How Impact Investing Can Change the World

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. thank you for joining us my name is Stephanie Kim and I'm the associate director of community strategy at the
  2. Wharton social impact initiative and I'm very excited to welcome our guest today
  3. lisel pritzker Simmons whorton social impact initiative's 2015 nazarian social innovator and residence the Angela and
  4. David nerian social innovators and residence program host leaders who leverage business-based solutions to
  5. solve economic and social challenges in communities around the globe leel is a co-founder and principal of Blue Haven
  6. initiative a family office dedicated to investing for-profit and nonprofit Capital to advance solutions to social
  7. environmental challenges leel thank you for being here thank you it's a pleasure
  8. so you supported wsi's impact investing research this year our report Great Expectations was released at socap last
  9. month and aimed to debunk the expectation that impact investors must always sacrifice Financial returns when
  10. seeking social returns we found no evidence that supports the tradeoff what was your reaction when you heard these
  11. results uh quite frankly I was not surprised I was very pleased to see um sort of the weight that Wharton can
  12. bring and the rigor that they can bring to the research but anecdotally from my own experience as an investor and um and
  13. working with other investors we have not actually seen that tradeoff that I keep
  14. sort of hearing about from um more traditional investers and so um I was I was very pleased that my sort of
  15. anecdotal experience was now um had some some some academic rigor behind it um cuz I think that's
  16. one thing that's been um a real struggle in the impact investing space is uh traditional
  17. investors sort of uh believe this myth that there needs to be a tradeoff sometimes there can be but if you're
  18. seeking commercial returns or market rate returns chances are you can achieve those and also achieve your impact goals
  19. as well awesome well let's talk about Blue Haven initiative with so many options for interventions and impact
  20. areas how did you decide upon your company's investment strategy and portfolio sure so Blue Haven initiative
  21. is the single family office um of me and my husband and um we sort of several years ago had a fairly traditionally
  22. invested um portfolio so was Diversified across asset classes according to a risk
  23. return profile that you know made sense for our family and our sort of capital preservation and growth um uh goals um
  24. but really didn't wasn't paying attention to what the social and environmental impact of those
  25. Investments were and we decided that that was something that we cared a lot about um we care about what our what our
  26. investments are doing in the world uh I don't think that uh Investments are just
  27. neutral I think that um where you put your money and how you invest it makes a difference and so it has an impact and
  28. we really wanted to make sure that impact was a positive one on all three fronts social environmental and
  29. financial and so starting sort of with that premise the real challenge um for us and
  30. for our financial advisers is can we do that with all of the Assets in our portfolio not just to sliver but
  31. actually with everything can we look across asset classes and um find best-in-class managers and strategies
  32. that meet our hurdles socially financially and environmentally um and so starting
  33. though with an asset allocation so again what makes sense for our family and then
  34. just finding managers that are also paying attention to their social and environmental strategies and so we
  35. started um we started with that approach and then populated the asset classes is
  36. uh once we found managers and strategies that that uh we felt proud of great so we have good managers that you can trust
  37. and you know that they're thinking along the same wavelength as you what about the target areas there's poverty there's
  38. hunger there's Health there's you know a million different solar panels there's cook stoves how do you pick what to
  39. invest in so that's a great question and um different investors will give you all
  40. different kinds of answers and and they're all right it all depends on what your approach is for us we decided to
  41. really start with the financial asset classes and be impact agnostic as to what the sector was that that manager
  42. was working in um because for us I think it's very difficult with the size of portfolio that we were dealing with to
  43. say we're going to solve water or we're going to fix women or um or to even set a certain geographic area it would be
  44. very limiting um to really try to find Best in Class managers um so with the majority of our portfolio we really said
  45. we're going to be geographically and uh sector agnostic and really look for diversity um across
  46. the financial instruments and strategies that they're playing with so you end up
  47. with you know you know Green real estate that has a steady yield we've got you know um uh private Equity Funds that you
  48. know obviously have a longer lockup but are focused on financial inclusion um there are some areas that are focused on
  49. health um a lot of uh uh project Finance into renewable energy projects I would say the environment is probably one
  50. theme climate change and environment that um we have a pretty heavy exposure to Across the entire
  51. portfolio um so with the sort of the majority of of of the portfolio we really we want the managers to pick the
  52. area and strategy from the impact standpoint so exposure to impact um really was more opportunistic than
  53. strategic however in our direct Investment Portfolio where we look at um sort of early and growth stage uh
  54. companies and make debt and Equity Investments directly into them there we have a very sort of focused strategy
  55. around Financial inclusion uh and renewable energy in in East Africa particularly so what does it mean to
  56. have a very focused strategy is it just finding a lot of different companies that are doing similar things are you
  57. taking a more systems holistic approach what does it look like what we what we've done with our direct
  58. investment strategy is we started sort of with a premise um we were very interested in um in East Africa as a
  59. geography it's growing pretty quickly and there's a very high penetration of mobile money there which allows a lot of
  60. really interesting technology platforms to be built off of that high penetration
  61. of not just mobile money but mobile phones in general um and the the fact that you've got a pretty large consumer
  62. base um that is extremely comfortable transacting over mobile money the highest penetration in the world you get
  63. lots of interesting companies that are popping up and and using that as a base for different kinds of financial
  64. services platforms um I personally have a background working in micro finance and
  65. so really good financial services for consumers that are um underserved with Good Financial products I have seen
  66. firsthand what kind of a difference that makes being able to have insurance products to cover a funeral of a loved
  67. one can keep a family above the poverty line um in a pretty significant way um being able to access savings accounts
  68. being able to access loans that are appropriate for your business and appropriate for your own cash flow needs
  69. um are uh make a very very big difference in somebody's life and so for me naturally I'm inclined to look at
  70. financial services and then the technology platforms that can help to disintermediate and lower costs for
  71. those consumers um that's an area I have deep passion around and as a financial investor makes a lot of sense you know
  72. I'm not coming into this with a deep background in how to develop wind turbines sure you know but financial
  73. services and products I get I understand um I understand those business models and so um as an investor it makes sense
  74. for me to play there and I think it's an area of sort of Deep Impact so East Africa um is good geography again with
  75. the mobile money um there's very high demand and um we we have seen a lot of innovation happening there right so you
  76. have the asset managers you have the different strategies that they're all choosing to take based on what they see
  77. makes sense for the asset class that they're managing you have a really focused uh F you have a strong focus on
  78. certain interventions that you see working and proven to work and that makes sense based on your interests and
  79. competencies rolling it all back up again to this idea of financial return and desired impact how do you make sure
  80. that happens well we do our very best um to measure and to monitor um and a lot of it is based on intentions so if we're
  81. invested in a certain fund manager that says well we would like to have this kind of mix of Muni bonds that are
  82. working and underserved communities or this kind of mix of corporate bonds that are um uh you know lending to
  83. corporations that have very high ESG standards um then did they meet those targets really um on the on the social
  84. and environmental side and then of course what's happening with the benchmarks that they're that they're um
  85. tracking against and so really did you do what you say you were going to do and for me as an investor did my money
  86. participate in what you said it would participate in um and you know hopefully the answer is yes and so we track
  87. against against those things and it's the same thing with with our with our companies directly as well um one of the
  88. wonderful things about the direct investing and with the companies that we're targeting um we look for companies
  89. where the impact is embedded in their business model so the more they scale the more they grow the deeper our impact
  90. is um and so we tend with those companies to be even less Hands-On on the impact side
  91. because really what those companies need are to be you know operationally totally
  92. streamlined and efficient and grow as sort of as quickly and as rapidly as they can and then you know by default
  93. our impact is is deeper and we're there though if there are if there are decisions that companies make to Pivot
  94. away from the impact we're there to try to help keep them on track but um so far
  95. we haven't found a lot of that and you know at Wharton we love seeing those types of companies where the impact is
  96. baked into the business model it's not a campaign it's not something on the side
  97. and you know the slogan that we've used many times is that business for good is good for business it is and actually
  98. with the um Great Expectations with the Wharton study that came out a lot of that was around preservation of mission
  99. on exit um for those companies and and did managers and and did underlying portfolio companies think that their
  100. mission was compromised upon exit and the answer is no really because if they were to Pivot away from from the impact
  101. piece their Core Business would probably change right and their consumers wouldn't want that right and so it's
  102. that's the thing is that really you really can have those things in alignment um and that's what I think is
  103. so exciting about the space and why I think it's it's growing as quickly as it is so at the end of the day we're all
  104. working towards a similar vision of a world you know without poverty without hunger preventable diseases Etc impact
  105. investing is a growing vehicle to address that but we're still working in a world with a lot of traditional
  106. philanthropic models traditional philanthropy charity how do you think that practice of philanthropy will
  107. evolve as impact investing continues to grow well I think that that I mean as you said there are there are lots of
  108. different kinds of tools um that that people have in their tool belt to try to attack some of these problems and impact
  109. investing is one of them and at Blue Haven so we engage in you know commercial rate return market rate um
  110. impact investing there are foundations that are happy to take concessionary returns um and that's wonderful and
  111. that's needed and then of course there's straight grant money um that you know is
  112. not seeking any kind of financial return but hoping to you know uh expand the environmental and social
  113. return of that capital and I think that all of these tools can play well together um but for me what I think is
  114. exciting about people looking at business models and um sort of financial tools to try to advance some of these
  115. social and environmental goals is it frees up some of that philanthropic Capital to do actual Grant work so
  116. sometimes I think that and and over the years particularly you look at um some of the development Aid models you've had
  117. philanthropic dollars or development dollars that are um being used for something a business would be better to
  118. solve um and it would be more scalable it would be more sustainable and also it would be something that people actually
  119. want people aren't going to buy something that they don't want um and so you've seen a lot of different kinds of
  120. weird products and widgets out there in the market Market that have been developed in you know some Lab in
  121. Cambridge Massachusetts and shipped over to Uganda and actually nobody really wants it or uses it after 6 months well
  122. if people actually have to buy something you know we try to make it as low cost as possible they're going to
  123. tell you really fast the market will tell you whether that is useful to them or not and so anyway I think that that
  124. using business in this way um helps to actually yes save that philanthropic money from being I think not so
  125. strategically dispersed and use it for things that only philanthropic Capital can be good for and I think things like
  126. that are you know disaster relief um Refugee crisis I think a lot of Education hate to I hate to denounce all
  127. of my edtech investor friends but I think I know I think that um a lot of education is still really needs to be
  128. Subs ized um and I mean there's a myriad Arts things that the market way undervalues um Arts music uh are I think
  129. are always going to need that philanthropic capital and hopefully it can impact investors can help to free up
  130. some of that so that it really goes where it needs to go what's next in the impact investing space What are you
  131. excited about what does it need I think what I'm really excited about is starting to see um more and more more um
  132. sort of traditional investment firms and larger Banks um instead of doing impact
  133. investing sort of out of their CSR or marketing departments actually it's sort of moving into products and services and
  134. they are starting to devote internal resources uh to their staff to try to get them up to speed it's not sort of
  135. that cute thing that's happening over in the corner in philanthropy y it's it's starting to move um into the more
  136. mainstream parts of the bank um I think a lot of that has to do with sort of this kind of big Millennial push for it
  137. um you're starting to see more mbas get incredibly excited about it and I think the banks know that and if they're going
  138. to recruit the best talent this generation really wants to see both sort of profit and purpose happening at the
  139. same time their standards are higher um and so uh I get I get very excited about
  140. seeing this sort of going mainstream um and I get really excited about um particularly with family
  141. offices uh not having such a bifurcated approach not having your investment vehicle over here making money and then
  142. you move it over here and you give it away um that seems very inefficient to me so I like having those two sides of
  143. the balance sheet start to come closer together um and that I think is really exciting that is exciting weel thank you
  144. for for being here thank you this was wonderful [Music]

Brief Summary

Lisel Pritzker Simmons discusses impact investing strategies and the integration of social goals with financial returns at Blue Haven Initiative.

Key points

  • Debunking the Tradeoff Myth. Lisel shares insights from the Wharton study, revealing that impact investors need not sacrifice financial returns for social impact.
  • Investment Strategy at Blue Haven. Lisel discusses how Blue Haven Initiative selects investments based on social, environmental, and financial criteria.
  • The Role of Philanthropy. Lisel reflects on how impact investing can free up philanthropic capital for more targeted uses.
  • Exciting Trends in Impact Investing. Lisel expresses enthusiasm for the growing mainstream acceptance of impact investing among traditional firms.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes