Back to the Drawing Board for Catalonias Separatists
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
📂 Public Policy
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- I'm happy to welcome back professor morrow Guillen and he's a management professor here at Wharton and he's also
- a native of Spain which makes it especially appropriate because we want to talk about the recent elections in
- Catalonia which many saw as a kind of proxy for an independence movement there was a court decision in Spain last year
- which prevented a legal vote on independence as i understand it for Catalonia nevertheless these regional
- elections which have just taken place we're viewed by many as a sort of Club a site or a proxy of that and and could
- have had some sore could still have some serious ramifications so I wanted to ask
- some thought there was going to be a clean outcome it didn't come out so clean or so clear so could you put it in
- context and tell us it was a little bit messy and it's going to make the politics messy going yeah I think macys
- the word although as you know the mock receipts are always missing right but I think the outcome of these particular
- election is especially messy and of course you know this is only three days after the election has taken place so
- you know one also has to be careful about over interpreting the results because we don't know exactly what kinds
- of conversations and the coalition building efforts are being made by the various parties right depending on their
- seats in parliament i also want to clarify one important thing which is that i was born in spain but I've side
- of Catalonia although my father was from Catalonia so I don't claim though to represent both sides of the issue and
- you know i think in Spain and Catalonia everybody in the world is always differences of opinion and there's a
- diversity of views right but yeah the outcome is messy because on the one hand what you have is that the parties that
- were that proposed a independence for Catalonia won a majority of the seats but there are two parties there there
- were two lists competing for seats and they don't entirely agree as to what the process should be moving forward right
- that's one of the problems here the other is that although they got a majority of the votes the only of I'm
- sorry of the seats the only got about forty eight percent of the votes and the reason for that is that
- the electoral law is such that the rural areas in Catalonia have an over representation in Parliament relative to
- their population whereas the greater metropolitan area in Barcelona which includes many industrial towns around it
- iced under represented in terms of you know its population wait but the Nationalists the independent movement is
- a stronger in the rural areas in the smaller cities than it is in Barcelona itself so the result is very messy and I
- think it is fair to say that you know the last couple of years have you know resulted in a situation in which a
- Catalan society is deeply divided evenly split right apparently between these two
- options there is a lot of issues connected with this if there were an independent Catalonia I mean there's the
- membership in the EU this is assuming the Catalonia left which isn't we're not assuming that but if it did leave the
- membership in the EU using the Euro membership in NATO all of these things there's also a big issue about debt that
- Catalonia owns but hoes i should say but that's also tied in legally with with spain and spain's overall that could you
- talk about some of those issues well if a any part of an existing country where to become independent there's a you know
- a number of very difficult issues that need to be addressed one is there is dead as you said that may be attributed
- to the region but that that is actually right now dead of the entire country right but there's also resources right
- so those conversations those negotiations in any case not just in this case would be extremely difficult
- right because there are assets and there are liabilities and if there's a divorce
- you need to come up with some arrangement as to how you are dividing up not only the assets right but also
- the liabilities you know the issue of a european union membership and the issue of nato membership scythe inc those two
- are separate but I don't think they are as severe in this case as there would be in the Scottish
- case it's in the case of Scotland you won one has to remember is that most of the population in Scotland right is
- pro-european union right as it is in Spain and in Catalonia but if you go to England most of the population right a
- majority of the population is probably against membership in the European Union as you know Prime Minister David Cameron
- has promised and a referendum in the UK about EU membership right so that's one very big difference that is to say that
- if Scotland were to you know become independent in the UK right from the UK then probably England and Wales would
- leave the European Union because most people want to leave right but Scotland you know would become a member right how
- quickly it depends on how fast in Scotland we're able we'll be able to replicate the kinds of institutions that
- Europe expects you to have like a central bank like a you know all of the institutions of the of the of the state
- right in the case of Catalonia you know both are people living in Catalonia and people in the rest of Spain want to be
- part of the European Union so the issue there is would kind of lonely be ready right that would be the issue and the
- other issue of course is whether any existing member country with Vito right catalonia's membership because culinaire
- would need to apply and people are saying well Spain might veto it or somebody else my video Catalonia and
- that's obviously this thing possibility but what I think is very clear and you know this is not just an opinion of mine
- it's based on analysis right but of course there are other analysis that come to the opposite conclusion is that
- I think a separation of Catalonia from Spain would be at least in the short run right very harmful to both Spain and
- Catalonia right and I say this because obviously there is a very long shared history right but more importantly
- because it is still a fact that has been demonstrated by this election four days
- ago that the support for independence in Catalonia is at best half of half of the of the of the country right
- is half of the population so it's very difficult to set into motion a process of separation process for independence
- when you have fifty percent of the people living in that part of the country opposed to it the rifts the
- conflicts the frictions that these would create I think would be so severe that I
- think most reasonable people would think twice about the benefits from that sip and this is with in Catalonia so
- absolutely Catalonia you know the elections have demonstrated is divided now I would like to add another thing
- which is very important I think both the central government in Madrid and the Catalonian government with their actions
- have polarized public opinion and have polarized the voters as if there were only two choices right the two choices
- being things remain the same or Catalonia becomes independent and there is very good survey research indicating
- that if you offer catalonian people who live in Catalonia a third choice somewhere in between which is for
- example to renegotiate the way in which Catalonia relates to the rest of Spain or perhaps to create more of a federal
- system in space or Spain is not a federal country right like the United States or like Germany then if you offer
- that third intermediate choice then suddenly what you get is maybe twenty percent of people want independence
- twenty percent want the status quo but you have a large majority like sixty percent of the population who would
- rather take the third intermediate option so this is really interesting because I did want to get to the
- fundamental issue which is what is the big beef for those that want to become independent what is their chief
- complaint it has something to do with feeling that their region produces more tax per capita I guess than other
- regions so that they're giving the federal system more than they're getting back there's also i guess some
- historical reasons about how catalonia became part of spain to begin with which wasn't even all
- that long ago as I understand it and and there are some other thing so I did want
- to ask you what are the chief complaints for those that want to break away and then also may be compared as you did
- with with Scotland how the Catalonian system may be similar or different from say Quebec or maybe there's other
- aspects between the relationship of Scotland and England that you'd want to touch on all yeah absolutely so first of
- all I mean one has to be very respectful about you know people's identities and I
- think everybody has to respect that you know some people may feel more Catalan than Spanish or they may feel only
- Catalan right or they may feel Spanish but they also think that you know they they have a connection to Catalonia
- right so there's all sorts of identities and shared identities or dual identities
- that people have and I personally want to be like really respectful to all of them including you know the people who
- feel that colonial should be an independent country and they feel only Catalan you know the reality though is
- that those people are in the minority right that is the reality that is the fact that I think this election
- corroborates now having said that right there are also other more you know rational issues at play because identity
- is at the end of the day is an emotional issue but it should be respected right that's really important there's the
- money issue as you said so Catalonia is one of the three richest parts of Spain along with Madrid and the balearic
- islands which are on the Mediterranean well in every country in the world the parts of the country that are richer
- make a bigger contribution to the budget right just because they're Richard that
- happens in the united states california makes a bigger contribution than alabama
- right to the federal budget in the sense that they get back right in service is less than what they contribute in the
- form of taxes this happens everywhere right so the situation of Catalonia within Spain is different than the
- situation of Scotland in the UK because in Scotland because of the decline of manufacturing industry is not as rich as
- some other parts of England especially the london metropolitan area right and that's also the case in in canada with
- Quebec so the Catalonian case is different right so absolutely I mean catalonia is contributing more to the
- central budget but that's not necessarily because it is being discriminated against a lot of that are
- not saying that all of it but a lot of that is driven by the fact another Richard right and therefore in any
- political system in any arrangement right that you can find you will always see that Richard regions contribute more
- proportionally speaking than the amount of services or the value of the services
- that they get from the central budget right so I think that's important to clarify and having said that once again
- there are people who believe that California should be independent I think they are more driven by their identity
- and their sense of identity as opposed to by the numbers right although the numbers as they exist today accessor
- bait that feeling right that feeling of oh will contribute a lot but you see an independent Catalonia in the context of
- Europe right will also be richer than the average country in Europe so they would also make a net contribution to
- the rest of Europe right and as you know Europe has very aggressive programs in place to help relatively backward parts
- of Europe cope with that backwardness and you know they get more money for investments in infrastructure and so on
- and so forth so Catalonia will always be because it reaches a successful you know
- country right it will always be a net contributor right even if it became a an independent state within within Europe
- two last questions what what do you think is most likely to happen realizing you gave the qualifier upfront that
- we're just after the election and the dust is settling so to speak and also is there a risk where i should say how big
- is the risk that over this debt issue it's a fairly substantial debt as i understand it and if there was some
- breakdown between spain and catalina could could that possibly lead to a financial crisis that would affect the
- rest of europe well I i think the you know once again even if there's no independence of Catalonia just the the
- messy political environment in which you know the relationship between Catalonia
- on the rest of Spain or the central government is in now I think is something that doesn't create the right
- conditions for investment that for job creation right the Spanish economy including catalonia's actually do
- quite well it is one of the fastest growing economies in Europe right now growing at slightly more than three
- percent right which is not bad given the circumstances so this uncertainty is going to be detrimental to economic
- growth and job creation but the other big thing that is coming up its end in December we have national elections in
- Spain so quite frankly I think the answer to your question as to what's going to happen next in Catalonia is
- that everything pretty much everything it's going to you know wait until you know the December election which is two
- and a half months away right and depending on the outcome of that election then we will see what's going
- to happen with the essentially this you know impasse that we have in Catalonia this situation in which you have one
- half of Catalonia being in favor of independence apparently right given the election results and another have been
- opposed to it although remember that I said that if you're give them a third option the situation would change right
- but essentially there's two possibilities here one is that the new government emerging in Madrid will be
- similar to the one that we have now which as I told you earlier has been trying to polarize the issue as if there
- were only two options right or there's another possibility which is that a different kind of government emerges and
- is one that is willing to propose a third intermediate option right and so depending on the outcome of the national
- election in which actually Colonel O'Neill's will also get to vote then we will see you know things evolving in
- Catalonia itself beginning in january down the path of more conflict and more friction and i think a continuing you
- know gridlock right because essentially the two opposing views are very balanced
- right or as an alternative you know they will be down the path of maybe a constitutional reform maybe very
- extensive negotiations as to a redefinition of how the not just Catalonia but possibly also other parts
- of Spain relate to the central government and there is a lot of discussion for example about taking some
- steps towards a federal system alright well we'll have to wait and see if it's a happier new year there
- in Spain and Catalonia thank you very much for coming in thank you for having me
- you
Brief Summary
Professor Morrow Guillen discusses Catalonia's recent elections and the complexities of its independence movement.
Key points
- Catalonia's Election Results. The recent elections in Catalonia revealed a divided electorate, complicating the independence movement.
- Divided Opinions in Catalonia. Support for independence is split, with many preferring a third option.
- Economic Implications of Political Uncertainty. The political tensions in Catalonia could hinder economic growth and investment.
Episode highlights
- Catalonia's Election ResultsThe recent elections in Catalonia revealed a divided electorate, complicating the independence movement.“The outcome is messy because the parties proposed independence won a majority.”1:46Oct 6, 2015
- Divided Opinions in CataloniaSupport for independence is split, with many preferring a third option.“If you offer a third choice, suddenly 60% prefer that option.”8:13Oct 6, 2015
- Economic Implications of Political UncertaintyThe political tensions in Catalonia could hinder economic growth and investment.“The messy political environment doesn't create the right conditions for investment.”13:12Oct 6, 2015
Tension
50/ 100Some tension





