Gender Lens Investing

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

πŸ“‚ Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. welcome to knowledge at Wharton I'm Sandy maroh hunt associate director at the Wharton social impact initiative and
  2. I'm thrilled to welcome you to a conversation today with Jackie vanderbrug managing director at Bank of
  3. America us trust welcome Jackie thank you so among many other things Jackie you are a thought leader in the gender
  4. lens investing space I'm very excited to have this conversation with you because
  5. we love to bring our Wharton Community whether students alumni and friends the latest in the impact investing and
  6. broader investing space so let's start at the beginning what is gender lens investing so first of all thank you for
  7. having me here thrilled to be here and gender lens investing is a process it's the deliberate integration of gender
  8. analysis into investment analysis and decision-making what's important to understand about that um is really two
  9. factors first um the definition includes this aspect of lend not limitation and often times there's
  10. an already listening when as soon as you say gender that people feel like oh you're excluding men this is not an
  11. exclusion it is a lens and not a limitation a lens is like a pair of glasses right through my glasses I'm
  12. going to see some things that otherwise if I didn't have them on I would miss yeah that's a really great point about
  13. how your your glass prescription is going to have a different one than my contact prescription we've got different
  14. lenses can you give us a couple examples about how that might play out in real world scenarios yeah absolutely um some
  15. investors for instance Sandy will say that they're really interested in getting women access to Capital and that
  16. may be women micro entrepreneurs in an emerging market or in a domestic situation here in the US might be women
  17. film directors it might be women hedge fund managers but they've realized that there are women who have less access to
  18. Capital than men and that's the lens that they use other investors use a lens where they look across the value chain
  19. of a company and they say how do I evaluate this company from the board through its Senior Management through
  20. the way that it's working within its organization to the supply chain and understand the way that they're valuing
  21. women and men equally in their organization still other investors are really looking at that product and
  22. service and how is it that if this company was wildly successful given what it does how would that
  23. change gender equality in its markets right does it have a product that's going to solve a challenge for women
  24. like women's safety um has it thought about gendered knowledge um there's really interesting research now on the
  25. way that software is designed and how software design has been predominantly for male patterns of problem solving wow
  26. and so thinking about how you could e bias software design could open up a whole set of new product offerings sure
  27. so those are very very different lenses and they all overlap and none of them are better than others in general what
  28. happens is I have an expertise I have an experience I have a theory of change and
  29. that creates my lenses yeah and what I love about that example or those examples thinking about the lenses is
  30. that it empowers everyone to have a voice whatever your experience you've got a unique lens that you're coming to
  31. this space and it sounds like there's no wrong way to ask those questions I've heard often in the space um folks will
  32. say well is it a sector like energy or in or you know education but it's really not it's a lens over all sectors so tell
  33. us a little bit more about why that's so important you're you're absolutely right
  34. right all Investments have impact as you probably often say all Investments have
  35. gendered impact exactly and so gender lens investing crosses all sectors it crosses all asset classes um and people
  36. use lenses in different ways so it's also important to understand that my gender lens might not be the same as
  37. yours um so it why it's important is because we're starting to realize that so much of the way that we allocate
  38. capital is gendered and so when we can be aware of that we can be aware of our biases we can be aware of the
  39. opportunities we can make much better investment decisions absolutely and that's a great case for gender lens
  40. investing why is it important to Bank of America Maryland us trust so it is important because we're
  41. looking as our all investors to make the best investment decisions and so having
  42. additional information about an investment um whether that be the role of women within the company whether that
  43. be the way that the company is attacking potential important markets whether that
  44. be the Safety and Security of the products that it's creating all of those factors gender has a part to play in um
  45. so that's important to us it's also important because it's important to our clients right so increasingly as many of
  46. your readers know clients are asking about the environmental and social impact of their
  47. Investments our research is that 58% of high- net worth individuals say that that's important to them interestingly
  48. 50% more women say that than men so we don't think that gender lens inv investing is Investing For Women it's
  49. investing for smart investors that said research does show that women are more likely to start asking these questions
  50. to say what is the impact of my portfolio on women and girls and also how is it that my portfolio is taking
  51. advantage of fully diverse organizations and the power they bring yeah and I'm curious about another demographic group
  52. that is emerging of particular importance and interest to the financial services industry which is the
  53. millennial group who is inherit in something around $40 trillion in this Boomer wealth transfer that's just begun
  54. to happen and will be happening for the next few decades talk to us about what you see from that audience and how you
  55. see gender lens as a part of their priorities and experience yeah so that audience to your point has a completely
  56. different worldview right when we ask them about do the social environmental impacts of your portfolio matter 93% of
  57. them said yes 93 93% so they're sort of saying why are asking us this question right almost rhetorical almost
  58. rhetorical exactly um and their view is that they're looking for equality right they want to um work in organizations
  59. that have um diverse management teams they want to buy from products that reflect their identity and increasingly
  60. their identity is one of community and us doing things together and so forth um they want to make the world a better
  61. place and they have understood and and some of this is research right the research of the time shows
  62. that countries that are more inclusive in terms of women's labor force participation in terms of women's access
  63. to legal rights have higher GDP growth over time right so that this is in the Zeitgeist of the time but they're also
  64. hearing things like Melinda Gates saying well wait a second women do do more unpaid work than men girls do more
  65. unpaid chores than boys and they're saying hm this isn't the world I want to live in I want to live in a true
  66. meritocracy and and it's particularly interesting you've heard this sandwich generation term for um individuals and
  67. and Partnerships that will be managing both child care and Elder Care at the same time so you sort of double hit the
  68. women who are doing that unpaid work so I understand why it's a a huge issue so we're painting a really positive picture
  69. for why gender lens investing matters and why it's so important what's what are the challenges if I can be a
  70. pessimist for a moment just a moment what are the challenges that are facing the space that are um prohibiting it
  71. from growing more quickly so partly I would say um there's a lack of understanding of what it actually is
  72. Right often times people think gender lens investing is um small soft and pink ah yes right so it's small Investments
  73. maybe a loan to a low-income woman to become an entrepreneur it's soft meaning it's not research-based and it's pink
  74. meaning it's just about women it's not actually about gender and the role that men and women play in society and so
  75. when we shift out of that bias we can understand what happens when say calsters starts working with State
  76. Street Global advisors and creates an ETF called shei and they move you know a half a billion dollars under both the
  77. ETF and the exchange the indices so there's yeah there's nothing smaller soft about sof about that right but part
  78. of it is the bias second factor is the data so the data is challenging um there's not enough of it
  79. it's not Apples to Apples across countries and across companies now you're starting to see companies being
  80. more revealing about the role of diversity across their ranks around questions like pay equity and so forth
  81. you're seeing organizations like data 2.x really look at driving more consistent gender data across
  82. countries and the sustainable development goals are going to push that forward as well because as we look at
  83. those and how gender is both a separate called out gender equality sustainable development goal and integrated
  84. throughout the other 17 goals you need measurement for that yes it's a lens throughout those other goals right
  85. exactly um what can someone do uh you know we often talk about and you and I have talked about how less people than
  86. are actually investors consider themselves investors right how we are all investors in the products and
  87. services we're buying we're supporting and how we manage our Capital what can someone do um if if they are curious
  88. about advancing the conversation around gender lens investing it's true that we tend to
  89. think of investors as has a small few talking headss on CNN M very wealthy ones exactly and those investors are are
  90. powerful and important but all of us have an opportunity to be curious about this and to ask questions and so if you
  91. ask questions of your investment advisor in terms of how a gender lens might be implemented in your portfolio that
  92. starts a conversation that is between the two of you but also between your investment advisor and their firm um and
  93. the same is true for any board that you serve on for any organization all of the
  94. questions around how are we inclusively using the talents of men and women as we
  95. do our work lead to Opportunities excellent and what are some um opportunities for advancement of the
  96. space What are some areas where you think a research institution like Wharton can play a role in advancing
  97. gender lens investing so I think there's a lot of research to be done around perceptions
  98. and communication as we've talked about it's very easy for people to get confused and to think genderland
  99. investing is just about investing in women entrepreneurs um and while investing in women entrepreneurs is
  100. important and women's access to Capital is critical there are other factors in terms of how men and women play roles
  101. throughout a a company in terms of the product and research um there's fascinating work being done in terms of
  102. the way that knowledge is gendered um so to the uh Title Here Right this question
  103. of what kind of data is an organization Gathering and how does that determine the products and services that they are
  104. creating so um lots of opportunities there um in in terms of how do we get that complexity into something called gender
  105. lens investing yeah I think there's great research around um the financial performance
  106. there's great research to be done around impact um and how the role of gender lens investors can drive impact um and
  107. then the the research that I'm most interested in is potentially the intersection of those right the flywheel
  108. that happens when gender lens work creates more impact which then creates better Financial returns let's move to a
  109. success story Jackie can you give us an example of something that has been particularly inspiring or exciting to
  110. you emerging in the gender lens investing space absolutely there's a lot it's hard to pick but I will say um one
  111. of my favorite examples of gender capitalism which is the the term that Sarah Kaplan and I use to explain the
  112. converging of those who traditionally were on the gender lens philanthropy side with those that were more
  113. traditionally just straight investors coming together to see the power of AG gender lens um to drive forward both
  114. objectives is the partnership between us trust and the women's Foundation of California where we came together to use
  115. the Deep gendered knowledge of the women's Foundation of California and the investment um Acumen of us trust to put
  116. together a investment fund we call the women and girls equality strategy it's a us all cap equity and fixed income
  117. strategy and what we do there is enable the woms foundation of California but other investors to invest in those
  118. companies that are thoughtfully engaging women as consumers as employees As Leaders of global change right how do we
  119. look across the entire value chain of a company and say how is it that they're harnessing um all of their Workforce and
  120. being thoughtful the thing that is the success story here is not just that it was launched but that at the three-year
  121. track record it's outperforming its Benchmark um and that it's now available you know more broadly Beyond us trust at
  122. maril Lynch um that there's a whole set of other investment opportunities in this space that are similar but that's
  123. the kind of model that I think is interesting where you take deep gender knowledge deep investment knowledge and
  124. you merge them excellent and as you look at that example and and you see it success is unfold I've heard you talk a
  125. lot about moving from counting to valuing women how did you measure SU ESS and what did you look at to determine um
  126. what would what you would do to consider this investment vehicle uh something that you wanted to grow in
  127. replicate so part of the question is um how is it generating change in the field
  128. and as we have more and more investment vehicles in the public debt and Equity space questions get asked um and so
  129. these vehicles are less about direct change and more about systemic change in the field um so I think the level of
  130. conversation around genderland investing which has happened because these Investments have been successful is
  131. really important this is such an exciting space and we love that we have a chance to work with great thought
  132. leaders like yourself in it we encourage all of our viewers and listeners of course to check out our website and
  133. follow along with the blogs and research and stories that we're putting out Jackie what else would you recommend
  134. readers and viewers look at to learn more about this space I've heard of a book coming out that might be of some
  135. interest it is true um in the fall we will have a book I've co-authored a book with Joe quinland who is our chief uh
  136. Market strategist at us Trust Bank of America um called gender lens investing so it'll be out in the fall and that's a
  137. great place to start there are lots of other great places though I would really suggest that viewers sign up for the
  138. blogs that Wharton puts out because your work on jeder lens investing is fabulous
  139. um there's a new community globally called women effect Investments that has a great resource list um on it it
  140. includes some of the best reports that have been written some of the research um bases so that's another place to
  141. start well thank you so much for your time today Jackie I've enjoyed talking with you and I'm sure our viewers and
  142. readers will enjoy learning more about the gender lens investing space I look forward to being back here with you in a
  143. couple years when we can talk about many more success stories in the gender lens
  144. investing space thanks for being with us [Music]

Brief Summary

Jackie VanderBrug discusses gender lens investing's importance, challenges, and a successful investment fund example in this episode.

Key points

  • Understanding Gender Lens Investing. Jackie explains how gender lens investing integrates gender analysis into investment decisions.
  • The Importance of Gender Lens Investing. Jackie highlights the significance of gender lens investing across all sectors and asset classes.
  • Millennials and Investment Impact. 93% of millennials believe social and environmental impacts of their portfolios matter.
  • Challenges in Gender Lens Investing. Jackie discusses misconceptions and data challenges facing gender lens investing.
  • Success Story in Gender Lens Investing. Jackie shares a successful investment fund that engages women thoughtfully in the economy.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes