Is U.S. Government Debt Different?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

With the spotlight on U.S. budget cuts, a timely book looks at the unique nature of the country's debt and the options available to avoid hitting the debt ceiling. Is U.S. Government Debt Different? -- published by the Wharton Financial Institutions Center as a collection of 15 articles -- is co-edited by Wharton finance professor Franklin Allen, who shares insights from the book with Knowledge@Wharton. 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] we're meeting today with Wharton Finance Professor Franklin Allen who's also one
  2. of the editors of a new book titled is US Government debt different the book's a collection of about 15
  3. articles based on a conference here at the University of Pennsylvania earlier this year or last year actually uh it's
  4. great to have you back uh and um it's a pretty timely topic uh given recurring talk of debt sealing and uh forced
  5. spending cuts through sequestering and also ongoing debt crisis in Europe um tell us what some of the major themes of
  6. this collection of Articles were what were some of the main ideas to come out of it well this book really arose as a
  7. result of the problems that we had with raising the debt ceiling back in July and August of
  8. 2011 and I think one of the things that that episode underlined was that there was very little knowledge about what
  9. would happen if they didn't raise the debt ceing and and how that would play out would there be a default
  10. as many people were claiming what would that mean and so forth so the Wharton financial institution
  11. Center in conjunction with the law school decided that we should hold this conference and have a whole range of of
  12. disciplines included and just look in general is US Government de different it certainly plays a very important role in
  13. the global economy and because of the nature of our constitution there are a lot of issues
  14. which are rather different than in other countries so we talked about the debt cealing but there are real issues about
  15. whether it's possible for the US to default or not the 14th amendment has a section which or which
  16. states that the validity of the US debt shall not be questioned and there's a real issue as to what exactly does that
  17. mean does that mean that we're constitutionally prohibited from defaulting or or what
  18. does it mean that we can push payments into the future or what so one of the the main issues was what would happen if
  19. we hit the debt ceiling and I think uh two of the very interesting articles by legal experts were looking at that so uh
  20. Professor McConnell from Stanford University had a very interesting history of of how that
  21. Clause got into the Constitution and how it would be interpreted and then um the
  22. treasury likely react if we did hit the ceiling for a prolonged series of time so that was one very important part of
  23. the book but it also has many other themes to it which is what's the historical background how did US debt
  24. get its special characteristics so we start with a historical description of Alexander Hamilton and so forth and then
  25. also we looked at the long run problem that we have in the US in the sense that we are spending and are likely to go on
  26. spending as we get into the baby boom retirement years much more on Social Security but particularly Medicare and
  27. Medicaid then we're raising in taxes and we have to do something about that and that's of course what much of the
  28. negotiations this year are going to be about and we we start with this sequester in March 1st and then we have
  29. a whole sequence of events the run out of spending Authority for for large parts of the federal budget in March and
  30. then we have uh the the debt ceiling coming up again so there are many other issues and and the book deals with with
  31. many of those and give tries to give a very broad view of the US debt situation the the debt ceiling coming up
  32. again so there are many other issues and and the book deals with with many of those and give tries to give a very
  33. broad view of the US debt situation it sounds uh very very in-depth and comprehensive um a lay person outside
  34. looking in about the debt might ask a a question such as well the US is the global Reserve currency um we're not in
  35. any sort of monetary Union we can always print more money not to say there aren't
  36. consequences inflation and so forth but to get out of a short-term Jam for which
  37. you'd have to patch things up later you can always print money and get out of it
  38. and also um for us investors in particular but Global Investors there what currency is there that is anywhere
  39. near as risk-free um and also able to handle the volumes um that that US currency can take up for investors so so
  40. there's just nothing comparable therefore the argument would be everyone's always going to be buying us
  41. treasuries aren't they so this is one of the very interesting issues so certainly
  42. at the moment particularly with the problems in the Euro Zone the US does have a dominant position uh the Euro
  43. Zone I I think many people expected to become a much more important currency in the sense that it would perhaps rival
  44. and and maybe even overtake in terms of the foreign exchange reserves held by central banks the US dollar that hasn't
  45. happened because of things like the Greek default and other problems that are out there in the longer run the
  46. Chinese R&B is likely to become another Reserve currency in my view that's probably 10 15 maybe 20 years away but
  47. at the moment certainly the US dollar is supreme and we see that with the S&P downgraded us because of the problems in
  48. July and August 2011 it really didn't affect things very much at all so I agree now they can print money but as
  49. your question suggested there are problems with that and uh the inflationary consequences and also the redistribution
  50. consequences of doing anything like that would be very large indeed and it would
  51. be very problematic if we were to do that in my view and some of those ideas I'm sure came out at the conference yes
  52. and so there a discussion of various things that we might do um Professor money from the law school has a very
  53. nice paper which is a very Pro provocative one and talks about what would be happening maybe 5 to 10 years
  54. from now if we had a 60% inflation rate in the US would 60% yes it's very it's very provocative um he has Professor
  55. president uh Sarah Palin in office and 60% sounds like a good movie yes we're a bad moving on so as you know what would
  56. be the options would we really want to have that kind of inflation rate or would we rather go in the direction of
  57. some kind of negotiated default so the these are issues which at the moment are a far far away from us the debt ceiling
  58. isn't to be clear but the long-term problems and and and so forth um are not imminent but they are there and
  59. financial have markets have a way of bringing the future to the present rather quickly um you mentioned that as a
  60. provocative idea another provocative idea by uh one of the contributors uh was that to help us get out of debt we
  61. sell off uh the family jewels in effect that we that we look at asset sales and when you look at asset sales in the US
  62. you're looking at mineral rights that that sort of energy rights um but um also was suggest that we sell off chunks
  63. of of one of our states Alaska which happens to be 85% owned by the federal government I think um which is I guess
  64. why that would even be presented but how was that received by by the group that idea I think uh Jim milstein who wrote
  65. that that essay wanted to stress that we are in a long run situation which is not a good
  66. one and the point the starting point there is in fact large parts of our country
  67. the Louisiana Purchase and the Alaska Purchase were made by countries that had massive fiscal
  68. problems and this was their solution to sell off large chunks and I think he wanted among other things to underline
  69. that we do have a serious situation and we need to worry about this and as you say they are you know the notion of
  70. selling off Alaska is something that I think most people would regard with with horror and that's I think underlines
  71. that we need to do something about this is not something that we can just push into the future like we've been doing we
  72. really need to do something now mineral rights are a little bit different I think uh there that's a valid way of
  73. raising revenues one of the very interesting things about that article is it it doesn't raise much money any of
  74. these strategies relative to the national debt so so it was meant to be provoc I think it was yes
  75. um were there any um particular um strong themes that would come out as um prescriptions for policy
  76. makers um maybe new ideas that even fairly well-informed people haven't heard of yet anything new that you could
  77. say this is these are there here's an interesting set of ideas that policy makers really should be considering
  78. that's maybe a little bit different than what's being talked about now now so I think in the in the literature there's a
  79. whole range of these ideas so I'm not sure that any of the ideas presented were particularly new it was
  80. really bringing together the literatures from a very diverse set of Scholars to to look at the problem seriously and I I
  81. think you know the major theme apart from the short run issues with the debt ceiling and the
  82. Constitutional issues there are to do with this long-term problem that we have we we are on a course to
  83. spend more than we raise in taxes and one way or another we've got to change that and there are many ways to do that
  84. one of the Intriguing ones was comparing the differences on our tax systems with
  85. those of other Advanced industrialized countries and basically we are an outlier we pay less in taxes but we
  86. we need to change that if we want to keep our benefit levels where they are and the main thing that is different is
  87. that we have a much lower proportion of GDP raised in sales taxes or Vats as they call them in in Europe value added
  88. taxes and if we ever need a silver bullet that is potentially one way we can simply solve the problem so a
  89. national sales tax a national sales tax or value added tax it it's well known how to do that they're very effective
  90. and we can easily raise 5 to 10% of GDP and just plug the Gap now of course there huge political problems to do that
  91. to do that but that is and no one's talking about that particular solution but I think that was one of the things
  92. that was very interesting that was raised in the conference probably go for that before selling off Alaska don't you
  93. think yes I think that that would be a much better solution part of um so we have some national taxes now some things
  94. do we on liquor perhaps are there National or cigarettes perhaps I guess there is on gasoline some syntax well
  95. gasoline also yeah so there are a few but they're not significant Revenue raises we raise about 4 and a half to 5%
  96. of GDP but that's mostly state sales taxes but I mean there's a presentent it wouldn't be completely breaking new
  97. ground in other words to have a fedal sales tax on something not as if that a constitutional amendment I don't think
  98. it is it's it's it's a political issue rather than a legal issue okay around 1999 or so not so far back the US had a
  99. relatively low debt it was shrinking it was shrinking so much that um fed chairman Alan Greenspan was starting to
  100. express worry that we might not have enough debt why why would that be a bad thing I guess because you need a certain
  101. amount of debt instruments to finance retirements of different sorts whether it's Social Security or private
  102. retirement plans um and that um um we were sort of running out of treasury bills to sell it sounds hard to believe
  103. today because it you know it's not that long ago and our problems are so different today but how how was that
  104. such a turnaround so in the late 90s we had the the uh Tech bubble in the stock market
  105. and we had a lot of asset pricings going up dramatically what that led to was was
  106. big tax receipts from the capital gains tax and and various other taxes and so that enabled the government to
  107. pay down the debt and they also got a lot just because the economy was booming so much and then after the tech Bubble
  108. Burst then we had problems and in the sense so we weren't having this big um excess of of revenues over over uh like
  109. over expenditures and so that problem went away rather quickly and now we have this other problem
  110. which can also if you look at um projections can explode quite easily it can also be solved uh the real problem
  111. is Medicare if you're going to guarantee people a certain level of of of Health Care and not do it in dollar terms as as
  112. chairman Ryan proposed in his plan then you have got this rather open-ended liability and and that's the real issue
  113. I think which which we need to tackle with just a couple minutes left what other ideas um came out of the book or
  114. the conference or and what other um ideas from that would you like to tell us about um do I think you know the
  115. interesting one would is which we may get to this year is how would a a uh de hitting of the debt ceiling work and my
  116. own reading o of the papers on this is that we will not default I think for the administration to actually even go into
  117. technical default would cause so much in the way of legal problems and constitutional challenges that they
  118. won't do that and uh one of the things that that the book outlines is that the various options in terms of
  119. prioritizing payments so that what we could do we'll still have a lot of Revenue coming in so that what we could
  120. do is prioritize the debt and so um that that the interest on that gets repaid and to the extent issues are retired
  121. that we're able to new we go down below the de seing and we able to issue new issues to replace them and so on so we
  122. would keep the debt hole and then the question is what else would we pay well there are various technical ways that we
  123. can pay social security and Medicare and Medicaid so that would be uh fairly safe
  124. for a while at least and then I find it very difficult to believe that any government would not pay the military so
  125. they would probably get priority too and then the question would be who else would be prioritized uh there may be
  126. some other groups that they decid politically have to be paid but then the suggestion in in Professor Jackson's
  127. chapter is to have um first in first out so he would stack up all the bills as the revenue that was in excess of these
  128. prioritized ones was um came in you would start paying the top of the pile and gradually of course what would
  129. happen is you would lengthen the time period before people were paid but eventually everybody will be paid but it
  130. may take some time and of course in the meantime the pressure on uh Congress and
  131. the president will be very large to do something about this who would be at the bottom of the
  132. Heap hopefully Congressional house members in the Senate perfect symmetry okay and I guess
  133. we have we have that we have that Clause as part of the Republican bill that was
  134. passed how interesting okay so then so then we're safe nothing's ever going to happen a good good thinking thank you
  135. for joining us and uh for telling us about the book if anybody wants to download this book then it's available
  136. on the financial institution Center website so if you just Google Wharton financial institution Center you can go
  137. there and Download a pdf if anybody would like to have a hard copy then please just write to us and we can mail
  138. one out to you and the downloaded copies are free the downloaded copies are free
  139. and the hard copies are also free if anybody would like that's a great price thank you thanks very much
  140. [Music]

Brief Summary

Franklin Allen discusses US government debt, the debt ceiling, and fiscal policy solutions in this episode.

Key points

  • The Debt Ceiling Dilemma. A discussion on the implications of not raising the debt ceiling and potential defaults.
  • The US Dollar's Dominance. Analyzing the current status of the US dollar as a global reserve currency.
  • Inflation Concerns. Discussing the potential consequences of a high inflation rate in the US.
  • Provocative Ideas for Debt Solutions. Exploring unconventional proposals like selling state assets to manage national debt.
  • Long-term Financial Challenges. Addressing the ongoing issues of spending exceeding tax revenue in the US.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes