Cutting the Fiscal Cliff Down to Size
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Mark Duggan, Faculty Director of the Wharton Public Policy Initiative and a Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy at Wharton, discusses the impact of the "Fiscal Cliff" on the country's near term future.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] we're meeting today with Mark Dugen who is a professor of business economics and
- uh public policy at Wharton and we're going to talk about the public policy implications of Obama's victory in the
- presidential election thanks for joining us today thanks for having me um the debt and budget considerations are the
- number one uh issue after the election uh all the talk is about the fiscal cliff could you explain what that Cliff
- is all about and what the options are for dealing with it sure uh so there are several things essentially uh on January
- 1st 2013 that will happen uh both in terms of taxes increasing in a number number of different ways and spending uh
- being reduced in a number of different ways uh just at a at a high level the size of the US economy plus or minus is
- about 15.5 trillion dollars is our GDP and on a calendar year basis this fiscal cliff amounts to about 750 plus uh
- billion dollars so 5% about 5.1% of GDP uh in terms of increased taxes and lower
- spending on an annual basis when we move into 2013 so that is a huge change a huge jolt to the economy in the sense
- that immediately people are going to see more taxes being taken out of their paycheck and we're going to see less
- spending on things like defense Medicare and various discretionary programs and it that and and and that will be a huge
- change for the economy that's baked in unless we change something baked in unless we change if policy makers do
- nothing for the next two months then starting on January 1st 2013 we will go over the so called fiscal cliff and with
- uh tax increases and spending reductions that add up to more than $750 billion over the course of calendar year 2013 so
- that is a huge huge huge change uh in sort of tax and spending policy and as a result uh especially given the economic
- recovery is somewhat fragile uh I think policy makers are kind of scrambling to try to figure out what to do
- and uh and it's going to be an interesting negotiation between the two sides well there's not much time left
- and interestingly it's the same cast of characters that's been around even though many of them will be leaving when
- we get into January but between now and January 1st it's the same cast of characters what do you think is likely
- to happen so I think that there are certain parts so if you look at the fiscal cliff if you sort of aggregate up
- the different things the increases in income tax rates the increases in dividend taxes capital gains taxes the
- increase in payroll taxes reductions in defense spending and so forth um there are a couple of components that seem
- very unlikely to be renewed which is to say parts of the fiscal cliff that will happen so the first being uh a reduction
- in the payroll tax so right now over the course of the 2012 calendar year payroll
- tax rates have been two percentage points lower than they typically are so that if you're a worker let's say
- earning $50,000 a year you've paid ,000 Less in Social Security payroll taxes in
- 2012 then you would have absent this change so if your salary stays the same in 2013 when we go into 2013 your taxes
- your your basically take-home pay will fall mechanically by $1,000 they're going to let that expire I think all
- indications are they will let that expire it's very expensive I mean that's over hundred billion dollar and you know
- we would like uh so I think that is one that's uh uh very unlikely to be extended second one is uh emergency
- unemployment insurance benefits so basically in a typical economy unemployment insurance provides benefits
- for up to 26 weeks uh and if a person doesn't find a job within 26 weeks unemployment insurance benefits are
- exhausted during this recent economic downturn the federal government intervened in many ways to extend that
- maximum duration as high as 99 weeks and that's gradually been coming back and it's going to come back further still
- and so I and that cost a lot of money and that is not going to be extended I think all indications are so those are
- sort of two things that we think that I think are it's pretty plausible that those are parts of the cliff parts of
- that $750 billion that I talked about that are going to take effect um a payroll
- tax return to its initial L it's not like an Inc it's basically it was temporarily lowered so it's going to go
- back to where it's basically always been for the last two 25 years um and unemployment insurance same deal it's
- going to get back uh closer to what it has historically been uh on the other things it's somewhat harder to predict
- so income tax rates are set to increase pretty much across the board uh the 10% marginal tax rate people for at these
- are would affect lower income folks that's set to increase to 15 percentage points that's a pretty big increase and
- that's you know that's going to affect many lower income workers middle- inome workers it affects essentially anyone
- because people pay that on their first uh let's say uh uh about $9,000 in taxable income even higher up up when
- we're talking about let's say $400,000 a year type folks uh those rates are set to increase from 35 to 39.6% and if
- there's one thing that is going to be sort of a defining uh issue here it's going to be do we uh allow do we extend
- tax cuts for let's say lower and middle- inome workers and let them expire for high income workers so these Cuts uh
- that uh George W bush put basically uh and and uh uh the their the so-called 2001 Bush tax cuts uh basically lowered
- the tax rate from 39.6 to 35 on high on the highest income group um and that is set to return back to 39.6 so will that
- uh the I think is that going to go back to 39.6 will they extend that to 35 that's going to be a huge issue I think
- both sides would be very very happy to keep those rates at lower levels uh for lower income and middle inome folks I
- think the big point of debate is at for people let's say 250,000 a year and above should we rate allow those rates
- to go back up to start to make more of a dent in the deficit so uh you know I've
- sort of highlighted some other things I mean on the estate tax that's going to be a huge issue right now if you pass
- away and your estate is worth less than $5 million no taxes will be paid on it whereas effective 2013 if it's it that
- that threshold Falls from 5 million to a million and on top of that the tax rate
- increase increases so dividends and capital gains tax is also set to increase it is going to be a very
- interesting negotiation if policy makers do nothing so you know we've heard all this talk about sort of what is the
- right mix of tax cuts and or tax increases and spending cuts if we're going to do something about the
- deficit and the changes that are set to go effect have more than $3 in tax increases for every dollar in spending
- reductions because the spending reductions are you know non-trivial but they're the vast majority of the $750
- billion dollar is coming through higher tax taxes so it is uh it'll be interesting I think that it's very hard
- to predict right now I think you know if you wanted to play it safe and predict that of the 750 billion they'll avert
- approximately half somewhere between a third and twoth thirds of that that seems like a plausible number how they
- will do that the devil will certainly be in the details yeah in Europe we've seen
- that uh Cuts in government spending appear to have made the public debt worse uh there's been a lot of austerity
- um that's resulted in uh slowing down the economy and at the same time it increases spending for safety net issues
- so it seems to be having exactly the opposite effect U of what was intended and this has been going on for a couple
- years now do you agree that's the case and and how would the US avoid getting caught in such a trap it's an extremely
- delicate trade-off that policy makers now have to face and I wish that I could have great confidence that they're
- optimally making this trade-off given the best available evidence but that's not always how policymaking works
- unfortunately um uh the uh so I think the figuring out so right now the federal government for every $3 it
- spends it borrows one and that is a big deficit and I think most agree that in the long run we want to get that deficit
- down at when do we start trying to make a dent in that that's sort of the critical question how do you start to
- make progress on reducing the deficit uh in such a way that you don't basically prevent the economy from getting sort of
- escape velocity from this current sort of not great situation that we're in so we've had some pretty good job growth
- over the last two or three months indications are that you know the economy may be starting to do better it
- would be highly unfortunate if let's say we went over this fiscal cliff and then
- went into a recession as a result which is totally plausible so I think is of that 750 billion I don't I wouldn't
- personally I wouldn't say the right number is zero which is to say I don't think that we should do nothing when we
- cross this fiscal cliff uh but I think the concern about doing the full 750 is that it will uh and remember that the
- number that you hear a lot in the Press is the 607 billion from the Congressional budget office that's a
- fiscal year number if you look at on a calendar year basis it's higher it's in this sort of$ 750 plus billion dollar
- range so it's bigger it's even bigger than it has has been being build in in in the Press uh and so uh is where
- between 0 and 750 is is the right number that is that's the critical question and
- I think 750 would pose a lot of problems for the economy but I do think there's value and starting to make a dent in
- this deficit and so those two things that I described the payroll tax letting it return to its previous level the
- unemployment insurance benefits letting those uh those uh emergency benefits uh expire uh that would now It's Tricky
- there's trade there's nothing's free here so whenever you raise taxes or you lower spending that there I me the
- people are affected by that so that's a real some you know something it's not just numbers it's something to think
- hard about it's 150 billion that's about a fifth of the uh fiscal cliff I think that is going to go
- ahead um how much further is you know at some level that what we're talking about
- right now is changing the the sort of parameters within the existing tax code I think what many economists and other
- experts hope is that sometime very soon policy makers will get together to try to make ra make design a tax system that
- makes somewhat more sense that is more progrowth okay and and do things to reform entitlement programs to get the
- country on a better longrun fiscal trajectory so I think in the short run we should be very careful that we don't
- sort of stop the you know sort of slowish recovery but it seems to be it seems like we're doing we're getting
- some recovery stop it in its tracks because as you say if the if we go into a recession that can have uh pretty
- negative effects on the budget uh thereafter so it's uh it it my hope is that instead of tweaking within the
- existing tax code and tweaking within existing entitlement programs they try to do something that puts the country on
- a better trajectory so um if nothing happens there would be uh a 750 billion dollar combination of tax
- cuts or or I'm sorry of tax increases spending cuts or or tax increases um you're suggesting that who really knows
- but maybe the compromise may come down somewhere in the middle yeah how much of a dent does that make in the deficit or
- or or or the or in the budget for the year so if you think so in terms of our our deficit is uh uh for this past year
- for fiscal year 2012 was essentially 1.1 trillion which is let's say 1,00 billion okay that deficit would fall by
- from 2012 to 2014 I'm not going to use the 2013 number because the the numbers are fiscal year so 2014 would be the
- first full fiscal year that it would be post the fiscal cliff you would see deficit the deficit decline by about
- 2/3 um uh over that period if we went over this fiscal cliff so it's a bit it makes a giant dent and it I think even
- if it kicked the economy into a recession it would still lower the deficit somewhat the question I mean it
- would but it wouldn't lower it clearly as much if it if it hampered economic growth a lot and and caused us to go
- into a recession so but it's it's real money I mean it's it's $1.1 trillion where's our current debt debt held by
- the public is about 11 trillion if you take gross debt which includes let's say what the government owes like basically
- social security has trust fund the Social Security program has a trust fund that has holds a lot of US federal debt
- so like two and a half three trillion dollar of the current debt of the 16 trillion debt is held by the Social
- Security program so 16 trillion is Big what we're talking about is you know 750 billion but that's not nothing I mean
- that's 20% I mean that's 5% of the uh of the overall gross debt so a move of that
- in that deficit on a Pere basis is a pretty big deal okay uh the other big issue big issue in the campaign of
- course was Unemployment uh you mentioned the numbers have been improving somewhat
- over the last couple of months job growth 170,000 or so this this latest number um which is a little bit better
- than just keeping up with population growth right um but even if that number were to continue if that froze at that
- number and we increase it by that amount every month for the next many months it
- would take many many years to get uh unemployment rates down to the level that they were at before the financial
- crisis oh absolutely so what what do you see happening with unemployment what are
- what are their programs uh what's most likely through these compromises to help um bring it down so I think you know to
- the extent that there are big policy changes on the tax side or on the spending side the hope that I have and I
- think most uh who who study this have is that they're going to do things in a program growth way that are going to
- enhance economic growth and enhance job creation I mean our tax code is a just a
- there are a lot of well-intentioned policies sort of packed into our tax code but in the aggregate it's a
- complete mess and so doing something to try to rationalize that thing so that we
- stimulate investment by companies so that we encourage people to work uh that I think can have desirable effects on
- employment growth and 170,000 a month is good it is better than certainly uh uh uh it's some it's a little better than
- keeping up with population growth but basically right now if you look at the employment to population ratio in the US
- we're about four to five percentage points below where we were before this this thing started and that's millions
- and millions of people so if you think about you know 170,000 a month just to do population you've got need about 125
- so you're talking about 45,000 extra a month half million a year that's going to take a long time for us to get to
- where we want to be so I think it's going to be very important for government for policy makers to um put
- in place policies and this isn't just on the tax and spending side this is on all
- kinds of levels trade policy energy policy Health Care policy housing policy and so forth do thing Financial
- regulatory reform do things in such a way that we're enhancing economic growth enhancing job creation because as a as
- the economy grows the deficit becomes less and less of a problem because mechanically you've got more people
- generating tax revenue fewer people going on to government programs because they need help and it just you know the
- problem can can to some extent take care of itself but 170,000 a month is just not going to it's not going to do it so
- the real answer is to grow our way out of it and that's that's the big conundrum how do actually do that that's
- right exactly and and and I think though that there are it is uh and it's hard I
- mean there it it is uh we're not we don't have the luxury of having a lot of sort of uh uh uh you know we we have now
- run these big deficits uh we don't have the luxury of being able to spend a few hundred billion more dollars to do this
- or that uh uh effort this or that tax cut if anything will be going in the opposite direction so figuring out I
- think it's an extremely difficult problem figuring out how do you design a package of policies that simultaneously
- reduce the deficit which is either you're increasing taxes or you're lowering spending or some combination
- and you're enhancing job creation so that is an extremely difficult thing to do simultaneously and uh I think it is I
- My Hope Is that it's going to require a better sort of policymaking process than
- we've seen in recent years I mean it is uh it is the environment is unfortunately dominated by the sort of
- it it's just it's not been conducive to uh e economic policies that are in the country's long run interests and I just
- really hope that policy makers can sort of you know really work together in such
- a way that they uh put the country on a better fiscal trajectory because you know there are a lot of I mean it's it
- and I think all these people work in DC I've spent a little bit of time working in DC they all I think uh you know for
- the most part maybe not every single one but they uh the vast vast majority of them are are well-meaning very smart and
- everything else but the process as a whole and the aggregate you take the way this process works and it's a just a
- disaster for the country if it keeps doing going the way it has so I hope they can work together and it there's
- going to be compromises and there will be uh and and it is you know I think the country needs to come together because
- the challenges we Face are so so massive and uh uh uh and you know stimulating job creation I think trade policy uh has
- some potential for doing that because to the extent that we can do a better job of uh uh uh opening up markets abroad
- and increasing their demand for our products that will uh that will raise exports and that can raise employment
- hard thing here is though the rest of the the rest of the world economically right now is struggling you see Europe
- even China slowing down and elsewhere so it's going to be uh that it is that's a
- challenge but on energy policy I think there are a lot of opportunities for us to do things that can stimulate job
- creation there so you know we sort of think about what is it going to be the thing that gets us to to improve the
- trajectory that's going to sort of be a GameChanger to economic growth and you know many people think that maybe the
- energy sector is an area that can really uh uh be a source of both good employment growth and helping us to uh
- reduce our dependence on foreign uh petroleum and so forth could you just give a little bit more detail about that
- energy sector that there's hope for in in your view so I mean I think you know there's we have uh the
- us we've uh seen in recent months years that uh the US has a very large amount of natural gas reserves and so there's
- some question about whether we should be doing more to try to harness to uh put that to use it certainly I think natural
- gas is now about a quarter of our uh energy consumption but it could potentially be more uh with government
- policies you can't really easily use natural gas right now in an automobile for example
- uh so natural gas but then there's also just the fossil fuel versus renewable kind of question and should we be doing
- more to try to stimulate Renewables I mean there's still a tiny fraction of our energy consumption I mean if you
- throw out hydroelectric and you only look at let's say solar and wind type stuff it's tiny tiny tiny I think two
- percentage points perhaps of our energy consumption is uh is is on Renewables maybe it's three but it's not it's it's
- not it's not very big and are there ways to an efficient way stimulate more more
- on that front um I think that's you know something to think about and you know for that matter I think nuclear power is
- something that you know we don't hear much talk about but it's a possible source of increased energy uh uh uh of
- you it's a potential source for more energy uh down the road but I think that's a it's just such everything's
- connected government policies for spending for taxes for energy for trade for housing for healthare for all these
- things to the extent that you move one policy you often have Ripple effects in other areas and you know sometimes you
- can move a lever and it helps you on two problems so you know you might think suppose that you decide that climate
- change is a big issue and and the uh uh CO2 emissions and so forth suppose you increase the gasoline tax that
- potentially helps you on the budget front and it helps you potentially on the climate change front because maybe
- it causes people to shift to cars with better fuel uh efficiency and so forth um but often unfortunately you move you
- so that's an example of what case where you can kill two birds with one stone with a policy but but often
- unfortunately when you move a policy deliv that helps you on one front it can harm you elsewhere and so I think the
- you know a really important thing for policy makers is part of the reason that I think you know people like uh you know
- e people who study uh government policies and who have some expertise in this area uh part one of the things that
- we can contribute is to try to help policy makers think through the effect of their policies before they're enacted
- because so so many government policies that sound good and that have a really uh laudable objective end up having
- unintended consequences that uh actually either you know have negative effects that you weren't worrying about or may
- even undermine the very goal that the policy was intended to help and so I think it is uh uh policy makers really
- you know they're back in these rooms and they're rolling up their sleeves and people with you know lots of experience
- with negotiation and and and political experience and 30 years on the hill or 20 years and this or that branch of the
- federal government I really hope that they call on the expertise that is out there because a lot of these policies
- that they're moving are complicated and they often as smart as they are and as talented as they are on the things they
- do they often don't understand the trade-offs at [Music] all
Brief Summary
Mark Dugen discusses the fiscal cliff, tax implications, and job growth following Obama's election victory.
Key points
- Understanding the Fiscal Cliff. Mark Dugen explains the implications of the fiscal cliff, which could mean over $750 billion in tax increases and spending cuts.
- The Urgency of Policy Action. Dugen warns that inaction from policymakers could lead to significant economic consequences as the fiscal cliff approaches.
- The Complexity of Negotiations. Dugen emphasizes the intricate details involved in negotiating fiscal policies and the potential impacts on the economy.
- The Need for Economic Growth. Dugen stresses that enhancing economic growth is crucial for reducing the deficit and improving job creation.
- The Role of Natural Gas. Natural gas currently makes up a quarter of U.S. energy consumption, but could be more with better policies.
- Renewables' Tiny Share. Renewable energy sources like solar and wind account for only a tiny fraction of energy consumption.
Episode highlights
- Understanding the Fiscal CliffMark Dugen explains the implications of the fiscal cliff, which could mean over $750 billion in tax increases and spending cuts.“This fiscal cliff amounts to about 750 plus billion dollars.”1:12Nov 9, 2012
- The Urgency of Policy ActionDugen warns that inaction from policymakers could lead to significant economic consequences as the fiscal cliff approaches.“If policy makers do nothing, we will go over the fiscal cliff.”1:50Nov 9, 2012
- The Complexity of NegotiationsDugen emphasizes the intricate details involved in negotiating fiscal policies and the potential impacts on the economy.“The devil will certainly be in the details.”7:44Nov 9, 2012
- The Need for Economic GrowthDugen stresses that enhancing economic growth is crucial for reducing the deficit and improving job creation.“We need to grow our way out of it.”16:13Nov 9, 2012
- The Role of Natural GasNatural gas currently makes up a quarter of U.S. energy consumption, but could be more with better policies.“Natural gas is now about a quarter of our energy consumption.”19:17Nov 9, 2012
- Renewables' Tiny ShareRenewable energy sources like solar and wind account for only a tiny fraction of energy consumption.“Renewables are a tiny fraction of our energy consumption.”19:37Nov 9, 2012
- Policy Trade-offsGovernment policies can have ripple effects, helping one issue while potentially harming another.“You can move a lever and it helps you on two problems.”20:26Nov 9, 2012
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





