Saving Social Security

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Social Security’s long-term prognosis is grim, and every solution that’s been suggested has been deeply unpopular with one faction or another. But Wharton’s Olivia Mitchell has found a partial remedy she says will be hard to dislike. More: http://knlg.net/1VA9PzQ 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I want to welcome Olivia Mitchell to knowledge at Wharton she's a professor of business economics and public policy
  2. here at Wharton and she has some new research on Social Security which I think is going to present some novel
  3. ideas for us and it's being published right now as an issue brief by the Penn Wharton public policy initiative Olivia
  4. is a recognized expert on retirement and Social Security so I'm especially happy
  5. to have her talking about this topic um and it's great to have you back uh could
  6. you give us a summary of your research which is based on a survey as I understand it and it's also uh based
  7. around the idea that the social security funds will run out at some point soon um
  8. the 2032 34 uh areas is usually what people site and the most common solutions to this deficit in funding are
  9. that we either in increase retirement age or cut benefits or we increase taxes or lift the cap as they say um on
  10. incomes above which are not paying Social Security at the moment but apparently there's another solution out
  11. there which is revenue neutral which is good news because um the other uh suggested Solutions are very unpopular
  12. in different camps but your solution is revenue neutral why don't you tell us about
  13. it so around the world Social Security systems are running out of money we're not unique in the United States in that
  14. regard and the typical policy recommendations are not very popular like raising the retirement age or
  15. cutting benefits or raising taxes what we set out to do in our research is to try to think of a new way to get people
  16. to delay claiming work longer and have all that happen without Social Security suffering financially so nutshell what
  17. we set out to do was to design a way to give people their benefit increases that
  18. they would receive if they delayed claiming but instead of giving them their benefit increases as a monthly
  19. payment we would give it to them as a lump sum at their later claiming date the money turns out to be quite
  20. substantial from 60 to 80 to $170,000 this is the actu neutral value of the additional benefit and lo and
  21. behold people like this idea in our experimental survey what we found is that people would delay claiming about
  22. half a year and they would work about a third to a half of the extra time all of
  23. that takes place without costing the Social Security System a penny on net uh and so it's very interesting so
  24. the idea is that right now people could retire at 62 let's say say with partial benefits or 66 or 67 depending on when
  25. you were born with full benefits Social Security offers an incentive if you wait and don't claim on
  26. those dates so if you're 66 and you wait a year your benefits will go up by a certain amount roughly 8% I think and
  27. then if you wait another year they could go up another 8% the idea being continue
  28. working or at least don't start draining the funds and we will give you uh incentive to do that so apparently
  29. that's of limited interest to people so what you're finding is that your lump Su
  30. some solution is much more attractive to people and actually accomplishes the same thing or even better than what's
  31. being done now what we find is that today over a third of Americans claim their benefits from Social Security as
  32. early as they can which is age 62 and the modal claiming age is about 63 so most people give up on their increased
  33. benefits that they could get if they waited to the latest possible claiming age in our current scenario in our
  34. current uh system the latest possible claiming age is age 70 it's a little known fact that if you wait to claim
  35. from age 62 to 70 either keep working or live on other other assets that your benefits go up by
  36. 76% this is an enormous increase and probably a better investment if you will than what most people can make in the
  37. market today today exactly so um the problem however is that people don't understand annuities
  38. they don't understand benefit increases which will be paid the rest of their lives so what we try to do in our
  39. research is take advantage of the fact that people don't understand benefit increases the rest of their life and
  40. instead what we do is we say all right if you're someone who would earn let who would receive 1,500 a month from Social
  41. Security if you claimed at age 62 under our scenario we would still give you that 1,500 a month if you
  42. claimed let's say at age 66 but then all the benefit increase you had earned by delaying claiming would be given to you
  43. as a lump sum at that later claim date and what we find is that people like lump sums not surprisingly a bird in the
  44. hand seems more than worth more than two in the bush so is this is this related to the idea that some people there are
  45. people who make calculation if I wait until 70 I do get a lot more money but then I have to live
  46. to a certain age before that that amount of money is worth more than had I taken
  47. payments all along up until that that point so is this taking that into account also right the Social Security
  48. Administration computes the benefit increase that you get each year that you delay so that the increment is just
  49. enough to offset the fact that you're not taking it for a year so in a sense it's actually neutral it's actually Fair
  50. it doesn't hurt the Social Security System it doesn't save us save it any money but so in that sense what we
  51. proposed in our experiment was to give people the benefit that they would get already in expectation but converted
  52. into a lump sum now not surprisingly the people that are willing to do it are the
  53. people who were say they are somewhat debth constrained so they have debts that they owe and they would still get
  54. the basic benefit that they're owed but they the lump sum would help them solve their debt problems other people who
  55. find it very attractive are the financially literate people that understand that they're going to get
  56. money that would help them uh cover other expenses and still get their base benefit the rest of their lives so as
  57. part of the psychology for the consumer that um if I wait till 70 I have to live
  58. until I forget what the age is it's like 84 or something before you know it sort
  59. of Nets out that I'm actually making a net gain over all those years but now I can sort of like change my mind anywhere
  60. along the way and I haven't given anything up I can I can just get this big lumpsum payment is that is that part
  61. of the psychology at work well unfortunately my research shows that a majority of financial advisers use this
  62. very flawed approach to advising on Social Security claiming which they call the break even approach and the break
  63. even approach is extremely misleading because they say to you you will have to live to some age say 84 for sure to get
  64. all the money back that you gave up by not claiming early that's a very flawed approach and um the reason that it is is
  65. that it ignores the fact that by delaying claiming the retiree gets a higher benefit for the rest of his life
  66. even if he he or she lives to be 125 years old so I would take is with the break even approach and I don't think
  67. it's an appropriate um way to frame the discussion okay um fair enough so um which of the conclusions if any
  68. surprised you from your research this is based on a survey yes so what we did was
  69. we fielded um a survey a nationally representative survey of older Americans and we asked them before we got started
  70. some questions about their lifetime earnings so we could figure out get a pretty good estimate of what their
  71. expected Social Security benefits would be at Future ages then we said under the
  72. status quo under the current system when do you expect the claim and they'd tell
  73. us and then we'd show them the alternative the lump sum option for example and we'd say given this set of
  74. opportunities when would you claim and not surprisingly the majority of people selected a later claiming age and we
  75. could then examine that delay in the claiming age and correlate it with attributes of the person answering the
  76. question and so one of the things that really surprised me was that we found that people who otherwise would have
  77. claimed very young at 62 were the most likely to be willing to delay claiming the reason that surprised me is
  78. is there's a common view that early retirees can't work anymore they're too sick they're too unable to find jobs but
  79. in fact this suggested there's a lot of give among the early retirees and if you
  80. give them an incentive to delay claiming they will delay and they'll work longer
  81. so if this idea this novel idea of lumpsum payment were adopted how would it change the finances that that you
  82. talk about in the paper where the money's going to run out uh or or at least largely run out uh onethird of the
  83. money is going to run out by 2032 well the Social Security trustees have projected
  84. that there will be only enough money to pay 2third of the benefits starting around uh 2032 which is getting closer
  85. as the years go by um so benefits would be projected to drop by a third for everyone the way we've designed our
  86. experiment we made it act neutral so that it wouldn't hurt the systems finances it wouldn't help the systems
  87. finances but we do say at the end of the paper that to the extent that people really prefer lump sums that it might be
  88. possible to get them to delay claiming and work longer for a little bit less than the actual fair amount which would
  89. actually save the system money I see and if um were you able to Project based on
  90. your survey or other data or knowledge um how much less you could offer and how it might benefit the system or is that
  91. the subject of the follow-up study the follow-up study we intend to do would try to vary the amounts that we can
  92. offer people um not necessarily making it a better deal because the system can't afford that but trying to evaluate
  93. whether people might take the lump some benefit if it were slightly reduced and my sense is it will in fact be popular
  94. okay so if I understand it correctly then where where your study is at now is you're finding a new way to do it it
  95. doesn't necessarily save Social Security from the deficits that everyone's talking about but it could be it could
  96. be changed in a way so that it it could have a positive effect on funding is it is it possible that it could make up
  97. that whole Gap do you think the Social Security shortfall is enormous uh the actuaries have estimated that it's on
  98. the order of $28 trillion uh in present value that's twice the size of the GDP of the US so a
  99. small delay in claiming will not solve the problem I think we're also going to have to have changes in the benefit
  100. formula we're going to have to have changes in the retirement ages but given that there need to be there needs to be
  101. a number of different tweaks or adjustments this could easily be one to make it more palatable to people that is
  102. we're not taking away anything from them we're giving them options and I hope that's more appealing than saying You
  103. must work another five years so it's their choice so what will you look at next well so we are looking further at
  104. uh alternative uh ways to get people to delay claiming and work longer there is some interesting research that's being
  105. done now showing that delayed retirement is actually better for you it's better for you mentally you stay networked with
  106. your peers it's better for you physically people that work longer are healthier and it's also better for a
  107. society in that if you encourage continued work you don't have to raise taxes so much on the young to be able to
  108. support the elderly so for a number of different reasons I'm very much in favor of delayed retirement not everyone will
  109. be able to do it but to the extent you can let's encourage it okay well please come back and tell us uh the results of
  110. the next phase thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Olivia Mitchell discusses a new revenue-neutral solution for Social Security that incentivizes delaying claims through lump-sum payments.

Key points

  • Innovative Solutions for Social Security. Olivia Mitchell presents a revenue-neutral solution to Social Security funding issues.
  • The Appeal of Lump Sum Payments. Research shows people prefer lump sums over monthly payments for delayed Social Security benefits.
  • The Flawed Break-Even Approach. Mitchell critiques the common break-even approach used by financial advisers regarding Social Security.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes