State of the Economy: Global Markets

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton's Mauro Guillen says the U.S. economy is likely to get stronger in 2013, but he expects economic and fiscal troubles to persist in Europe. The world economy could also suffer from the economic slowdown in the major emerging markets in China, India and Brazil.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] hello I'm Jeff Brown for knowledge at Wharton today we're with Maro guen
  2. professor of International Management for Wharton and thank you very much for joining us thank you for want to talk
  3. about the state of the economy the state of the world uh for 2013 and I'd like to talk about the
  4. Emerging Markets we often think that this is where the future is this is where the great growth potential is at
  5. the same time if you're an investor uh you you see a lot of volatility and you know that there are a lot of ups and
  6. downs in these countries what is the state of the emerging markets today well it's not as good as uh we would like it
  7. to be uh here in the United States or in Europe or in Japan in the parts of the world that are not growing that much and
  8. let me explain I think most people would like the emerging economies right now to
  9. become the locomotives of the global economy but um uh in recent uh months over the last year or so emerging
  10. economies have also begun to slow down a little bit they're still growing China is growing at 6 7% India is growing
  11. maybe 5% uh but Brazil is uh you know barely growing it's growing at less than 1% um so uh you know this uh slowdown in
  12. the emerging e actually comes at a at a bad point in time uh because we would like them to uh to be a little bit more
  13. Dynamic than what they are right now and is this a result of what's happened in the rest of the world spilling over to
  14. them or do they have their own factors that are causing this well uh it's the answer is yes to both uh so um the
  15. emerging economies of course export uh their manufactured products uh and some of their energy or other Commodities uh
  16. to Europe or to the United States so if growth here or in Europe is not as strong then of course these economies
  17. suffer uh but then secondly they also have problems of their own Brazil has uh encountered a number of bottlenecks in
  18. its economic development in its growth over the last uh three or four years interest rates were too high because
  19. they were trying to keep inflation down but that meant that then local businesses didn't have enough credit at
  20. the at an appropriate price to uh to invest and to create jobs and to grow uh India also is famous for many bottle in
  21. infrastructure in the legal system um and so on so U one economy emerging economy after another what we see is
  22. that both because of uh domestic reasons and um global reasons International reasons uh you know they're starting to
  23. grow less rapidly than they used to and China you know which was such a Powerhouse there for for for a while
  24. what what is what is going on in China it seems to be slowing down well in China we've had uh a leadership
  25. transition that is still going on uh in terms of filling uh in the uh the various positions in in the government
  26. so there's some uncertainty regarding that then of course we have the uh the problem with their exports to uh Europe
  27. in particular right now and a little bit also to the United States even though the US economy is growing faster than
  28. European economies which are not growing at all except for uh Germany and a couple of others um and uh then thirdly
  29. of course uh China has the problem of uh uh you know transformation right now uh
  30. it is an economy that has being uh you know investing a lot in infrastructure it has been uh growing uh in terms of
  31. exports uh but it is an economy that now needs to switch to uh the creation and the growth of a domestic consumption
  32. Market uh so again I mean these uh Transformations these transition phases are are difficult and I think China is
  33. now uh essentially wrestling with uh with those issues now how does this affect the developed countries I mean
  34. does this does do this make them more competitive or is this hurting them why should we care other than they our
  35. fellow uh fellow citizens of the world well the emerging economies are a very important part of the global economy
  36. they're nearly half of global output uh and uh also you know 40% at least 40% of the uh Global Market for
  37. consumer goods um so if things don't go well in the emerging economies uh that affects everyone not just them uh you
  38. know 20 years ago the emerging economy is where at most 15 or 20% of the global economy the bulk of economic activity in
  39. the world uh and the bulk of consumption was in Europe the United States and Japan but that's no longer the case so
  40. now we cannot really afford uh emerging economies not to uh play their role in the global economy which is to grow
  41. quickly right uh these are the uh the economies the up and cominging economies they supposed to grow quickly they're
  42. not growing as quickly uh as they once did and that's a problem and now you've mentioned the major ones China India
  43. Brazil what about some of the other countries the other Asian countries that that were once known as real comerce
  44. what's happening with them well we have uh uh in the emerging world we have uh new countries that have now become hot
  45. and attractive for investment and uh they're growing quickly uh I would mention for example in La America
  46. there's two of them Colombia and Peru uh clearly doing really well especially compared to 10 or 15 or 20 years ago
  47. uh if you go to Africa there's also two or three economies that are doing better
  48. than in the past uh even though there are many problems of course that continue to uh limit uh growth uh in in
  49. Africa um in the Middle East well we have U turkey which is uh doing pretty well uh but then right next to it we
  50. have Egypt uh which in the wake of the Arab Spring um has actually uh gone through a period of enormous difficulty
  51. from an economic and financial point of view for for a variety of reasons and then uh in Asia well we have Pakistan
  52. which is actually doing pretty well it is growing about the same at the same Pace as as India and this is a very
  53. large country as well uh and in South East Asia uh we have now Indonesia uh doing relatively well and Malaysia uh
  54. which seems to have finally recovered from the difficulties uh from 10 years ago or so uh but we still have other
  55. economies like Thailand uh we have other economies in the region that are not uh
  56. doing as well and uh so it's a mixed uh bag it's a mixed picture some countries are doing better than we were expecting
  57. them to to do and others are not performing as well but on balance I would say that we're worse off in terms
  58. of uh emerging um uh you know growth in in in the emerging economies than we were two
  59. years ago or three years ago now is there anything that the International Community could be doing to make this
  60. situation better uh wealthy Western countries or major agencies the world World Bank uh organizations like that
  61. well we have uh way too many question marks in the global economy right now uh I mean just to give you a short list we
  62. have the uh the Euro crisis in Europe uh it seems as if uh now is the month of January it seems as if over the last
  63. couple of months uh the problem has stabilized a little bit but that doesn't mean things are going okay in Europe in
  64. fact we have a recession going on so there's the the the double dip recession the second dip in this recession has
  65. been declared as of six weeks ago um so we have these very big problems in Europe and let's not forget that Europe
  66. is still 25% of the global market right uh and we have the continuing fiscal crisis in the United States uh which is
  67. I think for the most part self-inflicted at this point uh and uh we have of course Japan which doesn't seem to be
  68. able to find its way out of its own 20y year uh quasi recession right although the new prime minister seems to be um
  69. very adamant that he wants to change things let's see what let's see what happens um so those are the bigger
  70. problems but if you shift the level of analysis a little bit and you think about the global economic and financial
  71. infrastructure what we have right now is very little collaboration among governments in terms of what should be
  72. done in fact what we have is governments trying to uh you know take advantage of
  73. one another we have all of these um currency manipulations going on China has been for a long time accused of
  74. being a currency manipulator but they're not alone over the last year or so Japan
  75. has all also try to um you know reduce the value of the Yen so as to remain export competitive so has Switzerland
  76. right and so has the United States in the United States we have printed a lot of money and that has put downward
  77. pressure on the dollar and uh that has made uh possible a Revival um of US manufactured exports um so everybody is
  78. you know trying to look after their own interests uh we I see very little collaboration among key governments
  79. around the world and I think this this is also something that adds to the uncertainty out there now if there were
  80. to be more collaboration who who's the who's the where's the likely uh country or organization to lead that well I
  81. think uh you know there are three or four maybe five countries in the world that really matter right now that have a
  82. something to say about a possible way out from this uh you know big um Global uh slowdown that we you know happen to
  83. be are uh trapped into uh certainly the United States certainly China right those are the two biggest economies and
  84. they are very important from a financial point of view for for very different reasons uh then we have Germany uh which
  85. in my view should perhaps be the representative from Europe right as opposed to having the European Union uh
  86. as such Germany is the world's fourth largest economy and it is the second most important export power and then of
  87. course you have Japan and possibly the UK right but that's about it I mean I don't think U countries such as Mexico
  88. or Brazil or Argentina or Colombia or Indonesia or turkey should be sitting at the table trying to make decisions
  89. because then the table gets too big we have too many people uh negotiating uh so what I think we need is four or five
  90. key countries sitting at the table and helping us overcome all of the you know complexities that uh we're facing right
  91. now in the global economy now we also hear about fiscal imbalances and you can explain a little what that means and why
  92. that's a problem well we have all sorts of balances in the world I mean you mentioned fiscal which is uh government
  93. spending more money than uh what they uh take into us in the form of Revenue taxes for the most part uh we also have
  94. other kinds of imbalances Financial imbalances we have trade imbalances and so on so forth but focusing on the
  95. fiscal imbalances the problem of course is that U as you know investors no longer believe that some governments in
  96. the world can uh you know pay them back and so what we've seen is uh interest rates on on bonds government bonds go
  97. through the roof uh for those countries that uh uh have lost the trust of uh investors now at the other side of the
  98. uh the equation we have other countries that uh can pretty much borrow at zero interest rates right that includes early
  99. Germany uh but also Switzerland and uh at least up until now pretty much also the United States so these are countries
  100. that still are perceived as being solid and being capable of uh uh you know returning the money that they're asking
  101. investors to to give them now in the US again I mentioned earlier that most of the fiscal problem is self-inflicted um
  102. because the upcoming battle now in the month of February will be uh the debt ceiling and of course this is an
  103. artificial thing right and I'm sure there's going to be quite a bit of political uh fighting about it uh but
  104. you know the global economy and investors know that the US is a uh is at least so far is a government that can
  105. pay its debt right and like other governments around the world which cannot right now it it seems sometimes
  106. like the US can get away with murder you know I remember I think it was about 18
  107. months ago when we lost our credit rating our top rating and everybody said this will be a catastrophe and interest
  108. rates are lower now well and that was a signal I think that was a signal to the politicians in in Washington DC that
  109. they shouldn't do anything crazy because although the US continues to be the largest economy and it is the most
  110. important Financial power in the world uh its uh strength is not Unlimited right uh but the US has one big
  111. Advantage as we all know which is that the dollar continues to be the the most important Reserve currency like 70 about
  112. 70% of all allocated um reserves in the world are in in in dollar denominated assets now this gives the US uh quite a
  113. bit of uh you know leeway uh a lot of breathing room uh with which to uh to play because once again there is a big
  114. appetite uh for us denominated uh uh dollars and the US can therefore uh you know play you know a different role in
  115. the global economy than other economies that don't have that that kind of a privilege and it looks like investors
  116. around the world simply don't believe the US will ever default on its debt is that that what these numbers tell us
  117. well uh I would never say that we'll never ever default because obviously you know what is the time Horizon here is it
  118. uh 20 years or is it 50 or 100 or 200 years if history is of any guide uh well I would definitely bet my pension right
  119. now in saying that the US will default within the next 500 years right now I don't think it will default within the
  120. next five years or 10 years or 15 years not in the foreseeable future right uh but a lot of it depends also on what
  121. happens to China and whether China makes uh takes more steps in the direction of
  122. playing an active role in global finance and of course a very important um element in all of this will be the Yan
  123. what happens to the Chinese currency is the Chinese currency going to become at some point in the near future another
  124. Reserve currency and and then once it becomes a reserve currency of course I think the prediction is that it will
  125. probably become an important Reserve currency I don't think it will displace the dollar but it will become an
  126. important Reserve currency maybe at the same level as the Euro you know 15 20% of all currency reserves in the world
  127. but we're still at least five seven 10 years away from that in the meantime the US continues to you know be the most
  128. important economy in the world from the financial point of and will continue to be or to have the
  129. the the most important Reserve currency so let's just finish with a sort of a projection for 2013 do you think that at
  130. the end of this year conditions will look much different from the way they are now either Better or Worse well uh
  131. 12 months down the road uh I think um uh if we go region by region I think things
  132. will look much much better here in the United States unless of course something really weird happens in Washington DC
  133. over the next two or three months regarding all of these fiscal negotiations ations uh Europe I think uh
  134. is not going to be seeing the end uh the light of the end of the tunnel yet uh at
  135. the end of this year 2013 why well because they uh seem set on a uh an array of austerity measures and these
  136. austerity measures May at some point be effective but it's not going to be anytime soon you know if that's the way
  137. they want to uh overcome their problems it's going to take a while right and of course unemployment in the meantime will
  138. be very very high uh then I think the big question mark is where we started this conversation it's with the emerging
  139. economies will um uh the two that um worry me the most India and Brazil because of their size and because of
  140. some of the problems that they're encountering will they manage to reverse the decline in their growth rates uh I
  141. think this is a very urgent question especially in the case of Brazil uh uh so uh I think emerging economies uh
  142. hopefully more likely than not they will be better off at the end of this year but certainly not Europe and um
  143. hopefully the US will be better off yeah well we'll come back in a year and see how it turned out thank you very much
  144. thank you for inviting [Music] me

Brief Summary

Emerging markets face slower growth in 2013, impacting global economy; key challenges in China, India, and Brazil discussed.

Key points

  • The State of Emerging Markets. Emerging economies are facing a slowdown, affecting global growth potential.
  • US Economic Resilience. Despite challenges, the US economy maintains a strong position in global finance.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes