Negotiating Over Natural Gas

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Sarah thank you so much for joining us today you're welcome thank you for
  2. having me well I wanted to talk to you about uh Israel's Natural Gas gas uh situation and the and the tremendous
  3. find of of natural gas uh what impact do you think it's going to have on the overall geopolitical situation with
  4. Israel I just recently spoke in a panel where that was the question that was asked you know as the great discovery of
  5. gas in the Mediterranean something that's going to be something that's going to increase the tensions or could
  6. it be really a you know impetus for peace and for bringing countries together and sort of in the Israeli
  7. experience that at least um recent years we've sort of seen the ladder that we've
  8. seen the gas sort of be something that allows us to sort of move aside from traditional conflict related issues and
  9. sort of move into more positive areas um for example I was part of the legal team
  10. where we um we wrote a delimitation agreement our Mar to Define our Maritime borders with Cyprus the country that
  11. sits across from us and we were a little bit late in the game actually Egypt had
  12. already signed an agreement which went into force in 2004 Lebanon had signed a similar agreement in
  13. 2007 and and in 2010 we were Fally able um to sign an agreement which entered into force in February
  14. 2011 so now we're actually in the next stage in stage two which is entering into what's called a framework
  15. unitization agreement unitization from the word unit that there's a developing International practice um where you have
  16. if you have a transboundary reservoir the ideally to maximize both profits um to maximize from a technological point
  17. of view the best way to do it is that the both countries come together and then the private lienes will develop
  18. together so I would like to hope that definitely the discovery of gas will will lead to a positive direction for
  19. for not not just between Israel and Cypress but between all the players in the in the region so let let's focus on
  20. the on the Cypress issue can you describe what the main legal issues are regarding the Israeli cypriate gas are
  21. there any issues regarding the border of the two countries economic zones so in our case with Cyprus we're in a good
  22. situation because like I said in 201 our agreement on delimitation of what's called our exclusive economic zone which
  23. is the maritime zones that are usually under international law up to 200 nautical miles but in the case of Israel
  24. and Cyprus we actually have less than 200 nautical miles between the two countries we're talking about something
  25. like 180 nautical miles roughly depending on where you measure so we had to enter because of the overlapping
  26. areas we had to enter into a delimitation agreement now in that situation we already know where where
  27. Cypress is and where Israel is and that makes things a lot easier so now the next question is what happens when you
  28. have a reservoir that goes that sort of sits on both sides of that line and like
  29. I said unitization is the usual way that countries will handle that so we're in a
  30. good place with Cyprus in terms of knowing exactly where they are and we we are now if you have reservoirs and there
  31. on the Israeli side we've discovered quite a few reservoirs there are some very significant finds like the Tamar
  32. field and the Leviathan field which are entirely in are Israel's Maritime areas and once you have a defined line and
  33. those we know now for sure that those areas are nowhere near the cypriate border then we can go ahead and develop
  34. them um independently um when we're talking about areas that are on both sides then
  35. we have to work with our neighbors now we know that there's definitely one um transboundary Reservoir the Aphrodite
  36. field on Israel side it's the isai license sometimes it's called block 12 we know of of one and that that is a
  37. estimated to be around um 7cf in terms of its potential um the cyat have already started exploratory Drilling and
  38. Israel is is to begin it was just reported in the paper in about another month or so exploratory drilling on its
  39. end we're also moving along to sort of finalize the framework unitization agreement now that agreement it's it's
  40. sort of a two level two-layered agreement that you have the framework agreement between the governments which
  41. set forth on the macro level the rules um that the lies sort of have to play by in order to develop the field and then
  42. the lenses will have to um abide by those rules and develop together hopefully um the
  43. transboundary uh Reservoir which will be to the benefit of both sides do you expect uh Israel and Cyprus to
  44. collaborate in developing infrastructure for the export of natural gas these are
  45. issues that are definitely on the table there's a number of issues and gas related um issues that are on the table
  46. including possibility of cypriate purchase of Israeli gas as well um Cyprus is in a sort of there's a number
  47. of issues sort of that are before um the cypriots beyond the political issues on
  48. on the island with you know the the tur Turkish the situation with with the North and then the occupation there um
  49. but there are a number of issues including that it Cypress finds itself right now in an energy crisis they had a
  50. major explosion in one of their power plants about a year ago last summer um and so they're really looking for
  51. different options and and the whole option of cooperation with Israel is quite appealing
  52. um they also you know with the greater picture of what's going on in Europe and and what's going on in Greece it's it's
  53. sort of you know there's always the fear that that could sort of bubble over because there's a linkage between
  54. cyprius and Greek banks that that could bubble over into Cypress so there's a real um you know desire to to sort of
  55. work forward positively and and address these issues um before something negative happens and I think that's a
  56. positive in terms of the the inter dyamics um for how sort of allowing for cooperation Paving Paving the way for
  57. cooperation between the actors that maybe something that you know issues that are less positive can in the end
  58. sort of lead to more a more positive um situation between us so under the agreement if Cyprus and Israel do
  59. collaborate on infrastructure do you think this is likely to take the form of a pipeline being developed for Europe or
  60. do you think it might be uh a liquefied natural gas plant being set up somewhere
  61. in Cyprus and if so where might that be located uh nothing's been decided for sure and definitely there are a number
  62. of options and you've mentioned two of them one is the option of the pipeline um one is the option of of you know
  63. plant of of to liquefy in Cyprus another option is maybe floating um liquefied you know to do that in the water of of
  64. liquefying glass in the water and a lot of that just has to do with you know what are the mark the markets that are
  65. available in the needs and also you can't ignore the sort of Greater political situation um laying down a pipeline
  66. under International maritime law um on the high seeds all all states have a right to lay pipelines and also in
  67. states different exclusive economic zones meaning the areas beyond the territorial Waters you also have a right
  68. to lay pipelines even if it's not your own exclusive economic zone um the one thing is that also under international
  69. law the coastal state if it's in their exclusive economic zone um could object to the path of the pipeline and this
  70. could lead to possible objections um given particularly turkey's ways in there and turkey has a very different um
  71. sort of non-traditional approach to delineation issues in the Mediterranean what's your view of turkey I mean do you
  72. does Israel feel that it should U involve itself in in in the in dealing with turkey or the Cyprus issue or does
  73. Israel take the view that this is primarily something that the Turkish and the uh separate government should
  74. resolve among themselves I mean certainly you know politics is a side of economics and we and this has always
  75. been something even in better times that we've made clear to to the Turkish government that Israel wants to advance
  76. its its um vital economic interest in the region and I think the same would go for Turkey um you know overall we would
  77. like to to see ideally it would be best if if all the different actors in the region were on board I mean that would
  78. include our neighbors to the South it would include our neighbors to the north and you know we could maximize this
  79. great find in the Mediterranean if everyone sort of worked together um and we're not going to weigh in on on
  80. cypriate domestic issues just like we wouldn't want them to weigh in on our our own issues
  81. I those are two separate things sure that makes a lot of sense uh let's look now at Lebanon I mean what's the status
  82. of the economic um Zone boundary between Israel and Lebanon so first of all like
  83. I said at the beginning Cypress and Lebanon um actually signed a an agreement in 2007 um to delineate their
  84. overlapping exclusive economic zones in the Mediterranean like Israel there's there there are not those if you had 400
  85. nautical miles then everyone would get their own 200 nautical mile Zone but we have a very extreme overlap um Cyprus
  86. has already ratified that agreement in order for an agreement usually to go into full force both sides need to
  87. ratify it um and with Egypt and with Israel our agreements have been fully ratified on both sides and deposit in
  88. the UN in in full force in the Lebanese case although they signed it in 2007 which from a legal point of view once
  89. you already sign an agreement an international treaty you're bound by the terms of that treaty um Lebanon has not
  90. ratified that agreement Cyprus has so now you have a situation where they have a delimitation but they're still waiting
  91. for the Lebanese delimitation now in interestingly perhaps curiously um in 2010 um Lebanon went ahead with a couple
  92. of unilateral moves at the UN now generally speaking if you look at the UN Convention of the law of the sea which
  93. is sort of the Bible of peacetime maritime law and get sets out all the rules of how to delineate the different
  94. marit time zones um the the relevant Provisions call for states to work together and try to reach an agreement
  95. that would be ideal or if they can't reach an agreement at least try to reach provisional Arrangements but certainly
  96. if there's some sort of disputed Maritime claims to talk to one another now in the case of Lebanon um Lebanon
  97. doesn't recognize Israel and so instead of sort of turning to Israel and discussing Maritime issues it went ahead
  98. to the UN in 2010 and and um deposited a series of unil Al positions um the first
  99. unilateral position set what Lebanon sees as its delimitation with Israel um sort of
  100. between Israel and Lebanon um the line that runs East West between it from Lebanese perspective I won't call it a
  101. border because under international law a border is something that is agreed by both States um it then went ahead and
  102. did a second unilateral position which is that it took the line that it agreed with Cypress in 2007 and amended it and
  103. I say amended in quotations because to amend it you usually need both sides and under the terms of their agreement you
  104. would need both sides to amend but you pulled the line further south um entering into what Israel believes is
  105. its exclusive economic zone also entering into the area that actually Cypress and Israel divided um with
  106. another so you have a situation um of overlapping Maritime claims now under international law usually when you're
  107. getting to the point of trying to delimit the maritime Zone you usually start out with the
  108. mathematical um approach of trying to find out what the median Line is now clearly this is not one single number
  109. it's it's a complicated process where you pick points on the coast and there are there are definitely ways accepted
  110. practice in C cartography under law of how you pick those points in the in the on the coast you pick points and you try
  111. to reach a median line um that said if you were to go to International court if you were go to
  112. arbitration um the you know the judge or the the AR the the mediator might look at some other special circumstances to
  113. see if anything else should weigh in when delineating the maritime border now these special circumstances can be a
  114. number of thing there's no Clos list it could be um was there a historic agreement between the parties in the
  115. maritime Arena it could be something like you know is there a very odd Geographic situation
  116. that you might have all sorts of rock rock formations and how does that weigh in does the mathematical approach
  117. perhaps create total disproportionality in terms of who's getting what again a number of things now one of the things
  118. we've seen in case law that that also weighs in um was you know when the question of particularly in gas practice
  119. and oil practice you know would that influence the maritime Del delineation we actually have case law that says no
  120. that wouldn't influence the situation unless there was either explicit or tacit acquiescence now in the case of Lebanon
  121. in their unilateral positions from 2010 um we see those positions as being problematic Israel we see those position
  122. being problematic um from both a legal and cartographic point of view in terms of how we see the proper way of
  123. delineating the maritime what should be the border between Israel and Lebanon and so in order to prevent tacid
  124. acquiescence so that if we would ever get to a case where we were trying to resolve our situation we felt it was
  125. important in July in July 2011 um to submit our pursuing to a government decision our version of what
  126. we think the maritime delimitation should be between Israel and Lebanon and this created a sort of a triangle of a
  127. disputed area we'll say that Israel this is not unique and this actually doesn't
  128. have to do with with the politics of the Middle East there are loads of areas throughout the world um where there are
  129. ongoing and sometimes quite controversial Maritime disputes I me if you take a look in the I you're you're
  130. an economic journalist I'm sure you know about all the disputes going on between
  131. China and Japan this the the the the South China Sea area um Korea ways in there too there's a lot of many many
  132. Maritime disputes if you go into the website of the international court of justice see just how many Maritime
  133. border disputes they've they've been involved in you go in the permanent Court of arbitration they've been
  134. involved in a number the um there was a there's a chamber that was set up under the UN Convention of the law of the sea
  135. they just had their for first ruling between Myanmar and Bangladesh this is not something unique um that said what
  136. is somewhat unusual is that you're talking about particularly if you look at lebanes submissions you know it's
  137. difficult for them to even say the word Israel they usually um will not even say
  138. Israel by name and so the question is how we're going to get to a resolution in this area in our submission in
  139. Israel's submission to the UN in 2011 where we gave our own version of where we see the maritime border with Lebanon
  140. we did emphasize however in our letter to the Secretary General that we are interested um in resolving this dispute
  141. with all and and resolving all these issues with our neighbors and this is something that's very important we
  142. really took the language of the UN Convention of the law of the sea and we tried to mirror the language about
  143. trying to be positive and open to dialogue that is if the dialogue is a professional dialogue that is based on
  144. legal principles an accepted cardgraphic practice and doesn't tries to stay away
  145. from politics there a way to solve these problems in a purely technical kind of way and and we would hope I think again
  146. getting back to your question that that would really lead us to a win-win situation I mean there's a lot to be
  147. gained on the Lebanese side there's a lot to be gained on on the Israeli side and so long and we saw this in our
  148. experience with Cypress so long as you have ambiguity you know even about just a meter of where the border is supposed
  149. to be investors won't come investors will come when they know that they can get you know definite coordinates of
  150. where where each site is and and I think that the Lebanese government knows that
  151. as well uh let's turn on to Egypt uh is the Israeli government getting involved in the dispute between and the
  152. government of Egypt or is the official attitude that this is a commercial dispute I I would say on that issue um
  153. the latter that that particular issue um is a private commercial um matter it's being handled in private in private
  154. channels it's it's a classic you know contract's issue of uh you know material breach of contract and and it's being
  155. handled and in the way that any sort of breach of contract would be handled and does the Israeli government regard the
  156. discontinuation of natural gas supplies from Egypt as a diplomatic issue or and a test of the new Egyptian government's
  157. attitude towards the Egypt Israel priest treaty and Egypt's commitment to it I me
  158. I think that's going a bit far again I think that this is a commercial issue and it's and it's being handled between
  159. commercial actors there I think to tie it in with the peace treaty is is a little bit sort of getting mixing apples
  160. and oranges it's a stretch it's a stretch I mean for for us it is very important and and ha you know luckily
  161. thus far the Egyptian government has also said you know emphasized the importance of of maintaining um the
  162. peace treaty between Israel and Egypt this has been something that's been a wonderful thing um and so and we hope to
  163. to maintain that and so and you and you know who knows maybe we'll have the opportunity for
  164. cooperation on on our you know in the maritime Arena maybe we'll you we've been surprised they always said you know
  165. in biblical you know literature that we live in the land of milk and honey and we're always asking where's the milk
  166. where's the honey and here we've discovered all of a sudden you know everyone's kind of shocked by that and
  167. so again you know talked about the northern front maybe also on the southern front this could be something
  168. that could be positive well uh standing now to the the Palestinian Authority what's uh Israel's policy towards the
  169. gas Fields found in a near the area of the economic zone of the Palestinian Authority there's the Mediterranean
  170. coast of the Gaza Strip MH well and first of all there's some ambiguity in terms of the the legal status of the
  171. maritime areas off the coast of Gaza right now because the so far Hamas controls strip it's Hamas that controls
  172. it and not the Palestinian Authority now in the in late '90s actually um rights were granted um to to British
  173. company British gas um in in in gas Fields off the coast of the Gaza Strip um actually from an Israeli point of
  174. view we would like to see the development of those gas Fields so long as the proceeds don't fall into Kamas
  175. hands we don't you know have any objections to those rights being exercised um and then you know as As you
  176. move further north then there are there there are fields that are being being developed on the Israeli side that are
  177. on on our South border but not across from the Gaza Strip um there are other issues that are involved in terms of
  178. Maritime areas of the Gaza Strip but that more has to do with not peacetime law um Peace time maritime law but
  179. rather laws of armed conflict and the security situation and unfortunately in recent years we've seen um the maritime
  180. Arena which is really used for some 90 plus per of all all Transportation trade in the world at some Point goes through
  181. the sea and we've seen you know otherwise innocent commercial shipping being taken advantage of um to smuggle
  182. in um weapons in into our areas into terrorist groups um that are out for the destruction of Israel and we saw um
  183. about a year ago uh one ship Victoria with 50 tons of weapons being smuggled on it if you would have looked at the
  184. crates I actually I saw the crates you had um things like lentils and cotton on the crat and and and the crew had no
  185. idea but you know various actors figured out a way to smuggle in quite Advanced you know Atlanta sea ter weaponry and
  186. you have other situ we had one boat that was caught with 500 tons of Weaponry just to give you an idea of what we're
  187. talking about 500 tons of weap that's the entire amount of weapons that were used in the second Lebanon war against
  188. Israel so in that area I mean we have a sort of sensitive security situation but that's
  189. aside from peacetime issues now certainly if we are able to sit down negotiate move towards peace and you
  190. know one of the core issues that needs to be resolved between Israel and Palestinians is borders and when we're
  191. talking about borders we're not just talking about land borders we're talking about sea borders as well so do you see
  192. any Prospect of cooperation between Israel and the Palestinian Authority or even Hamas in developing these fields I
  193. mean again in terms of the there there's a potential there Hamas is not it's a ter terrorist entity it's just like
  194. under us law and under EU law in Israel it's an organization that does not recognize Israel is still committed to a
  195. violent approach does not accept any of the existing um agreements so in terms of and at least in the current
  196. configuration unless Hamas would suddenly change their their Charter their political platform that's not
  197. really uh a reality in terms of of cooperation with the Palestinians or with other you know countries that are
  198. being given rights again we have to see um what will happen sort of on the political side in terms of potential for
  199. cooperation but I think that overall Israel be open to the possibility for cooperation with the with moderate um
  200. Palestinian actors great just a couple of more questions Uh Russian President Putin visited Israel I think in June
  201. this year uh was this largely or in part Focus on the potential Russian involvement in the development of the
  202. Israeli gas Fields I I I don't know what the content of of the talks where I know
  203. that there's a number of actors in the area that are looking into you know we discovered large amounts of gas and sort
  204. of the the potential and the potential for investment in the area um but there's nothing sort of there that was
  205. set there's been a certain amount of speculation as you know that gazprom might be one of the leading players
  206. among the foreign energy companies to help Israel develop the uh natural gas Fields is that likely or I I can't
  207. really say in terms of the way and on the likelihood there there are a number of of actors that are certainly
  208. interested as thus far the major actor in The Maritime arena in Israel has been actually a US company Noble energy um
  209. that has both interests both on the Israel side on the cypret side as well actually the the agreement that we're
  210. I'm negotiating right now with the unitization actually we see Noble on on the other side um we have different
  211. companies including a sort of a a group of different countries including one has
  212. a Norwegian interests and stuff and so we've seen different different countries I can a number of countries not only
  213. Russia expressing interest and sort of looking into what exactly uh are there opportunities for them um I can't really
  214. say what will be in the future you know one of the other things we're working on
  215. the domestic side is also sort of developing our own policies and how we see our important export policies this
  216. whole area and I can say this on the legal side for sure you know was something that we we didn't know that
  217. the potential was out there and so you know we're still playing a bit of catchup in terms of getting everything
  218. in order including both of our domestic policies and and our legislation um just because this came as
  219. a bit of a surprise in terms of the the potential that was out there uh but you know there are a number of possibilities
  220. a number of actors that might play a larger or smaller role in our area as we move along
  221. [Music]

Brief Summary

Sarah discusses Israel's natural gas finds and their geopolitical impact, focusing on collaboration with Cyprus and Lebanon.

Key points

  • Natural Gas and Geopolitics. Exploring the impact of Israel's natural gas discovery on regional tensions and cooperation.
  • Israel-Cyprus Collaboration. Discussion on potential collaboration between Israel and Cyprus regarding natural gas infrastructure.
  • Lebanon's Maritime Dispute. Examining the unresolved maritime boundary issues between Israel and Lebanon.
  • Maritime Security Concerns. The maritime arena is crucial for trade but vulnerable to weapon smuggling.
  • Weapon Smuggling Scale. A shocking amount of weaponry was smuggled, equivalent to past conflicts.
  • Potential for Cooperation. Israel may cooperate with moderate Palestinian actors despite ongoing tensions.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes