Social Security Policy Simulator Overview

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi I'm Ken Smithers professor here at the Wharton School and I'm getting give you a quick overview
  2. of the new social security policy simulator that's available at the pen Wharton budget model group and you can
  3. see from the screen here is that you have a choice of various graphs that you can be looking at things like trust fund
  4. reserves non-interest surplus which the difference between benefits paid and taxes income receive Social Security
  5. taxes benefits interest income lots of other varieties and we also compare our results against those from the Social
  6. Security Administration and the Congressional Budget Office and first also BP before we do even think about
  7. any policy changes you can see that our model projects that we will exhaust the trust fund exhausting day will be about
  8. three and a half to four years earlier than the Social Security trustees project in particular we see our
  9. deficits happening around 20 31 and what come 20 31 we're seeing projecting that
  10. will actually have a non interest surplus of about 350 billion dollars in today's dollars eventually growing to
  11. over 1.2 trillion dollars per every single year again in today's dollars an hour 75 years shortfall is about a third
  12. larger than what you see from the Social Security Administration and to understand why you can look at the
  13. social security tax revenue and we have a more pessimistic projection of tax revenue coming in over time and that the
  14. reason behind that is that our model starts with census level data and we construct these transition rules based
  15. on various big data sets across many different key attributes age race marriage divorce number of kids
  16. education and many other attributes across a lot of population subgroups so we're really working kind of bottom-up
  17. and as a result of that we can see how productivity in the economy is changing as you have these large
  18. labor force composition changes as people are going into retirement they're being replaced by younger people and the
  19. average productivity per worker for example goes down as a result of that our benefits also go down a little bit
  20. relative social security but there are tax revenue is is is the main difference in our numbers line up a little bit
  21. closer to the cbo's own model on this all right so now let's consider some different policy changes and we have six
  22. options to pick from here increase in the payroll tax increase in taxable maximum and lots of other options
  23. there's altogether there's six options each has four different combinations associated with it so there's actually
  24. four to the sixth power different combinations 4096 policy combinations that you can run in our model you know
  25. each one takes about 30 minutes than our to run so you might be wondering how you're getting instant feedback as you
  26. move things around and different policy changes and we the reason is we're using
  27. cloud computing to do all the computations ahead of time and so that gives you instant feedback let's
  28. consider a couple policy changes that policy makers for years have been kind of talking about let's for example talk
  29. about raising the normal retirement age this one down here and we have a little tool tip here with it basically says
  30. what the current law is in particular the retirement age is going up to age 67 roughly about two months per year and if
  31. you want more info it can give you even more expanded info information and so this would be a policy change to
  32. continue that increase if you wanted to do that say even to age 70 and now when we do that you'll notice here that the
  33. impact on the trust fund exhaustion date from increasing the retirement age it's
  34. basically less than one year it's a very small change and by the way if you wanted to you can even kind of zoom in
  35. on the particular years and kind of it get more information you can you can actually look at particular yours the
  36. values and so forth and it doesn't have a big impact however over time increase in retirement age does have a much
  37. bigger impact on a non interest surplus the big deficit over time goes down and then what's going on here is essentially
  38. that we're increasing the retirement age is is simply basically too late to solve
  39. the problem at least for the trust fund it can be part of a longer term solution
  40. but it just simply faces in too slowly over a time and then we have some other things that you can consider here when
  41. is a progressive benefit reduction and you hear it explains the tooltip explains how benefits are currently
  42. calculated in particular the government you currently calculates your benefits equal to 90 percent replacement rate up
  43. to a certain value called a bend point then thirty two percent and then fifteen percent and so this is a policy where
  44. you keep the ninety percent replacement rate for poorer households constant but you decrease the replacement rate on
  45. Richard households and you can see the impact on the trust fund is actually also a fairly small and the current
  46. policies are blue line the red policy is kind of the new line and it barely kind
  47. of moves the trust fund exhausting a date and saying the intuition behind that is again it just is a bit too late
  48. they have an impact on things that phases into slowly however again over time it has a much bigger impact and
  49. then you can start to do interactions like you know suppose I want to do a progressive benefit reduction increase
  50. the normal retirement age and you can now start to see that it has a much bigger impact over time in terms of the
  51. trust fund reserves themselves again not a huge impact at least in the short run okay so now let's
  52. consider you know other things I mean you can a lot of people have argued for like increase in the taxable maximum
  53. right now your payroll is being taxed up to 118 thousand dollars 500 per year a 12 point four percent tax rate and so
  54. some people have argued that maybe we should levy that tax over our larger income base and what we can see is for
  55. example as we go to the say increase that $250,000 it actually has an impact on on the trust fund as we go to 400,000
  56. as a slightly bigger impact not much of a difference going from 250 to 400 thousand households there's just not
  57. enough households there and if you go above 400,000 house of dollars it has almost no impact going forward but again
  58. we get some life but you know over the long term it starts like you know I get a little bit bigger this is one of those
  59. policies as a much bigger impact on the short run because it's immediately happening then but the relative to the
  60. long term and so you can now start to think about different combinations I mean there's a 4096 combinations here
  61. that for you'll explore I I haven't even explored the every single accommodation
  62. and so you can see the trade-offs yourself especially between the long run and the short run by giving your own
  63. combinations a try thank you

Brief Summary

Professor Ken Smithers discusses a new Social Security simulator, its projections, and policy options for reforming the system.

Key points

  • Trust Fund Exhaustion Timeline. Our model projects the trust fund will exhaust three to four years earlier than expected.
  • Impact of Retirement Age. Increasing the retirement age has a minimal immediate impact on trust fund exhaustion.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes