide NGO is really to to be that voice hopefully of reason to really help to guide the
  152. governments to guide companies and corporates and to to build up a um a core of people who have that
  153. environmental un understanding and that can help to apply that as we keep going through this um this area of of
  154. tremendous growth and opportunity for Africa we must remember that climate change and global warming uh it's going
  155. to and is probably going to affect Africa um probably one of the worst of all the continents and so that all also
  156. needs to be be born in mind as we're going through this huge opport this huge period of growth so the role of civil
  157. society is critical in the future Democratic process of Africa as a whole and also in terms of the future of
  158. Africa as a positive turnaround um story we need Civil Society to be strong on all the those
  159. areas of human rights of poverty alleviation of environmental concern of sustainable practice that needs to come
  160. into the picture more and more and it's through the international pressure hopefully that
  161. that will happen and now getting back to um leadership questions I mean what has
  162. been your toughest leadership challenge and how have you solved it um well I need to look I think I think we you you
  163. are a leader because you're there to deal with the tough issues uh uh you know the easy stuff tends to get handled
  164. by other people you get the tough questions and the challenges I think a large uh portion of of leadership is
  165. dealing with people and sort of human resource related issues uh particularly in NOS where we don't have the luxuries
  166. of of having dedicated HR directors and and support the chief Executives often plays plays um a large role within the
  167. non-govermental field in those kind of issues but also you deal with a lot of the risk um you deal with a lot of the
  168. financial pressures and the and the uh opportunities I guess the the um the toughest decisions I've had
  169. to take as a CEO is is see the landscape of our country changing um uh realize that social and environmental issues
  170. cannot be separated realize that historically I've inherited a conservation organization not a social
  171. organization realized to have a future for this organization I need to embed strong social philosophy and programs in
  172. the organization and then convince everyone around me that this is the right thing to do and then lead the way
  173. in implementing it not not hard at all no just a day's work right and what would your advice be
  174. to somebody who a young person or anybody that really wants to enter this field um it's a wonderful field to enter
  175. Because really what you are entering is is really really um uh part of of of I think the most noble cause that you can
  176. be working for and that is for for a holistic approach to our planet Earth um to to Really ensure that that within all
  177. the challenges that our society and that uh businesses have going forward that a
  178. voice and advocacy and a sort of um strong proactive um approach to environmental social and the interface
  179. between the two with a business it's an exciting field to be part of of that and
  180. to really be an ambassador for that but one needs to be holistic one needs to be
  181. open one can't be closed one has to be able to communicate and and be able to embrace and be able to take on the
  182. things that perhaps you don't like and and you don't like to hear but you've got to think of the greater good and I
  183. mean I think our job right now is is we are at a period of our history as humankind where where we under great
  184. threat and the threat that we under is of our own making we are one of 13 million odd species that make up the
  185. Earth uh and yet uh in the past 150 years the impact that we've had on those other 13 million species is such that
  186. within the next 40 years 20% of them could be extinct and but the question we need to ask is if that does happen and
  187. there's a strong likelihood that it is going to happen what does that mean for us what does it mean when those species
  188. that we rely on in ways that we can't even quantify now when a fifth of them no longer exist because that is
  189. biodiversity that is our life support system so when the fifth of that life support system no longer exists what
  190. does that mean for us and I would like to see that as a positive challenge for people entering this field is to find
  191. ways to get people to understand and start doing something about it no Andrew thanks so much for being with us today
  192. great thank you very [Music] much

Brief Summary

Andrew Mure discusses mentorship and the Wilderness Foundation's approach to conservation and social issues in Africa.

Key points

  • The Power of Mentorship. Andrew Mure shares insights on the importance of mentorship in personal and professional growth.
  • Conservation and Community. Andrew discusses the Wilderness Foundation's mission to connect conservation with social issues.
  • Challenges of Leadership. Andrew reflects on the toughest decisions he faced as a CEO in conservation.
  • The Noble Cause of Advocacy. Entering the field of environmental advocacy is a noble cause for our planet.
  • The Threat of Extinction. 20% of species could be extinct in the next 40 years, raising critical questions.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes