Whats Driving Health Insurers' Merger Mania?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Finance & Accounting;Management;Health Care Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. welcome to Mark Paulie he's a professor of healthc Care Management here at Wharton and he's going to discuss the
  2. merger frenzy that's going on uh among healthc care insurers at the moment Mark the top five companies have been talking
  3. about merging with each other in different ways so we have Anthem which is a consolidation of Blue Cross
  4. companies uh talking they're making a play for Sigma that's a $48 billion deal if it went through United Health is
  5. talking about picking up Etna that's a $40 billion deal and Etna itself is talking about picking up human which is
  6. is a $30 billion deal these are the top five players all told and if all of these things went through somehow we'd
  7. be left with the top three instead of the top five so um first question is why are these merger efforts coming now yeah
  8. that's a good question I I think one answer is that in the period of Obamacare uh uh insurers found it
  9. politic to lay low uh and not do anything dramatic that might upset the boat because they had to maintain their
  10. position of of of probity uh uh and now it's almost as if somebody has said okay
  11. it's open season now uh all those things that have been bottled up for five years
  12. Obamacare actually started in 2009 uh now it's a free-for-all go out and do whatever you want to do so to to
  13. some exent I think the the uh Coincidence of uh all of this discussion right now is probably because the the
  14. Assumption the insurers are making is that kind of the corks out of the bottle and they can get back to doing whatever
  15. they would have been doing uh but there's certainly some features of Obamacare that have actually
  16. led to uh motivation for insurers to try to merge what are those well so they're
  17. really two of them uh one is uh the the main feature of Obamacare I think that most people know about is that it
  18. reformed the market buying individual insurance it's important to say most of us don't get our insurance that way we
  19. get our insurance through our job and if we work for a big company our employer is really not very much if at all
  20. affected by these mergers at least not directly so most of us can sleep well at night regardless of what happens but if
  21. you work for a small business or if you own a small business or if you get your insurance as an individual because
  22. you're self-employed and you're using either the Obamacare exchanges or even the remaining individual Market uh the
  23. the of course the per the the goal of Obamacare was to try to increase competition in the individual Market by
  24. making it much more transparent about what different plans would be and by regulating the insurers uh in an attempt
  25. to cut that profit margins in the individual insurance market and this is a kind of counter attack I think on the
  26. part of insurers saying well um if you're going to um uh try to uh uh stimulate competition uh we're going to
  27. counteract by reducing the number of competitors so at least we won't have to worry about our as many um competitors
  28. stabbing Us in the back by cutting prices if we can buy them up or acquire them so so that's number one number two
  29. uh an important part of Obamacare is particularly for the Medicare population to organize more or organized Delivery
  30. Systems accountable care organizations which are supposed to be entities to care for the full set of needs of a
  31. population of people and that has often meant for obvious reasons that since people use more than one hospital it
  32. means all the hospitals in town have an incentive to work together and when they
  33. get together Adam Smith probably could have warned us about this they not only talk about we suspect how to improve
  34. care they also talk about how to bargain more aggressively with insurers and so uh the ACO part of the Affordable Care
  35. Act has stimulated uh among other reasons uh consolidation on the provider side and I think what we're seeing here
  36. is a a reaction to that consolidation by insurers saying well if the providers are not going to gang up on us we better
  37. gang up on them so a battle of the Titans I guess right in which John Q public is probably going to get squashed
  38. yeah okay at least that's what economists say so um and I think that uh others have pointed out that um the
  39. consolidation for hospitals and Doctor groups and and for medical devices medical device companies has often led
  40. to higher cost for consumers I mean you point out since we mostly most people get their insurance through their
  41. employer that that might not have a big effect because the big employers especially would have some bargaining
  42. power and that it could affect consumers but can we generally assume that that um
  43. because of this consolidation were it to all happen that this does increase their
  44. Market power and their pricing power and that there will be a substantial effect
  45. on health care cost overall or is is that fair well that's sort of what Eon economists traditionally assume that
  46. that if you reduce the number of sellers that's going to uh increase pricing power and increase the markup Ratio or
  47. the markup percentage that a a seller can charge in principle there could be some reductions in cost if there are
  48. some economies uh associated with the mergers uh and the and the merge merger Partners have been talking about
  49. synergies and all of that but we're still worried that even if their costs fall whether those reductions get
  50. transformed into lower prices is somewhat up in the air because the markup will go up so uh you know it's
  51. not a foregone conclusion that prices are going to rise if you cut costs enough but there's still a concern that
  52. uh that would happen and I think there's in the research not only on mergers of insurers and even for that matter
  53. mergers of hospitals but mergers in general there's fairly profound skepticism that these economies of scale
  54. actually end up materializing to any appreciable extent and if they do whether they would trickle down or not
  55. trickle down now if you if any of these firms were the traditional kindly nonprofit Blue Cross plan in principle
  56. owned by its Insurance then you know if like Independence Blue Cross that's still in principle like that uh if it
  57. ganged up on uh healthc care providers here in town I probably cheer that uh but if it was bought out and converted
  58. to a company that trades on the New York Stock Exchange I might get a little more
  59. worried um not surprisingly there's already a lot of uh uh opposition to this the American Academy of family
  60. physicians has already come out they're they're reaching out to the Federal Trade Commission saying that
  61. they're not happy about this they're going to feel uh physicians may feel at a disadvantage if if they're suddenly
  62. dealing with a bigger Behemoth um so what are the odds of something like this getting past the Federal Trade
  63. Commission one assumes there's going to be challenges yeah well it would certainly be better if the opposition
  64. didn't come from the providers of healthc care who you know have their own acts to grind uh and came from consumers
  65. but I suspect that will happen uh certainly I I I personally would sign on to that and uh uh but uh but the
  66. government is in something of a compromised position because as I mentioned it has incouraged these
  67. accountable care organizations so far the Federal Trade Commission though kind of hasn't gotten
  68. the memo that that they that they should be um easy on mergers uh some other states in Massachusetts for example the
  69. Attorney General there Martha kley uh drafted a new policy which essentially said we will allow these Hospital
  70. mergers as long as the hospitals promis to play nice afterwards uh and and so there's a bit of a conflict that the
  71. Federal Trade Commission traditionally has taken the point of view that they view any merger with great skepticism
  72. it's kind of up to the merging Partners to prove that they're not doing something harmful to the welfare of
  73. consumers here though there is the counterargument well you the insurers can say you the government told us that
  74. uh you wanted the healthc care Market to consolidate for purposes of coordination
  75. of care uh and so we're just going along with the program that you outlined so uh
  76. uh I think the short answer is going to be politics and and in a way who's in charge who who employs the Attorney
  77. General at the time uh the uh the when and if these things actually uh um come to a decisive point so we've talked a
  78. lot about the sort of the business of this and the pricing and and and who who has more leverage in that sort of thing
  79. uh is there anything to be said about what this may or may not mean for Health outcomes of patients will will
  80. this have any significant effect or or is is that really not in the mix for something like well it's in the mix in
  81. the sense that if the consequence of the merger is to raise premiums and that frustrates the public policy which is
  82. intended to encourage people to take insurance uh uh the uh the and we think having insurance is a good thing for
  83. your health uh the more it um uh uh counteracts the uh existing public policy to encourage people to become
  84. insured the worse it'll be uh so the if the high prices discourage people from buying Insurance that'll be a bad thing
  85. for People's Health um otherwise though I don't think it's terribly relevant even um according to the Wall Street
  86. Journal uh article on this they've actually done some research for us uh maybe people there are hoping to get
  87. tenure I don't know but uh they had an interesting study which showed that the primary markets that would be affected
  88. by these mergers was the market for private Medicare insurance the so-called Medicare Advantage
  89. plans and uh although that's um and those plans cover about a third now of all people on Medicare but there is and
  90. I as you can tell by looking at me I am concerned about Medicare uh there is a there is a a protection which is that if
  91. the private insurers get together and try to rip off rip off us old folks we can still take our Medicare from the
  92. government plan so there's a protection there both in terms of quality of care in terms of cost of coverage uh that uh
  93. probably makes this less troubling than other mergers would be for example I'm much more troubled about mergers among
  94. hospitals or large physician groups than I am about insurers are there any other
  95. reasons for mergers other than gaining Market power well there are according to the research it and it's kind of common
  96. sense that you will um want to sell out or maybe would be a good takeover Target
  97. if your market value is lower than the true value of your company and I am intrigued by uh human which whose main
  98. business is Medicare Advantage put itself up for sale I think because it's making a lot of money off of Medicare
  99. Advantage and it thought now was a good time to cash in and have somebody pay a high price uh um and then my cynical
  100. side says in part because the salad days the gravy days of making a lot of money
  101. off of Medicare can't go on forever but if they can persuade some other insurer to buy them out at a relatively high
  102. price based on their current Good Fortune um uh the current stockholders can uh you know have a happy walk to the
  103. bank so there's some of uh some of this is probably also associated with perception that um that some of these
  104. firms are undervalued in the market relative to the value they would bring in a more Consolidated setting
  105. [Music]

Brief Summary

Mark Pauly discusses the healthcare insurer merger frenzy and its implications for costs and patient care.

Key points

  • Merger Frenzy Among Insurers. Top healthcare insurers are considering major mergers, potentially reducing competition.
  • Obamacare's Impact on Mergers. Mark explains how the political climate post-Obamacare has led to increased merger activity.
  • Concerns Over Rising Costs. Mark discusses the skepticism surrounding the potential benefits of insurer mergers.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes