Zillow CEO Spencer Rascoff: Pulling Back the Veil on the Housing Market

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Online real estate marketplace Zillow has brought to home buying and selling what a previous generation of travel websites provided to shoppers wanting to compare the prices of hotels, rental cars and airline flights -- transparency. But finding data that is reliable across the board can be hard to come by, according to Zillow CEO Spencer Rascoff. And the key is not just simply to offer the information, Rascoff said during a recent conversation with Knowledge@Wharton and Wharton real estate professor Susan Wachter; it's about the level of accuracy gained from the various sub-models the company's software incorporates. πŸ“‚ Real Estate;Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Uh Susan Spencer, thank you so much for joining us today. Great pleasure. Thank
  2. you. So Spencer, I wonder if I could start with you. U we are starting to hear that the housing market is
  3. recovering. Uh based on the data you see at Zillow. uh what do you see and um how
  4. even is the recovery across different regions? Well um housing is back. So in 2012 home values were up 6%
  5. year-over-year and in 2013 Zilla is forecasting 3% appreciation year-over-year which is a little bit on
  6. the conservative side as compared with other economists. But we've had 16 months in a row of appreciating home
  7. values which is great. Um there's very tight inventory across the country and one of the reasons for that is so many
  8. homeowners still have negative equity and so it's difficult for them to sell. So there's not that much inventory and
  9. that's because of low mortgage rates. That's creating bidding wars in a lot of areas. And so we're seeing some parts of
  10. the country appreciating at unsustainably high rates. Phoenix is over 15% year-over-year. South Florida
  11. is appreciating very quickly. Northern California is appreciating very quickly. And that's a little worrisome. I think
  12. those those rates of appreciation are unsustainable. Um but overall, this is a much much better housing market than
  13. really it has been in the last several years. What do you think, Susan? Well, I agree. And I think that the months of
  14. appreciation, 16 months and and ongoing restores confidence and the negatives in
  15. the market have been a lack of confidence, an unwillingness to put your money into housing when it's been such a
  16. threatening position to have been most people know people who've lost $40,000. And but this is a different world and
  17. this is a world where housing price rises are in fact sustainable. They will continue. I also concur and a 3% fact
  18. I'm forecasting 5% price rises this coming year. That's interesting. Well, uh let let's go back Spencer to to uh
  19. you know before Zillow was launched uh you founded Hotwire which you sold to Expedia and then you also worked for
  20. Expedia as vice president of lodging. How did your background in technology and marketing uh inform the the way
  21. Zillow was shaped? Um when we sold Hotwire to Expedia, uh I joined and my management team from Hotwire joined the
  22. folks that had created Expedia within Microsoft about 10 years earlier. And the whole um thesis behind creating
  23. Expedia was to provide information transparency to consumers. Prior to Expedia, as you probably recall, you'd
  24. have to speak on the phone to a travel agent and you could hear them type, you know, over the phone and all you'd want
  25. to do is jump through the phone and see for yourself what secret database is that travel agent looking at that I
  26. don't have access to. And that's what Expedia did. It turned around the screen so that you as a consumer could have
  27. access to the secret database. When we were at Expedia, we started looking at other industries that hadn't been
  28. revolutionized by the internet yet. And it was obvious to us that the real estate industry was among them that
  29. there were these secret databases that only professionals had access to and there was all this great data locked up
  30. in these these databases but also in county courouses. And so at Zillow we aim to unlock that information and make
  31. it readily available to consumers. The difference though is in the real estate space unlike the travel space there will
  32. always be an intermediary uh somebody in the transaction and that's that's fine by us. We actually think that real
  33. estate transactions are so infrequent, so expensive, so highly emotional, so complex that there will always and
  34. should always be a professional in the transaction. So, we have a very different business model at Zillow. We
  35. sell advertising and software tools to professionals. Um, that's how we make money rather than being in the
  36. transaction, which is how Expedia makes money by being an online travel agent. Uh, so what do you think of the business
  37. model that uh Spencer just described? Zillow is a game changer. I can't talk about the uh profitability of the of the
  38. company but the what it has brought to the consumer to the home owner in terms of valuation of their home is extremely
  39. important especially in these years of extraordinary volatility when people want to know what is their home worth
  40. has it in fact fallen by 50% which homes in many parts of the country have uh do
  41. you have to actually go to someone to an expert get several different views no this is getting the power of all all the
  42. data bringing it together in very sophisticated analytic models and it's there for you to test and by the way if
  43. it appears to be off in some ways there is now a way of going back. So this is this is really extraordinarily
  44. important. Um you need to know the value of your home today for many reasons. Are
  45. you going to sell as compared to your mortgage amount? Uh this democratizes data and it makes the market more
  46. transparent and more efficient. All of which is very important to this market which has seen its troubles. This helps
  47. bring liquidity back. That that's very interesting Susan that you said that because uh one of the things that I
  48. found most interesting on Zillow was the was the Z estimate. Yes. Uh and I promptly of course went and looked up
  49. the value of my own house. Uh now what I was very curious is how do you figure out what the house is worth? How does
  50. your algorithm work? Well, the the short answer is the the data base look the the
  51. the software looks at the property attributes of your home and compares it with like homes. Um the much longer
  52. answer is at each census tract level. Census track is basically a couple neighborhood blocks. We have um a meta
  53. model that sits on top of many other subm models. And so for example, a submodel might look at tax assessment.
  54. Another might look solely at uh distance to an arterial. Another might look at dollars per square foot. Uh, another
  55. might look at um just regressions against number of bedrooms for example. Um, and the meta model at the census
  56. track level tries different weightings of each of the subm models going back 15 years and is constantly improving itself
  57. by changing the allocations the relative weighting of the different submodels to
  58. figure out what's the right waiting across each submodel to be as accurate as possible. So as time passes as more
  59. and more data comes into the system it becomes more accurate over time. And point of fact, about a third of homes in
  60. the US now have had their property attributes changed on Zillow by homeowners or their agents. So much as
  61. Wikipedia is a living database of all the world's knowledge, Zillow has become a living database of all the property
  62. parcel information in the US. And that allows this estimate and other data on Zilla to become more accurate over time.
  63. And does it apply only to existing home sales or also new homes? We also come up
  64. with estimates with new homes based on the property records that either come to us from the county or come to us from
  65. the listings feeds from new constru from home builders who send us feeds. So um also when we get new information about a
  66. home it this estimate will change. So for example if county records have three bedrooms, three baths, 3,000 ftΒ² and
  67. then we become aware either because the listing information says so or because a
  68. homeowner tells us that the property has four bedrooms and four baths and 4,000 feet, we recalculate this estimate at
  69. that point. So, what is your view of the process that uh uh you Spencer just described is how sound from a pricing
  70. standpoint is it? It's a great process. It's using what we call hyonic analysis that is taking the attributes of the
  71. property and waiting them to efficiently use them statistically to come out with
  72. the best estimate. There are other ways of doing this. You could do repeat sales
  73. and that avoids the structure of the home and the differences in the structure of the home. What's
  74. interesting about this is it incorporates not just the value changes in the neighborhood the or the nearest
  75. neighbors but also the attributes of your own home and that's an advantage. Now, uh question for both of you is that
  76. I've heard some criticism especially from realtors uh that it's um that that uh this estimate or or the pricing model
  77. that Zillow uses may have some flaws. Uh and because there are some factors that
  78. just can't be captured and automated. Uh do you agree with that criticism? And if
  79. so, what do you what's your response? I I do agree with that. I mean, it's computerenerated on every home in the
  80. country three times a week. So, uh, it we Zillow, no employee of Zillow has ever been in your home. Uh, so, um, for
  81. a computerenerated valuation, we believe it's quite accurate and it's a good starting point. We call it a Zestimate,
  82. not as appraisal. It's meant to be a starting point. And if you want to figure out a more accurate determination
  83. of your home's value, then we encourage you to talk to a real estate agent or an
  84. appraiser who will come to your home and refine the valuation. Absolutely. If you
  85. have something special like um uh a um a pool for koi fish, let's say, they'll never know and you'll know. It's very
  86. important to you and might be important to some buyer. Uh so that's why it's a basic estimate and there may be some
  87. negatives as well that may not be incorporated. That's right. So u if you if you take some of the other companies
  88. that are active in the same space as Zillow uh say realtor.com or Trullia uh everyone has access to the same basic
  89. data which is from the multiple listing system or the MLS uh what is your strategy to contain to to create a
  90. sustainable advantage uh for Zillow based on the fact that you all start with the same you're you're right that
  91. at the core it's there's fundamentally commoditized listings information which is why we don't focus exclusively on
  92. that. So if you think of um the entire housing stock of the United States 110 million homes about 3% of them are for
  93. sale in the MLS at any point in time everybody has that information um and that's on tens of thousands of other
  94. websites. So we try to innovate on top of that. For example, by having estimates, by showing historicals
  95. estimates, by showing sale data going back 15 years, tax information, making predictions of what's going to happen to
  96. that home's value going forward. But fundamentally, the the price, the photos, the square footage, that's on
  97. every website. And so that's not enough. What we then do is we have information on hundreds of thousands of make move
  98. listings when an owner posts a dream price for their home, new construction listings, for sale by owner listings.
  99. We're the only website with over a million foreclosure and pre-forclosure listings um posted for free for
  100. consumers. And then of course we have market context. We have information on every home in the country. And then we
  101. have ratings and reviews, 250,000 reviews of real estate agents that consumers have left on Zillow. So we do
  102. our best to innovate not on that commoditized information but on all the other stuff which we think is what
  103. differentiates us from competitors. Do you think this is enough to create a sustainable competitive advantage for
  104. Zillow or can others catch up? The key is the algorithms which one can improve over
  105. time and which become self-improving with additional data and uh adding data particularly individual input that
  106. others don't have or can't organize and some of this data you can't just replicate back and forth individual uh
  107. reestimates of the property I think is a sustainable model. There's also of course the name Zillow and uh there
  108. aren't there isn't going to be room here. I don't think for many firms with many names, people are going to
  109. gravitate to whoever has the most information and then that firm will have the most information going forward. The
  110. the platform shift from the desktop to mobile has also been a great boon to our business because um we're a software
  111. company and we can devote massive amounts of resources to create software especially on mobile where it's very
  112. complex to write software across multiple mobile platforms. So for example, we went public about a year and
  113. a half ago. When we went public, 20 homes were viewed every second on Zillow on mobile. A year and a half later, it's
  114. 75 homes viewed every second. A year and a half ago, we had five mobile apps. Today, we have 24. Just to give you a
  115. sense of just how quickly our our usage is shifting to mobile. More homes are now viewed on Zillow on mobile than on
  116. the desktop. So, as more and more usage shifts towards mobile, it's difficult for individual brokerage websites at at
  117. a local level to compete because it requires so much software to create great mobile app great mobile
  118. experiences and great mobile apps. Um, and it's difficult for even other national players to compete. So, we we
  119. definitely benefit from that. Um, I I just saw some interesting data from Domino's Pizza, believe it or not. Um,
  120. at their investor day, they put up a slide that showed national uh market share of Domino's and Pizza Hut over the
  121. last 10 years versus local pizza places. And it was basically flat between national and local for the last 10 plus
  122. years. And then about two years ago, something interesting happened. The national guys gained a couple points of
  123. share really out of nowhere versus the local pizza um pizza stores. And the reason is the smartphone because all of
  124. a sudden people now are ordering pizzas from Domino's and Pizza Hut's mobile apps, but the local pizza guy can't
  125. really compete with that. And you know, a big shareholder of ours showed that to
  126. me and said, you know, I'd bet you never thought you'd have something in common with Domino's Pizza, but the way you're
  127. dominating on mobile is very similar. And you're seeing this in other verticals as well. That's really
  128. fascinating. Um, one more question about how do you ensure the accuracy of your data? Uh I was talking to some real
  129. estate developers and they said that for some markets your data is absolutely spot-on accurate and other markets maybe
  130. not so much. Do you think that the quality of your data is sort of uneven and if so what are you doing to address
  131. that issue? Well, this is an industrywide problem which as the largest player in the industry we um we
  132. definitely have and it's something that we focus on and that we apply a lot of resources to. Um, the data on Zillow
  133. comes partly from county records and there it can be corrected by owners or agents, but it also comes to us by
  134. agents. And so, for example, when a listing agent posts a home for sale and if the home sells, he doesn't take it
  135. down, well, we have a stale listing. So, we've deployed a lot of software, a lot
  136. of business expertise, and a lot of money towards improving this problem. And we've come a long way, but it's an
  137. industrywide problem, which unfortunately I think will will continue to be something that we that we work on
  138. for for years. It is a problem. It's a problem in part because our sales records are are are county level. Uh
  139. it's actually in some ways stunning that we as a country do not collect the data
  140. and don't verify the data. Uh and some states have really poor and some cities have really poor collection
  141. methodologies. This is a concern on a wider scale. Uh for example, Fanny Freddy uh which are national players now
  142. taxpayer owned. uh they have a price index which uh arguably is far behind the Zillow price index. So this tells us
  143. we should be putting more public resources I think in this direction as well. Uh you're also doing some
  144. interesting work in the area of uh rental housing. Could you tell us a little bit about what are some of the
  145. challenges involved in that? Sure. So rentals is a very big area of investment for us. We bought three companies in the
  146. last 18 months uh there for over $60 million. We have about 100 people out of 600 people at the company focused
  147. exclusively on the rentals opportunity. And the reason that we're so excited about it is it's a $5 billion market.
  148. Property managers and landlords spend $5 billion advertising their listings to consumers. And the structure of the
  149. industry is quite different than the structure of the forale industry. Notably, it's it's disorganized. There
  150. are no in most markets outside of Manhattan, for example, it they're not broker controlled markets. So property
  151. managers and real estate developers market their listings directly on sort of a many to many approach rather than
  152. going through a centralized MLS or centralized brokerage system. And that allows us, we hope, the opportunity to
  153. create the marketplace to basically superset Craigslist. So to give you some numbers, there are 4 million rental
  154. units available for rent in the US at any point in time. Craigslist has about 750,000 of them. We have about 600,000
  155. and a year ago we had 300,000. Most other sites have about 100,000. So the strategy is to give away software, give
  156. away property management software to the industry for free. And one of the acquisitions that I mentioned is a
  157. company that that built that type of software. Give it away for free in order to out Craigslist. Craigslist to end up
  158. with many more listings than Craigslist and then hopefully we'll become the marketplace and then we can monetize it.
  159. So today we don't monetize rentals at all or hardly at all. Um, and we're delaying that gratification until we are
  160. the marketplace and then we can focus on monetizing it. What do you think of uh Zillow's strategy, Susan? I think the
  161. rental market is growing in the US. So, it's important to have that coverage. It's less organized as we said. So,
  162. that's a a real strategic move. But even more so going forward, there's a lot of
  163. information in the comparisons of rents to values. And to be able to get that accurately, that too will be a gamecher.
  164. So let me ask end with one last question. So in so many ways Zillow has been highly successful and to take just
  165. one metric uh since your IPO in 2011 your stock stock price has gone up to $55 and I just saw a report from Goldman
  166. Sachs setting a $60 target for it. Uh but regardless of what happens to the stock, what is your definition of
  167. success for Zillow? Um my definition of success is about creating a ever everlasting and enduring brand that my
  168. children or maybe someday grandchildren will know. Um there are very few technology companies that have created
  169. brands that endure for 10, 20, 30 years. Um you know Microsoft is really one of the only ones and I suppose Apple that
  170. has endured for a long long period of time. And to me it feels like we're just getting started. We have less than 1%
  171. revenue share across the 35 billion dollars in advertising in our space. Um, and we have a relatively little known
  172. brand relative to the size of the opportunity. Only about 12% of Americans, believe it or not, have heard
  173. of Zillow. Uh, if you ask Americans, and yet we're the leading real estate website. If you look at other
  174. categories, you know, name a finance website, 90% of people will say Erade or CNBC.com. Name a travel website, 90% of
  175. people will say Expedia. Name a healthcare website, 90% of people say WebMD. name a real estate website, 12%
  176. will say Zillow. That to me, you know, you might think as the CEO of Zillow, that would be depressing, but actually I
  177. get very excited about that opportunity. You know, think of all the potential. Um, and to me, that's success is closing
  178. that gap. And if we do that, then a lot of other great things will follow. Revenue, profit, market cap, etc. Great.
  179. Susan, you get the last words. Well, market information in real estate is almost contradictory in in very
  180. sense, but in fact, this is this contradiction is being undone and um we're we're bringing transparency and
  181. Zillow is one of the ways that's happening. So, I congratulate the firm. Good luck and thank you to both of you.
  182. Really glad you joined knowledge at Wharton today. Thank you. [Music]

Brief Summary

Susan Spencer and Spencer Rascoff discuss Zillow's role in the recovering housing market and the company's innovative business model.

Key points

  • Housing Market Recovery. Spencer reveals that the housing market is recovering with 16 months of appreciation.
  • Zillow's Unique Business Model. Spencer explains how Zillow's model differs from traditional real estate transactions.
  • The Zestimate Explained. Spencer describes how Zillow calculates home values through a complex algorithm.
  • Zillow's Rental Strategy. Zillow aims to dominate the rental market by giving away property management software.
  • Vision for Zillow's Future. Spencer shares his definition of success for Zillow and its brand longevity.
  • Zillow's Market Perception. Only 12% name Zillow as a real estate website, highlighting a significant opportunity.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes