How the U.S. Can Get Its Debt Under Control

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Kent Smetters, Boettner Professor and Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy at the Wharton School, says U.S. debt has topped $38 trillion, driven by rising interest costs and entitlement spending. He notes the U.S. already has one of the most progressive tax systems but collects less revenue than other major economies. Fixing the imbalance will require both new broad-based taxes and gradual increases in the retirement age. Tariffs, he adds, are an inefficient way to raise money and hurt growth. Real progress depends on long-term, bipartisan fiscal reform, rather than short-term politics.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#FederalDebt #FiscalPolicy #BudgetDeficit #NationalDebt #TaxPolicy #EconomicUpdates #Tariffs #GovernmentShutdown ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The US economy saw its national debt climb above $ 38 trillion recently. But what may be even more concerning is the
  2. fact that it just passed 37 trillion two months prior. Part of that is higher interest rates. You have the higher
  3. interest payments title uh to those. It all means that we're racking up more and
  4. more debt at double the pace we saw at the beginning of the century. Now the bigger question, how can the problem be
  5. addressed and chart a new course like starting to reduce the debt? Kent Smatters is a professor of business
  6. economics and public policy at the Wharton School. He is also faculty director of the Penn Wharton to budget
  7. model. Hi Kent, how are you? >> Good to be back. Thank you. >> $ 38 trillion question right now. How do
  8. you address it? >> Yeah. Uh 8 trillion of that 38 is kind of the government you oweing itself. And
  9. so what we call the debt held by the public that did also hit a new high around $30 trillion. And so you know we
  10. are approaching almost World War II levels of debt relative to the size of the economy u which peaked in 1946.
  11. But um you know the difference relative to World War II is that um every projection given the current fiscal path
  12. has the debt GDP ratio going up even more. Um whereas after World War II it was you know a very punctuated spending
  13. and you know now uh you know spending went way down and therefore the debt GDP ratio also uh fell quite a bit. Where
  14. can you cut? I mean obviously there are a lot of public programs that are very important uh that you really can't do a
  15. whole lot with. Uh but where can you cut to try and maybe start to make an impact?
  16. >> Right. I mean there's a couple uh facts. It's not just potentially cutting. You
  17. could also potentially even get more revenue. So let's actually talk first about the revenue side. Um so two facts
  18. are uh important here. One, it is true that the United States has some of the lowest revenue relative to GDP amongst
  19. the OECD countries. But it's also true um that the United States has by far the most progressive income tax system rel
  20. relative to the OECD. And so um those on the left, you know, will often emphasize
  21. the first point, but then forget the second point and you know, conservatives will often emphasize the second and
  22. forget the first. And I think it's uh one of those things that's about balance. And that is you can only get so
  23. much out of progressive income tax system. And unless you go broadbased taxes like in Europe a value added tax
  24. things like that it's really hard to get more revenue um we're always squeezing that limit pretty tight. Um in terms of
  25. the spending side big drivers are things like growth of entitlement programs. Now on one hand it
  26. we knew that was coming and we didn't save it out for that. On the other hand, a lot of money can be achieved in terms
  27. of cost saving eventually by simply continuing to increase the retirement age, the normal retirement age at least,
  28. um, over time. And it doesn't have to be done immediately. We're talking about maybe for people under age, you know, 50
  29. instead of the retirement age being 67, it's going to be 67 and a couple months and then gradually increase with life
  30. expectancy over time. And so it's really that um the fact that it's not just that
  31. we're going to have a lot more retirees going into uh retirement is that they are continuing to live longer and we
  32. don't have that adjustment in both the health care program and in social security. So a combination of some
  33. revenue now um and then some cost savings in the long run it can put us on a sustainable path. It's it just
  34. requires both parties are very far away from anything that's they're talk anything related to um sustainability
  35. and but there are options. >> Well and in the midst of a government shutdown right now they've got a few
  36. other things that they're worried about. Um there is though some urgency especially
  37. on the social security point of it if you go by a lot of the estimates that have been out there the last few years
  38. that you know the issues of social security are going to come to a head in in about a decade maybe even less.
  39. >> Yeah even less. It's probably about uh 8 years or so. We're us uh the Congressional Budget Office and the
  40. Social Security Administration are basically around the same uh date and we're like kind of the three groups are
  41. doing independent estimation of that. And so I think it's um that's definitely true and unfortunately the last time uh
  42. the Social Security trust fund was about to deplete of its assets, we waited till
  43. kind of the last minute to make changes and that was really unfortunate. Hopefully we, you know, we get a little
  44. bit better at it now. Um, but nonetheless, um, it's one of those things that I think what you're starting
  45. to see is some very populous measures that people are proposing right now. Um, there seems to be this kind of this myth
  46. that, you know, if we in fact just go after the companies and have the companies pay more, um, because, you
  47. know, social security taxes are split between indiv uh, workers and companies that somehow that that's better than
  48. just having workers contribute more. In fact, economists agree from both you the
  49. left like Joe Stiglets to the right like Harvey Rose and they both have textbooks
  50. in public economics. It it it turns out it doesn't really matter which side that
  51. you tax whether it's workers or companies. The net impact of who really pays in the uh is going to all of the
  52. adjusted in the form of wages. And as a result of that, it doesn't really matter
  53. which side that you tax. um it doesn't mean that one's going to bear more than the other. It just means it doesn't
  54. really matter. So, we have to get away from some of these populist things and really do serious analysis of what's the
  55. economic impact? >> Well, and and uh then the revenue from tariffs that we've seen the Trump
  56. administration tout recently. Uh realistically, is that kind of a shortterm benefit? Because I I think I
  57. don't know what the expectation is of what tariffs will be down the road. Obviously, the the administration wants
  58. to try and build more businesses here into the US, which I guess is the hope that that will help kind of build the
  59. the tax base and will, you know, help to uh alleviate some of those issues on the
  60. debt. But that's that's a long process to begin with. >> Yeah. I mean, the more immediate concern
  61. that sometimes people have is the actual tariff revenue itself. So, this is going
  62. of course before the Supreme Court who will release their decision likely at some point in December. And that is the
  63. emergency powers that Trump used during the second term, will that in fact be you know upheld or not? Um and so uh if
  64. in fact the court says no um that uh the president did not have those powers uh to enact tariffs then the government
  65. will lose about $2.8 trillion over the next 10 years. Having said that though, tariffs are an extremely inefficient way
  66. of raising revenue. they are in fact the least efficient way of raising revenue.
  67. So it it would actually um be progrowth even u though we would lose that revenue
  68. that could otherwise be used to paying down some debt it would actually be progrowth just to get rid of the tariffs
  69. really realize is that um 40% of all imports into the United States is not uh is is just for helping businesses
  70. actually produce more efficiently. >> Right. And so the fact of the matter is we don't want, you know, a John Deere
  71. and so forth in making their own screws and metal sheets and so forth. We want them to focus on the really high margin
  72. stuff and get the cheap stuff uh and diverting resources to making our own screws is super inefficient. And so um
  73. there really is uh a lot of harms caused by the tariffs, but also the it makes capital markets
  74. even more contract contracted and smaller. Um, and we're trying to sell more and more debt over time. So that
  75. makes that a little bit harder. >> How then do you deliver the message to the public at large of where we kind of
  76. stand with this debt issue right now and maybe how you know they can understand it better so we can have a you know a
  77. path we can figure out a path down the road. >> Yeah. So there's really kind of three
  78. barriers that we've identified porn budget model why people don't seem to be that concerned with it. The first is,
  79. you know, people way overestimating the potential impact of AI and really misunderstanding its impact on the
  80. fiscal system. I think you and I have talked about this in the past. People going go to our website and see that AI
  81. is not going to generate um uh that much deficit reduction. Um but the second um
  82. issue is that people are saying you know why aren't things going bad in you know
  83. interest rates and financial markets and so forth not realizing that mortgage rates and everything else are actually
  84. much higher than they otherwise would be because we actually have a lot of capital per person right now because of
  85. everybody going into retirement. Um we really should have precoid levels of interest rates and uh mortgage rates
  86. right now. We're a couple hundred, you know, maybe 150 to 200 basis points higher than where we really should be.
  87. And that's all going to get worse over time as baby boomers eat away some of their capital. But the third real reason
  88. is that there have been some really irresponsible groups out there who are pretending to have numbers and doing
  89. analysis. They're just hacking things away. And they've been do being the boy who cries wolf for a long time. And you
  90. know, the sky hasn't fallen. And so therefore, maybe this isn't such a big deal. It's kind of the El Gore effect.
  91. You know, we're not underwater right now. You know, the all all the, you know, icebergs haven't melted. So
  92. therefore, you know, the environment must not be that important. And so, you know, of course that's all kind of
  93. facious, but nonetheless, um, the boy wealth has really been very damaging. Um, and so we what we really need and
  94. what we're trying to do here is put things into context and really do serious analysis that's a lot more
  95. convincing than just trying to get media citations and bribing reporters that cover us.
  96. >> Kent, great to talk to you as always. Thanks very much, sir. All the best. >> Thank you.
  97. >> You got it. Kent SMEs, professor of business, economics, and public policy here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Kent Smatters discusses the US national debt crisis and potential solutions, including tax reforms and adjustments to entitlement programs.

Key points

  • US National Debt Surges. The US national debt has climbed above $38 trillion, raising concerns about fiscal sustainability.
  • Urgency on Social Security. Experts warn that Social Security issues may come to a head in about a decade.
  • The Tariff Revenue Debate. The efficiency of tariffs as a revenue source is questioned amid ongoing legal challenges.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes