Big Banks Keep Watering Down Global Reserve Rules
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Even today, global banks still set aside too little cash to prevent another financial meltdown. Attempts to force them to do so -- like Basel III -- fall well short, says Wharton finance professor Richard J. Herring.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- knowledge Wharton today is speaking with Wharton Finance Professor Richard hurring about some crucial Bank
- regulations meant to be a first line of defense against another Global Financial
- meltdown in a nutshell uh various countries on behalf of their banks have lobbied hard to water down the strong
- protections that are supposed to prevent another financial crisis in the last crisis uh it was a lack of liquidity
- that led to uh the quickly escalating problems that we saw so the proposed Rules by the Bassel committee involve
- issues such as do banks have enough liquidity on hand uh in a form that they can get at fast in an emergency in other
- words how liquid are reserves and if the liquidity rules uh have to be relaxed which is what countries are lobbing for
- on behalf of their Banks then where does that leave us on the issue of too big to
- fail or lender of Last Resort issues so Professor hering you're also co-chair of
- something called the uh Financial the shadow Financial regulatory committee could you start by explaining briefly
- what that is and then tell us about the committee's views on on how there's this
- attempt to water down the new rules meant to prevent another meltdown uh the uh emphasis should be on the shadow part
- of the title because in fact it is completely non-official it's a group of U former Regulators uh academics um and
- lawyers who meet four times a year in Washington to review recent Financial proposals and ideas for new regulation
- uh each meeting is followed by a press conference where we release statements that uh reflect our group view on a
- particular proposal or a direction we think Financial regulation should take the one we're discussing today is an
- attempt by the Basel committee um which represents the uh supervisors of well now it's really the group of 20 uh and
- growing but the Key Bank supervisors in the world to set in place regulations that will prevent another banking crisis
- and I think you're right it stems from the perception that the cause of the last crisis was Ill liquidity um I would
- say that's more proximate than fundamental uh in fact the real problem was that many banks had very very weak
- asset positions and once the market found out it led to liquidity problems but nonetheless that's where it did show
- up so the response of the bosel committee was to establish two kinds of liquidity
- ratios um one of them is sort of Fallen by the wayside because people are very worried that it would reduce the role of
- banks in in intermediation altogether but the other which is called um the um short-term liquidity ratio is going
- forward uh it's been revised now at least twice and probably will will be revised again before it uh is written
- into law uh Governor banki has has said that the US will be revising it before it actually puts it into law the idea
- behind it was um I think fairly straightforward um if you're worried that Banks don't have enough liquidity
- then you define highquality liquidity that is liquidity that can be turned into cash for meeting uh demands for
- cash uh immediately at no cost relative to some scale variable and the scale variable they chose was the amount of
- outflow Bank might have to meet over a 30-day stress period now at that level it's very clear and makes some kind of
- sense but the problem began when the politics started because the European banks in particular realized that they
- were going to be in a very difficult situation so high quality liquidity got expanded to include all sorts of things
- that I think we'd all be fairly skeptical were high quality at all Equity with a haircut um some corporate
- bonds even some mortgages things that are really not remotely uh sure liquidity in all Market
- situations and remember we're looking at a stress situation so it really doesn't
- make sense to use things that are normally pretty liquid so liquidity should be cash and maybe something a
- little bit well less than cash it's the maybe that gets you into trouble now in the us we'd probably say Cash Plus
- treasury bills but if you're a Greek bank that's really not going to be very helpful so uh the the committee I think
- came down to the view that cash was the one thing that we could measure with certainty that was always liquid in all
- situations and would give you an unambiguous indicator uh then there were problems with regard to the denominator
- how much stress do we want to think about do we want to worry about something as stressful as what happened
- during the crisis uh well that became a fudge at first they used fairly extraordinary uh pretty stressful uh
- assumptions to figure out that amount equal equal to what the last crisis produced it wasn't that clean it would
- have been nicer if they had actually had some empirical evidence to hang it on but it was it was a fairly extreme
- assumption and then they began to water it down and they watered it down by saying gee how much of each liability is
- likely to out to flow out and it went from something that was very stressful for something that was more or less an
- ordinary day it was really uh so it's turned out to to be a mishmash that that really doesn't help uh Outsiders
- understand the liquidity position of Banks and really is just another very confusing way to uh look at a bank
- because you can't compare it across Banks since you're using very different rules and it all depends on the
- composition of A bank's um assets and its liabilities um our suggestion was to make it something much
- more straightforward uh to use cash in the numerator and in the denominator make an assumption that the bank can't
- roll over any of its liabilities that's extreme but the answer to that uh fraction will tell you the number of
- days the bank could keep going without relying on the market now in the future Regulators may or may not want to put an
- a limit or a minimum on that number of days but at least in the meanwhile markets would be able to read it in a
- way that was comp purle across Banks [Music]
Brief Summary
Professor Richard Herring discusses bank regulations and liquidity requirements to prevent future financial crises, highlighting political pressures and proposed changes.
Key points
- The Shadow Financial Regulatory Committee. A non-official group of experts meets to review financial proposals and regulations.
- Liquidity Rules Under Scrutiny. The Basel committee's liquidity rules are being challenged and revised amidst political pressures.
Episode highlights
- The Shadow Financial Regulatory CommitteeA non-official group of experts meets to review financial proposals and regulations.“It's a group of former Regulators, academics, and lawyers.”0:57May 2, 2013
- Liquidity Rules Under ScrutinyThe Basel committee's liquidity rules are being challenged and revised amidst political pressures.“Liquidity should be cash and maybe something a little bit less than cash.”4:20May 2, 2013
Tension
40/ 100Low tension




