Why Protecting Minority Shareholders Builds Stock Markets

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

While numerous factors play into whether a country has a dynamic financial market, there's one in particular that stands out, Wharton’s Mauro Guillen finds in a new paper. 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so we all know that financial markets and in particular equity markets don't develop every way in the world to the
  2. same extent we know that the US or the UK have very large equity markets and other countries have much smaller equity
  3. markets and my research addresses one of the reasons why we see those differences
  4. in the size and the vibrancy the dynamism of equity markets which is the extent to which the interests of
  5. minority shareholders are protected the argument is that when you have strong protections for the interest of minority
  6. shareholders then more people are willing to invest money in the stock market and as a result what you get is a
  7. larger stock market with more turnover and higher capitalization and more dynamism
  8. so what we did in this research is we coded the legislation exist in different countries since 1970 all the way to the
  9. present and we looked for legal provisions that protect the interest of minority shareholders and what we found
  10. was that at the beginning back in the 1970s the US and the UK and other countries that have a common law legal
  11. system having placed very strong protections for minority shareholders but then beginning the 1990s and
  12. especially over the last 15 years countries in Eastern Europe countries in Asia even some countries in Africa that
  13. used to have very very weak protections of minority shareholders change their legislation and they introduced actually
  14. quite strong protections and in some cases stronger than those present in the United States or the UK so in addition
  15. to finding that countries that didn't use to have strong legal protections now have them we also found that adopting
  16. the legal provisions defending the minority shareholders is not enough that you also need to enforce those kinds of
  17. regulations protecting minority shareholders and that is a very important finding because essentially it
  18. means that you know a lot of countries out there introduced these reforms for show only for so as window dressing but
  19. it's also important to follow up with enforcement otherwise you don't get the expected results which is you know the
  20. growth of stock market capitalization and a more dynamic equity market for me the biggest surprise coming out
  21. of this research project that was what happened in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet republics also including
  22. Russia itself because as you know most of these countries became independent in the 1990s so they didn't have their own
  23. separate corporate legislation and they were very aggressive in terms of introducing very advanced laws that
  24. protected minority shareholders and my assumption going in was that the in these countries actually the effects
  25. wouldn't be that great in terms of stock market development because I thought they were just adopting these things you
  26. know for fun they were just adopting these things to tell the IMF that they as they were introduced in reforms they
  27. were adding all of these new legal provisions just because they failed that it was the right thing to do so I was
  28. surprised to see that even within that set of countries right we're talking about maybe 20 or 25 countries in
  29. Eastern Europe and you know the former Soviet republics you observed that the implementation of these laws has
  30. resulted in the growth of a stock market which is something that I don't think most people would have expected and I
  31. certainly was not expecting well I think my reach has implications for both practitioners
  32. especially investors and for policymakers so let's start with investors for investors we all know that
  33. the world has become one big marketplace and essentially capital is chasing the best returns but obviously you also need
  34. to take into consideration the legal framework is not the same to invest in the US equity market as it is to invest
  35. let's say in the Nigerian equity market or in the Chinese equity market and that's for a variety of reasons what my
  36. research does is it you know cause the attention to the importance of legal institutions because at the end of the
  37. day portfolio investors they want to be protected they want to be able to sue they want to be able to have legal
  38. mechanisms at their disposal if they believe that they've been taken for a ride that's the implication for
  39. investors I offer them a map and in fact anyone can download the data that we have put together painstakingly for more
  40. than 70 countries between 1970 and the present time and those data are available from my website at the Wharton
  41. School now for policymakers I think the lesson is also clear which is that it does pay to introduce market-oriented
  42. reforms in the form of no legal institutions that support economic exchange and support the investment and
  43. at the present time as we all know governments around the world are competing against one another to attract
  44. investment so it is very very important for governments to realize that they need to have the right legal framework
  45. in place because the ultimately the development of their equity markets depends on the extent to which the
  46. protections of you know for minority investors are in place and also the extent to which they are actually
  47. enforced well I think the conventional wisdom is that there are safe markets in the world
  48. in which it is you know okay to invest and that you're likely not to lose your money for some you know strange reason
  49. other than that maybe you know the market goes south right meaning that it's very difficult for either the
  50. government or other interests to expropriate investors right which happens in many parts of the world I
  51. think that conventional wisdom is largely true that is to say yes you can classify countries right according to
  52. how easy it is for you to protect your rights as a minority investor what my research I think does is it addresses
  53. this myth that you know whatever the situation was back 30 years ago continues to be the same today that is
  54. to say what we observe is that laws and regulations concerning minority shareholders change all the time and
  55. countries that used to have very low protections do they actually have very strong protections in place and so it's
  56. very important for investors and for the general public i think to understand those legal frameworks because otherwise
  57. you could be making big mistakes as to exactly how you allocate your investments and let's not forget that
  58. most of us have a pension fund right and we can make choices about how we allocate you know the money that we have
  59. in it let's say between us equities and foreign equities and then within foreign
  60. equities different parts of the world so I think it's really important for us as
  61. citizens who have a pension fund to also understand these dynamics and how legal
  62. institutions effect or potentially can affect that returns to our investments what I think is unique about our
  63. research years how comprehensive the data are so we have hired more than 50 experts legal experts lawyers from
  64. different countries who speak the language and they read the relevant legislation over a period of 45 years
  65. since 1970 and they coded all of these different legal provisions so it is the detail that we have in our data it is
  66. the fact that we've covered nearly 80 countries more than 70 countries over 45 years that I think is unique about our
  67. research and the later can be downloaded for free from my own website within the
  68. Wharton school's website well now that we have these data on minority shareholder protections around
  69. the world we are planning to examine what happens after a major financial crisis such as for example the one that
  70. took place in 2008 as we know there's a lot of restructuring there's many marriages and acquisitions or what we
  71. want to understand is whether the way in which crises are resolved in which assets are restructured is different
  72. depending on the strength of different stakeholders in the firm and one very important stakeholder of course is
  73. minority shareholders and so we are expecting that the ways in which crisis unfold and ultimately are resolved are
  74. different depending on whether you're talking about a country that has very strong protection of minority
  75. shareholders versus another in which those protections are very weak you

Brief Summary

Strong minority shareholder protections lead to more dynamic equity markets, according to research from the Wharton School.

Key points

  • Impact of Minority Shareholder Protections. Research shows that strong protections for minority shareholders lead to larger, more dynamic equity markets.
  • Surprising Findings in Eastern Europe. Eastern European countries adopted strong protections for minority shareholders, leading to unexpected stock market growth.
  • Importance of Legal Frameworks for Investors. Investors must consider legal protections when investing globally, as they vary significantly by country.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes