Analyzing the Length of Hospital Nurses' Work Shifts

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] so Amy thank you so much for joining us today thank you for having me it's love
  2. to talk to you about the study that you and your colleagues have done uh about uh the working conditions of nurses now
  3. uh what's interesting to me in reading your paper is that uh the US uh labor history has had such a long tradition of
  4. of trade unions fighting for the 8-hour workday but in your study you found that
  5. nurses actually are not part of that they they many of them work 12 or 13 hours uh uh 13-hour shifts why why does
  6. this situation exist and how how has it come about so nurses traditionally worked 8 hour days and then in the 1980s
  7. and 1990s when there were some um structural changes in healthc care and there's Cost Containment measures put in
  8. it was actually less expensive to have nurses work 12-hour shifts because that was only two nurses per day instead of
  9. three and so nurses began working these 12-hour shifts and in fact they just decided they really liked it because it
  10. offered better work work life work life balance so nurses could work three days instead of five so they had more time
  11. off for their family and friends and me fewer commutes and they had more time to
  12. go back to school so it's really become very prevalent most hospitals either offer 12-hour shifts and 8 hour shifts
  13. and some hospitals only offer 12-hour shifts so it's very very common now so do nurses have a choice they can choose
  14. whether to is it voluntary or is it it depends on the hospital and sometimes it depends on the unit in which they work
  15. so some hospitals may give the option when a nurse is hired if they're going to be hired into a unit that only Works
  16. schedules 12 hour shifts or it may do a mix of 12 hours and 8 hours so from your
  17. research it uh from your paper it seems like nurses don't have uh uh work workout policies there are no workout
  18. policies for nurses are there other professions where such policies exist and why is there a difference there are
  19. so other safety sensitive Industries like Physicians um Pilots longdistance truck drivers they all have workout
  20. restrictions and there aren't any National workour restrictions for nurses um and in certain states there are
  21. mandatory overtime prohibition but nurses can work as much voluntary over time as they want and when this issue
  22. was looked into and um for example in the state of Texas a few years ago the State Board of Nursing was considering
  23. doing some work hour restrictions and when they put it to a vote over 90% of the nurses said that they do not want
  24. any restrictions on their work hours so it's a very um complex uh situation uh it certainly seems like it because I
  25. mean uh looking at your study you looked at the impact of long shifts on things like burnout and job satisfaction and
  26. other factors among nurses uh what were some of your major findings so our main findings we found that when nurses
  27. worked above the standard 8 hour shift um that they were at increased odds of being burned out and dissatisfied and
  28. also intending to leave their employer in the next year and this was worse for the nurses that work the longest shifts
  29. so if they worked over 13 hours they had um a twofold increase in the odds of being burned out and dissatisfied and
  30. intending to leave their employer so their overall well-being was definitely being impacted by these long shifts and
  31. yours was not a national study you covered four states right correct which were the in which states was the
  32. condition the worst um it it was very similar actually across the states um so we found that this wasn't a phenomenon
  33. found only in California but maybe not New Jersey it was found in all the states where um nurses were working
  34. these extended shifts when the nurses are overworked of course you know as you pointed out it
  35. the they get more frustrated and the chances of burnout are much higher but does it also have an impact on patient
  36. outcomes yes so this was actually the first study to look at the relationship between nurses shift length and how
  37. patients perceive their care in the hospitals and we found that when there's a higher proportion of nurses working
  38. those really long shifts of over 13 hours that patient satisfaction went down and that was in things like whether
  39. or not patients would recommend the hospital to their family and friends whether they would rate the hospital low
  40. on a scale of 1 to 10 um and then also things like communication with their nurses and then conversely we found in
  41. hospitals that had a high proportion of nurses working the standard 8 hour shifts patient satisfaction was improved
  42. so that's very interesting because uh obviously if making nurses work for very long hours brings down patient
  43. satisfaction then the business implications for the hospital are clearly very negative uh in spite of
  44. that why is does this situation exist uh any did your research point up uh point
  45. out any reasons for that well we found that um when we asked nurses questions about their scheduling and their shift
  46. length that overall actually they are very satisfied with um having flexible schedules being actively involved in
  47. their scheduling so that's um something that we found was really interesting that although most of the nurses worked
  48. these 12-hour shifts and they appeared satisfied with them that there were still these negative um implications for
  49. their well-being and then also for the patients uh now what what are some of the business implications of not
  50. addressing these issues in hospitals sure so um typically when nurses become burned out and dissatisfy those are
  51. precursors to um voluntary turnover and so if they leave the hospital the costs for recruiting retraining rehiring and
  52. um Staffing temporary nurses is very costly and it can be um the annual salary of a nurse which can be anywhere
  53. from $50 to $80,000 or so so it's very costly for hospitals if they have a a high number of turnover um and it's also
  54. you know bad for staff morale and it's not good for the patients either so there's certainly um a big cost
  55. associated with having overwork dissatisfied burned out nurses what implications do your findings have for
  56. uh on hospital reimbursements by Medicare and Medicaid sure so under the Affordable Care Act um there was a
  57. provision put in place so that Hospitals now face um reductions in their reimbursement if they don't achieve
  58. National um standards on their patient satisfaction and we use the hospital consumer assessment of healthcare
  59. providers and systems that are known as H caps um and that was a survey that we used in our study and if they don't
  60. achieve this Benchmark then they they face reductions in um reimbursements so one easy way to help um increase the
  61. likelihood of achieving those benchmarks is to have a well-rested um you know adequate nursing staff and so by
  62. investing in nursing hospitals have the potential to reap you know more rewards through reimbursement right uh now uh
  63. based on your research what changes would you recommend that hospitals make in the way in which nurses jobs are
  64. structured so we we were able to see that the nurses that work the longest shifts and we presume that they were
  65. overtime shifts um those were the most detrimental so certainly curbing overtime certainly completely reducing
  66. mandatory overtime and then monitoring the rest of the nurses work hours would be really important and then also
  67. educating the nurses and the managers about the effects of working these long shifts so that they are aware um that it
  68. can impact them the staff as well as their patients uh what was the most surprising
  69. finding of your research project I think the most interesting piece that we found
  70. was um what I mentioned earlier was that the most of the nurses really seemed on
  71. paper to be satisfied with these shifts and they are actively involved in scheduling them and so despite the fact
  72. that they seem satisfied with this scheduling there's a disconnect because those nurses were also at highest
  73. highest risk for being burned out and dissatisfied so we have to uncover a little bit more between what's going on
  74. there so maybe that's a topic for future research certainly uh and one final question uh based on your research what
  75. advice would you give high school students who may be considering going into nursing as a career I would
  76. definitely recommend it it's a very rewarding career and there's many many opportunities um as a nurse and many
  77. different places to work aside from just hospitals um I would um caution nurses to make sure though that when they go
  78. out on their first job that they ask about their scheduling and how much overtime is used on their unit and just
  79. make sure that they um take care of themselves so that they can take care of their patience Amy thank you so much for
  80. speaking with knowledge at Horton thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Nurses face burnout from long shifts, impacting job satisfaction and patient care.

Key points

  • Nurses' Long Shifts Impact Satisfaction. A study reveals that longer shifts lead to increased burnout and lower patient satisfaction.
  • The Complexity of Nurse Scheduling. Despite preferences for long shifts, nurses face significant burnout risks.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes