Funding Microfinance in Times of Uncertainty

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

New Wharton research examines how political and economic turmoil in a country can impact how microfinance organizations are funded, creating implications not just for the health of lenders, but also for their potential reach to, and ability to help, lendees. 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton management professors Tyler I and Adam Cobb to talk
  2. a little bit about their latest research which was done in conjunction with Indiana University's Eric Zhao it
  3. focuses on funding for microfinance organizations Tyler and Adam thanks for being here it's great to be here thanks
  4. for having us so first of all give us a short summary of this research so you were looking at funding for microfinance
  5. organizations tell us where this came from and what questions you were trying to answer sure so Adam and I've been
  6. looking at microfinance in different capacities for a while now and eric has as well and one of the things that is a
  7. little bit surprising about the space is that you're making loans to poor people
  8. but the money that is actually used to finance those loans it's not like a typical Bank where they mobilize their
  9. deposits to then lend out the money what happens in microfinance is you count on
  10. upstream funders and the microfinance organizations themselves are more of a flow-through and so no one had really
  11. looked at how this upstream funding works and we managed to get access to really great data through the
  12. microfinance information exchange and it gave us a chance to look at how the upstream funding works as a way to
  13. analyze downstream impacts now in the literature it suggests that microfinance in a nation works best when you have a
  14. really robust ecology of different kinds of microfinance lenders so you want to have big established more commercial
  15. profitable organizations but you also want to have smaller less profitable organizations that aren't quite
  16. financially sustainable yet maybe doing a little bit more outreach and you need that funding go to all these
  17. organizations to ensure you're getting sustainable outreach good competition and a healthy sector overall and so what
  18. we're looking at was how funding flows to these different types of microfinance organizations and who the different
  19. funders are so it turns out about 30 billion dollars a year that we can track flows into microfinance around the world
  20. each year and it comes primarily from two sources one is commercial lenders mostly in Western Europe in the United
  21. States and they have commercial goals they want to get their money back they may want a little bit of a social return
  22. on investment as well but really this is risk capital they're going to lend this
  23. money out but they want to see it returned on the other hand you have development
  24. banks and multilateral aid agencies and then we're interested in funding development in the sector and so when
  25. things are working well you have the commercial lenders funding the big established commercial microfinance
  26. organizations and you have the public organizations funding the smaller not yet sustainable ones and so no one had
  27. analyzed this our top line analysis would just to see if this actually held up in practice because some people
  28. suggest that doesn't and what we found is in fact it does you know in a steady state you see this ecology work the way
  29. it should it all kind of lines up nicely but when you start to look at uncertainty in a country political
  30. uncertainty financial uncertainty when things get volatile and it's a little less clear you know how previous
  31. strategies investment strategies are going to work you see all of the funders retreat to a safe harbor in the largest
  32. microfinance organizations and this is public and commercial funders and this is tied to a lot of very adverse
  33. outcomes in the microfinance sectors of this country and this is really you know
  34. what it was that was the gist of the paper and the big thing that we uncovered so you had you started out
  35. with a number of different hypotheses about microfinance and organizations and how they're funded and some of them held
  36. up and some of them there was a little bit of a surprise so tell us a little bit about some of the key takeaways from
  37. this paper yeah I mean I think one of the things that was at least a takeaway for me is it wasn't so clear to me
  38. exactly whether or not this would map on the way we expected in particular as Tyler alluded to there's there is there
  39. there is a little bit of work mostly anecdotal evidence that suggests that there's a lot of competition between
  40. these more public funders and these commercial funders and that they actually are both targeting these really
  41. large sustainable profitable organizations so I wasn't sure whether or not things would play out because the
  42. evidence if you look at the micro finance literature right now it suggests that there that there really kind of
  43. targeting the same types of microfinance lenders and so just uncover a well at least in a steady state that doesn't
  44. seem to be the case was I think a nice thing to discover actually doing what they profess to do
  45. and probably what they should be doing but at the same time the fact that even things that are a little bit further
  46. away or kind of higher level like political uncertainty or financial uncertainty is actually affecting these
  47. decisions that are being made by these commercial and public funders you know half a world away that they're actually
  48. really paying attention to these things and they're making conscious strategies to that wasn't exactly what may be a lot
  49. of people would expect and in fact we got a chance to talk to some of these people and they really like yeah this is
  50. totally what we do you know it doesn't make a lot of sense to invest in these smaller less sustainable microfinance
  51. lenders if everything's going to go you know if the economy is really going turning poorly and these entities might
  52. disappear anyway we should it actually fulfills our social mission and so another surprising thing is they
  53. actually still feel like they're holding to this social mission even though they're changing their lending strategy
  54. which is at least in our field is something that we wouldn't expect that actually that well that's seen as sort
  55. of kind of more of a change in your ideology or change in your strategy and they don't see that this that change in
  56. investment behavior is tied to a change in strategy they actually see those two things being compatible but this change
  57. in investment behavior it does have implications for people who might receive loans from them to the
  58. organization itself and so in terms of this paper what are some of the practical implications if I'm a
  59. microfinance organization especially if I'm a smaller one or one that's in an uncertain climate how can I take this
  60. paper and apply it what can I do yeah it's a great question um I'll a certain two parts there's the implications for
  61. the organizations and there's the what they can do and what they should do so in terms of the implications I mean
  62. building on what Adam was saying one of the really striking things about our finding is that under these conditions
  63. of uncertainty if you are a small microfinance organization even one that's managed well and turning a
  64. reasonable return on your investment there's a good chance that if things become uncertain you're going to lose
  65. this funding and it's going to put you in a really precarious position now at the same time these forms of
  66. political and economic uncertainty are also things that are likely to put people who are on the edge of poverty
  67. into poverty and so what this means is that as this is happening as people are more likely to be you know desperate and
  68. very poor the organizations that are the ones that are most targeted to addressing their needs are the ones are
  69. gonna have their funding dry up first so this is a it's a big issue and there's no easy answer to what should happen
  70. here so in the paper we talked about a couple of different things so one is on the policy side government should
  71. probably make provisions to step in have emergency capital reserve funds something to restore the funding to the
  72. organizations that are having it dry up when things become uncertain this is going to be the way that you ensure the
  73. money it keeps on flowing to the people who need it as well as ensuring that you're gonna have the the basis for a
  74. healthy microfinance sector once things calm down again beyond that you know seen as size seems to be the big driver
  75. of investment decisions under uncertainty we speculate that maybe the smaller not yet sustainable microfinance
  76. organizations could band together they could work together they could merge do other things to you know to get some of
  77. the advantages of size in order to you know compete for these loans that are progressively moving up market oh and
  78. another thing we found it's not as emphasized quite as strongly in the paper is that microfinance these these
  79. lenders if they have sort of better and more transparent financial reporting actually seems to help a little bit too
  80. and that is something that's relatively low cost for them to employ and it does suggest that really a lot of this is
  81. about risk so from from these these funders it's really about it's really about risk so anything that micro these
  82. microfinance lenders can do that make them appear to be less risky including more transparency including growing or
  83. sort of our size or anything governments can do that can you know guarantee loans
  84. or do other things is really going to make is really going to help ensure that the microfinance lending structure main
  85. you know kind of holds in place during these times of uncertainty so could you talk to me a little bit
  86. about some misperceptions that are dispelled by this research I think one misperception that is dispelled by this
  87. research is this notion that public and commercial funders are crowding each other out that Pacific alee there is
  88. this big concern and the microfinance literature that the these public funders don't need the same kind of rate of
  89. return on capital and so they're offering loans to really big stable good performing lenders in these countries
  90. and able to offer better rates lower interest rates and so these better loan terms and so it's actually not enabling
  91. the infrastructure that sort of this ecosystem to grow and so this is kind of this big push to get these public
  92. funders to go and invest in the smaller less sustainable and at least at the baseline our results do not indicate
  93. that that this is as big as a big of a problem as some the anecdotal evidence suggests I think that's definitely one
  94. thing yeah I think that's absolutely right you know the finding that Adams talking about caused quite a bit of
  95. turmoil in the microfinance community with the idea that the public funders weren't being faithful to their mission
  96. you know they disposed lofty goals of fostering development in the sector and if in fact they were just investing in
  97. the largest safest organizations trying to make their organizations look good make their investment team look good I
  98. mean this would have been a big problem and it certainly is out there in some instances in microfinance in different
  99. countries but I think you know one of the things that is valuable about our fiving is to put some boundary
  100. conditions around this and part of what let us do this was access to more complete data so the findings that were
  101. out there that were showing this crowding out effect were based on a limited sample of lenders and a limited
  102. sample of countries so it was really just looking in Latin American countries now with this broader data looking at
  103. the capital flows around the world we really get a much fuller sweep of what's going on and in doing that we can see
  104. that there are contexts where crowding out takes place and there should be action taken to address that but it
  105. really seems to be linked to political and financial certainty in a country where as under
  106. steady state these organizations are acting in ways that are faithful to their mission it's just that their
  107. mission changes a little bit under uncertainty and there's a lot of good rational reasons for why they'd behave
  108. in that way and now what would you say are some other things that kind of sets this research apart from other research
  109. being conducted about microfinance I mean a lot of research on microfinance is really looking at the lindy and the
  110. borrower relationship and and whether or not microfinance helps get people out of
  111. poverty whether it leads to these good social outcomes that's always been the promise of microfinance I think part of
  112. its due to data limitations people haven't really looked at this Thunder microfinance lindy relationship yet and
  113. the fact that microfinance lenders don't operate like banks so they don't mobilize their own deposits and they are
  114. dependent on these other organizations for them to get the capital necessary to lend out is something that I imagine if
  115. you talk to the two person who just has a casual understanding of microfinance might not even know that that's how
  116. that's how they get their money or whether or not how that money flows in and the terms actually has a big impact
  117. on downstream on the lindy borrow relationship so I think that was a really you know that was the one of the
  118. big appeals to me to take part in this research is it just really hasn't been explored there's only been maybe one or
  119. two studies and as Tyler alluded to they haven't had the best data and it hasn't
  120. been that complete over enough years and at least I think this is a good first step to start really looking at the
  121. importance of the funder Lindy relationship as opposed to not to say that the borrower Lindy relations that
  122. Linda relationship isn't important and obviously research needs to continue on that front as well but we really need to
  123. be looking at the entire supply chain and not just one part of it and what's next for this research where you guys
  124. going to go with this next well we've been talking about a bunch of different ideas it's a you know it's fun to think
  125. about where it might go so one of the things that we've been talking about is looking at the effects that different
  126. forms of capital have on the behavior of the organizations so in this research we
  127. were looking at how the funders cave and in follow ons we're thinking about taking that to the you know to the
  128. microfinance organization level and looking at how the composition of capital in a country affects the
  129. behavior of the organization's getting back to a question you asked earlier about you know what are the effects of
  130. this in terms of the organization's behavior on the ground doing their work trying to lend to poor people so we're
  131. starting to look at you know how these organizations make lending decisions in terms of how they apply the screens when
  132. they're deciding what organizations to invest in what sort of pressures this puts on the organization both directly
  133. and indirectly and how having different pots of capital available in a country might allow for different types of
  134. organizations to flourish or you know how it might you know just have the whole ecology you know implode on itself
  135. as well kind of like what we see under uncertainty in the funding relationship and you know to the extent that this
  136. speaks about issues of social finance it potentially has implications for understanding about how we affect
  137. positive outcomes not just through corporate social responsibility and social action but also how money comes
  138. in to corporations more broadly and so what we'd like to be able to show are some boundary conditions around when
  139. social investment has positive versus negative outcomes great thank you guys so much thank you
  140. you

Brief Summary

Wharton professors discuss research on microfinance funding dynamics and effects of uncertainty on smaller organizations.

Key points

  • Funding Dynamics in Microfinance. The research uncovers how upstream funding impacts microfinance organizations and their sustainability.
  • Surprising Findings on Funders' Behavior. The study reveals that funders retreat to larger organizations during uncertainty, affecting smaller ones.
  • Misperceptions in Microfinance Funding. The research challenges the belief that public and commercial funders are competing for the same organizations.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes