Is U.S. Government Debt Different?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
With the spotlight on U.S. budget cuts, a timely book looks at the unique nature of the country's debt and the options available to avoid hitting the debt ceiling. Is U.S. Government Debt Different? -- published by the Wharton Financial Institutions Center as a collection of 15 articles -- is co-edited by Wharton finance professor Franklin Allen, who shares insights from the book with Knowledge@Wharton. 📂 Finance & Accounting
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] we're meeting today with Wharton Finance Professor Franklin Allen who's also one
- of the editors of a new book titled is US Government debt different the book's a collection of about 15
- articles based on a conference here at the University of Pennsylvania earlier this year or last year actually uh it's
- great to have you back uh and um it's a pretty timely topic uh given recurring talk of debt sealing and uh forced
- spending cuts through sequestering and also ongoing debt crisis in Europe um tell us what some of the major themes of
- this collection of Articles were what were some of the main ideas to come out of it well this book really arose as a
- result of the problems that we had with raising the debt ceiling back in July and August of
- 2011 and I think one of the things that that episode underlined was that there was very little knowledge about what
- would happen if they didn't raise the debt ceing and and how that would play out would there be a default
- as many people were claiming what would that mean and so forth so the Wharton financial institution
- Center in conjunction with the law school decided that we should hold this conference and have a whole range of of
- disciplines included and just look in general is US Government de different it certainly plays a very important role in
- the global economy and because of the nature of our constitution there are a lot of issues
- which are rather different than in other countries so we talked about the debt cealing but there are real issues about
- whether it's possible for the US to default or not the 14th amendment has a section which or which
- states that the validity of the US debt shall not be questioned and there's a real issue as to what exactly does that
- mean does that mean that we're constitutionally prohibited from defaulting or or what
- does it mean that we can push payments into the future or what so one of the the main issues was what would happen if
- we hit the debt ceiling and I think uh two of the very interesting articles by legal experts were looking at that so uh
- Professor McConnell from Stanford University had a very interesting history of of how that
- Clause got into the Constitution and how it would be interpreted and then um the
- treasury likely react if we did hit the ceiling for a prolonged series of time so that was one very important part of
- the book but it also has many other themes to it which is what's the historical background how did US debt
- get its special characteristics so we start with a historical description of Alexander Hamilton and so forth and then
- also we looked at the long run problem that we have in the US in the sense that we are spending and are likely to go on
- spending as we get into the baby boom retirement years much more on Social Security but particularly Medicare and
- Medicaid then we're raising in taxes and we have to do something about that and that's of course what much of the
- negotiations this year are going to be about and we we start with this sequester in March 1st and then we have
- a whole sequence of events the run out of spending Authority for for large parts of the federal budget in March and
- then we have uh the the debt ceiling coming up again so there are many other issues and and the book deals with with
- many of those and give tries to give a very broad view of the US debt situation the the debt ceiling coming up
- again so there are many other issues and and the book deals with with many of those and give tries to give a very
- broad view of the US debt situation it sounds uh very very in-depth and comprehensive um a lay person outside
- looking in about the debt might ask a a question such as well the US is the global Reserve currency um we're not in
- any sort of monetary Union we can always print more money not to say there aren't
- consequences inflation and so forth but to get out of a short-term Jam for which
- you'd have to patch things up later you can always print money and get out of it
- and also um for us investors in particular but Global Investors there what currency is there that is anywhere
- near as risk-free um and also able to handle the volumes um that that US currency can take up for investors so so
- there's just nothing comparable therefore the argument would be everyone's always going to be buying us
- treasuries aren't they so this is one of the very interesting issues so certainly
- at the moment particularly with the problems in the Euro Zone the US does have a dominant position uh the Euro
- Zone I I think many people expected to become a much more important currency in the sense that it would perhaps rival
- and and maybe even overtake in terms of the foreign exchange reserves held by central banks the US dollar that hasn't
- happened because of things like the Greek default and other problems that are out there in the longer run the
- Chinese R&B is likely to become another Reserve currency in my view that's probably 10 15 maybe 20 years away but
- at the moment certainly the US dollar is supreme and we see that with the S&P downgraded us because of the problems in
- July and August 2011 it really didn't affect things very much at all so I agree now they can print money but as
- your question suggested there are problems with that and uh the inflationary consequences and also the redistribution
- consequences of doing anything like that would be very large indeed and it would
- be very problematic if we were to do that in my view and some of those ideas I'm sure came out at the conference yes
- and so there a discussion of various things that we might do um Professor money from the law school has a very
- nice paper which is a very Pro provocative one and talks about what would be happening maybe 5 to 10 years
- from now if we had a 60% inflation rate in the US would 60% yes it's very it's very provocative um he has Professor
- president uh Sarah Palin in office and 60% sounds like a good movie yes we're a bad moving on so as you know what would
- be the options would we really want to have that kind of inflation rate or would we rather go in the direction of
- some kind of negotiated default so the these are issues which at the moment are a far far away from us the debt ceiling
- isn't to be clear but the long-term problems and and and so forth um are not imminent but they are there and
- financial have markets have a way of bringing the future to the present rather quickly um you mentioned that as a
- provocative idea another provocative idea by uh one of the contributors uh was that to help us get out of debt we
- sell off uh the family jewels in effect that we that we look at asset sales and when you look at asset sales in the US
- you're looking at mineral rights that that sort of energy rights um but um also was suggest that we sell off chunks
- of of one of our states Alaska which happens to be 85% owned by the federal government I think um which is I guess
- why that would even be presented but how was that received by by the group that idea I think uh Jim milstein who wrote
- that that essay wanted to stress that we are in a long run situation which is not a good
- one and the point the starting point there is in fact large parts of our country
- the Louisiana Purchase and the Alaska Purchase were made by countries that had massive fiscal
- problems and this was their solution to sell off large chunks and I think he wanted among other things to underline
- that we do have a serious situation and we need to worry about this and as you say they are you know the notion of
- selling off Alaska is something that I think most people would regard with with horror and that's I think underlines
- that we need to do something about this is not something that we can just push into the future like we've been doing we
- really need to do something now mineral rights are a little bit different I think uh there that's a valid way of
- raising revenues one of the very interesting things about that article is it it doesn't raise much money any of
- these strategies relative to the national debt so so it was meant to be provoc I think it was yes
- um were there any um particular um strong themes that would come out as um prescriptions for policy
- makers um maybe new ideas that even fairly well-informed people haven't heard of yet anything new that you could
- say this is these are there here's an interesting set of ideas that policy makers really should be considering
- that's maybe a little bit different than what's being talked about now now so I think in the in the literature there's a
- whole range of these ideas so I'm not sure that any of the ideas presented were particularly new it was
- really bringing together the literatures from a very diverse set of Scholars to to look at the problem seriously and I I
- think you know the major theme apart from the short run issues with the debt ceiling and the
- Constitutional issues there are to do with this long-term problem that we have we we are on a course to
- spend more than we raise in taxes and one way or another we've got to change that and there are many ways to do that
- one of the Intriguing ones was comparing the differences on our tax systems with
- those of other Advanced industrialized countries and basically we are an outlier we pay less in taxes but we
- we need to change that if we want to keep our benefit levels where they are and the main thing that is different is
- that we have a much lower proportion of GDP raised in sales taxes or Vats as they call them in in Europe value added
- taxes and if we ever need a silver bullet that is potentially one way we can simply solve the problem so a
- national sales tax a national sales tax or value added tax it it's well known how to do that they're very effective
- and we can easily raise 5 to 10% of GDP and just plug the Gap now of course there huge political problems to do that
- to do that but that is and no one's talking about that particular solution but I think that was one of the things
- that was very interesting that was raised in the conference probably go for that before selling off Alaska don't you
- think yes I think that that would be a much better solution part of um so we have some national taxes now some things
- do we on liquor perhaps are there National or cigarettes perhaps I guess there is on gasoline some syntax well
- gasoline also yeah so there are a few but they're not significant Revenue raises we raise about 4 and a half to 5%
- of GDP but that's mostly state sales taxes but I mean there's a presentent it wouldn't be completely breaking new
- ground in other words to have a fedal sales tax on something not as if that a constitutional amendment I don't think
- it is it's it's it's a political issue rather than a legal issue okay around 1999 or so not so far back the US had a
- relatively low debt it was shrinking it was shrinking so much that um fed chairman Alan Greenspan was starting to
- express worry that we might not have enough debt why why would that be a bad thing I guess because you need a certain
- amount of debt instruments to finance retirements of different sorts whether it's Social Security or private
- retirement plans um and that um um we were sort of running out of treasury bills to sell it sounds hard to believe
- today because it you know it's not that long ago and our problems are so different today but how how was that
- such a turnaround so in the late 90s we had the the uh Tech bubble in the stock market
- and we had a lot of asset pricings going up dramatically what that led to was was
- big tax receipts from the capital gains tax and and various other taxes and so that enabled the government to
- pay down the debt and they also got a lot just because the economy was booming so much and then after the tech Bubble
- Burst then we had problems and in the sense so we weren't having this big um excess of of revenues over over uh like
- over expenditures and so that problem went away rather quickly and now we have this other problem
- which can also if you look at um projections can explode quite easily it can also be solved uh the real problem
- is Medicare if you're going to guarantee people a certain level of of of Health Care and not do it in dollar terms as as
- chairman Ryan proposed in his plan then you have got this rather open-ended liability and and that's the real issue
- I think which which we need to tackle with just a couple minutes left what other ideas um came out of the book or
- the conference or and what other um ideas from that would you like to tell us about um do I think you know the
- interesting one would is which we may get to this year is how would a a uh de hitting of the debt ceiling work and my
- own reading o of the papers on this is that we will not default I think for the administration to actually even go into
- technical default would cause so much in the way of legal problems and constitutional challenges that they
- won't do that and uh one of the things that that the book outlines is that the various options in terms of
- prioritizing payments so that what we could do we'll still have a lot of Revenue coming in so that what we could
- do is prioritize the debt and so um that that the interest on that gets repaid and to the extent issues are retired
- that we're able to new we go down below the de seing and we able to issue new issues to replace them and so on so we
- would keep the debt hole and then the question is what else would we pay well there are various technical ways that we
- can pay social security and Medicare and Medicaid so that would be uh fairly safe
- for a while at least and then I find it very difficult to believe that any government would not pay the military so
- they would probably get priority too and then the question would be who else would be prioritized uh there may be
- some other groups that they decid politically have to be paid but then the suggestion in in Professor Jackson's
- chapter is to have um first in first out so he would stack up all the bills as the revenue that was in excess of these
- prioritized ones was um came in you would start paying the top of the pile and gradually of course what would
- happen is you would lengthen the time period before people were paid but eventually everybody will be paid but it
- may take some time and of course in the meantime the pressure on uh Congress and
- the president will be very large to do something about this who would be at the bottom of the
- Heap hopefully Congressional house members in the Senate perfect symmetry okay and I guess
- we have we have that we have that Clause as part of the Republican bill that was
- passed how interesting okay so then so then we're safe nothing's ever going to happen a good good thinking thank you
- for joining us and uh for telling us about the book if anybody wants to download this book then it's available
- on the financial institution Center website so if you just Google Wharton financial institution Center you can go
- there and Download a pdf if anybody would like to have a hard copy then please just write to us and we can mail
- one out to you and the downloaded copies are free the downloaded copies are free
- and the hard copies are also free if anybody would like that's a great price thank you thanks very much
- [Music]
Brief Summary
Franklin Allen discusses US government debt, the debt ceiling, and fiscal policy solutions in this episode.
Key points
- The Debt Ceiling Dilemma. A discussion on the implications of not raising the debt ceiling and potential defaults.
- The US Dollar's Dominance. Analyzing the current status of the US dollar as a global reserve currency.
- Inflation Concerns. Discussing the potential consequences of a high inflation rate in the US.
- Provocative Ideas for Debt Solutions. Exploring unconventional proposals like selling state assets to manage national debt.
- Long-term Financial Challenges. Addressing the ongoing issues of spending exceeding tax revenue in the US.
Episode highlights
- The Debt Ceiling DilemmaA discussion on the implications of not raising the debt ceiling and potential defaults.“What would happen if we hit the debt ceiling?”2:45Feb 27, 2013
- The US Dollar's DominanceAnalyzing the current status of the US dollar as a global reserve currency.“The US dollar is supreme.”6:21Feb 27, 2013
- Inflation ConcernsDiscussing the potential consequences of a high inflation rate in the US.“60% inflation rate in the US?”7:15Feb 27, 2013
- Provocative Ideas for Debt SolutionsExploring unconventional proposals like selling state assets to manage national debt.“Selling off Alaska is something that most people would regard with horror.”9:31Feb 27, 2013
- Long-term Financial ChallengesAddressing the ongoing issues of spending exceeding tax revenue in the US.“We are on a course to spend more than we raise in taxes.”11:05Feb 27, 2013
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





