The Surprising Link between the Fracking Boom and Republican Power in Congress

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

When a shale boom enriches a region, there is shift by its residents to the Republican Party and they also elect Republicans to office, Wharton research shows. More: http://knlg.net/1UQ33bd πŸ“‚ Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here with Wharton finance professor Eric gilja to talk about one of his research papers which actually
  2. found a link between voter preferences and the shale boom that's really quite timely at this time when the election
  3. seems to be very raucous and very interesting so welcome professor thank you for having me so tell us about your
  4. paper so basically what we try to do is to try to we try to trace out how political change occurs in the US
  5. electoral system and so the basic idea here is there were kind of two sets of hypotheses one is that when voter
  6. preferences shift your elected officials change their positions to adapt to the new preferences the other is when voter
  7. preferences shift they throw out their old elected representative and bring in somebody new and so we kind of test each
  8. of these two hypotheses within the context of shell discoveries so she'll discoveries are interesting place to
  9. look at this because when these discoveries occur there's a large change in voter preferences to become more
  10. conservative and supportive of issues that will help underpin the development of shale and so what we see overall is
  11. that there's a shift in voting for more conservative political candidates Republican candidates and that linked
  12. with this rather than existing Democratic candidates changing their views to adapt that in fact they they
  13. lose their jobs and Republican candidates replace them and so in terms of which of these two hypotheses seem to
  14. dominate it's the case that you basically find a new representative that fits your preferences as opposed to
  15. Europe right your elected representative adapting their preference towards your views which is kind of interesting when
  16. we typically think of politicians is kind of saying whatever they need to say to get elected this evidence would
  17. suggest otherwise so you actually gather data from seven states I understand those are red states some of them are
  18. read some of them are I guess purple you have Pennsylvania West Virginia North Dakota Arkansas oh cool
  19. Louisiana Texas and many of these states actually were maybe not always considered red states certainly prior to
  20. shale discoveries so what are some key takeaways from your paper yeah so I think the key takeaways are this that in
  21. essence you see that that the mechanism through which the political change occurs is through bringing in new
  22. representatives and that that we find several other effects in that when you bring in a new representative you get a
  23. lot of other things with that not just people that help protect shale but also people that may vote differently on
  24. social issues or other issues that are unrelated to shale and then lastly we kind of have a final result in the paper
  25. where we show that even the the Democrats that had adjusted their voting record slightly to become more
  26. conservative still lost their jobs suggesting that maybe they couldn't kind of credibly convey that they had adapted
  27. to the new preferences of their congressional districts I think what really grabbed me about your paper was
  28. your major ah-ha finding which was you know when there's a major big economic positive economic shock to an area that
  29. actually more Democrats become Republicans and can you tell me why that is yeah and so this is one interesting
  30. aspect of the analysis where we're actually able to obtain access to exit poll data and so some people might say
  31. well this result was driven by the change changes in electoral makeup people moving into the area but in fact
  32. through this exit poll data people are asked about their prior political preferences and and we actually show
  33. that people that tended to be self-identify as historically being more liberal shift to become more
  34. conservative when these shell discoveries occur and it's not maybe surprising when you think about the
  35. positions at each of these political parties have tended to have on energy development in shale that you have in
  36. these areas large increases in income large increases in job growth and that basically you know people in these areas
  37. adapt their preferences to try to protect and ensure that this development continues and now that historically the
  38. Republican Party is being more consistent with doing that with energy development so I have to ask this
  39. question and that is so can you think you can handicap the race for us this election year well I think what the
  40. results suggest is not necessarily that that you know let's say one presidential
  41. candidate versus another because the results are really at the congressional district level but they suggest that the
  42. the magnitude of the shift that's occurred that has occurred that's linked to shell discoveries are quite large and
  43. so in our paper we talked about that in aggregate since the beginning of the shale boom 17 Democratic seats have
  44. switched to Republican and that that is in terms of kind of economic magnitudes that's half of the current Republican
  45. majority in Congress so to me what it suggests is that if the Democratic Party does not kind of adapt its views or seek
  46. out these energy voters in a way that they haven't been before that particularly gaining control of the US
  47. House of Representatives will be challenging for them because you know there's a large asset large component of
  48. the majority that the Republicans have that exists due to their preference and support of shale development and so
  49. until that part of the Democratic platform maybe changes or adapts to that aspect of the electoral calculus I think
  50. it will be challenging on at least the house side for Democrats to make significant headway did that come as a
  51. surprise to you the magnitude certainly came as a surprise I think I think we expected to see your some shift towards
  52. Republicans but when you actually trace out the effect on how seats compare that
  53. to the current majority in Congress what ends we were you end up seeing is that this was quite important for the shift
  54. in the US House that we've seen over the last 15 years and and this is linked with both you
  55. oil and shale gas development essentially when we plot this out we see one shift occurs from shale gas
  56. development happens in the mid 2000s and then and then and then another one that
  57. occurs later on in 2010 2011 2012 when shale oil development really gets going whether other thing finding said
  58. surprise to you I think the the last finding that i mentioned that that even those representatives that try to adapt
  59. in altering their voting records work to be more conservative and so for this we
  60. look at different interest groups scoring of congressmen and we find is even those that adapt just a little you
  61. know adapt a little bit are not able to maintain their their seats and so to me that suggests that kind of more
  62. significant more significant steps would need to be taken to kind of demonstrate
  63. that they've adapted to their new voter preferences so what are some practical implications of your findings yeah i
  64. mean i would say in practice what it documents a few things first it shows that there are a lot of spillover
  65. effects into other policy areas when one policy area changes so shift in energy preferences by voters leads to shifts in
  66. other areas social issues tax issues that maybe you know you may not have expected and i would say that's probably
  67. one of the kind of most interesting practical aspects of of it so what sets your research apart from prior work in
  68. this area yeah i would say prior work by and large has not focused on the spillover effects so they've looked at
  69. whether a change in voter preferences can be observed you can observe something in the data to see whether
  70. people actually change their votes one way or another we're showing that because of the electoral system that we
  71. have that having elected representative you kind of you know they have their views and if
  72. you you basically kind of rank how important your views are and you may end up getting some things in there with
  73. that electoral representative that you may not have anticipated and then the other aspect which is new is to show
  74. that even those who do shift more to the right it doesn't seem to matter for voters that much and so it's either a
  75. question of credibility they can't incredibly shift or a question of the the nature of the party structure that
  76. even if they do shift the rest of the party which is going to manage you know bills in the seniority system and
  77. committees may not be conducive to advancing the voter preferences that have now changed in these districts how
  78. are you going to follow up your research well there are a couple different avenues we're exploring so one avenue
  79. would be to look at what are the sorts of people that seem more apt to shift their preferences their particular
  80. characteristics or demographics there another is to look at how this political change spills over and affects firms and
  81. so you might imagine that firms are working to build political relationships to get favors of some sort or
  82. preferences of some sort in different aspects of government whether it's regulation or laws and now you have a
  83. shift that's occurred because of these the energy issue and so you might expect that some firms are not going to be more
  84. out of favor because they were connected to politicians that lost their seats some other firms may be more in favor
  85. because now they've they're connected to politicians that are in power thank you
  86. very much thank you you

Brief Summary

Eric Gilja discusses how shale discoveries shift voter preferences from Democrats to Republicans, impacting US elections.

Key points

  • Shale Boom's Political Impact. Research shows a shift in voter preferences towards more conservative candidates linked to shale discoveries.
  • Democrats to Republicans Shift. The study reveals that economic shocks lead to a significant shift of Democrats to Republican support.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes