Putting Markets to Work for Profit and Global Good

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In The Power of Impact Investing: Putting Markets to Work for Profit and Global Good, Rockefeller Foundation president Judith Rodin and co-author Margot Brandenburg say that impact investing offers investors a way to meet both their financial and social or environmental goals simultaneously.

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/U9ts8l 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello my name is Jacob gray and I'm the senior director of the Wharton social impact initiative and I'm happy actually
  2. delighted to be here with dr. Judith Roden who is the president of the Rockefeller Foundation and a past
  3. president of the University of Pennsylvania and we're here to talk about her book the power of impact
  4. investing which was co-authored with Margo Brandenburg so welcome dr. you I know a lot of people have heard the term
  5. impact investing not everyone knows what it means so just from a high level to start out can you can you sketch out for
  6. us what impact investing is right it's the intention to produce both the social or environmental and a financial return
  7. so it's a conscious investment that really looks for a double bottom line okay so in the book you talk about
  8. impact investing as existing on this continuum with traditional grant making over here and traditional financial
  9. investing over here and so my question is our impact investors people who are coming at this from more the
  10. grant-making perspective and they're trying to find new ways to do good or are they coming from the traditional
  11. finance perspective trying to make their capital work harder as the field started
  12. to develop it was either people who were investing philanthropically through grants through Family Foundation's or
  13. other kinds of grant making who were looking for ways to develop further flows of capital where they could use
  14. their grant making potentially to help bring in another kind of investor sometimes by deep risking the investment
  15. of being that first year of concessionary financing and then allowing another investor to come in and
  16. they found that that helped to build the field and build that capacity and in fact the term impact investing was
  17. developed at the Rockefeller Bellagio conference center in 2007 when we convened a group of investors to talk
  18. about what they had learned working in the space interestingly Jacob we've been working more recently around the world
  19. rather than just in Europe and North America and what we are finding is the Gateway in Asia the
  20. Gateway in Latin America and I think in Africa too is from the financial investor who is becoming more socially
  21. responsible in his or her own country okay and really is starting to think well I know how to do the financial and
  22. maybe I can put that money to work for social purpose okay all right that's really interesting so it's a different
  23. angle so you know in the in the book you cite the example of delight the the solar technology company which I think
  24. is a really accessible example of a social impact enterprise in other words an enterprise in which impact investors
  25. put their money can you talk a little bit more about how that company works somehow its what its social theory of
  26. change is um its theory of change is that electricity poverty is one of the root causes of poverty globally really
  27. so people who have no source of lighting that is reliable they tend to use kerosene or they can't have any lighting
  28. at night or they burn wood and that's environmentally unsustainable and so how do we get either solar or other battery
  29. light that doesn't come from solar but some way to really allow these people often in very remote areas of the world
  30. to have access to lighting and they started as a very small almost flashlight model idea yeah and then we
  31. ran a competition for them because they wanted to know could they scale their technology to light a whole room with
  32. the kind of technology that they already had and we're at a global competition through InnoCentive which is a platform
  33. that has inventors from around the world registered and they compete to win a prize and the winner was somebody in
  34. China and they helped them to develop the technology that allows that to light a room so that allowed them to go to
  35. scale and then impact investors started coming and now they are a phenomenal example so
  36. that's one example that is where there's direct investment into a social enterprise and that's wonderful for some
  37. kind of impact investors and we give a lot of those examples in a book I mean people who want to touch and feel the
  38. enterprise yes they want to help them they have they are themselves wealthy enough they have sources of capital but
  39. they really want to engage with the enterprise and they want to see and feel the outcome of the work yeah but not
  40. every impact investor is like that some impact investors really have very strong
  41. views about social purpose but some feel that they don't have the time or the experience or the energy frankly to
  42. engage that deeply with the enterprise itself and so there's grown just as there is in the financial only industry
  43. funds that are investing in these social enterprises that do the social and the financial due diligence and the
  44. investors then invest in the funds sown in capital is a very well-known one now that there are many others great funds
  45. exciting and so they can really use those opportunities to make impact investments but in a traditional
  46. investor way mm-hmm so I have noticed in the field so I was an impact investor for 14 years before I
  47. came to Wharton and over time the field has really professionalized and changed and you know I've noticed in the funds
  48. where as fund managers way back when I started might have been more like the executive director of a nonprofit type
  49. now we're seeing something different we're seeing people who come I mean if you can talk a little bit about what
  50. there's the sophistication of the industry now well the reason that that's important is twofold one the
  51. sophistication of the industry is helping it to grow so we have very experienced people now who are
  52. experienced investors doing it but it also is a stamp of approval we're seeing people
  53. leave from Goldman or JPMorgan or you know the traditional investment banks and move into this space in really
  54. interesting ways my favorite group as a group who invented the social impact bond social in social finance UK oh yes
  55. and those are young folks who went the investment banking route then stayed for about eight or twelve years and then
  56. with the leadership of serve on Alcoa and in the UK started social finance and invented this amazing impact investment
  57. instrument different from a fund and different from investing in a social enterprise social impact bonds all over
  58. the world I mean it's been and we we Rockefeller funded bringing it to other places in the world and we're scaling it
  59. in the u.s. that's very exciting yeah I often I was thinking about what you're saying about the stamp of approval from
  60. new people in the field and often I tell students that I would never make it into
  61. this field at this point as I did because I don't have their credentials so talk a little bit more about the
  62. overall scale I mean how big of an industry is this and and why is it what's the promise that's so exciting to
  63. you at the Rockefeller Foundation Rockefeller got interested in this because we are so clear when you look at
  64. the magnitude of philanthropy around the world which is enormous and wonderful and you add to it the magnitude of
  65. development assistance that comes from individual countries such as USAID in the US or differed in the UK and so many
  66. others around the world when you add those together it doesn't get to the trillions of dollars that we're going to
  67. need to solve the social and environmental problems and I mean this really broadly because I call crumbling
  68. infrastructure in the United States a social problem and so it's it's a broad category yeah and we realized that
  69. unless we really catalyze the private sector and private capital we're not going to solve all of the
  70. social problems and that when you bring in private capital you bring in market forces these are what are sort of
  71. philanthropic do-good impulses and we feel that's really important it is wonderful to feel good it is very
  72. important to do good but it is most important to have impact and so it's been a combination in a very interesting
  73. way of unleashing private capital but unleashing market force thinking into this field and it will never replace
  74. philanthropy and grant-making nor should it philanthropic capital is America's risk capital after all it's our tax
  75. advantaged dollars so we ought to be doing the most risky pilots we ought to be taking that most risky tier if we're
  76. doing concessionary financing and we've put in like we put in a with another group of foundations a 50 million dollar
  77. first year about 15 years ago for the Bloomberg administration to build affordable housing because the
  78. commercial banks wouldn't lend for the acquisition and pre-construction costs so we guaranteed the banks the first 50
  79. million of risk and then they put in three hundred and fifty million and the affordable housing started to be built
  80. so there's so many ways that grants and concessionary financing will always be useful but you see in these impact
  81. investors people who are very sophisticated financially and what we did and what we talked about in the book
  82. is that we saw the market failure and why the field wasn't accelerating quickly enough was that a lot of them
  83. said well I know how to do the financial due diligence but I don't know how to do
  84. the social due diligence so what does social impact look like how will I measure it how will I know that I've
  85. succeeded so we at Rockefeller invested in most of the metrics that are currently being used by the field the
  86. impact rating system and the global impact rating system that rates both the performance of the funds and rates the
  87. social impact potential social impact of the social enterprise yeah so I want to I want to get to a
  88. question about the critics of this industry one of them I mean maybe the more pithy ones was Marc Andreessen of
  89. the venture capital firm andreessen horowitz said you know the compared impact investing to a house book
  90. it's neither he said it's neither a great house nor a great boat so pettiness aside is there some sort of
  91. inherent tension between the desire to push toward purpose and and the push towards profit is there any fiduciary
  92. duty risk or pressure that that's in tension here yes so there absolutely is attention and that's why just as I said
  93. we never want to stop grant-making mmm we never want to stop innovative venture capitalists like Marc and Ben from being
  94. a financial only investor yes but this is for that category that says and Marc is a great philanthropist and a friend
  95. of mine and so he is investing making a lot of money and then with his wife Laura giving philanthropically and
  96. that's a wonderful thing to do yes and that's the traditional model so Marc doesn't like when I use the word
  97. traditional but there's lots of people now who really want to be in between are willing to take a somewhat lower rate on
  98. financial return look fixed income is a lower rate right and so it's for its it's never going to be triple digit but
  99. there are double digit impact investing funds for example generation capital which is a pool of public equities that
  100. do alternative energy is turning double-digit returns the Rockefeller endowment has a traditional investment
  101. in them and so there are some but most or not yes and there's a wide and widening pool of investors who are
  102. willing to take fixed income rates in order to have high social return and the impact investment as you know well also
  103. runs along a continuum so there's financial first with social second and vice versa so you can sort of mix the pie in
  104. whatever way meets your both social purpose and investment goals and I think people love that I so I do too and I
  105. particularly perhaps among the younger generations and I wonder if you also see this it but I but we see at least among
  106. Wharton students we see this that impact investing has gone from a sort of oddity
  107. to a really highly respected side pursuit and now to what people see is really a nascent or maybe it's just
  108. proto nascent industry and you know the students are actually paying attention like if they could actually get a job in
  109. this field absolutely and so we see surveys after surveyed JP Morgan and the gin the global impact investors network
  110. that we help to start surveys every year and they have a group of impact investors and so between 13 2013 and
  111. 2014 the amount that was being invested by this group that's being surveyed went
  112. up 19% from about ten point six billion to twelve point seven billion or something in that range so it went up
  113. 19% ninety-one percent of them said that they had met their financial objectives
  114. and 99 percent said that their investment had met their social objectives so we're seeing I think
  115. through the development of networks I think through the development of metrics and sharing data and more performance
  116. data and now coming out from older funds such as those that you worked on and others early in the game are really
  117. bringing more people into the field and young people are so excited about this and you know they see the world in need
  118. of change and they want to touch and feel it and if they can use capital to make that happen in a really
  119. constructive way I think it's very attractive I think so too so just as a closing
  120. question what's next in this field I mean what's going to be the next big jump or the next lever is it a public
  121. policy that needs to be built around it or what yes the next big jump will certainly come
  122. through public policy because right now ERISA requirements for example in the United States and some comparable types
  123. of legislation elsewhere prevent many of the pension funds from taking large positions and impact investing funds
  124. because it doesn't meet the hurdle of the financial return that they need to to address at one point the ERISA
  125. requirements were lower and then Congress raised them again about 20 years ago so as this field matures and
  126. as government starts to see that maybe it can attract this kind of capital as the UK government saw in the development
  127. of the social impact bond which is really getting a private investor to pay for a public program like recidivism or
  128. health or whatever then I think public policy around all of this will change and that will have an absolutely
  129. accelerating effect on the field because it will unleash significant amounts of potential capital catalytic I think yeah
  130. so dr. Ruden thank you so much for taking time out of your busy schedule to come back to campus and join us for this
  131. interview and thank you so much so it's great to be here thank you Jacob you

Brief Summary

Dr. Judith Rodin discusses impact investing's evolution, challenges, and its role in addressing global social issues with Jacob Gray.

Key points

  • The Power of Impact Investing. Impact investing aims to produce both social and financial returns, creating a double bottom line.
  • Electricity Poverty and Social Change. A solar technology company addresses electricity poverty as a root cause of global poverty.
  • Young Generations Embrace Impact Investing. Younger generations are increasingly interested in impact investing as a viable career path.
  • Future of Impact Investing. Public policy changes could significantly accelerate the growth of the impact investing field.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes