How Geopolitics Is Hitting Local Gas Stations

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Serguei Netessine, Wharton Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions, discusses how U.S. sanctions on Lukoil are disrupting franchise agreements, banking relationships, and customer perceptions for locally operated gas stations in New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#Lukoil #USSanctions #GasPriceHike #Geopolitics #EnergyMarket #OilIndustry ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Lukoil is a company that supplies gasoline to consumers in the New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania region. And those
  2. gas stations are run like most, with a franchisee model. But ongoing sanctions by the US against Russia over the Ukraine
  3. war is having an impact on those stations, many of which end up being family run. So it's an interesting story of how small
  4. business is being impacted by something half a world away, and still needs to try and survive.
  5. Pleasure to be joined to discuss how they go about this by Serguei Netessine, who is a
  6. Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School. Serguei, great to catch up with you. How are you, sir?
  7. Very good. Thank you for having me, Dan. Thank you, sir. Well, like, as I said at the top, a
  8. lot of these stations are family run, so it has to be quite the challenge being caught in the middle of all of this.
  9. Yes, absolutely. This is a very unfortunate situation where, you know, Lukoil's US footprint was built largely through
  10. acquisitions of existing station networks. First it was Getty stations, and then there was some Mobile, Exxon Mobile
  11. portfolio, followed by gradual rebranding. So today you have local operators running community businesses under a
  12. brand whose ownership is a geopolitical flashpoint. So that's what's going on. What is the relationship, then, that these local stations have
  13. with the larger company? How does that work out? Well, many of those stations are family run, locally operated
  14. businesses caught in the middle, really. They're kind of like a collateral damage, because they are franchised locations, and
  15. sanctions imposed on Lukoil, they really target ownership and control. But the shock travels straight to family run
  16. franchisees who have, really, nothing to do with with the ownership of the franchise.
  17. Right. And it's important to note that while these stations are from a Russian company, the gasoline
  18. from, what I read, from these stores, is gas that's refined here in the US, not in Russia.
  19. So those people that may have a concern of thinking that they are supporting Russia, that may
  20. not necessarily be the case. That is correct, yes. So the molecule— molecules in the tank
  21. may be American, but the reputational risk is about the logo, not the refinery. And this is what a lot of customers
  22. see. They see the logo, and the logo is from the Russian company, and that's why they often stop buying gasoline, even—
  23. even before any sanctions. Even, you know, above and beyond the effect of the direct sanctions imposed on Lukoil.
  24. And so the financial side of this for the companies is a challenge because they have certain relationships set up in
  25. terms of how they can bank the level of credit, where they can get credit from, and it's a challenge for them right now.
  26. Exactly, Dan. And the problem is that stations depend on credit card payments or debit card payments. And typical franchisee
  27. in this business gets something like 85 to 90% of their sales from cards. And cards are controlled by the bank, of
  28. course. And when the bank sees a risk— like in this case, a risk of sanctions— they just stop accepting payments. And so
  29. customers come to the station, payments are not accepted. On the other hand, the franchisee agreement corners the owner as
  30. well. Because when you are in a franchising agreement, you have to use certain equipment, you have to use certain bank. You
  31. have to use certain branding. And so these owners cannot even go to a different bank and say, "Hey, you know, my bank is not
  32. accepting payments. Let me go with a different bank." They are squeezed from both sides. There is a compliance risk on one side
  33. and then the contract default risk on the other side. So that's— that's a very, very unfortunate situation.
  34. And so if they wanted to go to another bank just to be able to solve their problems temporarily, what are some of
  35. the potential repercussions of doing that? Well, they would violate, potentially, rules of the franchising agreement.
  36. And that typically means they can get sued by the— by Lukoil, by the parent company itself. I mean, I'm not giving
  37. legal advice here. You know, I would definitely want to read their agreement and probably consult with a— with a lawyer and
  38. understand how the agreement works. But typically, that's what happens. You— you would violate the rules of the
  39. agreement, and potentially just lose entire franchising unit that you have. So then for the company, Lukoil, I guess, one
  40. of the potential solutions might be if they were to sell their assets to another owner, then. Correct?
  41. Yes, that would be probably the best solution for everyone. Divestment is kind of a cleanest structural solution I can think
  42. of. But the problem is, with timelines and approvals, that could be slow because of the sanctions. Because OFAC
  43. explicitly addressed this, and they said that, look, the general license that they give, it authorizes negotiations and
  44. all kinds of contingent contracts, plus due diligence, but it doesn't authorize the actual sale. So when it comes to
  45. sale, it still has to be approved. So that probably means extra months and months that are going— that are going to take place
  46. between the agreement is reached and then the approval is gained. So policy-wise, the sale is a nice off ramp, but it's a
  47. regulated off ramp. So— - Right. It would be a slow off ramp. But if you did have something like that occur, I would assume
  48. most likely that— well, I can't assume it, but would there need to be a rebrand of the stores?
  49. Practically, yes. Yeah. I think in most cases, either immediately or part of the sale. And there are multiple reasons.
  50. There is a commercial reason. You want to avoid kind of a customer seeing this sign, and the reputational drag is there. But
  51. then there is also compliance, operational reason. So banking and payment partners will be more comfortable. And then there
  52. is a contract reason. Usually rebranding is required as a part of termination of the agreement and sale of assets. So even
  53. if the fuel supply would stay the same, most likely, rebranding can be the difference between this political headline and a
  54. local corner store. A corner store. What, potentially, then, is the path that these local store
  55. owners need to consider right now? I mean, as you said before, they're kind of stuck in the middle here, and it doesn't
  56. feel like they have a lot of options at this moment. No, unfortunately not. And, you know, they kind of should have
  57. seen this coming. I'm frankly surprised that Lukoil wasn't sanctioned earlier. You know, it took so long. You know, the war
  58. has been going on for such a long time, and Lukoil is clearly supporting the Russian government in the war. There
  59. are a few things you can do. You can try to find redundant payment options. You know, try to encourage multiple processors
  60. to accept payments, for example, and hopefully there are some banks that are not as worried about sanctions. So that's kind
  61. of in the mediate, in the mediate term, to investigate. Then you really want transparent customer messaging. I would
  62. have— I would have, everywhere, "Locally-owned, employs local staff, fuel supply through US distribution," and so on, to just
  63. help customers understand that, you know, this is really— has nothing to do— it doesn't have much to do with a Russian
  64. company business. This won't solve sanctions, but it can soften this brand avoidance disturbance. And then you
  65. probably want to engage in some trade associations, start talking with each other, and push for practical guidance from
  66. OFAC and so on. So then you can get engaged into some medium term, you know, seek compliance pathways and negotiate some kind
  67. of franchising relief. That would involve some kind of a consultations with a lawyer, probably.
  68. How much is this really a story of kind of the nature of how small businesses have to deal with, you know, some very unique
  69. situations that may come out of the blue, that they may not have expected when they, you know, wanted to be an owner of a
  70. business like this? Yeah, it's— it's an— it's unfortunate in this case, that the policy goal is to cut off sanctioned cash flows, right? So
  71. you want to cut off cash flows to Russia, not to wipe out American family businesses, right? So, of course, I think
  72. OFAC realized this a little bit late, and kind of created this solution where they allowed stations still to operate, but
  73. then there is still a backlash, because customers see the brand and, you know, they kind of perceive it as not a good
  74. brand. So there are, unfortunately, no great solutions right now. Really, this acquisition would be the best.
  75. So it should be encouraged. It should be made relatively fast, because this really would be a good outcome for everyone.
  76. Serguei, great to talk to you again. Thanks very much. All the best. Yeah, thank you. Thank you, Dan. - You got it.
  77. Good to see you, as usual. Absolutely. Serguei Netessine, who is Professor of Operations,
  78. Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

US sanctions on Lukoil affect family-run gas stations in the Northeast, causing financial and reputational challenges.

Key points

  • Impact of Sanctions on Local Businesses. Ongoing US sanctions against Russia affect family-run Lukoil gas stations in the US.
  • Potential Solutions for Lukoil. Divesting assets may be the best solution for Lukoil amidst sanctions.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes