State of the Economy: Entitlements

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The U.S. economy has grown stronger and immediate issues like the fiscal cliff have been addressed, but Wharton's Kent Smetters warns that huge obligations for Medicare and other entitlements could be disastrous if they are not tackled soon. Higher taxes on the rich won't close the funding gap, and the U.S. must face the prospect of raising taxes on the middle class and cutting entitlement benefits. 📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] hello I'm Jeff Brown for knowledge at Wharton today we're with Kent Smets
  2. professor of business economics and public policy at Wharton and we're going to talk about 2013 and how things stand
  3. at the beginning and how we think they're going to go through the year so thank you for joining us my pleasure so
  4. the first thing I think is just a general question you what is the state of the economy it certainly seems to be
  5. a little bit better but I no one's really bragging about it is it going to get better or sputter along get worse
  6. what do you think I think it's going to sputter along and I think we're in this for for a while I think a lot of the
  7. projections that people have about a turnaround 2013 2014 are probably optimistic so historically since 1980 um
  8. fixed private investment has hovered around 16 17 18% of GDP and that's gone way down it went down to about 10 11%
  9. during the Great Recession and it's slowly climbing its way up but it it really has not um come back to where
  10. where we need it and the job market is still really bad I mean the uh job cre is barely keeping up with uh the growth
  11. rate of population um it's uh the at this rate we won't be back to the Natural rate of unemployment for another
  12. five years at least and um in fact most of the changes that we've seen the unemployment rate recently has actually
  13. been just because people dropping out looking for jobs rather than kind of real jobs and being created and so you
  14. know fundamentally in this Pro in this country and this is the big issue a lot of people weren't talking about is we
  15. really have an education problem if you look at the unemployment rate for um uh college graduates it never got that high
  16. dur even during this Great Recession it's been a lot of people who do not have a college degree um that's still in
  17. the double digits uh blacks and minorities still in the double digits and so that's the big um the big problem
  18. is that the world's changing there's big returns to education a lot of people don't have it and that's
  19. what we really need to be uh uh focusing on for those who don't have it I hate to
  20. be pessimistic but is there any real hope other than going back to school but what what if you're in your 30s or 40s
  21. or 50s and you don't have much education yeah there the truth is that there really is not a lot of Hope unless they
  22. obtain new skills and so it's I think the approach for education is multifaceted we need to have much better
  23. Public Schools public schools are really should be focused on educating kids and
  24. not as employment opportunities it should be more more power to kids and less power to the teacher unions um of
  25. course there's more issues involved than just that um we're spending a lot per capita on on kids in this country in
  26. terms of Education we're one of the highest in the world but we're getting very little return for it and so we need
  27. to get Public Schools fixed but we also need to get training um better for people in the 30s so they can acquire
  28. new skills but bottom line is a college degree is still the the big differentiator uh in the in the labor
  29. market today and while we're on public schools for just a second the one of the obvious problems is kids dropping out
  30. they're clearly not getting an education but for those who remain do you think that the schools are are are focusing on
  31. the right skills the right subjects uh no I don't think so I think um there has to still be more reward for getting
  32. people to understand a lot of the basic fundamentals and of Reading Writing Ari arithmetic I mean there's still um we
  33. have a a shortage still of Engineers of even computer science uh people in this country and we still have kids who are
  34. graduating who really can't um comprehend um reading and can't write and these are huge advantages in in the
  35. the labor market when you look at at the economy aside from the things we've mentioned what do you say are sort of
  36. the key issues that are kind of overhanging right now that will either push it ahead or uh could could send us
  37. back into a bigger slowdown yeah and I think the education reform is kind of a long-term investment other long-term
  38. Investments that we got to be making right now is entitlement reform um and I think there's um uh kind this belief
  39. this myth out there that we don't have to take any kind of big hits right now until we get the economy back so it's
  40. let's just get the economy back to um Full Employment and then we'll take our medicine and and that's that's the big
  41. problem that we face right now because that that's just the myth in particular we'll never get people to make large
  42. investments in this in this economy when they face tremendous uncertainty if they're going to get taxed to death kind
  43. of later on um and it's uh we really have to resolve the long-term financing problem of the government to encourage
  44. people to make kind of the big bets we've already seen this in the area of biology uh right now uh investment in
  45. that area has gone way down um Lots less of investment in um Pharma large molecule small molecule therapies and so
  46. forth over time because they're long-term bets and no one knows what that world's going to look like 10 years
  47. from now and given the low probability of success people are starting to shift toward less risky things and that that
  48. that's a big problem the government needs to uh create much more clarity for investors and people making big
  49. sacrifices what that world's going to look like a decade from now and we're just we're just not doing that a lot of
  50. the discussion of entitlements of course looks at Medicare as as the the real big
  51. one that's the that's a major major problem and you hear remedies proposed like well raising the eligibility age a
  52. year or two uh or clamping down on the payments to doctors and hospitals are those really enough or is I mean is
  53. there have to be something much more sweeping than that to make this work it has to be fundamental reform those are
  54. not going to do do much um increase in entitlement age or retirement age is not going to do much uh reducing
  55. reimbursements to doctors just means fewer doctors are going to take uh Medicare and so um what really has to
  56. change is we need to go in a fundamental reform away from the feed for service model that we have now more to toward
  57. perc capitation or having people um understanding um the marginal cost of the medicine that they are getting and
  58. so various plans out there bipartisan plans like the Ryan rivlin plan and other plans that have tried to move the
  59. the conversation in that direction right now I've been kind of um demagogued by all sides um but that's the conversation
  60. that that we need to have if we fix everything else and don't touch Medicare we're doomed and so and if we screw up a
  61. lot of things but fix Medicare Medicaid and Social Security we're in pretty good
  62. shape and so it really comes down to those uh and Social Security uh that I my impression is that's a problem but
  63. not as big a problem as Medicare is that correct it is it's a much smaller problem both in size and in the nature
  64. of the problem in size it's probably one6 of the problem of Medicare um and in terms of the nature
  65. of the problem at least with social security benefits is it it's a dollar benefit so you can decide who to get
  66. fewer dollars to and lots of plans out there about keeping the poor out of poverty but maybe reducing some of the
  67. benefits that go to higher income classes and and so forth and uh with Medicare much higher harder problem
  68. because what do you do you say you know we're not going to pay for half of this open heart surgery and you PID for the
  69. other half much harder problem um to fix yeah and and I gather that that raising
  70. the eligibility age or the starting age for Medicare doesn't mean much because those are the healthier people in their
  71. 60s it's the people in their 80s who are were really costing a fortune that's right almost all the Medicare uh
  72. spending I shouldn't say all but the vast majority of it has done in the last two three years of life and so increas
  73. in the eligibility age has very little impact now looming over all this of course is the question of the debt and
  74. deficit and the debt ceiling and all that how important is it that we get some sort of kind of long-term solution
  75. to these problems yeah it's it's critical I mean no one's going to make an investment um private entrepreneurs
  76. are not going to make it a sacrifice until they what the long run looks like and the signal so far from Washington
  77. has been entrepreneurs and people who've invested and succeeded they're going to
  78. get the ones they're going to be the ones who we go to for getting the money to to solve these problems and so until
  79. you create that type of certainty uh about what the future politics is going to look like by solving having us on a
  80. long run sustainable path today um we're not going to make any any real Headway I
  81. mean what I think the biggest myth that really just needs to be dealt with is this idea that we can just um balance
  82. all these problems and kind of the the backs of the Rich and it's it's that's been the group we've gone to in the past
  83. and that we can just pile it some more on right now we're carrying a national deficit of $99,000 per every us
  84. household um if the Bush tax cuts had expired so the taxes went up for everybody taxes would have only gone up
  85. about $2,000 per household and that's what everybody was calling the fiscal cliff and so and of course that couldn't
  86. possibly happen and so it's this big uh view in Washington really on both sides that the middle class should not be hit
  87. whether it's higher taxes or lower benefits um and uh that they should be participating in this whole debate um
  88. where it's just mathematically impossible to do something meaningful without them participating either in the
  89. form of higher taxes a broader base lower benefits and this that the most recent tax increase on the rich will
  90. close about six to 7% of the annual deficit this year trivial amounts and so we need to have a broad-based discussion
  91. I is there any way to deal with these problems without a lot of pain uh for the middle class and for others are
  92. there any technological breakthroughs or sort of dream solutions that we haven't
  93. thought of that may come along no no I mean we're just way over consuming right now we've gotten a a very rich appetite
  94. and it's going to be painful for people to think about I have to cut back but right now as as a nation we're spending
  95. much more um than what uh we can um and as a result we're not saving for the future and we're on a path that is just
  96. completely unsustainable the the middle class has to be part of the solution I think most people would uh you know if
  97. you ask them what they want out of the economy they want an improved standard of living uh better prospects for jobs
  98. and a comfortable retirement it sort of boils down to those what are the prospects for getting all of those in
  99. the next 10 15 20 years yeah it they're not good at least in our current path simply because we've already consumed a
  100. lot of that um we've saved very little um for the future average US household has save very
  101. little um our government has overspent um and we're we're simply not going to grow fast enough in order to
  102. allow us to kind of grow our way out of this out of this problem keep in mind certain benefits like Social Security
  103. and Medicare or to keep up with lots of the technology uh technological progress
  104. they keep up with the average wage rate and so it's not something that we can easily grow our way out of and and so
  105. real fundamental choices are going to have to be be made and this is why it's I think real important that we make real
  106. um uh hard decisions about saving more uh today and why what the tone of Washington has to completely change
  107. right now the president is essentially t uh you taking advantage I think of the weaken position that Congress has
  108. especially in the public Limelight whereas the president really needs to shift focus and say you know this is a
  109. national problem this is a bipartisan problem we're here because of both political parties and here we we need to
  110. have a fundamental um reform to our our tax code our entitlement problems um and
  111. but this is going to involve everybody's participation and this idea that we can
  112. just Finance this off the backs of a few is just it's just mathematically impossible well it's a it's Grim but I
  113. guess we knew we had to hear it so we'll hope things turn out better but uh thank
  114. thank you very much we'll talk about it again my pleasure [Music]

Brief Summary

Kent Smets discusses the stagnant economy, education reform, and the need for entitlement reform in 2013.

Key points

  • The State of the Economy. Kent Smets discusses the current economic situation and future projections.
  • Education as a Key Issue. The conversation shifts to the importance of education in the job market.
  • Long-term Economic Solutions. Kent Smets emphasizes the need for fundamental reforms in entitlements and education.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes